This review may contain spoilers
A critical look at "Kpop Demon Hunters"
"Kpop Demon Hunters" leaves much to be desired in terms of its premise and execution
From the onset, the premise of a bunch of demon hunters drooling over the demons they're tasked with defeating is frustratingly superficial and distasteful. Where they should be fighting the demons, they're busy ogling and pursuing them
The forced non-platonic exchanges between the male and female idols diminished my interest in their character arcs. There’s zero chemistry between the characters. Their "comedic" facial expressions aren't funny or comedic. And their supposed good looks are exaggerated. They do little to offset the monotony of their bland personas
The demons are subjected to the clichéd "romanticized" treatment that presents them as objects of desire and victims of circumstance rather than malevolent beings deserving of their fate in the underworld. Several of these demons (Jinu included) have earned their place in hell, having displayed a callous disregard for others. They've betrayed their own kin for self-preservation, and manipulated the truth to appeal to others' feelings
Rumi: "I know your story. You were a good person, and you still are"
Jinu: "I lied to you. I made a deal with Gwi-Ma to get myself out of that miserable life. I left my family alone while I slept on silk sheets in the palace with my belly full every night. I left them" (1:9:50)
Jinu abandoned his loved ones to a life of poverty and starvation to secure comfort and survival. And I'm expected to pity him for his time in hell? No amount of retrospective remorse can rewrite history or nullify the ethical transgressions he committed
To forgive, or not to forgive? This is not a question posed to courts or the public, but a war waged behind closed doors and in the chambers of the wounded heart. Should Jinu's family, the aggrieved parties, extend forgiveness, it'd be an act of courage and a near-divine suspension of justified anger. Should they withhold forgiveness, a dignified reclamation of agency in the face of violation, a solemn tribute to what was lost, and a refusal to be coerced into premature reconciliation by societal or doctrinal demands. However, they might've departed to heaven. We're left with no clarity on where they stand in the matter
The story still performs a psychological sleight of hand: it acknowledges the demons' past atrocities only to repress their significance. The audience is conditioned to internalize a distorted moral hierarchy that valorizes emotional catharsis over justice, and empathy over accountability. "They didn't deserve it," they'd insist. The truth is, the demons in question aren't misunderstood or fallen angels whose small errors brought about their condemnation
Rumi: "if this is the Honmoon I'm supposed to protect, I'm glad to see it destroyed" (1:14:42)
Rumi, who seconds ago endorsed the destruction of Honmoon, appears at the Saja Boys' concert with a newfound determination to protect it. Her abrupt shift in sentiment and subsequent behavior remain unexamined, to the detriment of character believability and emotional payoff
The entire production falls flat. The character designs, the dialogues, the decisions made, the songs
There's a notable divide in opinion regarding the songs featured in "Kpop Demon Hunters." Fans assert the superiority of the songs over those of established Kpop artists, and I disagree with them. Numerous Kpop groups, BTS, Stray Kids, ATEEZ, MAMAMOO, ITZY, FIFTY FIFTY, etc, released songs that I'm able to enjoy on a regular basis, on repeat, due to their catchy melodies and meaningful lyrics. I find the tracks from "Kpop Demon Hunters" to be unbearable to listen to more than once
Considering the exceptional bar set by certain Kpop groups, I believe the popularity surrounding "Kpop Demon Hunters" is disproportionate to its merits
TL;DR On a scale of 1 to 10, I'd rate the movie a 2
From the onset, the premise of a bunch of demon hunters drooling over the demons they're tasked with defeating is frustratingly superficial and distasteful. Where they should be fighting the demons, they're busy ogling and pursuing them
The forced non-platonic exchanges between the male and female idols diminished my interest in their character arcs. There’s zero chemistry between the characters. Their "comedic" facial expressions aren't funny or comedic. And their supposed good looks are exaggerated. They do little to offset the monotony of their bland personas
The demons are subjected to the clichéd "romanticized" treatment that presents them as objects of desire and victims of circumstance rather than malevolent beings deserving of their fate in the underworld. Several of these demons (Jinu included) have earned their place in hell, having displayed a callous disregard for others. They've betrayed their own kin for self-preservation, and manipulated the truth to appeal to others' feelings
Rumi: "I know your story. You were a good person, and you still are"
Jinu: "I lied to you. I made a deal with Gwi-Ma to get myself out of that miserable life. I left my family alone while I slept on silk sheets in the palace with my belly full every night. I left them" (1:9:50)
Jinu abandoned his loved ones to a life of poverty and starvation to secure comfort and survival. And I'm expected to pity him for his time in hell? No amount of retrospective remorse can rewrite history or nullify the ethical transgressions he committed
To forgive, or not to forgive? This is not a question posed to courts or the public, but a war waged behind closed doors and in the chambers of the wounded heart. Should Jinu's family, the aggrieved parties, extend forgiveness, it'd be an act of courage and a near-divine suspension of justified anger. Should they withhold forgiveness, a dignified reclamation of agency in the face of violation, a solemn tribute to what was lost, and a refusal to be coerced into premature reconciliation by societal or doctrinal demands. However, they might've departed to heaven. We're left with no clarity on where they stand in the matter
The story still performs a psychological sleight of hand: it acknowledges the demons' past atrocities only to repress their significance. The audience is conditioned to internalize a distorted moral hierarchy that valorizes emotional catharsis over justice, and empathy over accountability. "They didn't deserve it," they'd insist. The truth is, the demons in question aren't misunderstood or fallen angels whose small errors brought about their condemnation
Rumi: "if this is the Honmoon I'm supposed to protect, I'm glad to see it destroyed" (1:14:42)
Rumi, who seconds ago endorsed the destruction of Honmoon, appears at the Saja Boys' concert with a newfound determination to protect it. Her abrupt shift in sentiment and subsequent behavior remain unexamined, to the detriment of character believability and emotional payoff
The entire production falls flat. The character designs, the dialogues, the decisions made, the songs
There's a notable divide in opinion regarding the songs featured in "Kpop Demon Hunters." Fans assert the superiority of the songs over those of established Kpop artists, and I disagree with them. Numerous Kpop groups, BTS, Stray Kids, ATEEZ, MAMAMOO, ITZY, FIFTY FIFTY, etc, released songs that I'm able to enjoy on a regular basis, on repeat, due to their catchy melodies and meaningful lyrics. I find the tracks from "Kpop Demon Hunters" to be unbearable to listen to more than once
Considering the exceptional bar set by certain Kpop groups, I believe the popularity surrounding "Kpop Demon Hunters" is disproportionate to its merits
TL;DR On a scale of 1 to 10, I'd rate the movie a 2
Was this review helpful to you?
