News 
1
I Enjoyed This Far More Than I Expected — Despite Moth
On paper, You Maniac should not have worked especially well for me. It is relatively low-stakes, relationship-driven, and often feels almost slice-of-life. Yet after a fairly “meh” first episode, I became genuinely invested and ended up enjoying most of the series much more than I expected.
A huge part of that was William as Dean. Dean begins as the stereotypical promiscuous playboy with commitment issues, but he quickly becomes far more interesting than that description suggests. William gives him warmth, vulnerability, humor, and a wonderful wounded softness when Dean realizes that what he feels for Moth is very different from everything that came before.
Unfortunately, my biggest problem with the drama is Moth.
This is not a criticism of Est’s performance. Est played Moth very well. My problem is with how Moth was written and, especially, how the story framed his behavior. Moth is closed-off, judgmental, selfish, frequently rude, and repeatedly hurts Dean while demanding levels of openness and reassurance that he rarely gives in return. Dean apologizes when he behaves badly. Moth almost never does.
The show gives us plenty of reasons to understand why Moth is wounded, but understanding a character is not the same as giving that character a redemption arc. Moth cries, struggles with his artistic identity, and eventually breaks free of his old attachment to Mes, but he never meaningfully acknowledges how poorly he has treated Dean. Somehow Dean repeatedly ends up positioned as the one who needs to learn, apologize, pursue harder, or prove his love.
That imbalance became increasingly frustrating, especially because Dean was such an easy character to love.
Ironically, my favorite romance was the second couple, Ten and Pun. Barcode and Kin were absolutely delightful together. Their relationship was sweet, funny, mutually supportive, and refreshingly communicative. Ten’s insecurity and Pun’s growing certainty about him gave their romance real emotional payoff without making either character miserable for ten episodes first. I literally clapped when they finally got together.
There were also several things I genuinely loved: Dean’s family storyline, Moth’s Beautiful Chaos painting, the exploration of loneliness in very different personalities, and Mes ultimately being one of the few people who accurately recognized just how loving and devoted Dean really was.
The ending worked in the basic sense that everyone ends up where the drama clearly intended them to be, but I wish the writers had required more accountability from Moth before giving Dean and Moth their happy ending.
So this was a strange one for me: I enjoyed the drama, loved Dean, adored Ten and Pun, appreciated both William and Est’s performances—and still finished annoyed at the way the central romance was written.
Much better than the premise made me expect, but the main relationship needed a far more balanced emotional reckoning.
A huge part of that was William as Dean. Dean begins as the stereotypical promiscuous playboy with commitment issues, but he quickly becomes far more interesting than that description suggests. William gives him warmth, vulnerability, humor, and a wonderful wounded softness when Dean realizes that what he feels for Moth is very different from everything that came before.
Unfortunately, my biggest problem with the drama is Moth.
This is not a criticism of Est’s performance. Est played Moth very well. My problem is with how Moth was written and, especially, how the story framed his behavior. Moth is closed-off, judgmental, selfish, frequently rude, and repeatedly hurts Dean while demanding levels of openness and reassurance that he rarely gives in return. Dean apologizes when he behaves badly. Moth almost never does.
The show gives us plenty of reasons to understand why Moth is wounded, but understanding a character is not the same as giving that character a redemption arc. Moth cries, struggles with his artistic identity, and eventually breaks free of his old attachment to Mes, but he never meaningfully acknowledges how poorly he has treated Dean. Somehow Dean repeatedly ends up positioned as the one who needs to learn, apologize, pursue harder, or prove his love.
That imbalance became increasingly frustrating, especially because Dean was such an easy character to love.
Ironically, my favorite romance was the second couple, Ten and Pun. Barcode and Kin were absolutely delightful together. Their relationship was sweet, funny, mutually supportive, and refreshingly communicative. Ten’s insecurity and Pun’s growing certainty about him gave their romance real emotional payoff without making either character miserable for ten episodes first. I literally clapped when they finally got together.
There were also several things I genuinely loved: Dean’s family storyline, Moth’s Beautiful Chaos painting, the exploration of loneliness in very different personalities, and Mes ultimately being one of the few people who accurately recognized just how loving and devoted Dean really was.
The ending worked in the basic sense that everyone ends up where the drama clearly intended them to be, but I wish the writers had required more accountability from Moth before giving Dean and Moth their happy ending.
So this was a strange one for me: I enjoyed the drama, loved Dean, adored Ten and Pun, appreciated both William and Est’s performances—and still finished annoyed at the way the central romance was written.
Much better than the premise made me expect, but the main relationship needed a far more balanced emotional reckoning.
Was this review helpful to you?
