This series is absolutely amazing... acting, music, everything. You will keep on watching episodes unless you find out the truth. Not a single boring episode. It deserve legit 9/10 I didn't say 10/10 because towards the end you will feel some inconsistencies. Like why was Ki Dae call history was not checked when Jin YeongIn clearly called him multiple times before he was killed. Also why Yun su never mentioned this in investigation when in flashback Ki dae did told Yun su about this. There is inconsistency in Yun su character as well, she was literally smoking cigarette minutes after her husband death and showing no grief in the first episode. "Her unique, easy to smile, dress to impress personality" that's why she was doubted in the first place. But after she was arrested, she never showed that personality, she was normal throughout the series and even she showed more grief towards Mo Eun than her husband. Overall its a great watch. JUSTICE WAS SERVED AT END.
It seems like you didn't watch the full series closely. Let me address your points:About the photos: There were…
You are right, I was wrong about the graduation photo. His dormmates photo is also present. And I am sorry for missing that. All the other thing I said, still stays true to how this series made me feel. "After FL defending him the first time in restaurant, he started liking her" -> Still factually correct. About card scene, it doesn't feel right to me. "What would you have preferredāthat he force it out of her?" Obviously not, but that incident made her sad and it needed a conversation, which didn't happen. Maybe I expected too much from him as a 5 year old mature boyfriend.
It feels like you ARE saying the drama is perfect. I'm just sharing my feedback, feedback/opinion is very personal, just like how you said "not everything needs a heavy, melodramatic conversation" maybe few people like heavy conversation to understand a character on deeper level.
TBH this was my first comment and I didn't do a good job here. I should have also highlighted the good points why it deserve 8/10. Your reply did make me realise that I should check the facts before commenting.
Dropping at ep 4 I just can't get my head around that Abyss ball. Why would someone leave that ball with ML? Why? I mean it make sense that they revived him after accidentally killing him but to leave the ball with him so that he can revive whoever he wants, doesn't make any sense. And why would Abyss make FL looks like her former colleague, it doesn't make any sense either. To me, this feels like bad writing to keep the story going. I'm fan of both PBY and AHS but still can't watch it.
I like this show. It has lot of comedy and I loved it. FL dedication towards ML. I hoped that Nakastu should be ML as we see lot of good scene between FL and SML. ML is more sad type and no fun.
Man, it's a classic drama, but it's definitely not the best. I don't know who irritated me more: Xia Xiaoju, who…
I completely agree with you. Xiaoju said "I'll never like you" so many times that it was clear that she only consider him as a friend. It hurt me to see Shi Yi chasing after her for so long. And even if we assume for the sake of storyline that Xiaoju started liking Shiyi, even then their was no character growth from Xiaoju side, she never confessed her genuine feelings to CL and she never confessed her feelings to SY on time. A drunk kiss was all she did. She seems like such a toxic character.
I like all the actors and their acting. But for the storyline, I don't like it at all. 2/3 part of story Xiao Ju was focused on Cheng Lang but at the same time she was growing close to Shi Yi. But even after spending so much time with Shi Yi, she rejected every confession from him with clear NO. She didn't even spend time to think about it. And this 'SY: I like you" <-> "XJ: I'll never like you" keep going on for so long that me as a viewer was convinced that she only think of him as friend and only care for him as a friend. Their was no character growth from her side. She never confessed her genuine feelings to CL and she never confessed her feelings to SY. A drunk kiss was all she did.
And I don't like the ending at all. Everything was skipped as if this was 24 Episode drama. A 36 ep drama and they didn't even did justice to their happy ending. Why was their a marriage proposal directly? If there was no contact between Shi Yi and Xiao Ju when he was abroad, then they should tell each other their feelings rather than this cliche plot of finding the venue for proposal for "his girlfriend" and threating Xiao Ju with her job. This reminds me of old Shi Yi when he was just naughty and didn't care about the Xiao Ju feelings.
Overall XiaoJu character lack of growth, her being forced to grow feelings for Shi Yi was a let down for me.
I like the drama, but this series doesn't deserve 9/10. Its hardly 8/10.
I think whole series is from FL point of view. One of the biggest supporter for that is the ML graduation photo with FL. I agree they were close at the moment because of his tutoring but only keeping her photo in his house? Not his male friends group? It was so weird, I mean the guy you're so close with a guy that he randomly ask you to pick and drop his sister from school/college/airport, he is not present in photos but only his sister is. why? There is not much ML point of view shown. Its his good looks, kind gestures towards FL, poor family and a trauma that turn into responsible person. ML character lacks depth and there was not much development. After FL defending him the first time in restaurant, he started liking her and started to pursue her in no time. In that sense, he seems like any other boy. But FL keeps saying that "You're great" in all episodes after they start dating.
ML trauma wasn't shown properly. His creditor send him gifts that he never opens? keep messaging him? keeps following him? then also make scene in public by throwing water on his face even after he paid off the debts?
Also whenever something happens to FL and FL do/say something to ML, he just agrees. Like her giving her card after his creditor talks bad about him. In that scene he could have a deep conversation with her but instead he plays along and give her his card and cash and turn that scene into romantic. No ML past characters come into picture unless it was right before they appear in front of FL.
I started this drama for its name "Dali and the Cocky Prince" and hoped to some good interactions between main couple. But as soon as Dali's father died, Gallery become the main character. So much importance was given to gallery by all characters that main relationship feels like a prop. Dali has been showcased as weak girl who need to depend on others. Her character was degraded in most of the episodes. Our Cocky Prince feels like a thug who doesn't even know how to control his anger in front of his loved ones.
I didn't say 10/10 because towards the end you will feel some inconsistencies. Like why was Ki Dae call history was not checked when Jin YeongIn clearly called him multiple times before he was killed. Also why Yun su never mentioned this in investigation when in flashback Ki dae did told Yun su about this.
There is inconsistency in Yun su character as well, she was literally smoking cigarette minutes after her husband death and showing no grief in the first episode. "Her unique, easy to smile, dress to impress personality" that's why she was doubted in the first place. But after she was arrested, she never showed that personality, she was normal throughout the series and even she showed more grief towards Mo Eun than her husband.
Overall its a great watch. JUSTICE WAS SERVED AT END.
All the other thing I said, still stays true to how this series made me feel.
"After FL defending him the first time in restaurant, he started liking her" -> Still factually correct.
About card scene, it doesn't feel right to me. "What would you have preferredāthat he force it out of her?" Obviously not, but that incident made her sad and it needed a conversation, which didn't happen. Maybe I expected too much from him as a 5 year old mature boyfriend.
It feels like you ARE saying the drama is perfect.
I'm just sharing my feedback, feedback/opinion is very personal, just like how you said "not everything needs a heavy, melodramatic conversation" maybe few people like heavy conversation to understand a character on deeper level.
TBH this was my first comment and I didn't do a good job here. I should have also highlighted the good points why it deserve 8/10. Your reply did make me realise that I should check the facts before commenting.
I just can't get my head around that Abyss ball.
Why would someone leave that ball with ML? Why? I mean it make sense that they revived him after accidentally killing him but to leave the ball with him so that he can revive whoever he wants, doesn't make any sense. And why would Abyss make FL looks like her former colleague, it doesn't make any sense either.
To me, this feels like bad writing to keep the story going.
I'm fan of both PBY and AHS but still can't watch it.
I hoped that Nakastu should be ML as we see lot of good scene between FL and SML. ML is more sad type and no fun.
Xiaoju said "I'll never like you" so many times that it was clear that she only consider him as a friend. It hurt me to see Shi Yi chasing after her for so long.
And even if we assume for the sake of storyline that Xiaoju started liking Shiyi, even then their was no character growth from Xiaoju side, she never confessed her genuine feelings to CL and she never confessed her feelings to SY on time. A drunk kiss was all she did.
She seems like such a toxic character.
But for the storyline, I don't like it at all.
2/3 part of story Xiao Ju was focused on Cheng Lang but at the same time she was growing close to Shi Yi. But even after spending so much time with Shi Yi, she rejected every confession from him with clear NO. She didn't even spend time to think about it. And this 'SY: I like you" <-> "XJ: I'll never like you" keep going on for so long that me as a viewer was convinced that she only think of him as friend and only care for him as a friend.
Their was no character growth from her side. She never confessed her genuine feelings to CL and she never confessed her feelings to SY. A drunk kiss was all she did.
And I don't like the ending at all. Everything was skipped as if this was 24 Episode drama. A 36 ep drama and they didn't even did justice to their happy ending.
Why was their a marriage proposal directly? If there was no contact between Shi Yi and Xiao Ju when he was abroad, then they should tell each other their feelings rather than this cliche plot of finding the venue for proposal for "his girlfriend" and threating Xiao Ju with her job. This reminds me of old Shi Yi when he was just naughty and didn't care about the Xiao Ju feelings.
Overall XiaoJu character lack of growth, her being forced to grow feelings for Shi Yi was a let down for me.
I think whole series is from FL point of view. One of the biggest supporter for that is the ML graduation photo with FL. I agree they were close at the moment because of his tutoring but only keeping her photo in his house? Not his male friends group? It was so weird, I mean the guy you're so close with a guy that he randomly ask you to pick and drop his sister from school/college/airport, he is not present in photos but only his sister is. why?
There is not much ML point of view shown. Its his good looks, kind gestures towards FL, poor family and a trauma that turn into responsible person. ML character lacks depth and there was not much development. After FL defending him the first time in restaurant, he started liking her and started to pursue her in no time. In that sense, he seems like any other boy. But FL keeps saying that "You're great" in all episodes after they start dating.
ML trauma wasn't shown properly. His creditor send him gifts that he never opens? keep messaging him? keeps following him? then also make scene in public by throwing water on his face even after he paid off the debts?
Also whenever something happens to FL and FL do/say something to ML, he just agrees. Like her giving her card after his creditor talks bad about him. In that scene he could have a deep conversation with her but instead he plays along and give her his card and cash and turn that scene into romantic.
No ML past characters come into picture unless it was right before they appear in front of FL.
But as soon as Dali's father died, Gallery become the main character. So much importance was given to gallery by all characters that main relationship feels like a prop.
Dali has been showcased as weak girl who need to depend on others. Her character was degraded in most of the episodes.
Our Cocky Prince feels like a thug who doesn't even know how to control his anger in front of his loved ones.
Got to see so much of Chae Jong Hyeop in a single drama.
Everything is perfect in this drama... I was hooked up until last episode.