News 
Blades of the Guardians: When Your Donghua Was Better But You're Still Having a Good Time
Okay, I need to confess something first: I was a Blades of Guardians donghua apologist before this movie was even announced. I watched the 2023 anime adaptation, I read Xianzhe Xu's manhua, and I had opinions about the casting. So imagine my surprise when I sat down for this live-action spectacle and found myself... actually enjoying it? Like, genuinely? Not just "pretending to enjoy it so I don't look like a hipster" enjoying it?
But let's get the elephant in the desert out of the way: the donghua was better. There, I said it. The animated series had more room to breathe, more time to flesh out the political machinations, and didn't have to cram approximately seventeen factions, eight subplots, and five historical name-drops into a two-hour runtime. The movie's plot is so dense that I'm fairly certain I missed three betrayals and a marriage proposal while blinking.
However.
This movie is very watchable. Like, "I will absolutely watch this again on a lazy Sunday afternoon" watchable. And honestly? That's high praise for a live-action adaptation of a comic book that had to condense what I can only assume was a 47-volume arc into something that doesn't require a PhD in Sui Dynasty politics to follow.
---
The Plot (Or: How Many Factions Can We Fit in Two Hours?)
So we've got Dao Ma (Wu Jing), a rugged bounty hunter who used to be a cavalry soldier, traveling the Silk Road with his nephew Xiao Qi (Ju Qianlang). He gets recruited by Governor Chang (Jet Li) to train troops, declines because politics is icky, and then immediately gets framed for murder. Classic.
Cue the escape to Mojia Village, where Chief Mo calls in a favor: escort the empire's most wanted revolutionary, Zhi Shi Lang (Sun Yizhou), to Chang'an. Oh, and take his daughter Ayuya (Chen Lijun) and her friend Ani (Xiong Jinyi) along because he doesn't want her marrying a guy named He Yixuan (CiSha), who is such a piece of work that I genuinely hissed at the screen during his scenes.
Along the way, they meet Shu (Yu Shi), a bounty hunter with amazing hair and a mysterious past, and they all get chased by rival bounty hunters, corrupt officials, warring factions, and two mysterious warriors played by Nicholas Tse and Biying Liang, whose alignment is basically "yes."
---
Hello, Yu Shi! I See You!
Speaking of Yu Shi, can we talk about this man's screen presence for a second? He plays Shu, the calm, collected bounty hunter with the white-streaked hair and the red scar. He gets maybe fifteen minutes of screen time, and yet I spent the entire drive home thinking about him. This is a problem. A good problem. The kind of problem that makes me want to watch Creation of the Gods just to see him again.
This is exactly what happened with Creation of the Gods. I saw him for ten minutes as Ji Fa and was like, "Yes, this man is my entire personality now." And now he's done it again. Yu Shi is a menace and I need him in more things immediately.
---
The Action: A Masterclass from the Master
Yuen Woo-ping, the man who brought us Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon, The Matrix, Kill Bill, and Kung Fu Hustle, is back, and he's brought his A-game. The fight choreography is absolutely relentless.
The film's structure is basically "Mad Max: Fury Road but with swords and sandstorms." It's one chase scene after another, each more elaborate than the last. The opening fight between Dao Ma and the Two-Headed Snake (Zhang Jin) against Chang's men is so impressive it would be the climax of most action movies. Here, it's just the warm-up.
And then there's the Jet Li fight. Yes, the Jet Li. He shows up as Governor Chang, and the fight between him, Dao Ma, and Two-Headed Snake is a delicious appetizer for the main course. Li and Wu Jing feel a bit "restrained" in their physically demanding roles (they're both getting older, sue them), but honestly? I was too busy picking my jaw off the floor to notice.
The standout set pieces include:
· A sprawling sandstorm battle that is pure cinema
· Dynamic practical horseback stunts (no CGI horses here, folks)
· A desert oil field that becomes a flaming battlefield
· A villain who is, and I quote, "flame-engulfed"
The practical effects and on-location shooting in the desert regions of western China give the film a scale and texture that CGI just can't replicate. The elaborate costumes—Shu's white-streaked hair and flowing robes, Zhi Shi Lang's half-ghost mask with Sichuan Opera face-painting, Dao Ma's all-black ensemble—create a stark monochromatic color scheme that looks stunning on the big screen.
---
The Story: Dense, Convoluted, and Occasionally Incomprehensible
Remember how I said the donghua was better? This is why. The film tries to condense a massive multi-character comic book arc into two hours, and the result is a viewer being bombarded with a dizzying array of factions, subplots, and historical names that are impossible to track.
I'm fairly certain I watched the same five minutes three times without realizing it. The plot is so fast-paced that it occasionally feels like the filmmakers were worried the audience would lose interest if they slowed down for even a second.
But here's the thing: for genre fans, this doesn't matter. The story is a foundation on which to lay the stunning fight sequences, and that's exactly what it does. The narrative is compelling enough to keep you invested between fights, and the characters are well-drawn enough that you care about what happens to them—especially Ayuya, whose arc from naive girl to adult warrior is beautifully handled by Chen Lijun.
---
The Cast: No Weak Links
One thing this film does exceptionally well is casting. Everyone is dialed in:
· Wu Jing as Dao Ma: Weary, sarcastic, and absolutely lethal when provoked
· Jet Li as Governor Chang: Charismatic, menacing, and somehow makes politics cool
· Nicholas Tse as Diting: Has the presence to be a massive crossover star
· Yu Shi as Shu: The reason I'm watching Creation of the Gods again
· Chen Lijun as Ayuya: An opera singer who proves she can act AND fight
· Sun Yizhou as Zhi Shi Lang: The mysterious revolutionary with the killer mask
---
Final Verdict: Watch It, Then Watch the Donghua
Blades of the Guardians: Wind Rises in the Desert is an exciting, occasionally over-stretched, but ultimately thrilling martial arts extravaganza. The title is overly verbose (why the subtitle? What purpose does it serve?), the plot is occasionally convoluted, and yes, the donghua was better.
But if you're looking for two hours of jaw-dropping action, elaborate costumes, and stunning desert landscapes, this film delivers. It's part Lord of the Rings, part Mad Max: Fury Road, with a generous heaping of Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon. There's something for everyone here—even if the someone in question is just me, watching Yu Shi for fifteen minutes and then immediately googling Creation of the Gods.
Rating: 8 out of 10 (One point deducted for making me want to rewatch the donghua instead, and one more deducted for making me miss the donghua's extended runtime)
But seriously, go watch the donghua after. It's worth it. And while you're at it, check out Creation of the Gods. Yosh Yu is in it. You won't regret it.
But let's get the elephant in the desert out of the way: the donghua was better. There, I said it. The animated series had more room to breathe, more time to flesh out the political machinations, and didn't have to cram approximately seventeen factions, eight subplots, and five historical name-drops into a two-hour runtime. The movie's plot is so dense that I'm fairly certain I missed three betrayals and a marriage proposal while blinking.
However.
This movie is very watchable. Like, "I will absolutely watch this again on a lazy Sunday afternoon" watchable. And honestly? That's high praise for a live-action adaptation of a comic book that had to condense what I can only assume was a 47-volume arc into something that doesn't require a PhD in Sui Dynasty politics to follow.
---
The Plot (Or: How Many Factions Can We Fit in Two Hours?)
So we've got Dao Ma (Wu Jing), a rugged bounty hunter who used to be a cavalry soldier, traveling the Silk Road with his nephew Xiao Qi (Ju Qianlang). He gets recruited by Governor Chang (Jet Li) to train troops, declines because politics is icky, and then immediately gets framed for murder. Classic.
Cue the escape to Mojia Village, where Chief Mo calls in a favor: escort the empire's most wanted revolutionary, Zhi Shi Lang (Sun Yizhou), to Chang'an. Oh, and take his daughter Ayuya (Chen Lijun) and her friend Ani (Xiong Jinyi) along because he doesn't want her marrying a guy named He Yixuan (CiSha), who is such a piece of work that I genuinely hissed at the screen during his scenes.
Along the way, they meet Shu (Yu Shi), a bounty hunter with amazing hair and a mysterious past, and they all get chased by rival bounty hunters, corrupt officials, warring factions, and two mysterious warriors played by Nicholas Tse and Biying Liang, whose alignment is basically "yes."
---
Hello, Yu Shi! I See You!
Speaking of Yu Shi, can we talk about this man's screen presence for a second? He plays Shu, the calm, collected bounty hunter with the white-streaked hair and the red scar. He gets maybe fifteen minutes of screen time, and yet I spent the entire drive home thinking about him. This is a problem. A good problem. The kind of problem that makes me want to watch Creation of the Gods just to see him again.
This is exactly what happened with Creation of the Gods. I saw him for ten minutes as Ji Fa and was like, "Yes, this man is my entire personality now." And now he's done it again. Yu Shi is a menace and I need him in more things immediately.
---
The Action: A Masterclass from the Master
Yuen Woo-ping, the man who brought us Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon, The Matrix, Kill Bill, and Kung Fu Hustle, is back, and he's brought his A-game. The fight choreography is absolutely relentless.
The film's structure is basically "Mad Max: Fury Road but with swords and sandstorms." It's one chase scene after another, each more elaborate than the last. The opening fight between Dao Ma and the Two-Headed Snake (Zhang Jin) against Chang's men is so impressive it would be the climax of most action movies. Here, it's just the warm-up.
And then there's the Jet Li fight. Yes, the Jet Li. He shows up as Governor Chang, and the fight between him, Dao Ma, and Two-Headed Snake is a delicious appetizer for the main course. Li and Wu Jing feel a bit "restrained" in their physically demanding roles (they're both getting older, sue them), but honestly? I was too busy picking my jaw off the floor to notice.
The standout set pieces include:
· A sprawling sandstorm battle that is pure cinema
· Dynamic practical horseback stunts (no CGI horses here, folks)
· A desert oil field that becomes a flaming battlefield
· A villain who is, and I quote, "flame-engulfed"
The practical effects and on-location shooting in the desert regions of western China give the film a scale and texture that CGI just can't replicate. The elaborate costumes—Shu's white-streaked hair and flowing robes, Zhi Shi Lang's half-ghost mask with Sichuan Opera face-painting, Dao Ma's all-black ensemble—create a stark monochromatic color scheme that looks stunning on the big screen.
---
The Story: Dense, Convoluted, and Occasionally Incomprehensible
Remember how I said the donghua was better? This is why. The film tries to condense a massive multi-character comic book arc into two hours, and the result is a viewer being bombarded with a dizzying array of factions, subplots, and historical names that are impossible to track.
I'm fairly certain I watched the same five minutes three times without realizing it. The plot is so fast-paced that it occasionally feels like the filmmakers were worried the audience would lose interest if they slowed down for even a second.
But here's the thing: for genre fans, this doesn't matter. The story is a foundation on which to lay the stunning fight sequences, and that's exactly what it does. The narrative is compelling enough to keep you invested between fights, and the characters are well-drawn enough that you care about what happens to them—especially Ayuya, whose arc from naive girl to adult warrior is beautifully handled by Chen Lijun.
---
The Cast: No Weak Links
One thing this film does exceptionally well is casting. Everyone is dialed in:
· Wu Jing as Dao Ma: Weary, sarcastic, and absolutely lethal when provoked
· Jet Li as Governor Chang: Charismatic, menacing, and somehow makes politics cool
· Nicholas Tse as Diting: Has the presence to be a massive crossover star
· Yu Shi as Shu: The reason I'm watching Creation of the Gods again
· Chen Lijun as Ayuya: An opera singer who proves she can act AND fight
· Sun Yizhou as Zhi Shi Lang: The mysterious revolutionary with the killer mask
---
Final Verdict: Watch It, Then Watch the Donghua
Blades of the Guardians: Wind Rises in the Desert is an exciting, occasionally over-stretched, but ultimately thrilling martial arts extravaganza. The title is overly verbose (why the subtitle? What purpose does it serve?), the plot is occasionally convoluted, and yes, the donghua was better.
But if you're looking for two hours of jaw-dropping action, elaborate costumes, and stunning desert landscapes, this film delivers. It's part Lord of the Rings, part Mad Max: Fury Road, with a generous heaping of Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon. There's something for everyone here—even if the someone in question is just me, watching Yu Shi for fifteen minutes and then immediately googling Creation of the Gods.
Rating: 8 out of 10 (One point deducted for making me want to rewatch the donghua instead, and one more deducted for making me miss the donghua's extended runtime)
But seriously, go watch the donghua after. It's worth it. And while you're at it, check out Creation of the Gods. Yosh Yu is in it. You won't regret it.
Was this review helpful to you?
