how do you guys think the story would have gone had jeongyo not been kidnapped? we know pio said he would quit…
Great question. I've read different theories and I'm actually not sure. Mostly b/c I just don't know how much more toxic the family would have been if Pio lost and how that might have led to some later breakdown for him despite what healing happened b/c of Jeongyo's caretaking and love shown during the concert.
You know I often think about how Pio's low self-worth and inferiority complex really stemmed from his family's abuse, and without those things, what would he actually want and be like? I think of how happy he was to meet and play with Jeongyo when they were kids and how they even laughed about who would win--he didn't seem to really care about winning until his mother berated him for losing and broke his trophy after the contest. And then later we see the same thing, when Pio again felt the happiness and freedom he had with just enjoying playing music with Jeongyo, he didn't care about competing or about Jenogyo being better. He just cared about playing music with him and being happy. Then all of that fell apart when his mother got in his ear. It's like the inner voice of doubt people experience, but Pio was receiving it externally all the time from his own family. I just feel like the family would have poisoned everything he and JY had if they couldn't escape it. But that's what familial abuse can truly do.
ETA: Also, if not for the family, I don't think jealousy in and of itself would have poisoned Pio against JY. I think without the abuse, Pio would have learned to accept their differences because he loved JY and wanted him to succeed too (as we see later). And I say this as someone who also went to an arts high school with a lot of amazing talented geniuses and understand feeling inferior lol. My best friend and I were always up against each other, and he was a literal genius and more talented than me, and I accepted that he'd always come in 1st and I would be in 2nd. I was jealous sure, that's human nature, but more than anything I was happy for him and wanted the best for him b/c I also appreciated his talent and genius and was his biggest cheerleader. When you care about someone, you want them to be their best. I think this is how Pio and JY saw each other and their talents.
Someone said on Twitter that JeongPio relationship was similar to the main lead’s relationship in Secret Love…
Well, hmmm. My initial instinct, was to say no way! But okay, I guess it is lol. Because you do have the ML mistakenly thinking the FL was guilty of killing his gf. And the ML setting out to get vengeance on the FL. But I remember watching it and hating it so much because the ML was so toxic and basically tortured the FL for most of the series, and it was awful to watch play out. And then his obsession with her because of his revenge plan meant he was always stalking her and around her, so he slowly began to fall in love. So okay, I guess it's similar. 😭 But he was so awful to her at the outset I found it hard to enjoy the falling in love part. But it was old-school K-drama makjang, so it was longer and everything was able to play out over several episodes and be much angstier. If Jeongyo was given more episodes to be dark side and torture Pio, and if there were some more wild soap-opera level hijinks, it may have felt even more like Secret Love.
It’s been two weeks and people are still saying that Jeongyo reuniting with Pio wasn’t a good ending for him…
I always saw it like this: Pio took piano seriously, and JY took Pio seriously (and Pio comes with piano). JY's connection to the piano was always about its connection to the people he loved (his mother and then Pio). Losing his hand is devastating, yes, but part of why it is devastating is because it severs this connection to the people he loved more than I think just about the piano itself.
Not to say that both Pio and JY didn't love the piano, but as something meaningful to them, I don't think either ever found a way to be truly happy with the piano, without each other. It's that human connection to their other halves, which the music enabled, through which they found something like completion.
interesting… can I ask what you think the plot, the conflict, or the solution are? I’m not being sarcastic.…
No problem, google was my savior, lol. I also had no idea and was really curious b/c you were right, why hasn't Winner is King been released? Especially after JITD. Beside all the legal and regulatory stuff which sounds WILD, I do wonder if the director or production company fear blacklisting. Also now most of the actors from a lot of those shelved series are pretty famous. So maybe they fear backlash too? Although I saw the JITD actor in an another Chinese bromance recently.
At the end of the day, I'm just still hoping for a miracle or a cool hacker.
interesting… can I ask what you think the plot, the conflict, or the solution are? I’m not being sarcastic.…
Okay so I was wondering just now WHY more international companies haven't brought the other series since we're talking about Japan being the reason we saw JITD. And especially with the loophole happening with new series being broadcast overseas. OMG, it's so complicated, let me paste it here:
While streaming platforms outside of mainland China have previously been seen as a loophole for shelved Chinese Boys' Love (BL/Danmei) adaptations, the reality for Winner Is King (Feng Huo Liu Jin) is highly complicated due to extreme legal and regulatory hurdles.
- In China, a drama's distribution license must be periodically renewed if it remains unreleased. According to industry tracking and community updates, the original distribution license for Winner Is King officially expired without being renewed. Because the Chinese government enforces a strict, permanent ban on the broadcasting and distribution of BL content, the production companies (Tencent Penguin Pictures and Ciwen Media) cannot legally renew its domestic license.
- Historically, some Chinese production companies tried to recoup their massive financial investments by selling international streaming rights to overseas platforms (such as WeTV, Viki, or Netflix) or broadcasting channels in places like Japan and Thailand. However, Chinese broadcasting regulators have heavily tightened these loopholes. National regulations prohibit Chinese production companies from selling or streaming unapproved, unlicensed media assets to international platforms without explicit domestic clearance. Doing so can result in severe legal penalties or blacklisting for the production companies and the actors involved.
- Industry rumors periodically surface suggesting that international distributors (particularly in Thailand) have attempted to negotiate a deal to release the drama overseas. However, until the intellectual property and media regulatory standoff between the Chinese producers and the National Radio and Television Administration (NRTA) is resolved, the drama remains "shelved for life".
interesting… can I ask what you think the plot, the conflict, or the solution are? I’m not being sarcastic.…
We really need a BL-loving hacker to come and free them all lol. I remember all the conspiracies about someone at the network trying to sneak it out and that's how it accidentally aired lol. So we possibly had someone on the inside who wanted to see if they could get away with airing it.
And yeah it was a year, but I know it probably felt like forever.
interesting… can I ask what you think the plot, the conflict, or the solution are? I’m not being sarcastic.…
Such a waste. All that star power and investment gone to waste. But China does not care, it'll shelve series that aren't even gay if an actor or director does something they don't agree it. Plus the blacklisting. I'm actually shocked at all the actors willing to risk being blacklisted by being in the loophole Chinese BLs.
interesting… can I ask what you think the plot, the conflict, or the solution are? I’m not being sarcastic.…
I remember when that first happened, people were talking about how the network (was it IQiyi?) "accidentally" released the first 8 before the government cracked down. And then a year later, the series was released through a Japanese company. So it was all a sort of fluke. We'd need whoever owns the series to "accidentally" release them from the dungeon 😅
Or for international companies to buy broadcast rights. Though it must be hard b/c I would have expected the other shelved bromances to have been brought as well by now. It's been six years for Winner is King :(
interesting… can I ask what you think the plot, the conflict, or the solution are? I’m not being sarcastic.…
I appreciate you engaging and I do understand the frustration of feeling like we're still stuck in the days of Sherlock, lol. But honestly despite Heated Rivalry's success, I still feel like Western queer media has not moved much from the days of Sherlock, but that's another conversation for another message board lol.
But we actually did have a lot of conversations here while the series was airing. And I know folks would welcome more questions around the drama's other storylines. I love talking about issues the show brought up like toxic families, emotional abuse, familial piety, codependency, etc. I LOVE talking about what the series employs, whether it's the use of music or religious symbolism. And the parallels and mirroring of the characters, what they brought over from Wuthering Heights, etc. etc.
interesting… can I ask what you think the plot, the conflict, or the solution are? I’m not being sarcastic.…
The way I watched almost every version of SKAM back in the day! I love how real to teenage life that series felt, and the queer storyline was great, the coming out story and the mental health issues were all done so well (plus, actually having an entire season of a series dedicated to a queer couple was huge at the time). And I still say it's huge, lol. Even in Western countries like where the SKAM remakes happened queer rep in mainstream series is still rare; you don't get a mainstream series staring a queer lead almost ever.
And yes re: China: the loophole they've been using where BL series are filmed and only distributed outside China. I don't know how long that will last, but there is a glut of dramas coming out right now lol. Though I'm still craving the censored BLs/ "bromances" that were shelved when the ban came down. Those series had the sort of good funding and directors that allowed them to make those huge historical BLs that were like 50+ episodes. It's so frustrating b/c these new series will never get that support and promotion and can only get around 8-12 episodes. The live action of Heaven's Official Blessing (Eternal Faith) was supposed to be like 60 episodes! Ahh, I mourn it so much. 🥲
interesting… can I ask what you think the plot, the conflict, or the solution are? I’m not being sarcastic.…
"And I do find it sad, especially in 2026, when M/M shows are no longer a rarity and we can appreciate wider themes without focusing on proving (or refuting) the queer nature of something."
Just wanted to respond to this, as someone who has watched queer media most of my adult life, and still hungers for good portrayals. The idea that M/M shows are no longer a rarity is actually not true for most everywhere. While something like BL media may be booming in some parts of Asia, that can't be said for everywhere in the world, not even places like South Korea or China (and yes we see more in China b/c of the loophole, but we can talk about what kind of series we are actually seeing made). And not everyone feels represented by the media that does exist. Like I'm glad Heated Rivalry was a hit, but it's not a reflection of the queer reality I see in my own community that is rarely seen in mainstream series. And while BL utopian romcoms from Thailand are cute to watch, many people still hunger for better written stories and more realistic dramas that have the same funding, directing, and complicated storylines of mainstream het dramas. Queercoded Korean bromances like 4Hands often can operate in a subversive space by receiving the support (writing/directing/promotion) of mainstream networks like TvN while also delivering the emotional complexity folks are hungry to see in more BL media from South Korea.
All that to say, as long as homophobia exists, as long as queer representation is not normalized, we'll still be here debating if something can be read as queer. Many of us are still hungry for good representation of queer love on screen.
Me too. I think the same ending for Jeongyo wouldn't have felt so unfair if it weren't for Pio's mother happy…
Jeongyo as the Christ-like figure hits hard here. Suffered for all their sins.
Yeah I do wonder about the tone deafness of it all. Letting all the parents have redemption arcs (both Jeongyo's father, and also Gramps and Jihye) felt so deliberate, and I want to understand why this path. Is forgiving the evils and abuse of the family simply familial piety like we see in most K-dramas, or part of the religious Christian framing that sinners can be "forgiven."
Whatever the reason it really is deeply frustrating. I really wished they'd forced a confrontation from Pio with his mother. Their scene in Ep. 12 was necessary, but still it did not do all the things we needed to see given the extremes of her behavior. Same for the scene with Gramps.
The new theories going around about Jeongpio being parallels to Jihye/Hyunsoo and Jeon’s parents (this one was…
yes exactly. I didn't realize the direct parallel until rewatch and seeing how the scene is sandwiched in-between Pio and Jeongyo's reconciliation scenes. The adults conversation sounds exactly like one Pio and JY could have had if not for censorship, with Hyunsoo saying that being with Jihye was his happiness and he wanted to just be by her side, that all he needed was her. Then we have Pio basically going to seek his happiness at the end (we don't see any dialogue verbalized from him, but we can read into his actions the very same desire as we saw with the above). But because we grew up on romance series and tropes, we know Jihye/Hyunsoo are still being written as romantic, and any sort of friendship they rebuild now will also lead to a romantic reconciliation for them too. And if Pio and JY are mirrors...well, there you go!
But I'm bitter the het parallel got to hold hands when Pio and JY couldn't even get a reunion hug 😭
If you guys notice, Jeongyo’s revenge arc is literally about him recreating the moments when Pio did things…
yeah I always loved how he basically mirrored everything. I mean this entire series was about mirrors and parallels and how different choices can turn everything around.
it is relevant because it feeds the characters dilemma and further complicates the conflict. it also explains…
But the "romance" is the point. This series is not actually about revenge or music lol. It's about these boys' relationship, and as a queercoded text, that relationship can be read as romantic or platonic depending on the lens one takes. But that relationship is what the story is about. So reading it as romance makes sense to those who read through the queercoded lens. For those who don't, it can be about the bromance bond. Both are tellings of a love story, it's just that this series if forced to be defined through a heteronormative lens.
In my opinion, the most eloquent illustration and metaphor, which runs throughout the entire drama, is the story…
yesssss, the loss of an entire world he was building for them both 🥲 the potential of a life together with your beloved. I always think back to Pio's realization that he was happiest when playing music with JY, and how he was ready to give up everything just for that. that felt like such a declaration in the language Pio had available to him for choosing one's life partner.
that was such an early but clear indicator of the person he loved and who was always on his mind. still he hid…
Yes, love this so much! And I love when an actor really knows their character. You can tell Lee Junyoung added so much to JY's portrayal. I hear he adlibs a lot in his work, so I'm assuming he probably did that too in 4hands to really give his character added depth.
You know I often think about how Pio's low self-worth and inferiority complex really stemmed from his family's abuse, and without those things, what would he actually want and be like? I think of how happy he was to meet and play with Jeongyo when they were kids and how they even laughed about who would win--he didn't seem to really care about winning until his mother berated him for losing and broke his trophy after the contest. And then later we see the same thing, when Pio again felt the happiness and freedom he had with just enjoying playing music with Jeongyo, he didn't care about competing or about Jenogyo being better. He just cared about playing music with him and being happy. Then all of that fell apart when his mother got in his ear. It's like the inner voice of doubt people experience, but Pio was receiving it externally all the time from his own family. I just feel like the family would have poisoned everything he and JY had if they couldn't escape it. But that's what familial abuse can truly do.
ETA: Also, if not for the family, I don't think jealousy in and of itself would have poisoned Pio against JY. I think without the abuse, Pio would have learned to accept their differences because he loved JY and wanted him to succeed too (as we see later). And I say this as someone who also went to an arts high school with a lot of amazing talented geniuses and understand feeling inferior lol. My best friend and I were always up against each other, and he was a literal genius and more talented than me, and I accepted that he'd always come in 1st and I would be in 2nd. I was jealous sure, that's human nature, but more than anything I was happy for him and wanted the best for him b/c I also appreciated his talent and genius and was his biggest cheerleader. When you care about someone, you want them to be their best. I think this is how Pio and JY saw each other and their talents.
Not to say that both Pio and JY didn't love the piano, but as something meaningful to them, I don't think either ever found a way to be truly happy with the piano, without each other. It's that human connection to their other halves, which the music enabled, through which they found something like completion.
At the end of the day, I'm just still hoping for a miracle or a cool hacker.
While streaming platforms outside of mainland China have previously been seen as a loophole for shelved Chinese Boys' Love (BL/Danmei) adaptations, the reality for Winner Is King (Feng Huo Liu Jin) is highly complicated due to extreme legal and regulatory hurdles.
- In China, a drama's distribution license must be periodically renewed if it remains unreleased. According to industry tracking and community updates, the original distribution license for Winner Is King officially expired without being renewed. Because the Chinese government enforces a strict, permanent ban on the broadcasting and distribution of BL content, the production companies (Tencent Penguin Pictures and Ciwen Media) cannot legally renew its domestic license.
- Historically, some Chinese production companies tried to recoup their massive financial investments by selling international streaming rights to overseas platforms (such as WeTV, Viki, or Netflix) or broadcasting channels in places like Japan and Thailand. However, Chinese broadcasting regulators have heavily tightened these loopholes. National regulations prohibit Chinese production companies from selling or streaming unapproved, unlicensed media assets to international platforms without explicit domestic clearance. Doing so can result in severe legal penalties or blacklisting for the production companies and the actors involved.
- Industry rumors periodically surface suggesting that international distributors (particularly in Thailand) have attempted to negotiate a deal to release the drama overseas. However, until the intellectual property and media regulatory standoff between the Chinese producers and the National Radio and Television Administration (NRTA) is resolved, the drama remains "shelved for life".
🥲
And yeah it was a year, but I know it probably felt like forever.
Or for international companies to buy broadcast rights. Though it must be hard b/c I would have expected the other shelved bromances to have been brought as well by now. It's been six years for Winner is King :(
But we actually did have a lot of conversations here while the series was airing. And I know folks would welcome more questions around the drama's other storylines. I love talking about issues the show brought up like toxic families, emotional abuse, familial piety, codependency, etc. I LOVE talking about what the series employs, whether it's the use of music or religious symbolism. And the parallels and mirroring of the characters, what they brought over from Wuthering Heights, etc. etc.
And yes re: China: the loophole they've been using where BL series are filmed and only distributed outside China. I don't know how long that will last, but there is a glut of dramas coming out right now lol. Though I'm still craving the censored BLs/ "bromances" that were shelved when the ban came down. Those series had the sort of good funding and directors that allowed them to make those huge historical BLs that were like 50+ episodes. It's so frustrating b/c these new series will never get that support and promotion and can only get around 8-12 episodes. The live action of Heaven's Official Blessing (Eternal Faith) was supposed to be like 60 episodes! Ahh, I mourn it so much. 🥲
Just wanted to respond to this, as someone who has watched queer media most of my adult life, and still hungers for good portrayals. The idea that M/M shows are no longer a rarity is actually not true for most everywhere. While something like BL media may be booming in some parts of Asia, that can't be said for everywhere in the world, not even places like South Korea or China (and yes we see more in China b/c of the loophole, but we can talk about what kind of series we are actually seeing made). And not everyone feels represented by the media that does exist. Like I'm glad Heated Rivalry was a hit, but it's not a reflection of the queer reality I see in my own community that is rarely seen in mainstream series. And while BL utopian romcoms from Thailand are cute to watch, many people still hunger for better written stories and more realistic dramas that have the same funding, directing, and complicated storylines of mainstream het dramas. Queercoded Korean bromances like 4Hands often can operate in a subversive space by receiving the support (writing/directing/promotion) of mainstream networks like TvN while also delivering the emotional complexity folks are hungry to see in more BL media from South Korea.
All that to say, as long as homophobia exists, as long as queer representation is not normalized, we'll still be here debating if something can be read as queer. Many of us are still hungry for good representation of queer love on screen.
Yeah I do wonder about the tone deafness of it all. Letting all the parents have redemption arcs (both Jeongyo's father, and also Gramps and Jihye) felt so deliberate, and I want to understand why this path. Is forgiving the evils and abuse of the family simply familial piety like we see in most K-dramas, or part of the religious Christian framing that sinners can be "forgiven."
Whatever the reason it really is deeply frustrating. I really wished they'd forced a confrontation from Pio with his mother. Their scene in Ep. 12 was necessary, but still it did not do all the things we needed to see given the extremes of her behavior. Same for the scene with Gramps.
But I'm bitter the het parallel got to hold hands when Pio and JY couldn't even get a reunion hug 😭