With the knife wiped clean of blood
I'm fully here for anti-colonial struggle. And Harbin certainly provides that, depicting a fictionalised story of the events leading up to the assassination of Itō Hirobumi at the hands of Korean independence activist An Jung-geun.
But this is a war film. Its purpose seems more to heroise rather than provide any real analysis or insight. I agree with Misunderst0_od's assessment of the first half of Harbin with its "boring scenes of men discussing, planning, and excessively smoking in a dark room". In the first half – and maybe the second too – the film seems more concerned with the aesthetics of anti-colonial struggle and less so its substance.
This is fine, I guess. The approach lends itself well to the strong thriller that the second half successfully delivers. Personally, I'm more interested in the tricky dilemmas along the way. I wouldn't go so far as to say that Itō Hirobumi is portrayed as a complex character, as Misunderst0_od sees it. I think he's certainly shown to be clever and self-aware, but he's very much still a straight-up Bad Guy and he is not afforded any emotional complexity. But that's ok - he's not the tricky dilemma I was interested in.
What I was far more interested in was the character with the "inner conflict" (borrowing from Misunderst0_od here again). First, what intrigued me was the inner conflict itself. How do you come to terms with betraying what you hold dear? And second, seeing how the other characters judged the actions of this conflicted character. I thought this would've been an excellent opportunity to study how people factor coercion into their judgement of others. How much can you blame a person for their actions when they've clearly been coerced into them?
Yet Harbin does not answer these questions. At least, not to my satisfaction. It instead presents what is, in my opinion, far too clean an ending. Without giving anything away, the ending seems just a bit to good to be true – and in a way that avoids a difficult moral grappling.
I will say, the cinematography did boost my star rating for Harbin. The film opens with an impressive landscape shot and then feeds you a few more epic ones along the way. You can definitely see where the budget was spent.
But this is a war film. Its purpose seems more to heroise rather than provide any real analysis or insight. I agree with Misunderst0_od's assessment of the first half of Harbin with its "boring scenes of men discussing, planning, and excessively smoking in a dark room". In the first half – and maybe the second too – the film seems more concerned with the aesthetics of anti-colonial struggle and less so its substance.
This is fine, I guess. The approach lends itself well to the strong thriller that the second half successfully delivers. Personally, I'm more interested in the tricky dilemmas along the way. I wouldn't go so far as to say that Itō Hirobumi is portrayed as a complex character, as Misunderst0_od sees it. I think he's certainly shown to be clever and self-aware, but he's very much still a straight-up Bad Guy and he is not afforded any emotional complexity. But that's ok - he's not the tricky dilemma I was interested in.
What I was far more interested in was the character with the "inner conflict" (borrowing from Misunderst0_od here again). First, what intrigued me was the inner conflict itself. How do you come to terms with betraying what you hold dear? And second, seeing how the other characters judged the actions of this conflicted character. I thought this would've been an excellent opportunity to study how people factor coercion into their judgement of others. How much can you blame a person for their actions when they've clearly been coerced into them?
Yet Harbin does not answer these questions. At least, not to my satisfaction. It instead presents what is, in my opinion, far too clean an ending. Without giving anything away, the ending seems just a bit to good to be true – and in a way that avoids a difficult moral grappling.
I will say, the cinematography did boost my star rating for Harbin. The film opens with an impressive landscape shot and then feeds you a few more epic ones along the way. You can definitely see where the budget was spent.
Was this review helpful to you?
