Niina no Papa

Me too... :'(

My heart breaks for Gun, in my most humble opinion, her running away was SOOOOO wrong, that's why she's the post-it girl, a wet noodle for a spine, and not loving Gun enough to fight for their relationship. My heart, like yours is so heavy because of her actions. She was too easily swayed by Daniel, total betrayal to her heart and to Gun in my most humble opinion... :'(((

In my most humble opinion, both are good, I'm enjoying the 1st part of the Kdrama, whereas the 2nd part I am finding the Tdrama better thus far, they have changed a few details in the Kdrama from the original, but for the most part, they're following the same script, the major things are the same. :))) I do think you would appreciate this one more, especially the 1st half if you want the Tdrama first, I agree with Mitchelle there... Min Young I find is a much softer, loving, and caring type of personality, at least in the 1st part of the Kdrama, don't know after the 12th ep.

I like the Tdrama because at least when she leaves for Shanghai, she doesn't really know that Cun Xi has feelings for her, and neither does Cun Xi, whereas, here when she leaves, there's no excuse, she KNOWS Gun loves her, you saw the chemistry build, and the adoration and love Gun has for Mi Young, her running off with the jerk Daniel just ruined it for me. I do so agree with you, the emotions and chemistry between the two are so so SOOOO much better here in the Kdrama version. The only asshole's I saw were Dylan in the Tdrama, and Daniel in this one for trying to steal the girls from their husbands. I'm not making this up either, Wikipedia says, and I quote,
"Choi Jin-hyuk as Daniel Pitt
An internationally famous Korean-American designer whose single goal is finding his long-lost biological sister. He meets Mi-young by accident, and is intrigued by her kindness. From then on, he becomes her Daddy-Long-Legs, encouraging her when she is down and coming to her rescue when she needs help. Constantly worrying about her, Daniel begins to realize that what he feels towards Mi-young is something more than protectiveness.", and well, you saw Dylan, they became an item, even if but for a very short time, it still showed he wanted her more so than just a friendly encouragement. As to Daniel, you already saw it several times, but the most subtle one was the photo shoot. Then when Mi Young was waiting for Gun on their birthday, Daniel's stalking her sitting in his car watching her the whole time, not nice stealing or even trying to take another man's wife... Anyway, the first half of the Kdrama I really enjoyed more, whereas, after the accident, I'm enjoying the Tdrama more, just for the reason of the reason for leaving the country.

Yeah, I'm just watching it now from just after her accident, at the hospital, he crying and pleading to save her because she's
his wife, so how can she feel he hates her and doesn't want her anymore? This isn't meant to be hateful, but is she that dense not to know, is she that much of a simpleton? Seriously... He's constantly by her side, she wakes up with him there by her hospital bed, I just don't get her reasoning other than blaming him for losing the baby. That would be the only redeeming point
of me forgiving her for what she's done by leaving him, she just didn't love him enough, at least that's what my thoughts are anyway. He is to blame for her accident, and I'm so glad he takes responsibility for it, is that why she leaves? I hope it comes out in the upcoming episodes. As to the divorce form, she knows it's all a misunderstanding of both families, she knows he doesn't want it anymore, it was her mother who came and forced her out of his house and split them up, is she following her mother's wishes? She goes to see him at his office, and asks him if there's a chance of them starting over again, he's says sorry, but she had to know he still loved her, just from the hospital scene when he was pleading with the doc's saying she was his wife, to please save her. It was to easy and too fast a decision to go to France with Daniel, she didn't even fight, she gave up so easily, no spine, just a wet noodle for a spine in my most humble opinion, and that's why she went to France. She didn't even try, and that makes me even more upset with her, she just didn't love him enough, and you could see, at least I did, an attitude change in her in the hospital, a resentment building towards Gun for him not saving the baby. Very sad that she didn't even try, especially when she knew he loved her, she didn't even try to find out why he wanted the breakup, all she did was asked why he lied to her concerning his memory. They should have spent time together and talked about everything, instead, she runs away with Daniel to France. Total betrayal in my most humble opinion, and with another man to boot... :'( Only one my heart so breaks for is Gun... But I'm angry at both Gun and Mi Young, Gun for not talking to her about his disease and making the decision to leave her because of it, he's being EXTREMELY selfish for making the decision all on his own, I know why he did it, to save her from hurt later on, but he's causing her more hurt now, and has caused her more hurt because of it, being the accident losing her baby, and Mi Young for not trying hard enough, for being so easily swayed to run away with Daniel to France, but I am SO MUCH more angry with her, that's why she's a post-it girl...

I'm EXTREMELY angry with Mi Young for leaving, and Daniel, don't you remember at the photo shoot alone? His body language was not that of a neighbour oppa, he was after her as a woman, not a sister, Gun wasn't shoving her away for a long time, Gun was showing her sooo much affection, adoration, and love, and she knew it, and SO DID Daniel. I would ask one of my friends if I suspected something was wrong, but I'd be encouraging her to go talk it out with her husband/boyfriend, I MOST CERTAINLY would not do what he's been doing, the synopsis on Wikipedia even says he realizes his feelings aren't just being an oppa but love for her as a woman. Like I said, he's not been encouraging her but has been a real snake by trying his UTMOST BEST to get her away from Gun, for Pete's sake, on her birthday, what's he doing? He's stalking her, sitting in his car watching her, waiting for his opportunity to pounce. She knew Gun didn't hate her, and especially after the accident she knew, SHE KNEW, Gun loved her and was heartbroken not just for himself but for her. Then at the end of ep12, she's calling him Daniel, not oppa, he wasn't trying to help her out, he was after her like bee's on honey. At the auction, again, he's pushing and pushing trying to win her love as a woman, not a sister. In the beginning when he was just getting to know her, yeah, he encouraged her to go back, but as time progressed, that stopped, he told her to stay over how many times, stay for dinner how many times, not once did her tell her she needed to go talk to Gun and try to figure out their problems... You watch in the next few episodes, he'll be confessing his love for you, mark my words, if he hasn't already in those three years, I'm sure they're now an item already. Jonssister, I know how he's working, my brother did it to me, I see the signs because I've been through it. He's nothing but a snake and an asswipe who wants her for himself and can't bear to see another man's wife with her husband Gun. Unless they change the kdrama so that she doesn't date him, mark my words, if not already, they will be an item. The only reason I see Mi Young going to France is because she blames Gun for the loss of her baby, but from what I saw there were still stars in her eyes for Gun, and she knew his feelings for her, she knew he was lying to her, so why leave? Yeah, I'm EXTREMELY upset at her for what she did, and I can't bear to see her with Daniel, I'll be skipping a few episodes until like the Tdrama, Gun and Mi Young start working to getting back together again, or at least her showing affection towards him again. She really blew me away by leaving, but then, she had a real noodle for a spine to begin with, meaning, she let people walk all over her and was so easily swayed, hence, going to France with Daniel, Gun was always encouraging her to being super glue, to become stronger, so for that reason, I don't hate her, but she did, she SO betrayed Gun for leaving with Daniel, and for that reason alone, she's SO much worse than Se Ra, at least Se Ra didn't leave with another man, at least Se Ra didn't hurt Gun going with another man meanwhile knowing Gun loved her like Mi Young did. That's why I'm so livid and upset at Mi Young, she had ABSOLUTELY no business to run off with Daniel, is she so simple that she wouldn't know how much it would really and super hurt Gun by doing that? Was it revenge? If so, why? After this episode of the original, ep19, I'm going to have to watch from the accident again to see what happened, to see what I miss, to see why she decided to go with that asswipe Daniel, because tbh, I don't understand, I really don't, why she left Gun. You said it was because of Gun breaking up with her, but that was before the accident, and he made it clear to her just by his body language, weird though he is with his body language, she knew how much he loved her, so why do what she did, I am, I'm confused, stumped, angry, and just what just happened, stunned... By the way, I've dropped Fall in Love With Me, once he married that simpleton piece of you know what, that did it for me... Another drama of betrayal, I can't handle that... Anyway, if you seen more than I did as to why Mi Young did what she did, please explain it to me because I saw nothing but betrayal with another man, yeah, Mi Young didn't know Daniel's feelings maybe, but still no reason to run away with him, at least she should have sat down with Gun and talked it over with him and both decide if it was the right thing for her to do, not just tell him she's going to France and there's nothing he can do about it. Poor guy, my heart broke for him when they lost the baby, and now my heart feels shattered for him on account of her leaving. She didn't even give him a chance to ask her not to go, she didn't even give him a chance to tell her he didn't want the divorce any longer, that's why I like the tdrama so much better, Xin Yi felt at times that Cun Xi had feelings for her, but she wasn't sure because he didn't say or show very strongly how he felt towards her, he was mean to her, then the f'in wench girlfriend Anna giving her the abortion form making Xin Yi believe it was his idea, I don't blame her for leaving, but there again, the jackass snake, just like Daniel, took her away and they became an item, but I can handle it a little more than this drama just because she didn't really know that he loved her because of his and Anna's actions. Just a HUGE misunderstanding between Xin Yi and Cun Xi, but yeah, I'm livid with Mi Young, and I ABSOLUTELY despise and loathe the jackass Daniel for not leaving her the CRAP alone...

Hehe, that's if you love real snakes in the grass, he was despicable for stealing her away from CX, right from the get go, he wanted her for himself, to me he deserves a bullet straight between the eyes for what he did... :)))

Dylan's a real snake in the grass that deserves a bullet between the eyes for stealing her away from Cun Xi, he was around them enough to see the love building, he even brought the fact up to Cun Xi that he(CX) loved her, then to take her away and hide her, no, he's a despicable fool, how on earth was he sweet? In the background he's working away, biding his time, finding just the right chance to steal her away, then succeeds. That's not sweet, that's underhanded and a real crime... He deserves to rot and burn for what he did...

@jonssister, Se Ra is his sister, no doubt about it...

Se Ra's his sister, if you watch the tdrama, you'll see that Se Ra's his sister, and Se Ra has the burn mark on the back of her shoulder. In the beginning, it shows her sitting across the aisle from him in the airplane...

I'm now watching the original, I must say, I'm liking it so much better than this one, I'm really hating Mi Young right now for running away, especially when she knows he loves and adores her now, maybe I missed something, but she knows he didn't want her to go, the f'in asswipe Daniel, snake in the grass finally got what he wanted, taking her away from Gun, and right now the way I feel, she's worse than Se Ra by leaving, at least Se Ra, she was coming back, Mi Young just betrayed him by leaving him the way she did with Daniel... I don't think I'll watch the rest of this one, I'm enjoying the tdrama better, at least when she ran to Shanghai, she didn't know he loved her...

Yeah, and I don't like the fact in the Tdrama, he's chosen to get married to Anna, he has a real noodle for a spine, he meet's Xin Yi in Shanghai, tells her he loves her, but while he tells her this, he's getting married to Anna, I'm sorry, you don't love someone and get married to another, to me that's just plain WRONG, he doesn't love Xin Yi enough. At least Xin Yi, when she realizes she's still in love with him, says goodbye to the asswipe, although I still don't think she needed to tell him she was sorry and that she let him down, that was bogus and ludicrous in my most humble opinion...

Yes, I am now watching the Tdrama, and to be honest, I so don't like what Mi Young did in the Kdrama version, by running away and gone for 3 years, in the Tdrama, she leaves because she's made to understand it was his idea for her to get the abortion so she runs off to Shanghai, but here, Mi Young knew he loved her, she knew he adored her at that point, yes his amnesia messed things up, but she's just a royal bitch for running away with that f'in asswipe Daniel, who finally got his wish and stole her away from Gun. Everyone is making me out to be the bad guy because I felt Gun betrayed Se Ra for getting married without telling Se Ra first they were through, well, Mi Young in my heart was just as bad as Se Ra for leaving him to go to France with Daniel. I don't think I will watch at least the next 3 episodes because from what I see of the Tdrama, she'll be with Daniel for awhile, I think I might even drop it on account of her leaving. She KNEW his feeling, 100% of the way, and she chose to go with Daniel. The Tdrama, he was mean to her right to the time of her running with that asswipe Dylon, she thought it was his idea for the abortion, etc, I can't blame her for leaving, Dylan, like Daniel, was a real snake in the grass for stealing her away, and she betrayed her heart by leaving without talking things through with Cun Xi first, but Mi Young, she full out betrayed Gun, and the end of ep12, yeah, I don't like what is coming at all, she's just being a lowlife as Se Ra is by leaving him the way she did. I'll watch it again in case I missed something, but yeah, Daniel needs to be put in front of a firing squad for what he's done by succeeding in getting her away from Gun for himself, a bullet straight between the f'in eyes. My own brother did what he did, and it's not a nice feeling at all. This drama wasn't at all what I thought it would be, if I had watched the Tdrama first, then I would have known what it was about and wouldn't watch this one, too much drama in this one for my liking. It's gotten to be stupid and twisted like the now airing Fall in Love With Me, not quite as bad, not the Tdrama so far is soooo much better than this one. Only thing I was enjoying was the growing to full blown love between Gun and Mi Young and well, her runnning away like that just royally ruined it for me... :(((

Daniel may be a nice neighbourhood oppa, but that doesn't excuse him for trying behind the scenes to steal her away from Gun, Wikipedia gives more of a synopsis than this, and he looks at her more than just a sister/brother, just look at the photo shoot, he isn't fooling around, as well, anybody can see he wants her more than just being a neighbour oppa, look at his body language. And inviting her to France? Come on, it isn't just for her to learn more. Yeah, I didn't like the end of ep12 3 years later. Oh, and I didn't like the um, amnesia, that really ruined the plot, it really destroyed a really great thing going. If he hadn't gotten scared and dumped Mi Young for fear of his disease, that accident wouldn't have happened either. I do want to see them together and this time share a child because of love. If she has another miscarriage, I know you think badly of me for not sympathizing with her on account of going for an abortion earlier, I will sympathize with her because she is such a loving and caring person. Just remember, had it not been for Gun, that baby would have long been gone. Coffee Prince was a fairly great drama, a few idiotic idiots, but other than that, it was a great drama, I quite enjoyed it. :)))

Hehe, yeah, it really creeps you out, but not just his laugh, when he wants to touch Mi Young, his movements are just really creepy. I don't think I'll get his laugh out of my mind for a very long time... LOL

You are right R1N7B, divorce is there for a reason, because of the hardness of peoples' hearts...

Well, I'm just saying Gun and Se Ra both betrayed each other, her first. And yes, I would love it if they had drama's without divorce or these stupid despicable love triangles, and judging from the end of ep12, if 13 is showing her and Daniel together, this is so dropped. I would rather watch a real love bliss flick myself...

Hehe, I'm only saying marriage should only be out of love for the other person, and whenever marriage is mentioned in the Bible, you see that marriage was meant for two people who love each other to get married. A perfect example of a marriage with no love would be Jacob and Leah, he never loved her, and I don't believe he loved her through to the end, several times she complains because he love Rachel, he mourned Rachel when she died, he never mourned Leah, but, and I say BUT, to marry only to divorce is SOOO very wrong, and that was Gun's intent, how did that make Mi Young feel, how would you feel if it were you, I don't think that given it were you in her shoes, you wouldn't feel so good to know the other party is planning to divorce you in 10 months, not so nice at all. I was only using the Bible as an example before, it's just common sense to marry someone because you love them. And I'm just going by stats, how many divorces are there because of marriages without love to begin with, there's enough already where there was love in the beginning, let alone no love. Marriage is sacred, it isn't a play toy for us to play around with, it is a vow, a sacred vow, whether you believe in God or now, it is a promise, till death do we part. I was enjoying see the romance start to grow between Gun and Mi Young, but only to see the BS in ep12, and I don't think I'm going to like much of the rest of the drama so I will wait till the last episode comes out, I don't need to see her with the jackass, Daniel, who tried to pull her away from Gun when they were still together, the photo shoot was a perfect example. People are SOOOO selfish, and he is one of the worst, Se Ra is another, at least though, she chose her dream, he's just being a jackass by trying to ruin that relationship for himself. Gun is selfish too for deciding to divorce Mi Young on account of his disease, he should be sitting down with her and talking to her about it, not saying goodbye, had it not been for him dumping Mi Young, that accident wouldn't have happened, so the blame of losing the child is all on HIS shoulders. Anyway, I went off topic, not everyone marries for love, but love should be the reason for marriage, not other reasons. :)))

@hvnlyslayerangel, screw off!!!

I'm just trolling am I? Se Ra did get what she deserved, but both betrayed each other, she betrayed him by choosing her dream, he betrayed her by getting married, he knew she loved him, and he loved her, hence HIS betrayal...