Started with promise, ended in frustration
If you're someone who truly appreciates a solid psychological thriller — the kind that twists your mind and keeps your eyes glued to the screen — then sadly, this might not be the right drama for you.
“Hunter with a Scalpel” starts with immense potential. The initial episodes are crafted with attention, suspense, and intrigue. They really pull you in and make you think you’re in for something deep, intense, and mind-bending. But as the series progresses, the disappointment slowly creeps in.
Once you understand the direction the plot is taking, things begin to fall flat. Unlike some thrillers where knowing the killer adds tension, in this drama, the predictability kills the suspense. The excitement fades. There's no compelling psychological grip — just frustration.
Let’s talk about Dr. Seo Se Hyeon, played by Park Ju Hyun. Now this is subjective, but her portrayal didn’t work for me. I get that the character is meant to have layers, but all I got was a lot of wide-eyed expressions without emotional depth. It didn’t feel like she became the character — more like she was just acting it, and that disconnect really hurt the immersion.
Then there’s the bizarrely relaxed police chief, who treats a string of gruesome murders as if they were minor pickpocket cases. That totally breaks the realism. A psychological crime drama demands intensity — but here, the tension is barely there because the response from the law enforcement side is so dull and casual.
The biggest issue, though? The writing. The plot idea is actually strong, but it’s let down by weak execution. In a genre that thrives on psychological complexity and mental chaos, this drama gives you neither. It just follows a straight line after the reveal, without taking the viewer on a real emotional or intellectual journey.
I watched it live as it aired, which is probably the only reason I stayed until the end. The first few episodes did give hope, and that kept me going. But looking back, there are far better psychological dramas out there that I’d recommend over this one any day.
“Hunter with a Scalpel” starts with immense potential. The initial episodes are crafted with attention, suspense, and intrigue. They really pull you in and make you think you’re in for something deep, intense, and mind-bending. But as the series progresses, the disappointment slowly creeps in.
Once you understand the direction the plot is taking, things begin to fall flat. Unlike some thrillers where knowing the killer adds tension, in this drama, the predictability kills the suspense. The excitement fades. There's no compelling psychological grip — just frustration.
Let’s talk about Dr. Seo Se Hyeon, played by Park Ju Hyun. Now this is subjective, but her portrayal didn’t work for me. I get that the character is meant to have layers, but all I got was a lot of wide-eyed expressions without emotional depth. It didn’t feel like she became the character — more like she was just acting it, and that disconnect really hurt the immersion.
Then there’s the bizarrely relaxed police chief, who treats a string of gruesome murders as if they were minor pickpocket cases. That totally breaks the realism. A psychological crime drama demands intensity — but here, the tension is barely there because the response from the law enforcement side is so dull and casual.
The biggest issue, though? The writing. The plot idea is actually strong, but it’s let down by weak execution. In a genre that thrives on psychological complexity and mental chaos, this drama gives you neither. It just follows a straight line after the reveal, without taking the viewer on a real emotional or intellectual journey.
I watched it live as it aired, which is probably the only reason I stayed until the end. The first few episodes did give hope, and that kept me going. But looking back, there are far better psychological dramas out there that I’d recommend over this one any day.
Was this review helpful to you?
