Quantcast

Details

  • Last Online: 4 days ago
  • Gender: Male
  • Location: Italy
  • Contribution Points: 0 LV0
  • Roles: VIP
  • Join Date: January 10, 2022
Take Charge of My Heart korean drama review
Completed
Take Charge of My Heart
1 people found this review helpful
by Gastoski
13 days ago
10 of 10 episodes seen
Completed
Overall 6.0
Story 6.0
Acting/Cast 7.0
Music 6.0
Rewatch Value 6.0
This review may contain spoilers

Heart Of Triteness

A thin and predictable drama with touches of fantasy, “Take Charge of My Heart” starts with a premise that seems to offer plenty of opportunities to play with the conventions of the Korean romantic comedy, but ultimately takes a path that’s far more familiar than one might expect or hope for.
The protagonist is a novice screenwriter with a unique electrical quirk; the male lead is a chaebol heir haunted by past traumas; and their forced cohabitation is, as one might easily imagine, destined to evolve into a gradual romantic connection. Rounding out the picture are a heart condition that requires the male lead to have a battery and undergo periodic "recharges", the usual family conflicts, and a meta-narrative framework that could have been one of the most interesting elements of the entire drama.

The problem isn’t so much the presence of these elements—which have become an integral part of the genre’s repertoire—as it is the way they’re put together. “Take Charge of My Heart” doesn’t disappoint: on the contrary, it delivers on its promises, but it does so by following a path so predictable that speculating on how the story will unfold is often unnecessary. The tormented chaebol, the eccentric and socially isolated girl, the initially thwarted attraction, and the gradual revelation of emotional wounds all belong to a narrative world that fans of Korean dramas know all too well.

And while the familiarity of certain plot devices may be an enjoyable aspect of romantic comedies, their reuse would require at least a significant twist—an insight capable of breathing new life into well-worn tropes.

This aspect gives rise to the most obvious limitations; all those distinctive elements of the premise serve to justify and reinforce a conventional narrative structure, one that is incapable of truly altering its parameters. The protagonists’ unique traits, the circumstances that force them to share spaces and moments of intimacy, and the complications that arise in their relationship thus end up following a trajectory that can be easily predicted well in advance. The impression is not that of witnessing a story that consciously uses clichés to build something new, but rather a story that seems to regard them as a sufficient guarantee of effectiveness.

As in other cases, the premise offered a particularly interesting opportunity to address this very issue. A promising screenwriter, busy crafting a rom-com while also grappling with the difficulties of her creative work. A choice that could have transformed “Take Charge of My Heart” into something more than just a variation on a theme, making the act of writing itself one of the narrative’s central focuses.

This is where the series’ most curious paradox lies: A screenwriter protagonist who crafts a conventional rom-com offers the writers a valuable opportunity—to reveal the genre’s mechanics, deconstruct its conventions, and play with the viewer’s expectations. But if the story ends up following exactly the same path it seemed intent on satirizing, the game loses its appeal. Awareness of the cliché isn’t enough to redeem it: one must know how to subvert it, or reinterpret it with genuine originality. While the premise of “Take Charge of My Heart” features some elements eccentric enough to suggest less conventional developments, their integration into the narrative structure ultimately brings them back into well-worn patterns.

The male lead, Baek Oh Rang (played by Kim Young Kwang, who plays out the full chaebol repertoire, for better or worse), in particular, embodies—as usual—a sort of “greatest hits” version of the classic Korean chaebol heir: rich, brilliant, emotionally distant, marked by past trauma, and destined to find in love the chance to overcome his own vulnerabilities.

This is an archetype that certainly doesn’t need to be reinvented with every new installment, but one that would at least benefit from some element capable of giving it a personality distinct from the many models that have come before it: a man who possesses power, money, and privileges, yet depends materially on an external source to stay alive. The contrast between social omnipotence and physical fragility could have truly shaken the model of the dominant male protagonist. Instead, if past trauma and the usual power games return to center stage, even this distinctive trait risks being reduced to a plot device to justify the protagonists’ forced closeness.

The same goes for Na Bo Bae (Chae Soo Bin, perfect and utterly charming, just as the role calls for), a girl who delivers electric shocks to anyone who tries to touch her—a trait that goes beyond its obvious comedic element. The childhood accident responsible for this unique characteristic introduces an almost fairy-tale-like dimension, but also serves as a rather immediate metaphor for emotional and social isolation. The inability to freely experience physical contact translates into a real difficulty in forming spontaneous relationships, in allowing others to get close, and in surrendering to the vulnerability that is an essential part of intimacy.

Ji Eun Ho, conventionally “the third wheel,” on the other hand, could have represented a genuine narrative alternative—not just the usual romantic rival destined to lose out. His presence—especially since Cha Woo Min is clearly more likable than the pompous chaebol—would have made it possible to challenge the idea that love must necessarily follow the narrative’s preferred trajectory: that of the rich, tormented, and seemingly unattainable man who wins over the heroine through a gradual revelation of his own wounds.
A different kind of romance—perhaps less spectacular but no less authentic—could have introduced a more interesting conflict than those generated by the usual childish squabbles, not to mention the predictable family rivalries and secrets from the past.

It also offers a few variations on the meta-cinematic context, which almost feels like the series’ greatest missed opportunity. A story that reflects—at least in its premise—on the construction of a rom-com could have also explored why we continue to love these stories, how much we’re influenced by their conventions, and the difference between what works on the page of a screenplay and what might work in real life. But to do so, it would have had to accept the risk of defying the viewer’s expectations, rather than simply fulfilling them one after another—all while not skipping the usual, rushed final twist.

Ultimately, the series seems to fall into the same trap it attributes to the genre it belongs to: it confuses recognizability with narrative effectiveness. The viewer recognizes the tormented chaebol, the forced cohabitation, the thwarted attraction, the traumatic past, and even the love triangle; they already know what role each will play and can guess where they’ll lead us. And when a story can no longer surprise us or make us reinterpret what we already know, its awareness of clichés ends up becoming nothing more than a mere statement of intent.

The real missed opportunity, then, isn’t necessarily the chance to create a rom-com without clichés, but rather the chance to use those clichés as a starting point to tell a story that hadn’t already been told in the same way. The most obvious flaw is just that: a series that could have challenged the conventions of the rom-com ends up showing just how difficult it is to break free from them—even when you’re fully aware that you’re following them.

The question that remains, then, is not whether the audience is evidently forgetful, but rather whether the audiovisual industry has gradually come to view originality as superfluous, relying on the fact that the familiarity of the tropes is, in and of itself, a guarantee of engagement.

Baek Oh Rang’s heart becomes almost an unintended metaphor for the entire endeavor: a device that keeps running, episode after episode, as long as someone recharges it. Even when it seems to lack what should truly bring it to life: an authentic narrative heart.

6/10
Was this review helpful to you?