kaipeaches

i think tee is probably the "big villain" and will die last with the worst death. if my theory is right and new (non's brother) is white, it'll probably be white who kills him, and i'm soooo here for it hehe

if we go by the theory that non IS dead, phee probably approached the group to get revenge but knowing that jin wasn't the worst of them (since jin had a crush on non), and probably getting involved wasn't his top priority, but now that he's been fucking him for three years, he's involved romantically. it makes sense why phee didn't want to go from fuck buddies to real boyfriends (guilt about moving on from his dead boyfriend he's there to avenge), but also the boy just caught feelings ¯\_(ツ)_/¯

white is definitely non's brother. i think tan is just a dude, isn't there to serve anyone, but white and phee are definitely working together.

until now i thought non was alive, but now i think he's dead, and the duo working together to avenge him is white and phee.

so new (non's brother) is definitely white, and phee was his boyfriend. it would also explain phee's hesitance to go from fuck buddies to real boyfriends with jin, bc he probably feels guilty about moving on from his dead boyfriend he's there to avenge. it'd also explain why the plot armor has been thicker with jin than the others -- he had a crush on non, new/white and phee probably know he wasn't as bad as the others, and are taking it a little easier on him.

non's brother is likely white.

thank you!!! 🥰🥰🥰

yeah top was definitely to blame as well. actually from the og 4, ironically only fluke seems to be "innocent". he's going all psycho now because he's paranoid, but the way he talked to tee made it clear he wasn't supposed to even know about whatever they filmed.

i was obsessing over the trailer and pre-release video and i have a theory 👀

white is seen looking at tee from above, with a super creepy/calculating look, and tee is "?" about it. later, when jin is seen holding the camera, white's image flashes to standing beside him. i'm PRETTY SURE that means white approached tee for revenge. my guess is that he probably knew non. maybe even through the cult that the show keeps hinting at.

i think jin has personally killed the teacher. someone mentioned the teacher has abused one of them, and i think it'd make sense for it to be jin, but i couldn't find that info anywhere else, SO i'm still going on my original idea that the teacher walked in on them doing something cruel to non, and they accidentally killed the teacher in the panic to cover their tracks. again, i think jin specifically has killed the teacher.

non is probably alive -- it would've been even CREEPIER if non was dead and they knew about it and all of this started happening -- and working with at least one of the boys to punish the original three/four, but there may be more of them. phee is definitely in the clear re: cruelty, so he could be working with white and non.

something that points to jin possibly working with non as well: he's seen caring about non in the trailer, actually wanting him to be part of the friend group, and has been the least dedicated to keeping the secret of whatever they did to non; he's bitter about it.
something that points to jin NOT working with non: he clearly has feelings for phee. if non was alive and he knew about it, he'd probably continue having a relationship with non. if he moved on, he hasn't had contact with non.

we know only one couple is getting a happy ending, and my guess for it is jinphee, mostly because i'm so sure white is in this to fuck tee over. tee had some weird possessive/abusive vibes on ep1 before they had sex, so even if he cares for white, the narrative is definitely framing him as a Not Really Good Guy.

AND THAT'S MY THEORY FOR TODAY. next ep may ruin all my theories but we'll see lol

my theory is they (probably jin) only killed the teacher, but they (probably tee) have definitely done something horrible to non. if it's not SA, probably extreme bullying, though i don't know how they'd frame it as something bad enough to be done in that short period of time to make him "go missing"

100%, and the horror is sooooo badly done (i say, as i enjoy every minute of it, and it's one of my favorite airing dramas)

based on the pre-release video, i'm actually pretty sure white has approached tee just to get revenge for either non (who i think is still alive but probably suffered something horribly cruel) or the dead teacher. my guess is either he knew non through the cult, or was the dead teacher's younger brother or something like that.

ps: the hidden character is a Mess, it's rly bad, and it's probably the reason this drama has such a low rating. it was a set-up and made a lot of people angry at the company.

RIIIIIGHT. i love it so much!!!!!! there's a thousand plot holes but listen it's a slasher by a company known to go on vibes alone 😭 it's still so entertaining and got us coming up with a thousand theories!!! GOOD SHIT!!!!!

i'm 10000% sure white approached tee to get revenge for non so he /could/ potentially even be fvcking someone else!

i'm pretty sure it's a jinphee. white is probably working with non/to get revenge on him and will screw tee over.

based on the pre-release trailer and the calculating/creepy way he was looking at tee, i'm pretty sure he already knew non OR dead teacher and approached tee with revenge in mind. lol

i think jin didn't screw non over. in the trailer there's a scene of him saying something like "once the film is over they'll see you're necessary" and he's probably saying that to non, to convince him he'll be accepted into the friend group, bc that's what he wants to believe.

pretty sure no one

nah i think he is too!!! more likely that he's joined a cult and carefully planned his revenge lol if he were dead i think they'd just say it off the bat, it would make them even more scared, from a narrative pov

word

i think whichever theory's right (non being alive or not), at least one of the boys are working against the og boys who were there. by bet is definitely white (he has too much of final girl vibes, plus his sus vibes in the pre-release video) and maybe phee as well.