I don’t get why everyone is so obsessed with finding pointless flaws in this series. It genuinely makes me wonder…
Yeah I think much of what went unanswered was just there as formative character backstory. It's like reading a short story vs. a novel. In short stories the backstories are meant to be there as efficient characterization that you can get in a couple sentences, but not spend entire chapters on. Like I think the fatherless-ness of the two men was just mentioned as another way to mirror their similarities (besides the religious symbolism of some kind of divine birth lol). And like someone said earlier in this forum, both boys had enough with these parents, they didn't need anymore parents in this story. The point is that they had awful abusive adults in their lives, and that shared trauma of their childhoods was formative.
Also I think like others have mentioned here as well, that the couples in the show were there as mirrors to Pio and JY (there are so many mirrors and parallels throughout the series!) The mother and teacher's last conversation was a reflection of one Pio and JY could have also had. JY's father and mother's relationship is the "bad ending" that Pio and JY could have had if the revenge had gone differently (their ending is the actual Wuthering Heights ending, with the revenge leading to Catherine's death). So again all these side characters were meant to simply drive the tragedy through their abandonment or abuse, and then later to heighten the (subtextual) love story of the two boys through parallels.
Sorry you don’t need to be a masochist to feel guilt and wish you were punished. Remember PiO was raised by…
And yet Pio can still be a masochist, lol. We can see how Pio's behaviors are driven by his abuse, but that doesn't erase or dismiss how he navigates his own desires within this context. Catholics can be masochists. And if other fans see subtext into this, especially in a series like this one, laden with subtext and queercoding, that's our reading. Pio's masochism, the dominant/submissive vibes, and the unresolved sexual tension of the vengeance arc are dynamics that some fans see. But you can ofc read it your own way.
I am at episode 11 and so many thoughts are going through my head. I am immensely enjoying the complex psychological…
Oh it's something a lot of viewers have picked up on. I definitely think Pio is a bit of a masochist. His guilt and self-blame do present as a need for punishment. So I think this can definitely transform to a desire for that as it presents itself through the lens of his submissive and willing taking of Jeongyo's punishment. The vengeance arc has a very pseudo-sexual feel to it.
I loved it too. Fans during that time were arguing, mad at Pio for lying, mad at JY for being mean. And I was…
I feel you omg, yes you summed it up exactly, something so "buzzy" (like the kids say!) about their dynamic! There was just such a simmering submerged layer to their revenge-arc interactions and to the tension between them. And it felt like a game they both consented to and needed to play out. I agree that I felt that so heavily in their dynamic when Jaein came in to "rescue Pio." She was interrupting SOMETHING really intimate and private, and Pio and JY knew it. And Pio, who didn't want rescuing, was wanting to let Jeongyo continue releasing what he needed to release on him. It was so intriguing and complex and buzzy as all heck!!!! I was wanting at least one more episode of that ngl 😭
It reminds me of what it means when all history is written by a dominant culture that erases queerness. When terms like "bosom buddies," "lifelong best friends," and "roommates" are pretty much the only ones used for LGBTQ people in history and their lovers b/c for so long historians would get so mad, even despite so much evidence, when people would imply they were not "just friends."
everyone's gushing over their sweet moments..ig I'm the only one who enjoyed the Jeong yo "hating" Pio…
I loved it too. Fans during that time were arguing, mad at Pio for lying, mad at JY for being mean. And I was like...but if Pio never lied and if JY never took vengeance, then we wouldn't have this amazing ANGST would we???!! I loved both their terrible decisions. I actually wished the vengeance arc was longer, ngl. It was so angsty good! Pio's pining and sad sheep eyes, willing to let Jeongyo do whatever to him just to allow JY some peace. Jeongyo being vicious and mean alongside his hints of doubt -- that was A++ acting. I love angst, so I was eating it up.
Which love story in Western Lit are you referring to?
The author said in an interview in Time that the story was inspired by Wuthering Heights by Emily Bronte. Pio is inspired by the character of Catherine, and Jeongyo is inspired by Heathcliff.
Some quotes below from the article here:
"To construct this unique relationship between them, writer Shin Yiwon drew most deeply from Emily Brontë’s novel Wuthering Heights, and director Andrea Arnold’s 2011 film adaptation of Wuthering Heights.
“The relationship between Heathcliff and Catherine in that story is between a man and a woman, but setting that aside, the essence of their relationship is that, in that barren, windswept land, they were the only people each other could rely on.
In particular, I was struck by the scene in which Catherine quietly embraces and comforts the wounds of Heathcliff, who had been severely beaten by his father.
Catherine was the only person who cared for Heathcliff as a human being when everyone else turned away from him, and at that moment, Catherine became the one person for whom Heathcliff would devote his entire life.”
Writer Shin projected the image of Heathcliff, like a wolf roaming the wilderness, onto Jeongyo, while giving Pio the qualities of Catherine: cold and cynical to the point that not even a needle could penetrate her defenses.
Pio grew up in a privileged environment, but his family was never a source of comfort to him. Jeongyo, meanwhile, had to let go in his heart of the one person who had been like family to him: Pio. Ultimately, because they were each other’s only place of refuge, they were bound to have a relationship that could not be separated.
Writer Shin was also deeply moved by a comment on the piece that read: “A hungry wolf loves the sheep.”
By instinct, a sheep is prey to a wolf, something that can satisfy its hunger. But the moment the wolf comes to love that sheep, it becomes trapped in a contradiction between its desire and its love. Jeongyo is the same.
At the end of the revenge that has kept him going for nine years is Pio. Yet the more he tries to bring Pio down, the more he is forced to confront the fact that he still cares deeply for him. He is both the person he must take revenge on and the person he does not want to lose.
The writer layered Jeongyo’s dilemma: unable to hurt him because he loves him, yet unable to let him go because he hates him onto the image of the “hungry wolf,” deepening and completing the story of revenge and love-hate directed toward Pio.
Oh, yep I checked, it's under the Boys Love and Queer tags in my Netflix. Also, it's interesting to see it next…
It's funny right? I think they were in love. But the same raging debate people had for this series about whether it was a bromance, queerbaiting, or a BL/queer romance is one people also had for that series too. Some people read them as 'just friends' as it focuses on their deep 10-year bond, trauma, healing, etc. but no explicit romance or intimacy between them (very similar to how we could describe 4Hands minus the revenge lol). Some said they saw each other as friends and it wasn't a romance. I won't spoil but the ending is also debated about what they meant. But it also features a mainstream Korean actor and a mainstream Japanese actor and I think this is why we saw no overt physical intimacy and romance in canon.
I have no problem with the queer tag that everybody has been putting on the drama since the beginning but for…
Ah, for me what made the queer subtext clearer was the use of a lot of romance tropes that I see only in romance literature and romance K-dramas, and the way that added to the tension beyond the rival. But the author's music love is so present too - the author mentioned listening to a lot of it while writing, so her making musical shoutouts is really awesome and I love people picking up on them and discussing what they find with us!
So which is it friendship, bromance, BL or just queerbaiting? I am confused with all this contrary interpretations…
Yes, especially with all the attention it's getting and Netflix adding the tag. I'd love to see SK have a mainstream queer series on the same level as their straight romances. To get the same funding, good scripts, platforming, mainstream actors, and lauded directors. Part of the reason BLs don't have good scripts or high quality production is b/c they are so niche and don't have the same access to the resources straight dramas have.
So which is it friendship, bromance, BL or just queerbaiting? I am confused with all this contrary interpretations…
Oh good question! I think I am understanding you -- is your idea of queerbaiting more about intent or marketing of something?
But yes, many recent Chinese bromances (especially the censored BLs) are a perfect example of queercoding: when the creators of the series code their characters as gay (put hints into the subtext, mannerisms, and add story hints about the character and their relationship), but the story may otherwise textually not mention their sexuality, and only give the heteronormative nod to them being straight. This is done without ever stating their sexual orientation. because of the homophobic reality of where the series is made. This practice has been done everywhere in the world (in the US, in Europe, in Asia, etc), and it was born out of necessity and as a way to bypass censorship. I feel like 4Hands sits here, especially due to the story hints, romantic tropes, and how the writer based them on a romantic pairing. It reads as romantic.
I don't know if I really believe in queerbaiting per se, b/c I feel like viewers, actors and showrunners can all have different understandings and interpretations of how they see the characters. But from what I understand, it would be used to refer to a purposeful misleading by showrunners just for financial gain or some other benefit (getting LGBTQ people to turn into the show or to buy something), so they tease and market a ship as queer with no plans to ever deliver on it in the canon text of the series.
But this is where it gets murky for me b/c one can argue that writers who queercode characters are teasing without plans to deliver, but I'd say that they are delivering queerness as best as they can given the context -- 4Hands wouldn't get made by TvN if it was explicitly queer, so the writers can only hint at it. The Untamed couldn't be made as explicitly queer given Chinese censorship, so they must only hint toward it. I feel this way too about a lot of Western series accused of queerbaiting (writers sometimes still have to use subtext b/c even in more open countries queerness is still not normalized in TV series and it is hard to get queer characters into mainstream series outside of token and stereotyped roles).
These two concepts can really be confusing for this reason. I feel like queercoding is more about subversion, and queerbaiting is more about profiting from something popular but still giving into homophobia. But I think both concepts can overlap too.
So which is it friendship, bromance, BL or just queerbaiting? I am confused with all this contrary interpretations…
Oh yeah that makes sense! That's what I meant by "utopian" too, it's like those series exist in a world where queerness is normal and homophobia doesn't exist. Although early BLs were more realistic and had more coming-out experience and characters dealing with both internalized and external homophobia. But I feel like the last couple of years it's mostly been gay utopias. It's interesting to think about where a series like 4Hands sits b/c it's a K-drama and mainstream K-dramas often exist in an opposite setting -- it's a world where homosexuality doesn't exist (it's erased). So all we get is subtext :(
Also I think like others have mentioned here as well, that the couples in the show were there as mirrors to Pio and JY (there are so many mirrors and parallels throughout the series!) The mother and teacher's last conversation was a reflection of one Pio and JY could have also had. JY's father and mother's relationship is the "bad ending" that Pio and JY could have had if the revenge had gone differently (their ending is the actual Wuthering Heights ending, with the revenge leading to Catherine's death). So again all these side characters were meant to simply drive the tragedy through their abandonment or abuse, and then later to heighten the (subtextual) love story of the two boys through parallels.
I saw this on twitter earlier and was cackling. poor JY: https://x.com/_BreathingFiree/status/2109151828604764575
Some quotes below from the article here:
"To construct this unique relationship between them, writer Shin Yiwon drew most deeply from Emily Brontë’s novel Wuthering Heights, and director Andrea Arnold’s 2011 film adaptation of Wuthering Heights.
“The relationship between Heathcliff and Catherine in that story is between a man and a woman, but setting that aside, the essence of their relationship is that, in that barren, windswept land, they were the only people each other could rely on.
In particular, I was struck by the scene in which Catherine quietly embraces and comforts the wounds of Heathcliff, who had been severely beaten by his father.
Catherine was the only person who cared for Heathcliff as a human being when everyone else turned away from him, and at that moment, Catherine became the one person for whom Heathcliff would devote his entire life.”
Writer Shin projected the image of Heathcliff, like a wolf roaming the wilderness, onto Jeongyo, while giving Pio the qualities of Catherine: cold and cynical to the point that not even a needle could penetrate her defenses.
Pio grew up in a privileged environment, but his family was never a source of comfort to him. Jeongyo, meanwhile, had to let go in his heart of the one person who had been like family to him: Pio. Ultimately, because they were each other’s only place of refuge, they were bound to have a relationship that could not be separated.
Writer Shin was also deeply moved by a comment on the piece that read: “A hungry wolf loves the sheep.”
By instinct, a sheep is prey to a wolf, something that can satisfy its hunger. But the moment the wolf comes to love that sheep, it becomes trapped in a contradiction between its desire and its love. Jeongyo is the same.
At the end of the revenge that has kept him going for nine years is Pio. Yet the more he tries to bring Pio down, the more he is forced to confront the fact that he still cares deeply for him. He is both the person he must take revenge on and the person he does not want to lose.
The writer layered Jeongyo’s dilemma: unable to hurt him because he loves him, yet unable to let him go because he hates him onto the image of the “hungry wolf,” deepening and completing the story of revenge and love-hate directed toward Pio.
But yes, many recent Chinese bromances (especially the censored BLs) are a perfect example of queercoding: when the creators of the series code their characters as gay (put hints into the subtext, mannerisms, and add story hints about the character and their relationship), but the story may otherwise textually not mention their sexuality, and only give the heteronormative nod to them being straight. This is done without ever stating their sexual orientation. because of the homophobic reality of where the series is made. This practice has been done everywhere in the world (in the US, in Europe, in Asia, etc), and it was born out of necessity and as a way to bypass censorship. I feel like 4Hands sits here, especially due to the story hints, romantic tropes, and how the writer based them on a romantic pairing. It reads as romantic.
I don't know if I really believe in queerbaiting per se, b/c I feel like viewers, actors and showrunners can all have different understandings and interpretations of how they see the characters. But from what I understand, it would be used to refer to a purposeful misleading by showrunners just for financial gain or some other benefit (getting LGBTQ people to turn into the show or to buy something), so they tease and market a ship as queer with no plans to ever deliver on it in the canon text of the series.
But this is where it gets murky for me b/c one can argue that writers who queercode characters are teasing without plans to deliver, but I'd say that they are delivering queerness as best as they can given the context -- 4Hands wouldn't get made by TvN if it was explicitly queer, so the writers can only hint at it. The Untamed couldn't be made as explicitly queer given Chinese censorship, so they must only hint toward it. I feel this way too about a lot of Western series accused of queerbaiting (writers sometimes still have to use subtext b/c even in more open countries queerness is still not normalized in TV series and it is hard to get queer characters into mainstream series outside of token and stereotyped roles).
These two concepts can really be confusing for this reason. I feel like queercoding is more about subversion, and queerbaiting is more about profiting from something popular but still giving into homophobia. But I think both concepts can overlap too.