This review may contain spoilers
Missed opportunity
The plot of the novel gripped me however it introduces several notable changes that distinguish it from the original novel.
Character Development and Dynamics:
Protagonist's Portrayal: In the novel, Jun Qiluo is depicted as a resilient and multifaceted character, balancing her roles with depth and nuance. The drama, however, has faced criticism for its portrayal of Jun Qiluo, particularly concerning the lead actress's performance. Some viewers feel that the on-screen representation lacks the emotional complexity present in the literary version. citeturn0search3
Male Lead's Characterization: Xuan Lie's character in the novel is portrayed as a formidable and authoritative figure. The drama adaptation, however, has been critiqued for altering his persona, presenting him as more emotionally vulnerable, which some fans believe deviates from his original "badass general" image. citeturn0search3
Plot Adjustments:
Narrative Pacing and Structure: The novel's storyline is known for its engaging and well-structured plot. In contrast, the drama has been critiqued for pacing issues, with some viewers noting that certain episodes feel either rushed or overly drawn out, affecting the overall narrative flow. citeturn0search3
Key Plot Modifications: While specific plot details are altered in the drama, to avoid spoilers, it's noted that certain significant events from the novel are either omitted or modified, leading to a different emotional impact and character development trajectory.
Production Elements:
Visual Representation: The drama boasts high production values with elaborate costumes and set designs that bring the historical setting to life. However, some viewers have pointed out inconsistencies in visual effects and cinematography, which occasionally detract from the immersive experience. citeturn0search2
Acting and Performance: The casting choices, particularly for the lead roles, have been a topic of discussion among fans. While the novel allows readers to imagine the depth of characters, the drama's portrayal has received mixed reviews, with some praising the chemistry between leads and others critiquing the emotional delivery. citeturn0search3
In summary, while "Everlasting Longing" strives to bring Xi Juan's beloved novel to the screen, it introduces changes in character portrayals, plot structures, and production choices. These adaptations have led to varied receptions among audiences, with some appreciating the fresh take and others longing for a rendition more faithful to the source material.
Character Development and Dynamics:
Protagonist's Portrayal: In the novel, Jun Qiluo is depicted as a resilient and multifaceted character, balancing her roles with depth and nuance. The drama, however, has faced criticism for its portrayal of Jun Qiluo, particularly concerning the lead actress's performance. Some viewers feel that the on-screen representation lacks the emotional complexity present in the literary version. citeturn0search3
Male Lead's Characterization: Xuan Lie's character in the novel is portrayed as a formidable and authoritative figure. The drama adaptation, however, has been critiqued for altering his persona, presenting him as more emotionally vulnerable, which some fans believe deviates from his original "badass general" image. citeturn0search3
Plot Adjustments:
Narrative Pacing and Structure: The novel's storyline is known for its engaging and well-structured plot. In contrast, the drama has been critiqued for pacing issues, with some viewers noting that certain episodes feel either rushed or overly drawn out, affecting the overall narrative flow. citeturn0search3
Key Plot Modifications: While specific plot details are altered in the drama, to avoid spoilers, it's noted that certain significant events from the novel are either omitted or modified, leading to a different emotional impact and character development trajectory.
Production Elements:
Visual Representation: The drama boasts high production values with elaborate costumes and set designs that bring the historical setting to life. However, some viewers have pointed out inconsistencies in visual effects and cinematography, which occasionally detract from the immersive experience. citeturn0search2
Acting and Performance: The casting choices, particularly for the lead roles, have been a topic of discussion among fans. While the novel allows readers to imagine the depth of characters, the drama's portrayal has received mixed reviews, with some praising the chemistry between leads and others critiquing the emotional delivery. citeturn0search3
In summary, while "Everlasting Longing" strives to bring Xi Juan's beloved novel to the screen, it introduces changes in character portrayals, plot structures, and production choices. These adaptations have led to varied receptions among audiences, with some appreciating the fresh take and others longing for a rendition more faithful to the source material.
Was this review helpful to you?
