I like a lot of what you say about the various ways we can define love and romance, but by what definition does…
Yeah that's why I mention queercoding, b/c to me that implies more than friends and a bromance label cannot really hold that complexity. In queercoded dramas, the elements of attraction just can't be explicit in the text b/c of homophobia. All that to say, many people will look at this series and understand from their reading that this is NOT a drama about two platonic friends. They are seeing and reacting to the subtext. So fans would want another way to label this alternative understanding, and BL is what current fandom uses to talk about same-sex male attraction. And in this way, it has also become a shorthand to refer to the subtextual queerness we see in queercoded bromances. I don't think any of the labels are perfect-- these labels have to do a lot of work b/c they exist outside of heteronormative frameworks.
Yea, this is a bromance. Two men loving each other does not make it a BL. I know... it's complicated.A BL is a…
I like a lot of what you say about the various ways we can define love and romance, but by what definition does a BL = sexual desire? To my understanding, all BL means is "Boys Love," a shorthand used to describe a genre of media (originating in anime/manga) that features love stories b/w male characters. To me it's about non-platonic same-sex attraction (which can be romantic, sexual, amorous, etc). Also given the asexuality spectrum, and queer asexual people being in romantic relationships, I think limiting BL to sexual desire would erase them.
I think this series is purposely queercoded, so I do think it's okay if people want to use BL as a shorthand to refer to a queer reading and same-sex relationship that goes beyond a standard friendship. But queercoding obviously means there is no explicit showing of queer desire in the text, and thus romance and sexual desire would all be in the subtext. Which is why the bromance label is thrown on. But I do think the bromance label is very limiting b/c it implies only friendship and doesn't make room for the subtext.
I think surfacely Pio and JY's relationship could present as "queer platonic." But when I read the subtext, their bond feels full of romantic and sexual desire. But again, it's all about how people interpret and read what they are seeing.
How do you define "visible" love? What to you is proof of it? Is it only shown in words and flowers? Or…
I understand! And yep, we're definitely all have different capacities for love and forgiveness. I've forgiven people personally for things that others might not. I've seen others forgive people for things, I'd never forgive. And with family and lovers, it's even more complicated. And given all the fan debate we saw we know some fans can't forgive Pio for lying to JY, and some fans can't forgive JY for torturing Pio, and were labeling either villains depending on that. And well I was like...we weren't supposed to see either actions as righteous, and I think the show is like that with their ideas of love too. People can love in ways that harm, hurt, and cause greater grief. People can also love in ways that save and heal. I feel like the show was illustrating this with both men when it came to each other. I do think that 3-year time apart to heal was important for this reason, b/c I think by the end of the vengeance arc, we still had Pio and JY operating out a selfish (and recklessly selfless) but deeply broken kind of love for each other. Pio's obsession, even dating back to his teen years, was of a spiraling deep need for love and connection that consumed him. Pio's emotional-stagnation was rooted in a need for validation and approval that exploded outward and doomed JY. And maybe that's why this story is more tragedy than anything? Two lonely boys deeply broken and desperate to be seen, and they were only truly seen by each other. Oh, but I do agree that I wish we'd gotten Pio showing his growth by the end in being able to vocalize his feelings beyond self-blame/guilt; he was still too emotionally stuck, although him breaking through the music I think was supposed to illustrate his emotional growth and his heart opening and being completely receptive and ready for JY's emotions.
How do you define "visible" love? What to you is proof of it? Is it only shown in words and flowers? Or…
Ah, we may also just see love differently in a sense too. Doesn't love always exist with a huge amount of self-centeredness? I don't think most people love selflessly. For instance, JY's love would also be the same as Pio's if we only read it through the lens of him needing Pio and/or obsessing over him whether in love or vengeance. That is deeply about his own needs, his hunger for belonging, his need to be wanted, and his connection to something that makes him happy. I don't think this sort of need is ever truly divorced from the ego, or the need to find something that fills us up. Both men's love in this sense can be seen as selfish & selfless (selfless in how they both give up music for each other, would risk their lives for each other). But also because they NEED each other and can't function fully without each other, doesn't it also make it deeply selfish. But love is like that often, right?
I would disagree with you on Pio not noticing JY's pain or caring about his safety. Searching for him for 9 years is an act of caring about his safety imho. To say it's just guilt, that simplifies it too much, and I think the show is implying a deeply complex web of feelings. Even the acts I described in their teen years were evidence of Pio caring about JY's safety (and many of the acts occurred even before they were partnered up). I understand that you don't like Pio forgiving his abusers and that you think Pio should hate his mother for what she did to him and JY. I also don't like the framing familial piety in the series (although I've seen write-ups by Korean fans about how Pio's decision is a very hard but true reflection of Korean society). I don't define Pio's capacity for loving JY based on Pio not throwing away his mother, or by his act to take the blame for his mother. These were also acts of love complicated by both selfless and selfish desires. But I do think acts of selfless love are seen in both characters, but none of it is without flaws. Neither give up abusive parents, and both forgive unforgivable things in each other and others around them. They are protective but within limits, so the question of safety is not simple. We see their protectiveness paralleled when Pio threatens his mother if she ever thinks of harming JY again, and when JY threatens the loan shark if he ever thinks of harming Pio. But neither time is the person who can create the harm removed. All that to say, acts of love are never easy to define or simple in my eyes. Love is inherently self-centered because of our personal needs for validation, joy, and emotional security. But let me stop rambling here. 😭😭
Jeong yo's love for Pio was clearly visible. But i don't see pio's love for him. He seems to be too consumed by…
How do you define "visible" love? What to you is proof of it? Is it only shown in words and flowers? Or can it be quieter, shown in looks and acts of care? I absolutely see Pio's love, from the early episodes to the end, so it's interesting when I see a post like this. But there are many write-ups on the internet refuting the idea that Pio doesn't love JY, I can link if you want lol. But I will say, if Pio was incapable of thinking about anyone else, why did he do any of the acts of care for JY when they were teens? Even from the earliest acts of saving him from a bully, recovering the CCTV footage, finding his music sheets, and not to mention saving him from the loan sharks, how were those self-serving acts? And like most of the early episodes, their acts of care for each other were actually paralleled and mirrored (Pio helps JY, JY helps Pio; JY bandages Pio, Pio bandages JY). And even after JY's disappearance, Pio's is feeling something for someone else even through his guilt, enough to spend millions and search the world for that person. And of course his trophies were also about making his mother and grandfather happy, seeing his mother smile, so obviously he is thinking about his family then. Even if he is seeking love and acceptance, he is also wanting his music to make those people happy. Emotionally-closed off abused people consumed by their own issues and locked in their heads, can still look outside themselves. In Pio's case, how he vocalizes his love may be different b/c he's been conditioned by his abuse. But I don't think anyone would spend half their life looking for someone, which is the ultimate act of love IMHO, if they were incapable of thinking of anyone else besides themselves. And if they didn't deeply care for, even love, that person.
Oh my heartu😮💨 Love in the Big City is my favorite kbl drama. It got so much hate from the k-homophobes…
All of this! And TvN has never had a queer romance story, so a series like 4Hands, which can be read through a queer lens in its intense love between two male leads, is one way of "sneaking" same-sex love into the mainstream. I wish the world was further along, but until then, there is nothing wrong with fans seeing queer love in these stories.
"In a country where the law does not recognize same-sex marriage nor protect against discrimination based on sexual orientation, there has yet to be a mainstream queer romance. When Love in the Big City, a slice-of-life drama centering a gay protagonist was released in 2024, it was met with homophobic outcries from anti-LGBTQ groups within Korea, accusing the drama of 'glorifying and promoting homosexuality..'”
This is an important point. And the actor from Love in the Big City was warned not to do the role, told by his agent it would ruin his career and he'd get blacklisted. Which is something that happens to many actors doing BL and other queer roles in SK.
So when people get upset about fans interpreting queerness in mainstream K-drama bromances, why are you so upset really? How is it hurting you? The truth is queercoding is often the only mainstream representation for queerness in K-dramas, and the truth is that historically (in every country in the world!) there have been writers and directors that have added queercoding elements to "same-sex friendship" stories as the one way to add those dynamics until actual queer representation was mainstreamed. And in SK, until these stories move from the niche of the BL market to mainstream networks and platforms, don't be upset if fans see romance in the intense bonds b/w same-sex pairings. Fans have read heterosexual "romance" into every male/female setup since forever. Why is one okay and the other not?
its so funny seeing ppl still dismiss their gay asses as friendship like girl did we watch the same show?
Homophobia and the desire for everything to be seen through a heteronormative lens is why queercoding even exists in films. The dominant homophobic culture is so dismissive of queer identities and always seeks to erase them.
Someone said this in twt "how fhts production felt after they called it a "bromance" then had a character…
Yes, the hints are so done wonderfully throughout like some of the best queer-coding I've seen. Having JY compare his own relationship with Pio to JY's own father and mother (a heterosexual couple) is laced with the subtext.
Official thumbnail of Nemesis btw… "To you my light and hope, whom I could never hate.” – Choi Jeongyo
Wow. I love how non subtle it is lol. And I read this and I also hear, "to you [my love/the love of my life] whom I could never hate." There's the text and under it all the subtext.
I wrote my review earlier but I want to write this that people need to understand that Pi O never loved or liked…
I cackle that canonically they have Jaein saying in the series, "Let Pio and Jeongyo love each other in peace." The writers were having a hilarious time adding things into the subtext.
It’s still funny how they didn’t move on and date someone else during those three years especially since they’re…
it was very purposeful coding. when even the female lead read the script and realized that her character was just there to give a dying dude CPR b/c he was mourning the love of his life, yeahhhhhhhh. neither Pio nor JY showed actual interest in women.
I think this series is purposely queercoded, so I do think it's okay if people want to use BL as a shorthand to refer to a queer reading and same-sex relationship that goes beyond a standard friendship. But queercoding obviously means there is no explicit showing of queer desire in the text, and thus romance and sexual desire would all be in the subtext. Which is why the bromance label is thrown on. But I do think the bromance label is very limiting b/c it implies only friendship and doesn't make room for the subtext.
I think surfacely Pio and JY's relationship could present as "queer platonic." But when I read the subtext, their bond feels full of romantic and sexual desire. But again, it's all about how people interpret and read what they are seeing.
I would disagree with you on Pio not noticing JY's pain or caring about his safety. Searching for him for 9 years is an act of caring about his safety imho. To say it's just guilt, that simplifies it too much, and I think the show is implying a deeply complex web of feelings. Even the acts I described in their teen years were evidence of Pio caring about JY's safety (and many of the acts occurred even before they were partnered up). I understand that you don't like Pio forgiving his abusers and that you think Pio should hate his mother for what she did to him and JY. I also don't like the framing familial piety in the series (although I've seen write-ups by Korean fans about how Pio's decision is a very hard but true reflection of Korean society). I don't define Pio's capacity for loving JY based on Pio not throwing away his mother, or by his act to take the blame for his mother. These were also acts of love complicated by both selfless and selfish desires. But I do think acts of selfless love are seen in both characters, but none of it is without flaws. Neither give up abusive parents, and both forgive unforgivable things in each other and others around them. They are protective but within limits, so the question of safety is not simple. We see their protectiveness paralleled when Pio threatens his mother if she ever thinks of harming JY again, and when JY threatens the loan shark if he ever thinks of harming Pio. But neither time is the person who can create the harm removed. All that to say, acts of love are never easy to define or simple in my eyes. Love is inherently self-centered because of our personal needs for validation, joy, and emotional security. But let me stop rambling here. 😭😭
"In a country where the law does not recognize same-sex marriage nor protect against discrimination based on sexual orientation, there has yet to be a mainstream queer romance. When Love in the Big City, a slice-of-life drama centering a gay protagonist was released in 2024, it was met with homophobic outcries from anti-LGBTQ groups within Korea, accusing the drama of 'glorifying and promoting homosexuality..'”
This is an important point. And the actor from Love in the Big City was warned not to do the role, told by his agent it would ruin his career and he'd get blacklisted. Which is something that happens to many actors doing BL and other queer roles in SK.
So when people get upset about fans interpreting queerness in mainstream K-drama bromances, why are you so upset really? How is it hurting you? The truth is queercoding is often the only mainstream representation for queerness in K-dramas, and the truth is that historically (in every country in the world!) there have been writers and directors that have added queercoding elements to "same-sex friendship" stories as the one way to add those dynamics until actual queer representation was mainstreamed. And in SK, until these stories move from the niche of the BL market to mainstream networks and platforms, don't be upset if fans see romance in the intense bonds b/w same-sex pairings. Fans have read heterosexual "romance" into every male/female setup since forever. Why is one okay and the other not?