I know this is supposed to be a classic, but I find so many other dramas that have tighter plots and better production.…
Oh, I wanted to add that the 2018 version of Meteor Gardens did a much better job of the faults I found in Boys Over Flowers. The second male lead was handled better. The female lead was less frustrating. The back and forth between the main couple being at odds and together was more balanced so you got a better mix of good and bad. It contains many similar scenarios but isn’t really the same story at all. However, I would recommend it over this.
I know this is supposed to be a classic, but I find so many other dramas that have tighter plots and better production. Having said that, there are points in this story that rubbed me the wrong way.
I really hate the “one guy is her soulmate, a different one her love” concept. What wife would want their husband to have a closer and more emotionally intimate relationship with another woman, and what man would want that with his wife? It makes no sense.
Jan Di’s refusal to tell the man she loved that she liked him was truly spectacular to the point of being unbelievable. At one point in the show Joon Pyo brushes her off in a cruel way, yet it was hard to truly feel bad for her given that he didn’t even know she really cared. She did other things too. She avoided him and hung out with other guys rather than admit she was struggling, then was shocked when she looked like she was cheating. Throughout the show, she suffered, but so much of that suffering was caused by her stubbornness, failure to communicate and her awful handled of her own feelings. It was more frustrating than dramatic, and I don’t like stories built on characters that act in frustratingly illogical ways.
It is fatiguing when the two love interests are at odds with each other for many many episodes. Equally as difficult is when they are on screen together for only a few minutes in a several show stretch. Add to that their being on screen together with the second male or female lead far more than with their main love interest and you just start to wonder who exactly you’re supposed to be rooting to end up with whom. Fatigue sets in when all you get episode after episode is bad stuff, with no good moments to balance it out.
I never understood shows that take you through so much pain and suffering for the main characters only to have them part for multiple years. The “four years later” syndrome really starts to get annoying and predictable after a while and it renders everything that came before it pointless. What was the point of going through so much heartache and struggle to be together, only to not be together in the end. It’s frustrating, not entertaining..
This was a sweet, touching story that could have been great except that it suffered from an ending that was utterly predictable. She worked as a cleaner in a cleaning company, which meant in the eyes of the makers of dramas she was not a valuable and worthwhile person. So, it was a forgone conclusion from episode one, that the couple would have,to suffer a protracted separation at the end of the story where she “fixed” her defective self so she would be worthy of the man.
Apparently, being a sweet, lovable, caring person who helps the man she loves heal his disease wasn’t good enough. As happens with predictable regularity in all too many shows, she had to suffer a period apart from him while she repaired her broken self as a menial worker and became an “impressive” cog in the corporate machinery, thereby becaming “good enough” for the man. That message devalues and demeans the love and caring the woman brought to relationship.
The message on the man’s side was equally as messed up. With patience and caring, she helped him overcome his disease. Yet it is never good enough for people in a relationship to help, support, love, and heal one another’s faults. No. All the care she put into healing him had to be utterly undone, she had to make him even worse and separate from him so he could heal himself without her help. Why?
Don’t get me wrong. Overall it was an otherwise good story, but I grow tired of this message that you can’t have a relationship where his support helps her become “impressive” and her caring helps him heal and become whole. Instead we get these contrived periods apart at the end of the story where we learn that women aren’t valuable as people simply by being who you are, they must be exemplary employees or have impressive academic credentials before they can be valued in a relationship.
I'm on episode 10 right now and I honestly don't think Soo Jin is worth this much effort. It's nice to know I…
Changing one event in the past never changes just one thing, it changes everything. His parents treated him different because his entire past was different, making him an entirely different person. It made perfect sense to me.
I don’t know why I liked this so much. Perhaps it was the way it took a simple idea and turned it in surprising directions. It was fun, which made it easy to overlook many of the flaws, so long as you were able to laugh at it and go along with the idea. Perhaps best of all is that in the end the main character didn’t heroically (and predictably) solve everything on his own. It took the couple working together to overcome the obstacles and reach a satisfying ending. It was good, light-hearted fun. If that’s what you like, give this one a try.
I have a soft spot for paranormal romance stories and this one hit that spot perfectly. It is stunningly well done for a Taiwanese drama. Not that there’s anything wrong with Taiwanese dramas, it’s just this was equal to the best Koreans dramas on every level. The plot is intricate and subtle, surprising at many a turn. It was extremely well acted and had many great moments. The production was first rate and the ending while a bit quick was very satisfying. There is really no way in which this didn’t please.
So much fun. Hackers, Super spies, intrigue, comedy, and romance, blended into a wild ride that never ceases to entertain. And the ending was very satisfying.
I loved the way this drama bucked the tendency for historic dramas to be one tragedy after another. Sure, bad things happened, but on the whole, it was very upbeat, positive and uplifting.
For me, this was about as near perfect as you get. Great, quirky characters whose lives were shattered by a tragic accident. Brought together by fate in a story full of twists and surprises, they help each other heal and find happiness again. The surprise ending was as touching And perfect as it gets, and shows how masterful Korean drama can be. I saw this a year ago and the story still stays with me.
I really wanted to like this drama, and in some ways it was quite good. What was hard to get past was the way it seemed to Create drama out of nothing. The male lead had some huge, world shattering events hit him which he was heroic in his efforts to apologize to the female lead for it all.
Rather than his psychologist girlfriend making allowances she becomes disenchanted . What followed was a string of terribly supported reasons why she can’t be with him: they’re from different worlds, she’s been stuck in the same place for the last year, his apology was overboard and didn’t value her work, the ups and downs were too extreme, they aren’t in step with one another, she’s unlucky in love.
On their own the reasons might be valid if backed up by something significant and troubling. In the end it seemed like the writer was flailing, trying to make up some plausible reason why the psychologist girlfriend was adamant in running away from her problems rather than talking it through with her near-perfect boyfriend. To make things worse, she never got past it on her own and had to be badgered into admitting her mistake by her male friend.
Had it been short, it might have been forgivable, but we were treated to five episodes of trumped up angst, followed by a long distance relationship caused by the woman’s stupidity, but allowed the woman to spend her days with the second male lead while she video chatted with her boyfriend in the evenings. So disappointing.
I really enjoyed this one. Despite the awfully forced ugly kisses and lack of chemistry, it had some great messages…
Watching recent dramas, the societal norm seems to be for women to always put career above relationships and family. You see it over and over and over in recent dramas. For women, jobs make them happy, for men people are more important. That is the new world order, that is what women should aspire to be, that is the new norm.
Yeah, but now I’m confused. Morning sickness usually presents around six weeks. So when does Gyu Jin think this…
I know. It’s just one of those things dramas sometimes do that leaves me scratching my head. “Let’s take it slow.” “Let’s jut date.” “No we’re not thinking of marriage.” “No, no we’re just dating.” Episode after episode. Then, bam, oh look we’re pregnant, and it isn’t a surprise. It leaves me thinking: huh? When did their relationship get to that level? I must have missed it. And how ready are they for a baby if they weren’t ready to remarry?
Yeah, but now I’m confused. Morning sickness usually presents around six weeks. So when does Gyu Jin think this…
Yeah. More confused now, after this weeks episodes. She was so insistent they were just dating, all the way up until now. I’m sorry, what you see in television notwithstanding, conceiving a child is not something most highly educated people with ready access to the technology to prevent accidental birth do while adamant on not committing. Most hope for some form of family there to raise the child before they take chances.
OMO!! OMO!! cannot believe Na Hee is actually pregnant...that is awesome
Yeah, but now I’m confused. Morning sickness usually presents around six weeks. So when does Gyu Jin think this happened? Surely they were divorced more than six weeks ago. Or perhaps their definition of taking it slow isn’t the same as mine :)
I don't think so...they need to do the procedure for that ....I don't think so they did it
Episode 63, I believe. They had just gotten back together. They had drinks and woke up in bed together in the hospital. We have no idea what happened while they were drunk. Perhaps, they do t either.
I don't think so...they need to do the procedure for that ....I don't think so they did it
Episode 63, I believe. They had just gotten back together. They had drinks and woke up in bed together in the hospital. We have no idea what happened while they were drunk. Perhaps, they do t either.
I don’t know if we’ll squeek by without any drama. Will Gyu Jin think the baby is the director’s, after…
I guess I was thinking of episode 63, was it, when they went and had drinks and woke up bed together in the hospital. We have Jim idea what happened. Perhaps neither do they.
I guess Na Hee is pregnant again! I really really hope they wont make it so that she loses baby again.At first…
I don’t know if we’ll squeek by without any drama. Will Gyu Jin think the baby is the director’s, after all he saw them kiss, or so he thinks. He may not remember them sleeping together. Neither of them may. If he even hints that it might be the director’s will Na Hee get upset? Enough to break up?
I really hate the “one guy is her soulmate, a different one her love” concept. What wife would want their husband to have a closer and more emotionally intimate relationship with another woman, and what man would want that with his wife? It makes no sense.
Jan Di’s refusal to tell the man she loved that she liked him was truly spectacular to the point of being unbelievable. At one point in the show Joon Pyo brushes her off in a cruel way, yet it was hard to truly feel bad for her given that he didn’t even know she really cared. She did other things too. She avoided him and hung out with other guys rather than admit she was struggling, then was shocked when she looked like she was cheating. Throughout the show, she suffered, but so much of that suffering was caused by her stubbornness, failure to communicate and her awful handled of her own feelings. It was more frustrating than dramatic, and I don’t like stories built on characters that act in frustratingly illogical ways.
It is fatiguing when the two love interests are at odds with each other for many many episodes. Equally as difficult is when they are on screen together for only a few minutes in a several show stretch. Add to that their being on screen together with the second male or female lead far more than with their main love interest and you just start to wonder who exactly you’re supposed to be rooting to end up with whom. Fatigue sets in when all you get episode after episode is bad stuff, with no good moments to balance it out.
I never understood shows that take you through so much pain and suffering for the main characters only to have them part for multiple years. The “four years later” syndrome really starts to get annoying and predictable after a while and it renders everything that came before it pointless. What was the point of going through so much heartache and struggle to be together, only to not be together in the end. It’s frustrating, not entertaining..
Apparently, being a sweet, lovable, caring person who helps the man she loves heal his disease wasn’t good enough. As happens with predictable regularity in all too many shows, she had to suffer a period apart from him while she repaired her broken self as a menial worker and became an “impressive” cog in the corporate machinery, thereby becaming “good enough” for the man. That message devalues and demeans the love and caring the woman brought to relationship.
The message on the man’s side was equally as messed up. With patience and caring, she helped him overcome his disease. Yet it is never good enough for people in a relationship to help, support, love, and heal one another’s faults. No. All the care she put into healing him had to be utterly undone, she had to make him even worse and separate from him so he could heal himself without her help. Why?
Don’t get me wrong. Overall it was an otherwise good story, but I grow tired of this message that you can’t have a relationship where his support helps her become “impressive” and her caring helps him heal and become whole. Instead we get these contrived periods apart at the end of the story where we learn that women aren’t valuable as people simply by being who you are, they must be exemplary employees or have impressive academic credentials before they can be valued in a relationship.
Rather than his psychologist girlfriend making allowances she becomes disenchanted . What followed was a string of terribly supported reasons why she can’t be with him: they’re from different worlds, she’s been stuck in the same place for the last year, his apology was overboard and didn’t value her work, the ups and downs were too extreme, they aren’t in step with one another, she’s unlucky in love.
On their own the reasons might be valid if backed up by something significant and troubling. In the end it seemed like the writer was flailing, trying to make up some plausible reason why the psychologist girlfriend was adamant in running away from her problems rather than talking it through with her near-perfect boyfriend. To make things worse, she never got past it on her own and had to be badgered into admitting her mistake by her male friend.
Had it been short, it might have been forgivable, but we were treated to five episodes of trumped up angst, followed by a long distance relationship caused by the woman’s stupidity, but allowed the woman to spend her days with the second male lead while she video chatted with her boyfriend in the evenings. So disappointing.