Nooooo, I was so worried JY would still read the situation wrong. Jae-in is essentially telling him it's not true but JY doesn't believe her. He's assuming everything Pio did to find him was to ensure he was dead. Ahhhhh. We really need the private detective to come and tell him the truth. I don't think JY's going to believe anyone else, I doubt even if Gramps, Teacher, and Pio himself now said the truth, why would he believe them? I'm not even sure he'd believe Pio's mother if she confessed (why wouldn't JY assume she's lying to protect Pio?).
I am cackling. Also added to say it also maps over classic K-drama romance tropes (which is why I still think…
"one appears sullen and indifferent, but saves the other when the other is in trouble." --> omg this is classic K-drama! The stoic/standoffish one pretending not to care but secretly caring!
This also gives us a bit of a sunshine + grumpy romance trope (and dog + cat). 17yo!Jeongyo had that happy puppy vibe to Pio's sullen kitty vibe (but of course the only time we see Pio smile is with JY). I didn't even realize it until I saw a video where someone had collected all the times he smiled in the series. Devastating really.
I love all these additions. And yes so many more in the scripting that tease at classic romance storytelling.
Also, I hope we see them in their special place again. I was just reading on twitter that the translation for their musical hideaway is "paradise."
This drama has everything that could meet Chinese BL's requirements except a kiss scene. 1.12 episodes2.Obsessed…
I am cackling. Also added to say it also maps over classic K-drama romance tropes (which is why I still think surprise brothers would be WEIRD). Let's see we have:
Rich Character + Poor Character as a Star-Crossed Pairing Childhood Meeting (establishing them as first-loves and having a soulmate connection) Wound Tending!!! (We get it both ways too) Forced Proximity or Bed Sharing (the awkward dorm room shenanigans) Epic Date Night where they “fall” in love (Pio literally falls on the ground and looks up at JY’s smiling face lol) Fake Death and/or Amnesia Causing Separation/Distance Controlling/Domineering Parent(s) Against the Relationship Enemies/Rivals to Friends to Lovers (to Enemies and Back Again!)
And of course the dreaded misunderstanding and miscommunication trope (done spectacularly in this series IMHO)
Now only 2 episode are left and I just realize one thing that this drama may have 3 main character but the true…
Yep, Pio is the main POV. It's a narrative choice. It happens even in double lead series, and also in ensemble series, you'll still sometimes have a main "POV" character we call it in writing --> this is the lens through which the audience primarily experiences the series and the plot. Sometimes you'll get equal POVs with two main lead characters, but often times you don't, and you'll still mostly "sit" with the character that tends to anchor the majority of the plot and through which the other characters have the most interactions (or through which POV we want the audience to be introduced to the world of the story). It is often a function of what story the writers want to tell. I mentioned to another commentator that this is likely a result of the "mystery" element needing us to not know what JY is up to in order to amp up the tension. At least it feels like this was the writer's intention to me. If this is what plays out in the last two eps, I do wish we'd get a bonus ep where we get to follow JY's journey (tell us about your monk life! about relearning music! about your tears and betrayal! about plotting your vengeance!).
Replying as someone who also genuinely likes both characters and their moral greyness (and I actually do like…
"I don't personally see how knowing how how much JY suffered in those past 10 years will lessen any mystery" --> Oh that is not what I meant, not about the suffering. What I mean is that us not getting his full backstory (which would include the suffering) is b/c of the choice of POV is how they decided to map out the "mystery." To me the choice feels deliberate (I read a lot of thrillers lol). It's like the writer wanted to introduce Part II so we can feel as surprised and in the dark as Pio would be. We find out with Pio that JY is alive! OMG! And JY enters as this mysterious figure risen from the dead and who may or may not be up to something. Very much a mystery trope. And because they want to keep him a mystery, we're not getting these episodes from his POV, which means the 9-year story of his backstory now became a casualty to the writing choice. But that's how I read it when this half of the series started. When we didn't get JY's POV and his backstory byEp. 8/9, I said to myself, oh they're doing this deliberately so we have no idea what is happening with JY. Totally a mystery series trope. It's so we can be surprised by the amnesia reveal, and now by the vengeance plan. A sort of slow reveal. But I do agree that it means robbing us from JY backstory b/c we don't spend those opening scenes in his head. I'm not sure if I made sense, it just seems to me to be a narrative choice. I like reading screen plays so this feels familiar in the way these beats are handled to build tension. What is known/unknown to the viewer.
Someone posted a short about Jeongyo and his friend Joo Rider’s friendship and they are genuinely sweet but…
Yes, this. Joo siding with the loan shark, or even forgiving his father's abuse -- JY can frame their betrayals in ways that are not directly tied to the core of who he is, but with Pio it is a much more intimate connect. I think one parallel between them is that they found in each other their PERSON, the ones they were willing to trust despite being hurt in the past, and someone with whom they felt it was safe to let their walls down. That connection was forged through the music. I was thinking about this last night b/c I was talking with someone on twitter about what would make a satisfying ending for this, and how Pio and JY reconcile or forgive each other would need to be different if this was framed as just a "regular" friendship. There is something to their connection that is framed beyond that, whether you read it as a deeper (romantic) love or platonic soulmatism. This person thought that they couldn't be friends after all this b/c the betrayal is too deep, and I thought the narrative is not hinting at separation as the solution, but as a sort of coming together into wholeness (a single song they both can play together and understand).
Replying as someone who also genuinely likes both characters and their moral greyness (and I actually do like…
We'll disagree. You said you didn't see the last three weeks of hate, but you can probably search and see how people had to literally break down what is happening on screen with Pio for some viewers in the same way we are doing with JY now in his arc. If the hate is "valid," one could then say JY "hate" is backed by his action in the drama if people are upset about the vengeance arc. See how in both cases anyone can justify "I hate X!" and call it valid based on how they respond to what the characters are doing on screen. Which is fine if that's how people need to engage, but that's why valid is not a useful term to me. It's still just an emotional response dependent on how people interpret what they deem a wrong action by one of the characters. That's what I'm seeing the majority of the engagement being.
Replying as someone who also genuinely likes both characters and their moral greyness (and I actually do like…
You see audience members calling JY a villain? Using that word? Again I am thinking more from a literary term villain vs. antagonist. While a villain is often an antagonist, an antagonist is not always the villain of the story. An antagonist is just a character set up to go against/stand in opposition to the protagonist in some way, and both have played this to each other. So when I see people saying (for either character), "I hate him b/c he was mean to X! He needs to pay/suffer!" that to me is not necessarily a function of screen time, as I said, I see just as much if not more Pio hate, and fans are getting his POV. Fan emotional connections don't always map the narrative or story intention, and in this case a rivalry trope will always need to set one up against the other, so an antagonist will exist for each character, and fandom tends to always respond by taking sides.
I still say the screen time is a function of the mystery narrative. I enjoy the not knowing, but again I would be curious how much narrative tension would be present in an equal POV situation and how the writing would need to shift.
pio got physically sick when he heard jeongyo died. pio messed up on stage for the first time in his life n went…
You know miscommunication tropes drive me crazy for this reason, where we as an audience can see what the characters have experienced, but the other characters never know. Like it's such a great sadness if this series ends without JY knowing the depths of how much he was loved and wanted and missed in those ten years by Pio. I hate that JY thinks he was forgotten. How heartbreaking. And to know on the other side of the aisle, that Pio had basically spent 10 years as a war widow without reprieve or an ability to move on. As someone said here, I still think it is wild Pio was playing through his grief by hallucinating JY being there. The Angst.
Pio is definitely grey character.when I saw trailer from that moment I knew he will be morally grey.But I relate…
I think if anything the real world will show you more and more as you age and experience life is this truth: no one, not even the ones you consider good people, are always making the most moral or right decisions. "Good people" can and do make very bad decisions, and that is the most human thing we can see explored in film and literature. Look at the mess of the world, or how it plays out in our families. That human to human tension and struggle is so often fed by our human failings or the sometimes hard decisions we are forced to make to survive.
Honestly reading this is very validating, cause I feel like the fact that jeongyo only tortures him with music…
Wanna debate anger issues lol? Also the generalization that "any normal person will defend themselves" is not actually true to human psychology. People react to being bullied in very different ways, much of it shaped by access to power, yes anger issues, socialization, etc. Same as people react to trauma differently. But I am fascinated in why some of you all are quick to point out, "he was 17" for one character and not the other. Anyways...
To me, Pi-o's character has always been a morally grey character from the start. Yes, JY's character turned morally…
Replying as someone who also genuinely likes both characters and their moral greyness (and I actually do like both even if I first noted the Pio hate on here lol). The only reason I am this interested in the story is b/c I love both characters (and their terrible decisions) and bringing them together into this complex dynamic is catnip to me. But you said fans being upset with Pio = valid criticism and not hate, but earlier you were discussing how it was wrong for fans to be upset with JY. Honestly I think its murky, b/c one can then argue about what is "valid" vs not (which feels tiring tbh), but I don't think the response from fans is showing itself to be this complex if you look at the hate comments. I think if we actually analyze fan reaction to both men, they are very similar in mainly coming from places of emotional connection to the character and not liking when that character is hurt. Which is fine b/c that is what good fiction does, it puts you in the place and makes you feel empathy (I was talking compassion vs empathy vs sympathy below to another commentator and I think viewer perception is interesting here as well). Personally I've seen both get I think needless "hate" based on misreading of the text (although much more for Pio since the series premiered in my social feeds, mainly Twitter, MDL, and TikTok, I'm not on Insta ), and I've seen what could be called "valid" (again I am not married to this word) criticism of both. But even for me the word choices are murky lol; I still say who gets to say victim and perpetuator is something both sides have the right to use. But we discussed that already.
I am interested in your reflection on thinking JY has been cast as villain. Is it just the question of POV for you? Again having seen more Pio hate, and Pio is the main POV, I don't think the POV matters so much for this idea of who audience sympathizes with. For me, I've never thought the narrative shaped JY as a villain IMHO; he is an *antagonist* to Pio in this second part, yes. But not the villain. The mother (and grandfather to some extent, although he's likely getting a redemption arc) has been framed as the villain I believe--the mother as the driver of the moral injury and dilemma both leads now face. I think there's a difference in terms of narrative function for these characters. I do agree that since Pio has been the main POV character of the series, we get a clearer sense of his journey and his emotional wound. I think this was an unfortunate (though understandable) choice of the how the emotional beats leading to this climatic arc of the script played out ---> in Part II, it feels like the writer/director wanted to create a sort of "back from the dead" character mystery so we are experiencing the revelations about JY the same way Pio is, with us as viewer not knowing what JY is planning as part of his revenge and thus having that anticipation be a source of tension and the unknown that moves the story to its end. I think it's effective (I find not knowing so exciting!), but I also understand people wanting JY's POV on the screen instead of told and implied through actions. But I imagine from the writers' perspective (and again I am thinking of the narrative function of this decision) to reveal JY's POV in this part is to take away the element of mystery. Even with us not knowing if JY will go through with his plan, that sense of not being able to see in the cloudiness of his mind or to read his thoughts, I think is purposeful. I don't think it was done to make him the villain, but to drive the tension. Am I making sense? Again I think the show was not trying to paint one or the other as the true victim or true villain of their relationship arc. To me the show is interestingly subverting this all by showing us so deeply how these boys' victimhood is the story calculus, and how their response to trauma (Pio in Part I especially, and JY in Part II), amplifies the rivalry. I think at the end of the day it's about how external forces can cause injurious harm in ways that first created this rivalry and pitted two people who should love each other against each other. And in doing so, these two characters have to navigate their way out of the darkness (and their ensuing dark choices) in order to heal. I guess I just can't see either of them as villains in this formation (for me personally).
And I finally witnessed rare sighting of Pi-o hate that maboheme have been mentioning lol.
I don't see how any of this is actual analysis about the character arcs. You are mad one of the characters is rich? Like 90% of K-drama characters? And that justifies his abuse? What. As for the biased fangirl, I have not gotten on here to hate lol. The opposite actually, in that I noted how exhausting the hate pile ons are. If you had engaged with me beyond just pissing on Pio in my comment where I mention how the hate and "who is suffering more" debate is a silly thing for the fandom to focus on, you'd have seen that. I've seen enough 12yos fighting over their favs to know much of it has nothing to do with story. And again and again I have talked about my interest in both characters b/c I actually like both and enjoy both their "dark" arcs and understand why they have been written the way they are from a narrative and story making POV. I have said time and again they are emotional mirrors and that shapes their arcs. I enjoy complicated, messy characters and prefer to discuss that verses randomly hating. And I get that the showrunners are clearly showing both as victims and people who've done "shitty actions." But you can hate all you want. For me, random "I hate Pio" diatribes are the least interesting way to engage with this series IMHO. But you do you.
This also gives us a bit of a sunshine + grumpy romance trope (and dog + cat). 17yo!Jeongyo had that happy puppy vibe to Pio's sullen kitty vibe (but of course the only time we see Pio smile is with JY). I didn't even realize it until I saw a video where someone had collected all the times he smiled in the series. Devastating really.
I love all these additions. And yes so many more in the scripting that tease at classic romance storytelling.
Also, I hope we see them in their special place again. I was just reading on twitter that the translation for their musical hideaway is "paradise."
Rich Character + Poor Character as a Star-Crossed Pairing
Childhood Meeting (establishing them as first-loves and having a soulmate connection)
Wound Tending!!! (We get it both ways too)
Forced Proximity or Bed Sharing (the awkward dorm room shenanigans)
Epic Date Night where they “fall” in love (Pio literally falls on the ground and looks up at JY’s smiling face lol)
Fake Death and/or Amnesia Causing Separation/Distance
Controlling/Domineering Parent(s) Against the Relationship
Enemies/Rivals to Friends to Lovers (to Enemies and Back Again!)
And of course the dreaded misunderstanding and miscommunication trope (done spectacularly in this series IMHO)
I still say the screen time is a function of the mystery narrative. I enjoy the not knowing, but again I would be curious how much narrative tension would be present in an equal POV situation and how the writing would need to shift.
I am interested in your reflection on thinking JY has been cast as villain. Is it just the question of POV for you? Again having seen more Pio hate, and Pio is the main POV, I don't think the POV matters so much for this idea of who audience sympathizes with. For me, I've never thought the narrative shaped JY as a villain IMHO; he is an *antagonist* to Pio in this second part, yes. But not the villain. The mother (and grandfather to some extent, although he's likely getting a redemption arc) has been framed as the villain I believe--the mother as the driver of the moral injury and dilemma both leads now face. I think there's a difference in terms of narrative function for these characters. I do agree that since Pio has been the main POV character of the series, we get a clearer sense of his journey and his emotional wound. I think this was an unfortunate (though understandable) choice of the how the emotional beats leading to this climatic arc of the script played out ---> in Part II, it feels like the writer/director wanted to create a sort of "back from the dead" character mystery so we are experiencing the revelations about JY the same way Pio is, with us as viewer not knowing what JY is planning as part of his revenge and thus having that anticipation be a source of tension and the unknown that moves the story to its end. I think it's effective (I find not knowing so exciting!), but I also understand people wanting JY's POV on the screen instead of told and implied through actions. But I imagine from the writers' perspective (and again I am thinking of the narrative function of this decision) to reveal JY's POV in this part is to take away the element of mystery. Even with us not knowing if JY will go through with his plan, that sense of not being able to see in the cloudiness of his mind or to read his thoughts, I think is purposeful. I don't think it was done to make him the villain, but to drive the tension. Am I making sense? Again I think the show was not trying to paint one or the other as the true victim or true villain of their relationship arc. To me the show is interestingly subverting this all by showing us so deeply how these boys' victimhood is the story calculus, and how their response to trauma (Pio in Part I especially, and JY in Part II), amplifies the rivalry. I think at the end of the day it's about how external forces can cause injurious harm in ways that first created this rivalry and pitted two people who should love each other against each other. And in doing so, these two characters have to navigate their way out of the darkness (and their ensuing dark choices) in order to heal. I guess I just can't see either of them as villains in this formation (for me personally).