KingLouie

Turns out, everyone watching has a theory, it shows how much invested we are in this show..LOL.

Thanks you for recommending. This is my first drama of Ji Hye. So i wanted to watch her more after this..

I hate netflix, it took away from me the fun to watch Kdramas..

Me too. It was not necessary. I think if they just made their last scene more touching, or warm.. it would have been nice rather than the sudden kiss and prompt love confession.

It was fun to watch . Not the 10/10 type ( i think it was not supposed to be). But it was totally worth the time..

IU, you will be the death of me...LOL>>

I think there is a couple like that in #Melodramatic, and they are not hiding it at all..

I don't think that there was relationship like that in Search WWW. It was misleading at first but they soon revealed that their relationship was more platonic, as one thought the other a only person who cares for her, owed her big time and didn't want to disappoint her. First few scenes they did to mislead us or to make us feel giddy..LOL.. but that was all there was to it..

I agree with @KpoppedByMyMicrowave .. Hwi Young parents invested in it. Remember the scene where Hwi Young was telling his mother to let him handle the trip as he is the class president and his mother told him she will take care of it and then made a call. It infidelity was her mother's doing. Hwi Young going to the trip is not mystery too. His group said they will go but won't get involved in time wasting stuff and this was the reason Jun Woo and Hwi Young made two groups. And the fact that the trip was compulsory to everyone.

I love this drama, its cute, strong, and beautiful concept. All the characters are portrayed nicely and main leads are interesting to watch.

Dong Jo at the street meeting her (children..LOL) and realizing how much they cared for her and then again by the river, God, she can act. It was so painful to watch her.
What was more heartbreaking is that she wished her mother to be healthy and happy and that she won't try to find her anymore. It was beautiful yet painful. Maybe Dong Jo is the kindest/purest character i have ever seen. It doesn't make sense that she is so naive and kind, but Han Ji Hye made it look so real. I begin to believe that Han Ji Hye is actually like that. LOL..Superb girl..

Ohhhh, did we just discover another secret..
Secretary Han and Chairwoman Jin's husband had a child.. she left that child in orphanage,
Is it Oh Mi Jo.. it looks like her to me..

Thats what good in a drama like this, they focus on every character. Dong Joo's friend, Chairwoman Jin and her love life, secretary Han, Pil Seung's partner.. every one of them.. and give the main leads enough screen time to make them leads..

I feel so bad for Dong Joo. She is such a nice person and she will be hurt more and more in the upcoming epsiodes..

That's what i felt during those episodes too, but i don't want to spoil more for you..LOL..
Profile pic it all thanks to Louie, i thought of changing it, but then i remembered the drama and kept it..haha

My theory has loopholes, mainly is that how on earth did she find a knife. Its not like she was carrying it all along.
The theory about him being gay is also interesting. Just like you said, it might have been Maestro who tool the pictures, and maybe Yi-Young knew about them that's why she seems so close to Kim Ian in Pics.
But that means that father killed his son. Otherwise nobody has the motive to do so. That means they made culprit someone else instead of Yi-Young. But what not connecting is that, they wouldn't have known that Yi-Young would lose her memory. If Yi-Young was witness of anything, why spare her. Unless there is a reason to keep her alive, maybe she have some sort of secret that they want to know thats why they are spying on her.

Well, this is getting interesting. LOL.. lot of theories. lot of drama..hahah
I hope the story turns out to be different from all the theories. then it would make it more interesting to watch.

I love this drama so much. Its been a while i have been invested in the story of a drama so much. And reading these comments, i feel i am not the only one. Everyone is hsaring their theories but i couldn't connect anything. But after watching episode 12. I got my theory.

It is far-fetched and maybe some people might hate to think in that direction. So if you don't want to mess up your mind, don't read. LOL..

I think there is one thing that has been hidden in this drama from the start. Theories regarding foundation corruption, nepotism do make sense, but when you consider that Kim Ian was the son of chairman who had the most authority (episode 11,12) its hard to digest why would a powerful man's son will be replaced by self-made person (Nam Jo Wan) and why would his father cover up his own son's murder.

My guess is that Kim Ian was the culprit. (yes, i said it..LOL)
He abducted her or something (or forced himself on her), and kidnapped her and she probably stabbed him in self-defense. Nam-Jo-Wan might have known the intentions of Kim Ian and he followed them when he learned Yi-Young left with Kim Ian after the party. Father covered the murder as an accident because he didn't want to reveal what his son did. They made another person culprit even though Yi-Young statement was there where she said she might have killed him. Because if they caught Yi-Young, investigation would have been done and there was a chance Yi-Young might remember something. And that would ruin the reputation of father and music foundation.

It doesn't make sense that as soon as Kim Ian lands, he starts telling Yi-Young his real name. Yi-Young's friend only know that yi-young only picked him from airport. While Jang-Yoon have the pictures of them like they have been together for some time. (weird).

Everyone including father, Nam-Jo-Wan, Jang-Yoon accomplice CEO, and apparently everybody knows about Yi-Young having memory loss and being in an accident with Kim Ian. If they know she was the murderer why would they blame the driver guy and bail him out and keep spying on Yi-Young knowing that Jang-Yoon is trying to make Yi-Young remember everything.

That's what i think. Kim Ian was not a good person and people close to him knew. Jang-Yoon didn't really knew Kim Ian because they were not close. Nam-Jo-Wan might have known as they were close (another theory, that they liked each other..). He knew Yi-Young and that's why he ran after them. Plus if Kim Ian was killed to not let him become the maestro, then why wait 1 year to make Nam-Jo-Wan the maestro.

To me these things relate to my theory.
I really really hope that it is wrong, otherwise it would be too painful of a memory for Yi-Young and would be sad for Jang-Yoon because he made her remember. I don't want them. I don't like jang-Yoon character already, if this theory comes true and Jang-Yoon is the one who helps Yi-Young remember this painful memory, i might hate him more ( i mean the character, not the actor).

There is this natural thing, that even if you are not a very skilled teacher, you just gets bonded with the student. They way most of his class students were happy to hear him coming back.. That's what matters the most being a teacher i think.. that any student feels comfortable and looks up to you, can share his/her struggles with the mind that he/she won't be judged..

Seriously, i was thinking the same, dude..what wrong with you...LOL..
I think she just have inferiority complex and it might have something to do with her father etc. But they all said she hails from good background, but it was surprising to see how she was treating her father,,
Also i seconds @Maria712...

The main couple is so cute and sweet, they definitely look good together with amazing chemistry...