This review may contain spoilers
Pretty, punchy, and strangely hollow.
Coming off the emotional gravity of the original Tale of the Nine-Tailed, this one felt like a reunion that looked right on paper but didn’t quite land in the heart. I went in with soft expectations — just a hope, really, that the bond between Yeon and Rang might be explored again with that same raw, aching tenderness. But this wasn’t that kind of show. This was louder, faster, glossier — a polished spectacle trying to recreate magic by turning up the volume.
And sure, it was fun in moments. Time travel, new characters, chaotic brawls in vintage suits — there’s no denying 1938 was swinging big. Lee Dong-wook still wore Yeon like a well-cut coat: smooth, stoic, and self-aware. He knows this role, and he knows how to give it enough gravity that it doesn’t float off into camp, even when the plot veers close. But even he couldn’t summon the emotional resonance of the original season — because the writing didn’t go looking for it.
The Yeon-Rang dynamic, which in the first season was this thread of complicated brotherhood you felt even in the silences, here felt like a nod to a past connection more than something actively unfolding. Kim Bum showed up with the same sharp charisma, but without that soul-deep grief driving his actions, Rang became more of a sidekick than a wound. That emotional rawness was missing — replaced with quips and fight choreography.
And look, I get it — prequels are tricky. You’re working backward from resolution, trying to carve tension out of a story where you already know the ending. But the emotional stakes in 1938 felt… manufactured. Almost like the show knew it needed something to fill the space left by the original’s quiet devastation, and it filled it with noise. Stylish, well-produced noise, but noise all the same.
The humor was hit-or-miss. Sometimes it landed with a wink. Other times, it barged into scenes that could’ve had weight and deflated them before they had a chance to breathe. It often felt like the show didn’t trust its own audience to sit in a feeling for more than ten seconds.
What hurts most is that there was potential. The time period offered a new lens, the cast had solid chemistry, and the cinematography — clean, rich, confident — did the heavy lifting when the script sagged. But without the emotional ache, without the stillness and sincerity that made the first season so unexpectedly moving, this installment felt more like a fanservice loop than a continuation of something meaningful.
I didn’t hate it. But I didn’t carry it with me either. It showed up dressed to impress, full of tricks and flourishes — but it never really said anything new. And for a story built around ancient spirits and timeless bonds, that silence said more than it meant to.
And sure, it was fun in moments. Time travel, new characters, chaotic brawls in vintage suits — there’s no denying 1938 was swinging big. Lee Dong-wook still wore Yeon like a well-cut coat: smooth, stoic, and self-aware. He knows this role, and he knows how to give it enough gravity that it doesn’t float off into camp, even when the plot veers close. But even he couldn’t summon the emotional resonance of the original season — because the writing didn’t go looking for it.
The Yeon-Rang dynamic, which in the first season was this thread of complicated brotherhood you felt even in the silences, here felt like a nod to a past connection more than something actively unfolding. Kim Bum showed up with the same sharp charisma, but without that soul-deep grief driving his actions, Rang became more of a sidekick than a wound. That emotional rawness was missing — replaced with quips and fight choreography.
And look, I get it — prequels are tricky. You’re working backward from resolution, trying to carve tension out of a story where you already know the ending. But the emotional stakes in 1938 felt… manufactured. Almost like the show knew it needed something to fill the space left by the original’s quiet devastation, and it filled it with noise. Stylish, well-produced noise, but noise all the same.
The humor was hit-or-miss. Sometimes it landed with a wink. Other times, it barged into scenes that could’ve had weight and deflated them before they had a chance to breathe. It often felt like the show didn’t trust its own audience to sit in a feeling for more than ten seconds.
What hurts most is that there was potential. The time period offered a new lens, the cast had solid chemistry, and the cinematography — clean, rich, confident — did the heavy lifting when the script sagged. But without the emotional ache, without the stillness and sincerity that made the first season so unexpectedly moving, this installment felt more like a fanservice loop than a continuation of something meaningful.
I didn’t hate it. But I didn’t carry it with me either. It showed up dressed to impress, full of tricks and flourishes — but it never really said anything new. And for a story built around ancient spirits and timeless bonds, that silence said more than it meant to.
Was this review helpful to you?
