1
Good cast, unfortunate plot development
Foremost, the series started off really well with a good cast and great characters. I was very much looking forward to how it plot evolved and unfolded. However, it started to falter hard in the middle of the series for multiple reasons.- When a dramatic incident occurred, before you can take a breather, another immediately begins. It may not have been as difficult to digest if the all the incidents and resolutions also didn't feel horribly repetitive.
- The character introductions were great in the beginning but there was almost no character development in latter episodes. It would have helped if more time was spent on their backgrounds and history.
- The main ML prince/king is likeable but also unrealistically idealistic. His character was far more interesting outside of the palace and it slowly devolved into a one-note. Other than being born into half-royalty and recruiting others to help his righteous fight, he didn't really have any particular skills that would lead you to believe he was a step above others. He mostly did what he wanted and let those around him save him.
- The romance between the ML and FL was awkward and really unnecessary. She was also initially an interesting character who just faded into the background.
Around episode 13 (or 26), was when I started fast-forwarding hard which is why I technically did not properly complete the series. It's quite unfortunate as the cast was great and there was a really good base for the plot.
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
Pleasantly Entertaining
The series starts off with quite a dramatic entrance that throws you off initially (definitely memorable) but fortunately, the series moves along quickly into a more historical setting. It evolves into a hint of The Story of Ming Lan due to the different classes involved within families, the emphasis on what women had to endure in those days, a multitude of scheme within schemes, and a sweet romance between the ML an FL. It's a few tiers below but still very much worth watching if you are a fan of Ming Lan as I am.What makes the series great is the well-paced underlying revenge plot, a great cast, a fantastic sprinkle of humor, and a romance that doesn't trigger my eyes rolling. The FL plays her role well but the star of the show is definitely the ML and his boys as they are the ones I'm consistently looking forward to showing up in the next scene.
As some reviewers have mentioned, the FL is a bit older for her role particularly because of how young the woman she was "replacing" was. But no complaints on my end as I appreciate the older woman/younger man flip from the typical older man/younger female concept. My biggest criticism with the female FL is that her intellectual capabilities started off strong and her character gradually became more of a sidekick once she began trusting the ML to just take care of things.
The other criticism would be in the latter part of the series. It almost felt like there were either two writers or directors between the first half and the second half. The plot started getting a bit mushier and rushed and the sprinkling of humor trailed off. And while the FL did honor her promises to the women she came across, there was a tinge of her just using them as stepping stones for her own selfish desires. I also wish they resumed focus back to some key supporting characters such as the Yue family, but that may mean the series pushes far past 40 episodes. The ending was fine as well but it also felt a bit out of place.
Nevertheless, kudos to an overall entertaining series. And FYI, while the younger generation may not know her, Leanne Liu has been such a fantastic and memorable actress in so many older series. It's great to see her on screen again.
Was this review helpful to you?
Memorable but...
This is a review based on a second attempt to re-watch the series as I recall having watched this many years ago. It is a memorable series because as the characters come to screen, they were all still very recognizable despite how long it has been. This is not something that can be said about many other ones I've seen.Positives:
- The plot itself is relative interesting with good twists.
- There are some very likeable and fun characters where the supporting actors/actresses play their roles well.
- The comradery was rushed but still good with a nice layer of humorous interactions.
- There were pockets of good action scenes.
Negatives:
- The two main roles, Chen Chang Sheng and Xu You Rong, were just really dull. No chemistry with their romance which the series played on heavily and both barely had a different expression throughout the entire 52 episodes. The supporting roles really were the ones who carried them.
- Chen Chang Sheng is supposed to be this righteous victim of circumstances but there are areas where he just comes off as a hypocritical narcissist.
- While the overall plot itself was good, too many scenes felt very repetitive and much too drawn out. Skip large sections at a time and you wouldn't be missing much. To top it off, the scenes where they should have spent more time to bring more depth to the characters, were brushed over too quickly.
- The fantasy visuals and hand gestures were amateur and sometimes cringe but not over my personal threshold of lenience.
I feel slightly conflicted with the scoring because there were some very positive areas that keeps you interested as you anticipate what's to come next. But the flow was done poorly midway through and the main protagonists themselves were either given poor direction/dialogue or needs improvement with their acting abilities. It's a shame because the story itself had good potential.
Was this review helpful to you?
An almost perfect historical drama
This is one where you will lose sleep over because it's just that binge-worthy. Unlike endless other palace dramas out there, this one is particularly unique. So much so that I decided to redo my original review after another re-watch.While you still have your typical treachery occurring within the palace, it doesn't have the same incessant evil cringe moments as most others do. The main focus is around a Queen who is does her best to manage her role while being a mother to her five children. This may sound boring in writing but the dynamics of the relationship between her and her children are both realistic, intriguing, and heartwarming. It is also quite special to finally see brothers with very different personalities that are strongly bonded with one another instead of the typical infighting. The Queen, of course is the main star of the show and her sons are a great reflection of her character.
There are many familiar faces in the series for me and they all did an incredible job in their roles. You felt every emotion even when they were silent. They played their roles so well that it's one of those where you feel your heart breaking with theirs and you can't seem to stop the tears from falling. Even after a second watch, it still had me in tears all over again.
But don't get discouraged from the tears mentioned above, the series did such justice to truly being able to balance the somber with plenty of lightheartedness. You'll laugh and smile just as much. This is really unlike many historical k-dramas out there. There is no melodramatic moments, no long-winded moments, no sappy romances, no annoying characters... and man, the pacing leaves little room for you to be disengaged. I really hope more series follow suit with this style and serious kudos again to the actors.
Was this review helpful to you?
Very different score to season one
Although they did a true continuation from the ending of season one, they probably should have kept it as is... based on this season two. The reasons why I loved season one, took a few steps back in this follow up. Unlike the pacing of a real feel previously, they've upped the dramatics and tried to do too much in a small number of episodes. Because they tried to do too much, there were multiple holes in the plot which became confusing.However, it's not terrible by any means. Just that season two took the entirety into the average zone. There is potential for them to bring it back up to par if they manage to fill in the gaps on all the unanswered questions and provide the rationales for certain actions into a season three. For the time being, the slightly higher scoring on this is to give a nod to season one as I've already become invested in the characters from it (and because of this, season two still triggered a few tears).
Was this review helpful to you?
Draggy and a bit corny but...
The series started off at a good pace, where I found myself binging the first 10 or so episodes until the romance scenes began to drag on and then all of the scenes slowly disintegrated into long drags. The remaining episodes were completed through a heavy-hand of time skipping. But there is something to be said for the effort of even making it through to the last episode rather than just dropping it completely and it'll be easier to just highlight the negatives into a list:- While the acting was average, there was enough chemistry with the ML and FL that the trials and tribulations of their romance will tug at your heart.
- The action scenes/CG effects started off okay and slowly deteriorated (even on the sound effects). And the number of times people will bleed from their mouths in the series has got to be record-breaking.
- They increasingly incorporated way too many flashback moments that only contributed to the drag.
- The plot also increasingly deteriorated with each time skip era.
- The characters started off well and then would bounce around between being out of character and then back into character for no naturally good reason.
However, despite all of the above, there was enough suspense of wanting to know how things end. Unfortunately, the ending was lackluster. The concept of the plot is really interesting and it's a shame they didn't do a better job with the series. It started off with so much potential. If they didn't spend so much time on the drags and focused on diving into the supporting characters and their character evolution, or if they put a little more effort into the details of the events unfolding instead of just jumping into it, or if the cut down on the repetitive romance scenes, it would have produced a far more well-rounded effect.
Was this review helpful to you?
Worth the Watch
This isn't a series for those looking for a thriller or fictional suspense story. It follows the simple format of a broken legal system and a judge who does her best to both implement the law while getting to the bottom of the truth with each case.The series does a really good job in realistically portraying common legal issues from non-violent situations to the more extreme cases. For almost each case, it presents the background to the viewer as if you're watching the news from afar, where it's human nature to be quick to judge and quick to trust the initial facts of what was presented. You'll then find yourself welling up with tears as the truth of the cases are peel backed layer by layer like an onion, partially for the victims, partially for the traumas in this world, and partially because of how foolish you were to judge with the masses.
There's no glaring negative other than some pacing of stories and its developments. There were also some moments that felt a little too prolonged and other moments that felt too abbreviated. There is no humor in this one but if you're in the mood to be hit with some hard and sad realities, this is the one to try. Despite the somber mood however, it is balanced well with encouragement, empathy, and realistic satisfactions of justice.
As a side note, our judge here is also the lead in "Under the Queen's Umbrella" and I'm really enjoying her as an actress. The other characters were also written well as even the smaller supporting roles served a purpose. I hope they come out with a sequel.
Was this review helpful to you?
Hits the Spot
I love these types of plots where help is being provided to different individuals/families, particularly with a supernatural baseline. Most series don't do it very well for one reason or another. This one, despite my initial judgment on the title name (which of course is why should we shouldn't judge based on cover/name), really hit the spot with exception of some minor gripes.Everyone involved including the supporting cast jived well together and had great chemistry. There are scenes that will make you tear up, scenes that will make you laugh, and scenes where you're anticipating the unraveling of situation. There's nothing overly gruesome or frightening (though I wouldn't mind it) and the blended-in humor helps ease any of the darker aspects.
The only character I didn't care much for was the female cop. It is more of how she was written rather than the actress herself. She was more immature than the young MLs, selfish (though somewhat self-aware), much too needy, and didn't know when to stop talking. The other minor grip is the series ended with many unanswered questions and rather abruptly, but is also a bit expected with only 12 episodes.
I found myself looking forward to every next episode and would highly recommend for folks who also enjoy these semi-episodic and supernatural plots. The series gets extra kudos for doing a great job at this particular type of plot/genre.
Was this review helpful to you?
Surprisingly Enjoyable
The summary on the site for this series doesn't do it enough justice. There really isn't anything negative to point out: the actors were charismatic, the story flow was done well, the action scenes were good, and nothing was under or overdone.There are multiple mysteries involved that are relatively standalone (where it isn't being forced into being related to the overall plot). Because of this, I never felt the need to time-skip at all for the entire 36 episodes. The mysteries are interesting with some dark undertones and an added touch of the supernatural. The comradery between the main crew is warm and fun which helps create a balance. An added bonus is that any romance mentioned is relatively minimal and doesn't have any overwhelming scenes as many other series.
For those who enjoy watching supernatural elements along with case solving as I do, this one is highly recommended. I'm looking forward to season two.
Was this review helpful to you?
Along with the Gods 2: The Last 49 Days
0 people found this review helpful
This review may contain spoilers
As Sequels Do Often
Foremost, I appreciate how the sequel picks up right at the ending of it predecessor. If you enjoyed the first movie, this one is definitely worth the watch as it covers a significant portion of the guardians' past lives. Unfortunately it lacks the same charisma (potentially due to losing Cha Tae Hyun as a main) and the characters all get a bit cornier. Outside of the guardians' backgrounds, the blanketing plot around the grandfather and kid is pretty dull and the lackluster acting for the roles enhance this. The actions scenes however have improved a tad and the animation work feels even better this time around.Most sites I've used to stream the movie has the same horrible subtitles. It left me guessing incorrectly on what was going on and twenty minutes in, I would have unfairly given the movie a significantly lower rating. Make sure you find one with subtitles that actually make sense (personally went with Viki).
Was this review helpful to you?
Unexpectedly Entertaining
When giving series/movie a first watch, I don't really dive into who the actors/actresses are. So seeing Cha Tae Hyun as a main was a nice surprise. He has the perfect expressions for comedy-dramas, my favorite blend of genres.The movie doesn't have the most complex or intricate plot but it has enough of an unpredictable essence that will keep you on your toes. Why was it unexpectedly entertaining? Because I do have a slight bias toward movies that lean too far into animated work as they tend to be poorly implemented and have even poorer dialogues. If you can stomach a few less than average actions scenes, this one was actually done pretty well. And although Cha Tae Hyun's story is a pretty basic tearjerker, it is one of those that will still jerk those tears. So if you looking for an easy watch with likeable characters that will also have you laughing out loud, definitely recommend. I'm looking forward to watching the sequel.
Was this review helpful to you?
Dropped It Once
The first time I tried watching this many months ago, dropped it relatively quickly after a couple of episodes. Mostly because at the time, I was looking for a series with actual substance. However, this is a perfect series if you enjoy the "mystical" genre and need something very casual to watch (i.e. don't care if you miss out on a conversation or two).The plot is simple/predictable, and that has its own entertainment factor, especially when the actors are still charismatic. Just go in without any expectations of a tightly-knit execution of a story. This is one where characters just drop in because it is convenient for the plot to progress. The fantasy/action visuals also have the low-budget feel but it does kind of tie into the series' overall comical theme.
Overall, it can still satisfy those days when you just want a couple of laughs, don't want to get in too heavy, and still catch a bit of feel-good moments.
Was this review helpful to you?
This is one where in addition to your fantastic mains, all of the other actors also did a great job with their roles so it didn't feel like anyone was pulling any heavy weight for the rest. The plot maintained enough suspense to keep the momentum going and the pacing worked well. Unlike many others in its genre, there wasn't any glaring or obvious issues with how the crimes scenes were managed and it doesn't rely on excess dramatization to keep it interesting. Although some actions/reactions didn't always seem to fit the characters, it's easy to overlook because we in the real world aren't always rational.
The minor disconnect I had was they tried to interweave too many players into the underlying plot without providing enough background/focus on some of them. They gave just enough for you to see the connections but not enough for you to really feel them, if that makes sense. Because of this, it can slightly feel as if the plot drags on for just a bit at times. Nevertheless, the character developments were done well and the dynamic between Shin Ha Kyun and Yeo Jin Goo in itself makes it worthwhile to check out.
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
This one is difficult to describe because on the one hand, the suspense of the series was well laid out until it neared the end but it was also littered with plot holes. But despite the plot holes, it mostly flowed better than most with exception of the weak ending. I really wish they zoned in on some necessary areas that would have given it more depth:- It makes total sense for Kim Dan to mourn her Kim Ho Ki but really odd that she never mourned her real mother, not even when she was little. And no, the memory loss later doesn't justify this.
- They never provided any background on the children who were tortured and ended up as murderers, or even much about their interactions with each other. Sometimes it seemed they knew of one another and other times they didn't? How did the rest of the children end up where they did after the major event?
- The whole future vision aspect also didn't make much sense and there's only so much that can be interpreted if there's too many inconsistencies.
Having jumped into this one with just the brief plot summary, thought this one would be more episodic but it all revolves around peeling back layers from a past event. The comedic scenes were actual quite fun but it was awkwardly placed, and it sometimes took away what should have been more serious for the characters. However, what was great about this one was the actors and supporting actors. They managed to pull it together despite the flaws and poorly scripted character developments. And I really, really hope to see Kang Ji Hwan and Shim Hee Sub together again in better written/directed series. Both of them already bring their own charm individually, but they also have great on-screen chemistry. These guys deserve more spotlight in this arena and the higher score is mainly due to them.
Was this review helpful to you?
This one definitely had a similar feel to Rebel: Thief Who Stole the People except the setting is in more modern times. As with some of the older series, there is an abundance of dramatics but it was done with care and done better than what newer series attempt to do. While it's heavy handed with politics, it interestingly didn't feel as redundant as one would think despite some repetitiveness in the back and forth competition. Likely because the actors were all really fantastic in their roles, particularly when they switch between various facets of being ruthless or kind. I also always appreciate when the plot takes the time to lay out the beginnings well because it only draws you in closer and has you rooting for them harder.
Put this one off for a while because it's not the typical plot that I'm immediately drawn to but it wonderfully exceeded expectations. Be prepared to be biting your nails often and quietly yelling at the screen, be prepared to grab a Kleenex for the successful emotional tugs, and be prepared to laugh out loud at some of those hilarious characters. Towards the end, it does attempt to heightened the drama by throwing in some even more unrealistic events but it wasn't enough to deter from the overall enjoyment.
Was this review helpful to you?
