This review may contain spoilers
A chaotic mess, a surprising gem
The return of Suzy and Kim Woo Bin. A duo that once made headlines in uncontrollably fond and remains a fan favorite pairing even to this day. While that particular drama may have had it's issues, it evidently crafted a dynamic so popular it warranted a second go at it. Did the pair succeed in recapturing the same allure that justified their renewed pairing?
Well, to start with, the story is an absolute mess, but it's highly entertaining. Which means that according to any self proclaimed critic I've just committed the ultimate sin; subjective scoring.
I'm not just bringing that up in a vain attempt to sound witty but because this is one of those shows where it's very easy to grade it low and call it a day. I've learned over the past decade that a great show is not always one that tells the greatest story. Korean drama's in particular aim to invoke emotions in you. They do not (usually) aim to tell an oscar worthy story.
This doesn't necessarily mean criticism of the writing of any drama is unwarranted, but that I do not find it to be the most important aspect of a good drama.
This drama is elevated to something really quite special by just two things;
- The believable portrayal of a psychopathic main character.
- A charismatic duo that justified it's existence by strong acting chops, chemistry and camera charisma.
Let me get one thing straight; I absolutely have not and will not research psychopathic behavior to ascertain the accuracy of Genie's portrayal of one. We all know what a stereotypical psychopath is. Genie however aims to tell a different kind of story from the stereotypical. One that, in order to criticize or praise, one would need extensive knowledge about.
I only care about the believability of it. If it's managed to sell me on that then it's a good portrayal to me.
I'm sure a psychologist could analyze this show and find faults in the portrayal but that's not my job nor my desire to care about.
I found the idea that a whole village comes together to quote unquote raise a psychopath into a functioning adult to be highly compelling. Unfortunately the show doesn't go into too much detail about this, but we see the results. We see what it takes for Gayoung to live a life resembling normalcy and the struggle. She often remarks that life is boring. She engages in activities that place her in proximity of death as she's pretty much passively suicidal throughout the entire show. On top of that she actively enjoys the idea of getting hurt or dying as this seems to invoke a strong feeling in her.
I have to shout out Suzy's acting here. She really brought this character to life and she was perfectly cast for this role as it requires a specific type of acting. The way she changed the tone of her voice and articulation was a great touch as well.
This is one of those roles that on the surface might seem like anyone could do because of the lack of expressions required but in reality it's the micro expressions that sell the performance, and Suzy nails it.
I really only think someone like Seo Yea Ji could do a comparable, if not better job but Suzy delivers and shows everyone that she's far different from who she was in earlier works such as Uncontrollably Fond and Gu Family Book.
The whole drama is pure entertainment and especially the first two episodes were an incredible entry to the show. I'd give the combination of those two episodes a 10/10. The show didn't quite keep up that level of quality but it awkwardly weaved in scenes of people making wishes, the unraveling of multiple factions and the really fun scenes of Gayoung being herself or interacting with Genie. Not all of it was done all that well and many times I was a bit lost on what we were actually doing as the scene transitions are really awkward sometimes. That being said it all sort of comes together by the end of it and it has a couple fun and clever uses of foreshadowing, which is something I always appreciate.
I'd have to say the romance aspect was a bit off. It's going to be hard to write a believable romance involving a psychopath.
The show opted for a ''don't tell, don't show'' approach with this. No, seriously, we just don't know why Gayoung wants to be with Genie. She doesn't love Genie (she can't), she doesn't say she likes or loves him (she'd be lying) and she's still constantly trying to hurt him physically (it's played up for jokes but still). I figured what was presumably her first kiss was a new and different sensation that she latched on to, which is why she was so adamant about kissing him again but that's really all I have and the show has for us.
Ultimately Genie, make a wish is a technically flawed show that compensates for that with highly skilled acting and one of the more intriguing leads in recent drama history.
It probably doesn't deserve this high of a score, but I believe it warrants it for the experience it gave me, even if it was flawed.
Well, to start with, the story is an absolute mess, but it's highly entertaining. Which means that according to any self proclaimed critic I've just committed the ultimate sin; subjective scoring.
I'm not just bringing that up in a vain attempt to sound witty but because this is one of those shows where it's very easy to grade it low and call it a day. I've learned over the past decade that a great show is not always one that tells the greatest story. Korean drama's in particular aim to invoke emotions in you. They do not (usually) aim to tell an oscar worthy story.
This doesn't necessarily mean criticism of the writing of any drama is unwarranted, but that I do not find it to be the most important aspect of a good drama.
This drama is elevated to something really quite special by just two things;
- The believable portrayal of a psychopathic main character.
- A charismatic duo that justified it's existence by strong acting chops, chemistry and camera charisma.
Let me get one thing straight; I absolutely have not and will not research psychopathic behavior to ascertain the accuracy of Genie's portrayal of one. We all know what a stereotypical psychopath is. Genie however aims to tell a different kind of story from the stereotypical. One that, in order to criticize or praise, one would need extensive knowledge about.
I only care about the believability of it. If it's managed to sell me on that then it's a good portrayal to me.
I'm sure a psychologist could analyze this show and find faults in the portrayal but that's not my job nor my desire to care about.
I found the idea that a whole village comes together to quote unquote raise a psychopath into a functioning adult to be highly compelling. Unfortunately the show doesn't go into too much detail about this, but we see the results. We see what it takes for Gayoung to live a life resembling normalcy and the struggle. She often remarks that life is boring. She engages in activities that place her in proximity of death as she's pretty much passively suicidal throughout the entire show. On top of that she actively enjoys the idea of getting hurt or dying as this seems to invoke a strong feeling in her.
I have to shout out Suzy's acting here. She really brought this character to life and she was perfectly cast for this role as it requires a specific type of acting. The way she changed the tone of her voice and articulation was a great touch as well.
This is one of those roles that on the surface might seem like anyone could do because of the lack of expressions required but in reality it's the micro expressions that sell the performance, and Suzy nails it.
I really only think someone like Seo Yea Ji could do a comparable, if not better job but Suzy delivers and shows everyone that she's far different from who she was in earlier works such as Uncontrollably Fond and Gu Family Book.
The whole drama is pure entertainment and especially the first two episodes were an incredible entry to the show. I'd give the combination of those two episodes a 10/10. The show didn't quite keep up that level of quality but it awkwardly weaved in scenes of people making wishes, the unraveling of multiple factions and the really fun scenes of Gayoung being herself or interacting with Genie. Not all of it was done all that well and many times I was a bit lost on what we were actually doing as the scene transitions are really awkward sometimes. That being said it all sort of comes together by the end of it and it has a couple fun and clever uses of foreshadowing, which is something I always appreciate.
I'd have to say the romance aspect was a bit off. It's going to be hard to write a believable romance involving a psychopath.
The show opted for a ''don't tell, don't show'' approach with this. No, seriously, we just don't know why Gayoung wants to be with Genie. She doesn't love Genie (she can't), she doesn't say she likes or loves him (she'd be lying) and she's still constantly trying to hurt him physically (it's played up for jokes but still). I figured what was presumably her first kiss was a new and different sensation that she latched on to, which is why she was so adamant about kissing him again but that's really all I have and the show has for us.
Ultimately Genie, make a wish is a technically flawed show that compensates for that with highly skilled acting and one of the more intriguing leads in recent drama history.
It probably doesn't deserve this high of a score, but I believe it warrants it for the experience it gave me, even if it was flawed.
Was this review helpful to you?
