19
27
1
1
1
1
1
2
1
2
Slow burn? More so no-burn...
I fail to understand the high rating on this platform. I like slow romances, I generally don't mind clichés and I didn't expect anything when I started watching this.I also like the quiet type who lets their actions speak for themselves rather than verbally express their feelings.
It's just that here, ML says "I don't like you", ML's actions say "I don't like you" and the script goes "He likes her." We never get much insight into why he is so very reserved, and the few things we do see come in way too late. We also never find out what the characters exactly like about each other, and the reasons they name don't really sound like love, but more like convenience.
As we see them go through several stages in life, there is almost no character development. No matter their relationship status, their dynamics barely change. Hence, I wouldn't say the story has a slow pace, I'd say it has almost no pace, because there is absolutely no progress whatsoever. The couples` chemistry in the very last episode actually was so adorable and I wish we could have had more of that. But it's just not worth going through the 22 episodes before where the characters experience the same things, act the same way and make the same decisions. Not once do they have an honest and open talk with each other. Their whole relationships is so, so unhealthy. I wouldn't use the words toxic or red flag here, because they're young and simply don't know better - but they also never learn from it. Had they shown the characters learn from each other during their relationship, this could have been a decent drama, but maybe 2017 just wasn't the time for a story like that.
As of the year 2025, I don't recommend watching this anymore. You can watch it, but you could also spend your time watching one of the other hundreds school nostalgia dramas that actually show characters growing up and maturing along the way. If you like the school nostalgia trope more than the maturing and coming of age trope, you might love this drama still, but this dramas repetitiveness and overall tone simply failed to catch me.
Was this review helpful to you?
A well-made but pretty standard action watch
What can I say that hasn't been said before? I guess the main point whether you will like watching or not is whether you like the typical action-series tropes or you've grown tired of them.The main principle is interesting but it's obvious they added the last story arch to leave room for a second season and I hate when writers do that. Especially with already having a second season in mind I would've loved to give the main issue of this drama - vigilantism - a lot more room and fully delve into that.
But with the in comparison rather standard plot coming up, it also started to show all the standard issues I have with almost every action series I ever watched. The police are stupid, we have a police officer going rogue yet never really seeing consequences for it. The series overall is utterly violent and I saw a lot more people die than I expected to (yes, I have read the description and watched the trailers, but it's a lot), yet for the sake of the plot people survive the craziest stuff whenever it's needed and heal crazy fast. On the other hand, of course not only the police, but also other characters make the stupidest mistakes just because.
Furthermore, we have tropes like "just in time", "one person attacks at a time" or "talking a bit before the final blow so the other character can rescue themselves" just as "bored evil rich guy" and as these tropes added up, it started to annoy me. The female main character is way over the top, we only gain little insight into her motives way too late and many other characters' motivation stays in the dark as well.
It was a very thrilling and exciting watch with a very good premise, good music and a nice approach to challenging moral principles, especially with how likeable the main character became in the course of the series. Without that main character, everything else would have fallen apart. But after all, MDL is suggesting I give this a 7.5, simply because of all the tropes that in their abundance I cannot overlook.
I am rating this an 8.5 as of now just due to how much I liked it (and I am not sure whether an action series can actually do without all these issues), but that surely has less to say about the quality of the series and more so of my ability to overlook its flaws. With season 2 I am almost sure they will lose track, the plot will become crazy and utterly predictable and a whole lot different than what this series started as, but the first season is watchable without ever having to see another prequel, so don't let that hold you back.
Was this review helpful to you?
In comparison... don't compare | When you should watch this
Disclaimer: I have watched Go ahead but will write this review so anyone can follow no matter their knowledge about the plot.In general, I recommend watching both versions, but it doesn't really matter where you start. If you really hated one of both, though, I won't recommend watching the other as the main parts of the plot stay the same. This isn't a romance drama. It is about family, growing up and redefining what family means to you while going through the process of finding a healthy way to cope with (your) struggles. The plot elaborates perspectives of people at different life stages, although young people of course are the main focus.
While the Chinese version is a lot longer and its plot felt more realistic, this remake managed to resolve or at least smooth out some of the issues I had with the Chinese version (some I didn't even realize I had until I saw this remake). It does come with its own issues though you will need to be able to overlook.
The fewer amount of episodes means, of course, they had to shorten parts of the plot and character development I would have loved to dive deeper into, but overall, it seemed like this version portrayed more of an ideal version of how things should be. Someone in the comments described this version as quite healing and I found that word very fitting.
While many people described the chemistry to be wearing off after the first couple episodes, it was the opposite for me. With the progress of each episode I could also feel each character grow just as their chemistry with each other became more and more apparent. The music was used so well to bring out the emotions of every scene and support the already great acting skills instead of overruling them. For everyone being hesitant, I want to reassure you to stay patient, watch the characters grow and rethink their (past) decisions just as you probably have done in your life, too. While I understand watching this can feel draggy, boring or frustrating to some people, I loved every step of their way.
What I also really loved were the comedic scenes that almost always lit up the atmosphere. The humour was just perfect to me and even though there were heavy scenes of course, overall, almost every episode had something to make me smile or laugh.
As I already watched the story twice in two different versions and liked both, I don't know what should indicate I couldn't watch it a third and fourth and fifth time.
So, as a general recommendation: Don't watch this if you want to watch a pure fast-paced, heavily dramatic romance drama. Don't watch this if family issues trigger you easily. And, of course, don't watch this if you hated the Chinese version.
But go watch it if you want something about family, something deeply emotional, something to make you smile or something to make you overthink your own idea of what defines a family. I for sure will go and call mine now.
Was this review helpful to you?
A lot of potential not fully used
While I agree with most of the criticism mentioned in more sceptical reviews, I was still able to enjoy watching this drama, mainly because I didn't expect much. So here's a heads-up on what to expect before you get disappointed:- E-sports will play a big role and the tournament games will create a lot of the excitement other drama series create differently. I am not knowledgeable enough to determine how realistic everything shown is. To me as an uninformed viewer, it did not feel false, unrealistic or exaggerated.
- There's only little explanation on terminology, so for anyone who doesn't know anything about e-sports, this might not be something you watch easily in-between because following might need focus. I recommend especially looking out for the scenes where they show who plays which character in order to be able to follow the animated scenes.
- From what I've read, it will be different than the novel it's adapting.
Due to the focus on e-sports, I, like many others apparently, felt the emotional side of the story to fall a bit flat. I liked that emotions didn't bubble up constantly, creating a lot of tension and drama and hasty decisions (which I usually find unrealistic and over the top anyways). On the other hand, that also made character and relationship development as well as reactions a bit hard to follow since as a viewer, we do not get a lot of insight into the character's way of thinking and feeling (not saying there is none, it's simply not the focus of the story).
Furthermore, I loved the fact that even the side characters fit well into the story and actually had various and complex relationships with one another instead of fulfilling one designated purpose . The team's dynamics for all the e-sports teams were so nice to see as they each differed and had their own "personality". Each team's dynamics was great and heart-warming to watch.
Speaking of chemistry, the comedic chemistry between all the characters felt great. Xu Kai did a great job of making his character seem interesting and complex despite not showing a lot of emotions openly. The character's dynamics allowed for a lot of comic scenes. The romantic chemistry, on the other hand, could not develop fully as the viewer didn't get enough insight into the characters. It was the romantic relationship issues that I disliked the most as they felt so constructed and weren't resolved well.
What is also playing a role for the story is the public opinion/ fan's influences, which some mentioned to feel exaggerated. I did not feel as it was too much, but rather realistic, especially in regard to the different reactions each character had. (And I say that as a person who doesn't use social media outside of their work because I don't like them and think they are playing a way too important role in our daily life.) I didn't like how certain characters dealt (or didn't deal) with this, though. Here, too, I agree with some of the negative reviews.
Towards the end, and that's where I deducted most points, we did get more of the typical drama moments that felt unneccessary to me as with the fan's and family's reactions, the e-sports games, the (side) characters' stories and the development of the romantic relationships the series had more than enough to create suspension with, which would've been a lot more inventive than the classic tropes it relied on.
Overall, we have a lot to enjoy on the plus side. It is up to you whether you feel like this series wasted its potential, as it didn't execute its positive aspects to the end, or if you are simply glad this series even has those points where other series fall flat immediately. I, personally, think the series would have had to be longer to be able to really follow through with all the different aspects it tried to show, while furthermore not accentuating the focus to where viewers would have preferred to have it. Rationally speaking after having given it some thought, I would rate this series 8/10, but from how much I felt entertained personally while watching, I'll give it a 9/10.
Was this review helpful to you?
Can magic be real? - Ignore the tags and find out yourself
Everything I liked most about this movie turned out to be the things I also disliked the most.The music: Awesome. Until they threw in some just outdated pop-songs and played them almost in full length, ignoring whether it suited the scenes.
The characters: I didn't care about them or their lives, but I genuinely liked them. Until their actions became less and less conclusive.
The concept: Great. But it lacked a story to tell.
The magic: So beautiful and stunning until they exaggerated it. If you know a bit about the "classics" of magic that are also referenced throughout the movie, you'll find nothing new or original here, but it was still nice to watch.
The mystery: Had me genuinely intrigued throughout the whole movie but turned out to be highly underwhelming.
I think you'll enjoy this movie the most if you're looking for something to spend a nice evening with and then forget about it in a couple weeks. For me, it had no message, no relatablility and no red string in terms of storytelling, visuals or music. And of course it's not scientifically accurate in any form.
If you like magic and mysteries, chances are the highest you'll get enjoyment out of watching.
Was this review helpful to you?
Disappointment on detour
Disclaimer: I had to switch to another video after the first half, hence subtitle quality was significantly worse for the second part.The inital idea was quite intriguing: A highly skilled assassin suddenly wakes up in the body of a high school girl. Although she seems to have no intention to find out what happened to her former body or to return to her former life, that part of the plot appeared quite consistently throughout the story until the last quarter of the drama. Since 99.9% of vertical dramas cater to some sort of damsel in distress trope, I was excited to finally find one where the "helpless girl" wasn't the least bit interested in ML's attempts to "save" her.
If you're expecting this kind of plot, you'll end up being disappointed. FL turned into a damsel in distress almost every episode and her only ideas to save herself lied in showing off how pretty she was or turn to some sort of violence. ML's rescue missions relied on his social status and economical power every single time, becoming less and less sophisticated as the drama progressed. If the dialogues hadn't said so, you could have thought the main leads actually hated each other and were trying to rain on each others' parade. With all the attempts to make FL badass and independent, the writers forgot to give her feelings for ML, too. I would've loved to see both team up instead of each doing their own rescue missions neither of them appreciated. And while FL's former life kept being mentioned, it was more of an unexplored plot device than a new spin on an old tale.
If you like pretty leads, the damsel in distress trope and an interesting initial setting, this might be sufficient to entertain you. Still, I recommend watching a vertical drama that's easier to find. The original plot idea isn't worth digging through the web for.
Was this review helpful to you?
Choose your priorities before watching
When it comes to thriller dramas, especially those with limited runtime, you will often find that the screenwriter has to make cuts in certain areas you might find to be crucial.I find that to be the case here, too.
If you're looking for a Japanese thriller where the crime(s) actually are not predictable from the start, I really recommend this one. On the drama side we have a lot going on at the same time, so if you're all about the mysteries that keep building up, you'll be entertained, trying to figure out the puzzle pieces as you go. Although I do feel this drama promised more than it delivered, I was satisfied with the overall resolution of things.
The overall tone is very emotionally heavy and not an easy watch at all, but with so much happening it's really fast-paced and easy to binge. That is, if you're able to endure the mixture of hoping for a happy end and hardly doubting that's even possible at this point.
Music and cinematography were very well-used, the imagery clear with a lot of room to interpret and connect the dots without foreshadowing too much. With few plotholes and unrefurbished visuals, the plot and its delivery are so realistic that everything seems likely. Realism is the main theme overall, while being just artsy enough to allow you to dive deeper if you wish to do so.
Only the characterisations were a bit weak with how much the plot tried to convey in a short amount of time. Hence, any sympathy towards the characters you feel will more likely be based on own experience and the simple knowledge of the grave impact the plot must have on the characters, rather than to be experiencing these things with them.
If you like deducing hints, you will find it easy to imagine why each character acts the way they do, but the focus lies more on how characters deal with what is thrown at them.
As I have been listening to the drama's OST these past days, with every song I also remembered scenes from the drama and the mood it conveyed. It's a perfect example of how big of a role music plays in creating a lasting impression.
Masaru Yokoyama, the main contributor for the OSTs, is known for his soundtracks for popular anime like Anthem of the Heart or Your Lie in April and his experience really showed.
I recommend watching if you're interested in looking behind what you see on screen, questioning motives and facts and your own perception or if you want to be emotionally affected heavily. Your investment is likely to leave a lasting impression.
Was this review helpful to you?
How can nothing be so good at being everything?
Everything about this movie screamed "this is not for you", but I decided to start watching anyways. If you too are wondering whether you should watch, here's a couple points to consider.Having read all the reviews about this being a calm slice of life countryside movie, I thought my hyperactive brain could never focus on this. And I won't lie, the first 30 minutes felt like an hour. But at the same time, I didn't want this movie to end.
I don't like movies for a dozen reasons so it's rare that I watch any, and I never would have thought I'd like a movie where absolutely nothing happens. Turns out, when life is being crazy, nothing happening can be a blessing. I just wanted to immerse myself in the images and never stop looking at how beautiful they were, be it large wide or close-up shots.
Nonetheless, it is not the indeed very beautiful scenery that's this movie's biggest strength.
I also have ARFID, which is roughly the complicated word for "picky eater" and "dislikes food". So me admitting that after watching this I want to try almost every dish they showed is the biggest compliment I could ever make about someone else's cooking.
Regarding the characters, as much as I disapproved of the FL's decisions at times, I was still able to like her as a character. Maybe, sometimes we judge someone's decisions on the grounds that we wish we could do the same but feel we can't. The FL's acting fit her character really well and conveyed the character's love for cooking and nature convincingly enough to make you want to join her. All side characters and their interactions felt very realistic and there wasn't a single character I disliked - not even the ones I thought I'd hate after the first couple minutes.
The biggest selling point of this movie though is that it doesn't romanticize the countryside, nor does it make it look terrible. It's able to portray that to some people, the pros simply outweigh the cons without failing to demonstrate the cons have to be addressed nonetheless. While we actually see characters addressing their issues instead of just mentioning them, the movie never even once loses its calm, relaxing, inviting and healthy atmosphere. And while it feels like nothing happened at all, looking back at the end you will find that, just like the seasons, things indeed have changed.
I'd recommend watching this if you:
- Like slice of life and calmness
- Ever thought about moving to the countryside or enjoy being in nature.
- Like food OR don't like food and want to change that
- Want to take your time. If you quickly want to watch something, you won't be able to enjoy watching. Sit back and wait for this movie to have its effects on you.
PS: No need to get the snacks out. After being twenty minutes in, I put aside my chocolate because I suddenly craved a salad.
Was this review helpful to you?
Well-made story losing potential in execution
The story of this short drama was what I imagine is pretty close to today's teenage lifes. Except all the not-studying, but I guess nobody wants to see that. That means, if you don't like the typical teenage drama, you won't like this one. Had this been an American series or a series in full length, I probably never would have watched beyond the trailer. I'm glad I watched though as even understanding I'm not the target audience this felt like a cute youth-series that a teenager might really like.Story-wise, I thought it was really good, with an interesting premise executed well overall. The pacing was a bit off in the middle as it seemed a bit slower then suddenly picked up rapidly for the last two episodes. To me, the ending didn't feel rushed, but the middle part definitely was a bit slow.
Other than that, the message here wasn't out of the ordinary, but very nice, and I loved the friendships between all characters, but both FLs especially. Although the identity swap of both FLs was the focus point, we got at least short insight into all other character's stories which allowed for a wider picture to make the message more relatable and convincing. Unlike many others, I didn't dislike the FL's personality and found it to be realistic as I do know people like that irl. With changing dynamics, the chemistry between characters changed, too, but sometimes seemed to be lagging behind the relationship status.
Watching this felt like eating a fancy dish you put a lot of effort into making just to realize you forgot to add salt. So many scenes were so slow. Slow walking, slow camera movements, slow focus onto the faces, slow responses. Every dialogue felt like it took twice the time it would take in real life. It was odd and made many characters look a lot more stupid than they were.
The actors are young, playing even younger characters, most of them also had their debut with this and it sadly showed. You could see they tried hard, but with all those slow scenes focusing on their barely existent facial expressions, it was like the direction put a spotlight on the one thing they shouldn't have highlighted. Maybe they were trying to play the face card, but that doesn't work on me. Even when I was a teenager I wouldn't have been happy looking at the same "pretty" straight face for six hours on end.
It's a cute, calm and slow teenage drama with young actors acting almost their age. If you want something to watch between heavier stuff, you won't be making a bad choice watching this.
Was this review helpful to you?
Almost no reason not to watch it
I watched this show when I didn't have time in-between to watch a full episode of other series and I liked it a lot more than I initially thought. The story isn't very original or complex, let alone logical, but it's sweet. I usually don't like the misunderstanding trope that is heavily relied upon here to drive the story, but they actually solved it considerably well and quickly. Overall, this is a series with not much drama, angst or red flags/toxicity. The main character still had her backstory, although I wished to see her grow a bit more.The acting wasn't top-notch, but not horrible either, and I'm almost sure they exaggerated certain expressions on purpose to make it funny (as it was). After all, I wish this was a tad longer, because I really enjoyed watching.
I would recommend watching it on platforms other than YouTube, though, as the music is almost nonexistent and they had to remove the lyrics. I watched the later episodes on a different platform which really improved the show's atmosphere.
Was this review helpful to you?
Left my brain at home to enjoy this
This felt like one of the stories dissatisfied housewives read in between the struggles of their daily life. It's got action, sensuality and mystery but yet needed not a single brain cell to be able to follow. Maybe it's because as a bookworm with never enough reading material I grew up reading books like that and hence gotten used to overlook plotholes and red flags as if I was half-blind that I was actually able to enjoy this as much as I did.This was a mess. The relationships between characters were wildly unhealthy, to say the least, and consent was in the grey area most of the times. If red is your favourite colour, go watch this.
While many details were so well-made such as the choice and use of music, small hints, complex entanglement and a generally pretty stable concept for the action-part of the plot, it at the same time had plotholes the size of Sagittarius A*. The amount of coincidences and dumb decisions was crazy.
People pointed out the lacking acting of the FL but I honestly have no clue how the story could have worked with a character that actually seemed to care about what was happening around her. The ML did a good job at acting, though, he actually did display emotions quite well when suited. From how much I enjoyed this series, I would rate this a 7 or even higher, but my own morals won't allow to rate something with so many red flags higher than a 6.5.
I recommend watching if you want an easy action-packed watch that's nice on the eyes, has some spicy scenes and a little mystery. With the short episodes it's very easy to breeze through on a bad day. Even if you find nothing else to like, the stupidity of some scenes might make you laugh.
That being said, if you're easily triggered by questionable consent or want an action-packed plot with less holes than fishnet tights, I recommend you pass on this one.
Was this review helpful to you?
Sadly not the best of both worlds
For whatever reason I was hoping for this to be similar to Unforgettable Love. A nonsensical, sweet story with adorable characters to just watch for fun. This series never aspired to be that and I never should have treated it as such from the start.I would separate this series into two quite different parts, although both happened at the same time with different prioritisation throughout the episodes. They seemed to follow different intentions and appeal to different tastes, which might be good if you are consciously looking for several very different emotions, intensities and tropes in one series, but honestly, I didn't. I wanted to watch a sweet cute family romance so that second part sadly failed to catch me.
Regarding the "first" part: The kids were cute and the overall acting skills of all characters were pretty good. The main lead however didn't seem to have the full bandwith of emotions in his acting repertoire. He was so good with sincerity, sadness and consternation, but his smile really wasn't to die for or even to be taken seriously.
The developing friendships and other relationships were such a nice watch and probably the only reason I still enjoyed the drama as much as I did. The two main leads had great chemistry - as best friends. They did things most people would not consider appropriate to do with a best friend like kissing, holding hands and such, but their overall interaction to me felt like exactly that. I didn't think they properly showed the development of their romantic feelings for each other, it came quite abrupt for me, and the following scenes couldn't make up for that. At times, I rooted a lot more for the second (and hinted third) couple, but that arch turned a bit too childish for me at a certain point. Overall, I wasn't fully satisfied with either couples, but would have given this drama a solid 7.5 if it had been only that for the sweet kids and the great friendships forming among the way - as well as the relationships that weren't too intense, sweet or romantic, but nice to watch.
Regarding the "second" part: They tried to bring mystery, suspension and a connecting common theme into this and I frankly didn't enjoy it. It was very exciting, very dramatic, but first, again, that wasn't what I initially came for, and second, it was simply too much. The drama either was too short to display both sides of the plot evenly well, or too long to go with just one of both. The couples barely had a few actually happy moments with each other as the next bad thing happend. And the next. And another. I don't recall a single episode where we could simply see them grow as a family. It was never a small mishap or short drama easily resolved, it was plottwist after plottwist after huge dramatic events - and most of them were quite foreseeable. The connecting common theme was quite obvious quite early on but was artificially exaggerated to create so (so) much tension when it would have fully fit into that sweet family story without all that extra drama.
Now, if you think this would actually suit your taste quite well because you love one thing happening after the other, the suspension, the drama - let me warn you, the first half might bore you to death. If, on the other hand, you are looking for a sweet cute family drama - you might never want to finish this, just as I ended up watching this while doing chores to just get it over with. (Which didn't do it justice, the last episodes were convincingly thrilling and would've made a pretty decent thriller series.) Be prepared to see both and you might be happier than I was.
Now, for the overall quality, both parts seperately, I would rate this a 7 at least. But the amount of reluctance every time I started a new episode because I was hoping for something sweet but figured I'd get served something sour once again wasn't all too appealing to me.
Was this review helpful to you?
Short, but full of potential
There is absolutely no reason not to recommend watching if you are looking for a short diversion.The initial setting wasn't to my liking but I liked the almost philosophical implications that came with it. The end of course was highly predictable, but even though it wasn't my preferred way of closure, I was fine with how it turned out. Just know that there is some suspense, especially towards the end, it is not just a sweet short romance story.
You can leave your brain at home watching this, but it's not like the series isn't giving you a chance to dive deeper into it if you prefer to do so.
Speaking of diving in deeper: What I don't understand is why they had to make the supernatural abilities so inconsistent. There were huge gaps between scenes. The special effects of course weren't brilliantly made either. Call me nitpicky, but it's so sad that a few minor changes could've fixed those.
Furthermore, I just didn't see the main leads as a couple, maybe because there just wasn't enough time to get to know the characters. But I liked the side characters a lot more than the main leads so I guess it was more of an issue of chemistry and personal preference.
On the up side, it made me smile and even laugh a couple times, so as a cheer-up drama, this fulfils its purpose well enough. There were no massive red flags, no overexertion of misunderstandings and drama, no side storys left in the grey, no grave plotholes. And despite naturally being foreseeable, it's not trope-packed either. Hence it was able to avoid many of the biggest hurdles for short series and I clearly enjoyed watching.
Was this review helpful to you?
A worthwhile watch to pass some time
I am glad I took my time to watch this series , hence it already accomplished what it was meant for. Considering it was their debut I think the actors did a decent job. The chemistry betweem them both was definitely there and it was addictingly satisfying to watch their relationship grow in the course of this series.The end did seem rushed, but, honestly, even series of 20 or more episodes manage to rush their end similarly, so I will give them the benefit of the doubt and blame it on the limited time they had to deal with. I really think the plot would have benefited from more episodes.
Lack of time also muddled up a lot of the story. The characters had depth to them due to their background stories being shown, the development was there, but there was just no time to mend all the lose ends, display the characters motives, thoughts, emotions and growth.
Contrary to other reviews, I did not mind the characters not being more physical with each other - I actually appreciated that. But even with the actors not feeling comfortable with physical intimacy on screen, there could have been solutions other than hinting at doing it without ever following through. For them to grow so close with nothing actually happening, it would have needed to further get into why they decided to keep it low like that.
As for my recommendations: If you hate the "developing a liking for your bully" trope, you might want to reconsider whether you really want to watch. I dislike it a lot, but can deal with it if the turning point is made well and the bullying stops as soon as there is a first hint of sympathy. I percieved that to be the case, so I was able to overlook it.
If you consider watching, adjust your expectations to the limited time available to tell a rather complex story and you'll probably be satisfied. If you expect a drama where every detail fits, the setting would have to be entirely different to enable that with so few episodes.
Was this review helpful to you?
I've never been so ambivalent about a series
I didn't know anything about this series when I started watching it years ago. And to me, personally, it was hard to get into every single time I picked it up again. But after the first half episode, I watched several episodes in a row, because something about it had me hooked. Just to then forget about the series again for a while.So, will I watch the second season? Honestly, I don't know, but since it's only 8 episodes, I might, simply because I like the initial concept.
Most important to say is this: this is not about revenge. Or justice. It's just like real life - outsiders and innocents get their share of consequences, too. . But that is also where the series failed to catch me.
In general, I liked the idea behind it. It was to show that anyone can be manipulated into doing horrible things, it was about group dynamics, social pressure and the lenghts some people would go to to preserve what's important to them - as well as digging into people's fake facades and their reasoning behind it. But even though the message mostly was very clear and hence delivered well - it wasn't convincing.
With messages like that, they can only leave a long-lasting impact if people identify with the situations. If they feel like "oh, that could have been me" or "I probably would have acted the same", but I never thought that with any episode I watched.
1) Nanno was the catalyst of all the scenarios, which I would have been fine with, but
2) At times, the outcomes were so unrealistic, they had to give her mysterious magic powers to explain the escalation of a situation
3) These mysterious magic powers in itself were weirdly inconsistent between and in episodes so everything could go as the writers wanted it to
4) Which added a ton of smaller and bigger plotholes and incomplete settings, making the whole scenario pitted like swiss cheese
5) Yet the writers often shunned away from happy ends just as much as sad endings - and while sometimes this lead to a great open ending to make up your own mind, some endings felt very people-pleasing (like "choose whatever ending you'd prefer")
The quality of the episodes differs vastly and so does the acting. While "Nanno" is doing a great job throughout, many of the side characters don't. The horror elements and special effects often were terrible, even for me, and I hate violence and gore anyways and prefer my series to go light with these if needed for the story.
As I had a four year gap between watching the first and the last episode, I realised that I barely remembered any of the episodes I watched four years ago, which is highly untypical for me. There couldn't be better proof on how few impact it was able to create on me.
Do I recommend watching it? If you like the concept in general and don't mind a... questionable execution, absolutely. If you are looking for a high-quality production in terms of consistency, I'd say you could only enjoy watching if you are able to ignore a ton of plotholes and incomplete settings.
Was this review helpful to you?
