Alchemy of Souls Season 2: Light and Shadow
82 people found this review helpful
Story/ Plot/ Script: 9
Acting/ casting: 9
Character development: 9
Production quality/ budget management: 10
Enjoyment/ impact: 10
10=perfection 9=exceptional 8=really good 7=solid 6=it's fine 5=meh, forgettable 4=simply bad 3=waste of time 2=brain-rot 1=garbage
Was this review helpful to you?
Story/ Plot/ Script: 8
Acting/ casting: 9
Character development: 8
Production quality/ budget management: 9
Enjoyment/ impact: 8
10=perfection 9=exceptional 8=really good 7=solid 6=it's fine 5=meh, forgettable 4=simply bad 3=waste of time 2=brain-rot 1=garbage
Was this review helpful to you?
Story/ Plot/ Script: 6
Acting/ casting: 6
Character development: 6
Production quality/ budget management: 6
Enjoyment/ impact: 5
10=perfection 9=exceptional 8=really good 7=solid 6=it's fine 5=meh, forgettable 4=simply bad 3=waste of time 2=brain-rot 1=garbage
Was this review helpful to you?
Story/ Plot/ Script: 8
Acting/ casting: 8
Character development: 9
Production quality/ budget management: 8
Enjoyment/ impact: 9
10=perfection 9=exceptional 8=really good 7=solid 6=it's fine 5=meh, forgettable 4=simply bad 3=waste of time 2=brain-rot 1=garbage
Was this review helpful to you?
Story/ Plot/ Script: 6
Acting/ casting: 7
Character development: 6
Production quality/ budget management: 8
Enjoyment/ impact: 5
10=perfection 9=exceptional 8=really good 7=solid 6=it's fine 5=meh, forgettable 4=simply bad 3=waste of time 2=brain-rot 1=garbage
Was this review helpful to you?
Good potential but…
First of all, I enjoyed this drama, but it it had many flaws.I don’t understand the amount of hate this show got. Why an actress has to apologize for her characters actions, I will never understand. That is acting. They are not the same as the character. Apart from that, I didn’t see a need for even the character to apologize. It may be common in China to obey your parents, but I personally felt that the parents’ requests went too far. They were just as willing to lose her because of their pride, as they were accusing her of being willing to lose her family. If you love your child, you would want them to be happy. I saw online that she was called rebellious and willful, but in my opinion, she was very cowardly. She learned to stand up for herself only towards the end of the drama.
Things I enjoyed:
Overall storyline was good.
Leads acting, started rocky, but improved a lot
Made an effort with the firefighting scenes
I liked the depiction of brotherhood in the firefighting house.
Character development was good with both main characters. Female lead gained a backbone towards the end and male lead became less prideful.
Chemistry between the main characters was OK
Things I disliked:
Waaay too long, could’ve been 20 episodes shorter, I got bored many times
Acting of main male character could’ve been better (although I don’t understand the massive hate, it wasn’t that bad)
The medical scenes were a disaster, they didn’t even try to be medically accurate. In an emergency situation, as a doctor you just don’t stand around stating the obvious.
May be a cultural difference, but as I said before I couldn’t understand the female leads family. They expected a slave instead of a daughter. Why would you be so willing to lose your daughter, just to control her?
The brothers storyline felt weird to me
Was this review helpful to you?
Enjoyable but acting is lacking
I did enjoy this drama. I like the storyline and overall pacing. I didn’t get bored in between, which often happens with cdramas because they are so long. I’m not interested in gaming, but the drama managed to keep me engaged during those parts.I was disappointed with the acting. Both female and male leads were very stony faced and had an overall lack of emotions. The show was dubbed, which already annoys me, so when the facial expressions do not convey emotions that are not possible to convey with ones voice, the acting looks flat. I also didn’t feel the passion between the main leads and didn’t believe they were really in love. it feels more like young first love than anything serious.
Nevertheless, I still enjoyed it for what it was. My expectations were not very high, so I wasn’t overly disappointed. It managed to keep my attention which is a great plus. Even though sometimes it was overly sweet, I still felt giddy at times.
Was this review helpful to you?
Story/ Plot/ Script: 9
Acting/ casting:10
Character development: 10
Production quality/ budget management:10
Enjoyment/ impact: 10
(plus points for the OST)
10=perfection 9=exceptional 8=really good 7=solid 6=it's fine 5=meh, forgettable 4=simply bad 3=waste of time 2=brainrot 1=garbage
Was this review helpful to you?
Story/ Plot/ Script: 7
Acting/ casting: 6
Character development: 7
Production quality/ budget management: 6
Enjoyment/ impact: 7
10=perfection 9=exceptional 8=really good 7=solid 6=it's fine 5=meh, forgettable 4=simply bad 3=waste of time 2=brain-rot 1=garbage
Was this review helpful to you?
Story/ Plot/ Script: 7
Acting/ casting: 7
Character development: 8
Production quality/ budget management: 8
Enjoyment/ impact: 8
10=perfection 9=exceptional 8=really good 7=solid 6=it's fine 5=meh, forgettable 4=simply bad 3=waste of time 2=brain-rot 1=garbage
Was this review helpful to you?
Story/ Plot/ Script: 6
Acting/ casting: 6
Character development: 5
Production quality/ budget management: 7
Enjoyment/ impact: 6
10=perfection 9=exceptional 8=really good 7=solid 6=it's fine 5=meh, forgettable 4=simply bad 3=waste of time 2=brain-rot 1=garbage
Was this review helpful to you?
Story/ Plot/ Script: 8
Acting/ casting: 8
Character development: 8
Production quality/ budget management: 9
Enjoyment/ impact: 8
10=perfection 9=exceptional 8=really good 7=solid 6=it's fine 5=meh, forgettable 4=simply bad 3=waste of time 2=brain-rot 1=garbage
Was this review helpful to you?
Story/ Plot/ Script: 7
Acting/ casting: 7
Character development: 7
Production quality/ budget management: 8
Enjoyment/ impact: 6
10=perfection 9=exceptional 8=really good 7=solid 6=it's fine 5=meh, forgettable 4=simply bad 3=waste of time 2=brain-rot 1=garbage
Was this review helpful to you?
Story/ Plot/ Script: 8
Acting/ casting: 9
Character development: 8
Production quality/ budget management: 8
Enjoyment/ impact: 8
10=perfection 9=exceptional 8=really good 7=solid 6=it's fine 5=meh, forgettable 4=simply bad 3=waste of time 2=brain-rot 1=garbage
Was this review helpful to you?
Story/ Plot/ Script: 7
Acting/ casting: 7
Character development: 8
Production quality/ budget management: 8
Enjoyment/ impact: 8
10=perfection 9=exceptional 8=really good 7=solid 6=it's fine 5=meh, forgettable 4=simply bad 3=waste of time 2=brain-rot 1=garbage
Was this review helpful to you?