Details

  • Last Online: 1 hour ago
  • Gender: Female
  • Location: ❤️EXOPLANET❤️
  • Contribution Points: 5,658 LV14
  • Birthday: May 06
  • Roles:
  • Join Date: January 29, 2016
  • Awards Received: Finger Heart Award35 Flower Award118 Coin Gift Award10 Reply Goblin Award1 Lore Scrolls Award1 Drama Bestie Award3 Comment of Comfort Award2 Hidden Gem Recommender2 Gaslight, Gatekeep, Girlboss1 Clap Clap Clap Award1 Sassy Tomato2 Reply Hugger1

XingBack

❤️EXOPLANET❤️
Who Is She korean drama review
Completed
Who Is She
8 people found this review helpful
by XingBack
Jan 24, 2025
12 of 12 episodes seen
Completed 4
Overall 1.0
Story 1.0
Acting/Cast 5.0
Music 7.5
Rewatch Value 1.0
This review may contain spoilers

Bad writing

The og was so beautiful, a story of reliving a dream, getting a second chance, rediscovering passion and love

But this was so cheesy… honestly I love jiso, her serious roles are amazing but they do her dirty with the comedies..

And as an idol fan, she was really mismatched with her team
She’s beautiful, everyone is, but idol companies are shallow, they go after an image and everyone looks the same for the balance and symmetry
And I’m only talking about her height ;> since she’s the lead, they should’ve casted more diverse team members to fit her


And for such an amazing singer that deserves to fight the world for, she didn’t have that big an impact in the group
She literally goes missing and her group is fine xD

This goes back to Janet/real Emily, they made it seem like such a big surprise xD but that poor girl never had the chance to debut and she was just a setup to make Daniel chase after dori
But he was already crushing after her and doing everything to make her debut… so that’s another creep factor..
Another ridiculous plot move was making him the son of fls enemy…..


All of that honestly and she still ends up with him? Ridiculous… cheesy…

This drama wasn’t about love, they had horrible chemistry…
her dream wasn’t to fall in love, her dream was to sing… so if she stays young, she should’ve stayed with element… and why leave her family behind… Daniel wasn’t worth all of that…

Mr park deserved so much better so I’m glad she didn’t end up with him xD she never deserved him, she acted like her life was miserable, but she had a better life that her sister whose kids sent her to a retirement home… she was better than the “enemy” that had to lie about her son and never got to experience the motherly love
And she always had mr park, so a cheating husband wasn’t the end of the world when you have so many loyal friends and family

She only lacked her chance to sing, and she was robbed of that again
She didn’t get a happy ending, and Daniel, not knowing anything deserves the truth, his lover is +40 years older than him xD
Immortal stories are believable cuz that person lives as a 20s something for XX years
Dori was an old lady that experienced all the hardships of growing old
And having the cheap amnesia plot move is soooo annoying

I keep thinking about it and I’m annoyed now, the daughter love out-ways the one of a man, so it’s her daughter that should’ve looked for her, and kept her in her family sheltered and loved
She loved, and loved wrong in the past, she worked hard and suffered to gain stability for her and her daughter

And yet now, with no singing chance, she’s back in a cafe cleaning, waiting for the guy to save her..
the only difference, this guy is super rich xD

What she lacked from the beginning was a family, her sister and mom leaving, her dad passing away
If she stays young, her daughter becomes her mom, her son in law becomes her dad and her granddaughter becomes her sister
So she gives that away again, to go back for a man …..
Was this review helpful to you?