Fans shouldn't be comparing suffering, like what's the point?. But I've not seen anyone say they both suffered…
Yes, all of this, beautifully said. This is how it feels to me too and it breaks my heart truly for BOTH of them when we put it all into words. Thanks for your thoughts. Also this: "I refuse to quantify Jeongyo and Pio's pain and trauma because neither of them think that the other had it easy." This, this. this. And if anything the series is leading to them each having a deeper understanding of each other and their pain and truths, and seeing each other fully in that truth no matter how messy and hard. Seeing each other in the music, their feelings of fear and grief, and seeing each other through their trauma, which will hopefully lead them to the other side of this forced "rivalry" (and toward some kind of healing).
IT'S MORE THAN 2😭 BL vs Bromance & Team Pi O vs Jeongyo + a category who can understand all of these perceptives
This is hilarious. You're so right, it's been a mess here since the series was announced. The bromance vs. BL battles were all encompassing before the Jeongyo fans vs. Pio fans battles took off. It's kind of hilarious when you think about it. World peace is impossible I guess.
I am still thinking about the fact that Pi O comes out at Jeong Yo's door unannounced at 1am and Jeong Yo still…
Like he comes by all the time, just unannounced and JY lets him inside!! Ahhhhhh I am on the floor laughing at these two. More evidence that their innate bond and trust is still there, underneath it all. Like if JY truly believed in his innermost heart that Pio tried to kill him or was some kind of potential murderous threat who can try again at any moment, no way would JY be letting him get so close to him ALL THE TIME. Whether in his home or during the private lessons when they are like 2 centimeters apart. It's like their bodies instinctively know where they belong.
Yeah the writing makes us like this. If they worked together against evil or something, we wouldn’t compare…
But no one is at all asking fans to compare suffering, and definitely not the text itself. Many people are not doing that. I see brilliant analysis elsewhere where folks are talking about symbolism, the music, the language choice, the structure of the story, and all kinds of things that are not reducing the story to who suffers more. The only people I see nitpicking about who suffers more are people siding with their favs. Which is okay if that's why you're watching it for, but it's not a more natural or only way to engage. Why do you only want to focus on why JY's actions should be perceived as right? That's not what the story is about to me.
Fans shouldn't be comparing suffering, like what's the point?. But I've not seen anyone say they both suffered…
Haha, we'll disagree again. But it's always fun, lol. Okay, so "they both suffered, period" is not at attempt to downplay anyone's experience, it's recognizing that both have suffered. Which is actually something I've seen haters deny, so that's why I began to emphasize it in my posts. That's it. That's all it's saying. Both have suffered. How can that not be important? It's in no way meant to erase JY. It's meant to say both matter to the narrative. Both are human stories that matter. The show has made it so clear that both have suffered. We see it on screen, it was paralleled, and that suffering carries emotional weight for them so much so that it impact sEVERYTHING.
Also, it's a core way the two characters trauma bonded and why they needed to find safety in each other. Their suffering is also what creates the drama and the conflict that follows. To pretend only one character's suffering matters doesn't make sense at all to me (b/c both matter), and it's not what the script is implying IMHO even if the main POV is Pio. Also, I don't at all believe fans are being asked by the narrative to compare the suffering. Or to take sides. I've watched plenty of rivalry series and enjoyed both characters. I tend to enjoy the dance and the interaction b/w rivals the most. Taking sides is not how ALL fans engage, and I've seen that from my discussions on other sites. I've seen brilliant analysis talking about so many other interesting aspects of the writing, even about how and why the trauma manifests and how it impacts the arcs that is not focused on comparing that trauma. So all that to say: it's not some inevitable way to engage with the show. But fans often take sides b/c it's how we're socialized (it's why sports games, nationalism, and heck even war exist; we think something is better and fight about it). So it's nothing surprising. But for this series? I just feel it's missing the point and shadowing otherwise interesting character writing. But that's just my opinion lol.
People saying that, as an audience, we’re not supposed to “take sides” or criticize one character more than…
Fans shouldn't be comparing suffering, like what's the point?. But I've not seen anyone say they both suffered ~equally. They both suffered, period, and are both acting out of that trauma in ways that both create plot and impact plot. That is clear. But the "who suffered MORE?" debate is just so silly and tends to miss the entire point of the drama IMHO. The writer isn't wanting fans to obsess over who makes the best woobie lol. And sure, a fan can relate to JY (or Pio) more, feel sorry for him the most, or argue that his pain should be the main concern of viewers. But that's just a perspective coming from wanting the narrative to center the character that fan connects to. It's common, everyone has different narrative interests. And in a rivalry show fans almost always mimic the show by taking sides and arguing one character against the other. It's fascinating to see, and I think in this series it was interesting to see fans pitting the characters against each other the same way the toxic adults were in the script. But fandom needing to tear down the other characters or to claim the writer hates a character simply because the writer is telling a story that doesn't always go the way the fan wants for a character....eh that is where things get exhausting.
i'm confused, if you understand jeongyo's pov, why is it so hard to understand jaein's? she doesn't know jeongyo…
I get it, it’s so tiring. I kind of feel like the writer has an interesting story they are trying to tell and put a lot of work into this script (the religious imagery, the symbolism, the character names, the parallels, etc). But often it seems to get lost when fans only approach through what they want the character they favor to experience. It feels like fan/character attachment often comes with seeing anything (or anyone) that goes against this character in the script as an attack on the character as opposed to just plot-forward momentum. Jaein confronting JY is so in-character. It's not meant to villainize. Or maybe I feel an attachment to the writer b/c I can understand why they chose to go the way they did to extend the angst and to extend the vengeance plot so far, even when I disagree with some decisions. Honestly I just love angst so I love all the terrible decisions the characters are making and all the confrontations that push them toward some inevitable emotional climax.
i'm confused, if you understand jeongyo's pov, why is it so hard to understand jaein's? she doesn't know jeongyo…
This exactly. Why are people always assuming the writer hates one of the characters? Clearly we are watching different shows b/c to me the writer is not hating one of the characters just b/c Jaein makes an assumption about the conflict. Both JY and Jaein are clearly acting from what knowledge they have.
I saw another round of people predicting a tragic end for one or both characters after the latest interview from the actors. I could be wrong and we do get a tragic ending with one of them dying, but I think it would do the series a big disservice (and the characters too). So much suffering already! We had basically 9 episodes of pure suffering, and 9 years of them suffering away from each other. To have them end by death and not getting to be with each other? Ah. I just don't think this is that level of makjang or melodrama where we see the main leads die.
Both boys do have traits of a tragic hero, which in literature is a protagonist, someone who is generally good or well-intentioned, but who experiences a terrible tragedy due to a flaw or bad choice, and this leads to their downfall and/or death. While both characters have made a morally dubious decision (Pio covering for his mother, or JY taking revenge) that could lead to some tragic result, I don't think this story is in essence a tragedy.
I kind of think (and hope), it's a story about how two people got tossed around by forces outside of their control, and were able to get through to find each other again. This is why "who suffered the most" and "who is the villain!" doesn't make sense to me as a way to read the story. It's too reductionist and misses the clearly beautiful paralleling and complex character work that the writer has been doing.
To me the point of the series is that both suffered, both were traumatized by family (their experiences were literally mirrored in the first episode to show this). Both found home in each other, a sort of salvation and safe space away from that trauma, but that was taken away from them by controlling violent adults with more power and with a vision for them that was not the vision both boys wanted. JY and Pio simply wanted to be together and make music, to find happiness in each other and music (Pio told us the audience and JY that he was happiest when he was with JY and making music).
In essence, both are tragic characters who become antagonists to each other b/c they were forced into these roles by these extreme external forces --> created to be "rivals." They are both acting out of trauma. It's not always healthy and we may disagree on their choices, but it's compelling b/c it's so real and complex and beautiful to watch (and cry about).
And I say it again, antagonist does not equal villain. Antagonists simply means two characters pitted against each other. They became each other's antagonists. The villain of the story and the cause of the core wound and moral injury that has nearly destroyed them both is the mother (and truly every adult in their life lbh).
Some people on X saying that its the screenwriters fault and the script only wanted to show Pi O as a victim and…
This exactly. The lack of media literacy is the issue truly and it was clear since Ep1 when people were here saying Pio was a bully villain lol. And JY has clearly been shown to suffer and we know he suffered. Just b/c he's doesn't have the major POV does not mean he's a villain. There is difference b/w a villain and an antagonist, and both boys are *antagonists* to each other, not villains.
And same for folks hating on Pio. It's so silly b/c what the writer is doing is actually quite brilliant, and I say this as someone who reads screenplays. It hasn't been bad writing (at least in the first 10 episodes, can't say for the finale eps). But the narrative choices have been quite fun, and the choice to keep JY mysterious has also been a function of the story itself. People can disagree with her choice, but I think it was to create tension, which is hard to do. There is a reason we are screaming and crying for the characters every episode and not knowing what will actually happen --> that tells me the writing is EFFECTIVE in making us feel emotions and maintaining suspense.
Hmmm, I didn't read it as her turning her back or as the writer asking everyone to turn their back on Jeongyo.…
I think Jaein assumes it is from the rumor for the same reason the teacher did when he asked Pio's mother about her worries around JY. It has to have been the main thing about the two boys discussed for years, so it seems the logical assumption. Why would she ever think anything else is happening, especially after following Pio's search for the last five years? I just don't at all see this as a "judging" action; she is just making an educated guess about what could be the possible cause of friction given what she knows. It seems a quite reasonable assumption, and she's obviously there b/c she saw JY being violent with Pio at practice and wants answers as to why. You don't think this is reasonable for her to do when she has always being protective of Pio (even as far back as highschool protecting him from bullies)? And Jaein repeating that Pio was looking for JY would again make sense as it's an act of devotion in her eyes, something anyone would reassert as evidence to JY. I'm sorry I just don't at all see any of this as an attack on the character of JY or the writer hating the character. It's all very much in-character behavior from Jaein and IMHO it's such compelling storytelling b/c of the tension it creates when both characters don't know the full story and are trying to figure out what is happening. And protective!Jaein is established character trait canon.
Imagine yourself as the screenwriter of Four Hands: you’ve written a multi-layered script, infusing the two…
this cracks me up. artists have to suffer b/c fans don't understand their work and reduce it to things it's not even about. Oh is this what JY and Pio must go through when they don't understand what they are trying to say in their music? 😭
Wow even in the new preview, it’s jaein blaming jeongyo and judges him for hurting pio because ‘he believes…
Hmmm, I didn't read it as her turning her back or as the writer asking everyone to turn their back on Jeongyo. Why do you think that? It makes sense that from Jaein's POV and what she knows of their bond, that she would wonder why JY would believe the rumor and be surprised he does. Why would she think she needed to bring proof? She'd do the same if it was reversed (if confronting Pio about JY) b/c she knows them.
I remember reading a comment here earlier that said that even though this is not a BL, it has a great deal of emotional depth, even more than some BLs provide. While I know bromances get a lock of flack, I've always loved a good bromance for this reason, and think they can actually provide levels of deep emotional storytelling for two male leads.
We often get to see two men showing deep vulnerability and emotional intimacy with each other (which is rare), and tropes of protectiveness and fierce loyalty. And in queercoded bromances (argue with your mama!), I really love THE YEARNING we get. The devotion, the "I'd die for you" aspect of the bond, the unspoken sacrifices, the mutual trust (or the movement from distrust to mutual trust). The "you and me against the world" level of soulmatism. Anyway, I know folks say this is not quite a bromance because we got only 5 minutes of them being happy and acting as "friends", but I think it still has all the qualities of a bromance. Even with having only known each other a few months, and having spent 9 years away from each, these two people have only ever been it for each other. Pio spent his early adulthood basically as a war widow unable to move on. When his memory returned, Jeongyo spent his following Pio around the world and thinking he'd forgotten him. They can be codependent, toxic, obsessive, wild, passionate, but the "romance" in bromance is the thing keeping them connected. Two halves of a whole.
Nooooo, I was so worried JY would still read the situation wrong. Jae-in is essentially telling him it's not true…
This is a good point, maybe after Jaein leaves Jeongyo starts to doubt his belief that Pio did it. And after that I do wonder if Pio will be the one to confess the truth and make JY believe him somehow, or will JY hear it again from an outside source and this breaks through (the teacher, Pio's mother, Maestro, the private investigator). Jaein can at least maybe tell JY how broken up Pio was, something to counter the idea that JY has that Pio didn't miss him. I wonder what will be the thing that makes him believe.
Or maybe...wait...will the music speak the truth? Will the music make him believe?!
Also, it's a core way the two characters trauma bonded and why they needed to find safety in each other. Their suffering is also what creates the drama and the conflict that follows. To pretend only one character's suffering matters doesn't make sense at all to me (b/c both matter), and it's not what the script is implying IMHO even if the main POV is Pio. Also, I don't at all believe fans are being asked by the narrative to compare the suffering. Or to take sides. I've watched plenty of rivalry series and enjoyed both characters. I tend to enjoy the dance and the interaction b/w rivals the most. Taking sides is not how ALL fans engage, and I've seen that from my discussions on other sites. I've seen brilliant analysis talking about so many other interesting aspects of the writing, even about how and why the trauma manifests and how it impacts the arcs that is not focused on comparing that trauma. So all that to say: it's not some inevitable way to engage with the show. But fans often take sides b/c it's how we're socialized (it's why sports games, nationalism, and heck even war exist; we think something is better and fight about it). So it's nothing surprising. But for this series? I just feel it's missing the point and shadowing otherwise interesting character writing. But that's just my opinion lol.
Both boys do have traits of a tragic hero, which in literature is a protagonist, someone who is generally good or well-intentioned, but who experiences a terrible tragedy due to a flaw or bad choice, and this leads to their downfall and/or death. While both characters have made a morally dubious decision (Pio covering for his mother, or JY taking revenge) that could lead to some tragic result, I don't think this story is in essence a tragedy.
I kind of think (and hope), it's a story about how two people got tossed around by forces outside of their control, and were able to get through to find each other again. This is why "who suffered the most" and "who is the villain!" doesn't make sense to me as a way to read the story. It's too reductionist and misses the clearly beautiful paralleling and complex character work that the writer has been doing.
To me the point of the series is that both suffered, both were traumatized by family (their experiences were literally mirrored in the first episode to show this). Both found home in each other, a sort of salvation and safe space away from that trauma, but that was taken away from them by controlling violent adults with more power and with a vision for them that was not the vision both boys wanted. JY and Pio simply wanted to be together and make music, to find happiness in each other and music (Pio told us the audience and JY that he was happiest when he was with JY and making music).
In essence, both are tragic characters who become antagonists to each other b/c they were forced into these roles by these extreme external forces --> created to be "rivals." They are both acting out of trauma. It's not always healthy and we may disagree on their choices, but it's compelling b/c it's so real and complex and beautiful to watch (and cry about).
And I say it again, antagonist does not equal villain. Antagonists simply means two characters pitted against each other. They became each other's antagonists. The villain of the story and the cause of the core wound and moral injury that has nearly destroyed them both is the mother (and truly every adult in their life lbh).
And same for folks hating on Pio. It's so silly b/c what the writer is doing is actually quite brilliant, and I say this as someone who reads screenplays. It hasn't been bad writing (at least in the first 10 episodes, can't say for the finale eps). But the narrative choices have been quite fun, and the choice to keep JY mysterious has also been a function of the story itself. People can disagree with her choice, but I think it was to create tension, which is hard to do. There is a reason we are screaming and crying for the characters every episode and not knowing what will actually happen --> that tells me the writing is EFFECTIVE in making us feel emotions and maintaining suspense.
We often get to see two men showing deep vulnerability and emotional intimacy with each other (which is rare), and tropes of protectiveness and fierce loyalty. And in queercoded bromances (argue with your mama!), I really love THE YEARNING we get. The devotion, the "I'd die for you" aspect of the bond, the unspoken sacrifices, the mutual trust (or the movement from distrust to mutual trust). The "you and me against the world" level of soulmatism. Anyway, I know folks say this is not quite a bromance because we got only 5 minutes of them being happy and acting as "friends", but I think it still has all the qualities of a bromance. Even with having only known each other a few months, and having spent 9 years away from each, these two people have only ever been it for each other. Pio spent his early adulthood basically as a war widow unable to move on. When his memory returned, Jeongyo spent his following Pio around the world and thinking he'd forgotten him. They can be codependent, toxic, obsessive, wild, passionate, but the "romance" in bromance is the thing keeping them connected. Two halves of a whole.
Or maybe...wait...will the music speak the truth? Will the music make him believe?!