This review may contain spoilers
It was ART: a beautiful story, but Shu He's character development was questionable
I loved it, the cinematography, OST, characters, dialogues, everything was great. A must watch.
BUT for some reason many seem to dismiss the inconsistency in Shu He's character and blame Duan Zi for everything.
If anything Shu He was the red flag, not the other way around. Shu He turned out to be quite "patriotic" for someone who never cared about politics.
First things first, what was up with returning that presented string to the Crown Prince and giving him cold shoulder after he returned from battle? He gave his insecure brother all the wrong signals to be suspicious of him and never even properly talked to him.
I can understand why he would choose to stay behind and not follow Duan Zi during the rebellion, I understand why he felt betrayed upon learning Duan Zi's origin, but if you think deeper, he himself used Duan Zi and whatever Duan Zi's lie was, he actually had all the reasons to harm South Hi's clan for losing his family and being forced into becoming a Red Shadow Guard since childhood. Yet he put Shu He first and didn't kill any of them up untill that scene at the bridge. Keep in mind, that a person who was devoid of a normal household and was trained to kill, held back.
Yet Shu He still holds Duan Zi accountable for his brother's and even father's death for 5 years - Duan Zu literally killed the Crown Prince after he lunged forward swinging his sword to put Shu He out of his "misery." And the Prince himself killed his own father. So Shu He wanting to "atone" for his unstable brother that wanted to disable him and in the end hurt his hand, framed him and wanted to kill him makes little sense. I understand their bond, and I'm not simplifying Crown Prince's character or their dynamics, but hating Duan Zi all those years and refusing his letters doesn't make. Why doesnt he also hate his brother for killing his father? More importantly revenging a DYING person also doesn't make sense - I can see why Shu He wanted to die, but there're many ways to queitly die without traumatizing "the love of his life". He once mentioned failing he protect his mother, himself and Duan Zi, but turned out to be the only person who actually hurt Duan Zi. He harbored ill will towards no one for any wrongdoings, except for Duan Zi. As if it's easy to confess that you were trained to become an assasin.
I loved all 5 main characters and their stories, almost all of them made many mistakes and were complicated, and all of them carry the reaponsibility for their choices. But Shu He shifted all the blame on Duan Zi up untill the very end. Shu He was the one that lacked coherence and purpose the most - he was like a poison both to the Crown Prince and Duan Zi.
BUT for some reason many seem to dismiss the inconsistency in Shu He's character and blame Duan Zi for everything.
If anything Shu He was the red flag, not the other way around. Shu He turned out to be quite "patriotic" for someone who never cared about politics.
First things first, what was up with returning that presented string to the Crown Prince and giving him cold shoulder after he returned from battle? He gave his insecure brother all the wrong signals to be suspicious of him and never even properly talked to him.
I can understand why he would choose to stay behind and not follow Duan Zi during the rebellion, I understand why he felt betrayed upon learning Duan Zi's origin, but if you think deeper, he himself used Duan Zi and whatever Duan Zi's lie was, he actually had all the reasons to harm South Hi's clan for losing his family and being forced into becoming a Red Shadow Guard since childhood. Yet he put Shu He first and didn't kill any of them up untill that scene at the bridge. Keep in mind, that a person who was devoid of a normal household and was trained to kill, held back.
Yet Shu He still holds Duan Zi accountable for his brother's and even father's death for 5 years - Duan Zu literally killed the Crown Prince after he lunged forward swinging his sword to put Shu He out of his "misery." And the Prince himself killed his own father. So Shu He wanting to "atone" for his unstable brother that wanted to disable him and in the end hurt his hand, framed him and wanted to kill him makes little sense. I understand their bond, and I'm not simplifying Crown Prince's character or their dynamics, but hating Duan Zi all those years and refusing his letters doesn't make. Why doesnt he also hate his brother for killing his father? More importantly revenging a DYING person also doesn't make sense - I can see why Shu He wanted to die, but there're many ways to queitly die without traumatizing "the love of his life". He once mentioned failing he protect his mother, himself and Duan Zi, but turned out to be the only person who actually hurt Duan Zi. He harbored ill will towards no one for any wrongdoings, except for Duan Zi. As if it's easy to confess that you were trained to become an assasin.
I loved all 5 main characters and their stories, almost all of them made many mistakes and were complicated, and all of them carry the reaponsibility for their choices. But Shu He shifted all the blame on Duan Zi up untill the very end. Shu He was the one that lacked coherence and purpose the most - he was like a poison both to the Crown Prince and Duan Zi.
Was this review helpful to you?
