News This review may contain spoilers
Oops! Mysteriously unsatisfying
This series had one of the best pilot videos ever but unfortunately many of the good parts of the pilot didn't survive the transition to the series itself. As a result I think "Mysterious Sounds" will best be remembered for introducing the lead actors Namna and PK to the BL universe. They deliver excellent performances even if you set aside the fact that they're newcomers.
A problem throughout the series is the need to sustain a romantic plot alongside a supernatural murder mystery. The final scene of Episode 3 shows how clumsily this is done:
Jin's best friend Anda has died under suspicious circumstances. Meanwhile, Jin's relationship with Pod is still on shaky ground, occupying a no-man's land between "enemies who are fake dating" and the first stirrings of real attraction. Nonetheless, even with the ongoing tension between the two of them, when they're alone together Pod comforts Jin with some beautiful dialog:
"Jinna, maybe you don't see it yet, but I really loved Anda as an actor. He was my source of joy. It broke my heart when someone insulted him. I was happy when someone complimented him. And when this happened to him, I could barely hold myself together. I just want to tell you that if you're hurting, just let it out. Don't worry how people will see you. He was your best friend, Jinna. Everyone understands you."
Jin then shyly asks Pod, "Can I hug you?" And Pod nods, and they hug.
This is a very touching moment, but then all of a sudden, out of nowhere, the musical score that's been playing somberly in the background shifts into a bouncy, happy tune. Why? Because -- omg!! -- the two boys might actually kiss! From there the scene is suddenly played like any generic rom-com, with the boys slowly getting into position for their lips to meet. Closer, closer, closer... And then, also like in any rom-com, the scene (and the episode) cuts out before we see if the kiss actually happens.
It's tone deaf and a little bizarre.
Another issue is the clumsy incorporation of the supernatural element. Although Anda has died he manages to speak to Jin and Pod through a pair of earbuds, directing them on how they should proceed with solving his murder. By the end of the series, though, we learn that Anda's ghost should have had a very good idea about who the killer was. So why wouldn't he just reveal that to Jin and Pod, or at least suggest that they look closely at that person in particular?
Probably most disappointing to me was the handling of the enemies-to-lovers aspect of the series. This is my favorite trope, and in this area the pilot raised many expectations, giving us a nice taste of how Jin would taunt Pod and how Pod would sass him back. The Jin in the pilot was a rascal, with a little too much swagger in the way he teased Pod, and it made it satisfying to see Pod cut him down in response.
In the series, though, Jin is simply the greenest flag ever, a shining star in every way. We see one example after another where he proves to be exceptionally mature, respectful and caring, even as he's met with Pod's constant distain. It gets to the point that Pod starts to look like a jerk for not being nicer to him. What exactly is his beef with Jin? We never get a good explanation, and that only serves to reflect poorly on Pod.
Having said all this, though, I still enjoyed the series enough to finish it. Like many, I fell in love with Namna and thought he and PK had great chemistry. "Mysterious Sounds" is worth watching if only to see the beginnings of two promising careers.
A problem throughout the series is the need to sustain a romantic plot alongside a supernatural murder mystery. The final scene of Episode 3 shows how clumsily this is done:
Jin's best friend Anda has died under suspicious circumstances. Meanwhile, Jin's relationship with Pod is still on shaky ground, occupying a no-man's land between "enemies who are fake dating" and the first stirrings of real attraction. Nonetheless, even with the ongoing tension between the two of them, when they're alone together Pod comforts Jin with some beautiful dialog:
"Jinna, maybe you don't see it yet, but I really loved Anda as an actor. He was my source of joy. It broke my heart when someone insulted him. I was happy when someone complimented him. And when this happened to him, I could barely hold myself together. I just want to tell you that if you're hurting, just let it out. Don't worry how people will see you. He was your best friend, Jinna. Everyone understands you."
Jin then shyly asks Pod, "Can I hug you?" And Pod nods, and they hug.
This is a very touching moment, but then all of a sudden, out of nowhere, the musical score that's been playing somberly in the background shifts into a bouncy, happy tune. Why? Because -- omg!! -- the two boys might actually kiss! From there the scene is suddenly played like any generic rom-com, with the boys slowly getting into position for their lips to meet. Closer, closer, closer... And then, also like in any rom-com, the scene (and the episode) cuts out before we see if the kiss actually happens.
It's tone deaf and a little bizarre.
Another issue is the clumsy incorporation of the supernatural element. Although Anda has died he manages to speak to Jin and Pod through a pair of earbuds, directing them on how they should proceed with solving his murder. By the end of the series, though, we learn that Anda's ghost should have had a very good idea about who the killer was. So why wouldn't he just reveal that to Jin and Pod, or at least suggest that they look closely at that person in particular?
Probably most disappointing to me was the handling of the enemies-to-lovers aspect of the series. This is my favorite trope, and in this area the pilot raised many expectations, giving us a nice taste of how Jin would taunt Pod and how Pod would sass him back. The Jin in the pilot was a rascal, with a little too much swagger in the way he teased Pod, and it made it satisfying to see Pod cut him down in response.
In the series, though, Jin is simply the greenest flag ever, a shining star in every way. We see one example after another where he proves to be exceptionally mature, respectful and caring, even as he's met with Pod's constant distain. It gets to the point that Pod starts to look like a jerk for not being nicer to him. What exactly is his beef with Jin? We never get a good explanation, and that only serves to reflect poorly on Pod.
Having said all this, though, I still enjoyed the series enough to finish it. Like many, I fell in love with Namna and thought he and PK had great chemistry. "Mysterious Sounds" is worth watching if only to see the beginnings of two promising careers.
Was this review helpful to you?

5
7
2
1
