Sweet, tender, and handled with a care I didn't expect
I could have watched these two for a lot longer than the series allowed. That's probably the most honest thing I can say about it.What stayed with me most wasn't the romance itself — though the chemistry between the leads is genuinely lovely — but how the series treats Shao Peng's deafness. Not as tragedy, not as a plot device to generate sympathy, but as something that simply belongs to him. The frustration of job searching, the optimistic front that masks real uncertainty — it's handled with a specificity that felt respectful to me personally, even as someone who can't fully assess how accurate it is to lived experience. The fact that this story exists and was told this way matters.
My one personal gripe is the mafia backdrop surrounding Zi Xiang. It could have been almost anything else and the story would have worked just as well — probably better, honestly, since that element always felt slightly out of place against the quieter emotional register of everything else. Fortunately it never takes over, and what the series is actually about — two people, their warmth, the way they move around each other — remains front and center throughout.
Sometimes the story around the couple is the weakest part, and the couple is more than enough. This is one of those times.
Was this review helpful to you?
Wes Anderson made a BL series in southern China and nobody told me
That's not literally what happened, but it's the closest I can get to describing what this series felt like to watch. The colours, the framing, the unhurried way it moves through lychee orchards and starlit nights and two people slowly finding their way toward something neither of them has words for yet — it has a visual and emotional language that feels genuinely cinematic rather than televisual. I caught myself pausing it more than once just to sit with a single frame.What the series captures so well for me is the specific texture of first feelings — the kind that are all possibility and vulnerability, that exist in shared art and quiet proximity before they become anything nameable. Young love at its most unguarded.
And then the crack appears. The moment where the real world remembers it exists, where a summer has to reckon with what it actually was and what it can be beyond itself. That shift is handled with a restraint that I found genuinely affecting — it doesn't overdramatise, it just lets the weight land.
This is not a typical BL series. It's closer to a small film that happens to also be a love story, and I mean that as the highest possible compliment. One of the most visually and emotionally complete things I've watched in this genre.
Was this review helpful to you?
Charming, but Over Before It Truly Begins
There's something genuinely sweet about the setup here. A misunderstood first love that fell apart under unfortunate circumstances, seven years of distance, and then a job interview — for a dating simulation game, of all things — that puts them back in the same room. That kind of quiet narrative irony works for me, and the series has its heart in exactly the right place.The problem is purely one of space. Ten to fifteen minutes per episode, eight episodes total — by the time I'd settled in it was already ending. There's a version of this story that has room to breathe, to let the reunion develop with the weight it deserves, to give the characters time to actually process what seeing each other again means. This version doesn't quite have that luxury, and it shows.
I don't think that's a failure of writing or performance — what's there is warm and handled well. It's more that the format works against the emotional ambitions of the story. Some narratives need more than two hours to land properly, and second-chance romance is almost always one of them.
Left me wanting more in the most literal sense possible. Which is either a compliment or a frustration depending on how you look at it — for me personally, it was a little of both.
Was this review helpful to you?
A Beautiful Escape with a Heartfelt Romance
The setting alone got me. A small island off Taipei, surfer-hippie atmosphere, a family ice cream shop, a father's airbnb — the kind of place my mind drifts to when I think about disappearing somewhere and starting over. The series understood exactly what it had in that location and used it well.What makes it genuinely strong for me are the characters. Everyone here was given room to actually be someone — layered, contradictory, real in the way people are real — and because of that you understand the pull between them without being told to feel it. The intimate scenes landed harder than I expected, warm and familiar in a way that suggested two people who actually like each other. That's rarer than it should be.
My personal sticking point is with the wish as a narrative engine. It drew me in at the start and I appreciated what it made possible — there's a conversation between a son and his father at a fish market that I found quietly beautiful. But somewhere along the way it started to feel more like a constraint than a gift, and there were moments where my patience with it frayed. For me it would have worked better treated like a fever dream that shakes something loose rather than the central mechanism driving everything forward.
A little Groundhog Day, a little Taiwanese indie film, and a lot of genuine warmth. The heart of it is real.
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
Beautifully Shot, Emotionally Powerful, Yet Frustratingly Flawed
The central love story between Qi Lu and Qin Xiao has a quiet depth that I found genuinely moving. Every small touch carries weight, and the visual language is so carefully composed that I paused it more than once to sit with a single frame. That doesn't happen often. The darkness surrounding them — a father who sees his son not as a person but as an instrument, who takes out his bitterness on the child left behind — sits heavily in exactly the way it should.The second couple is where my experience started to fracture. After See Your Love handled deafness with such care and specificity, watching it reduced here to a plot point that gets resolved with a hearing aid — and then quietly forgotten, no more sign language, no more acknowledgment — felt like a step backwards that I couldn't ignore. The dynamic between them also never convinced me personally, and there's a particular element to their history that I found genuinely difficult to move past.
What frustrated me most though is a storytelling choice near the end that I have limited patience for in any series: one character deciding unilaterally to cause pain in order to protect the other, choosing silence over communication at exactly the moment when honesty matters most. I find that trope exhausting at the best of times. Here it landed especially hard because everything that came before it had felt so considered. And a six year time jump that doesn't quite explain what changed didn't help close that wound.
The core of this series is genuinely beautiful. I just wish it trusted itself more in the final stretch.
Was this review helpful to you?
The pair outperforms the story around them
The chemistry works and the character development feels earned — you buy into the shift from calculated revenge to something genuine. There's also an undeniable charm to the classic "the plan backfires" setup: someone who sets out to seduce his ex's new boyfriend out of spite and ends up catching real feelings in the process. On paper, that's fun.In practice though, the series kept me at arm's length emotionally. I watched it without ever really being pulled in — the story stayed on the surface in a way that's difficult to explain but easy to feel. The pairing does its job, the intimate scenes land inconsistently, and by the end there's a noticeable imbalance between what the couple delivers and what the show around them offers.
Worth a watch if you're drawn to the pairing or the premise, but don't go in expecting the story to match.
Was this review helpful to you?
Hard to watch without the noise — and the noise is loud
I'll be upfront: I didn't finish this one, and the reasons are both personal and circumstantial.
The off-screen situation surrounding SmartBoom made it genuinely difficult to watch without that context bleeding in. The allegations around Boom, and Smart's very public legal dispute with WeTV — including his own accounts of difficult working conditions on set — create a weight that's hard to set aside, even when you try. Whatever the full truth of those situations is, SmartBoom as a pairing no longer exists in this form, and that shapes how the series feels in retrospect.
As for the show itself: the intimate scenes worked well enough, but the chemistry between the leads only partially landed for me, and the story never gave me a reason to stay. I'd already struggled to connect with the source material in its animated form, and the live action didn't change that. Sometimes a story and a viewer just don't find each other, regardless of how it's made.
I don't think this is necessarily a bad series — it's more that it wasn't for me, on multiple levels.
Was this review helpful to you?
My Stand-In vibes — but it never quite got there for me
The premise has something — a famous actor who dies on the night of his greatest success, betrayed by the person closest to him, and then gets to go back. Time resets, a mysterious fan enters the picture, and the road to the top begins again. There's emotional potential in that setup, and the intimate scenes actually delivered.But the series never pulled me in the way I needed it to. It reminded me of My Stand-In in its basic DNA — the second chance, the identity questions, the love complicated by circumstances that shouldn't exist — but where that series at least held me through its messier moments, this one lost me early and didn't find me again. By the end very little had stayed, and I wouldn't go back for the pairing alone.
Was this review helpful to you?
To My Star Season 2: Our Untold Stories
0 people found this review helpful
Pretty to look at — but looking is about all it gave me
A fallen actor and an elegant chef. Visually, the combination works, and there's an aesthetic pleasantness to both seasons that I can appreciate. But pleasant to look at and emotionally engaging are two very different things, and for me this series stayed firmly in the first category.The core conflicts — two people too different to make it work, a separation reduced to a note, the slow question of whether they find their way back — none of it landed for me in the way I wanted it to. I followed the story without ever being drawn into it. It passed by rather than through me, if that makes sense.
By the end of both seasons, very little had stuck. The pair didn't move me enough to make me want to revisit them, and I think that's ultimately the most honest thing I can say about it. Looking good together on screen is a starting point, not a destination — and for me personally, this one never quite got further than that.
Was this review helpful to you?
Thai Skins — ambitious, messy, and a little too much of everything
Thai Skins. That's genuinely the best way I can describe it, and I mean that as both a compliment and an explanation for why I ended up skipping large chunks of it.There's a lot going on here — multiple couples, overlapping storylines, drama upon drama — and at some point I simply lost the thread. Not because the show is bad exactly, but because the ensemble is so large that I never got close enough to anyone to really care. When you're spread that thin across that many characters, emotional investment becomes difficult to sustain.
FirstKhaotung have their moments and I can see why people connect with them. But for me personally, nothing stuck. The overall feeling is diffuse — I watched it without ever being fully in it, and by the time I decided to stop, I didn't feel like I was missing much. I couldn't tell you honestly whether I'd go back for any of the pairs.
Sometimes a show tries to give you everything and ends up giving you not quite enough of anything. For me, this was one of those times.
Was this review helpful to you?
The ingredients were there — it just never came together for me
Years of unrequited feelings, one last attempt to get over them, a week of fake dating to force the issue — on paper, that's a setup I should have responded to. And I went in genuinely wanting it to work.It didn't, at least not for me. The chemistry between the leads never quite built into something I could feel, and the intimate scenes didn't land either. I followed the story without being pulled into it, and by the end I was already halfway to forgetting it. That particular kind of forgettable is hard to pinpoint — nothing went dramatically wrong, it just never sparked.
There are people who will connect with this more than I did, and I don't think it's a bad show. It's just one of those where my personal experience was mostly indifference, which is its own kind of disappointment when the premise had real potential.
Was this review helpful to you?
Weird premise, familiar feeling — present but never quite there
The setup is genuinely odd in the best way — an undercover tattoo artist, a burger joint fronting as a hitman operation, and a one-night stand who turns out to be at the center of the investigation. That combination should be a lot of fun.And yet. FirstKhaotung work well enough together and individual scenes deliver, but I never found my way in emotionally. There's a distance to the whole thing that's hard to shake — like watching through glass rather than being inside the story. JoongDunk as the second pair don't bridge that gap either. Both couples have their moments, but moments aren't enough to build a lasting impression on.
Was this review helpful to you?
Watched it for the leftover MaxkyBas — ended up curious about one more pair
I won't pretend I watched this for the new storylines. I was there for the remaining MaxkyBas moments, and once those were done I mostly moved on. The new couples didn't pull me in enough to follow all three properly.That said — Ngern and Oat caught my attention more than I expected, enough that I followed their storyline at least. A small surprise in a season I came to with limited investment. The rest I left largely unwatched, which probably says enough.
Was this review helpful to you?
Watched it for the leftover MaxkyBas — ended up curious about one more pair
I won't pretend I watched this for the new storylines. I was there for the remaining MaxkyBas moments, and once those were done I mostly moved on. The new couples didn't pull me in enough to follow all three properly.That said — Ngern and Oat caught my attention more than I expected, enough that I followed their storyline at least. A small surprise in a season I came to with limited investment. The rest I left largely unwatched, which probably says enough.
Was this review helpful to you?
The couple carries it — the story, less so
The chemistry between the leads is what makes this worth watching. Warm, believable, and the friends-to-lovers setup actually lands — two people who've known each other since childhood, one university play, and then a moment where a line gets crossed and nothing quite goes back to how it was. You root for them, and that counts for something.What lingers afterwards is mostly just them. The plot itself left little impression — it fades in a way that's hard to pinpoint but easy to feel. Not because anything goes wrong exactly, just because nothing sticks hard enough. The series is pleasant while it lasts, but it doesn't follow you out the door.
If you're in the mood for low-stakes, feel-good friends-to-lovers with genuine on-screen warmth, this delivers. Just don't expect it to stay with you for long.
Was this review helpful to you?
