This review may contain spoilers
A Brilliant Premise Undone by Disappointing Performances
To My Beloved Thief started with immense promise. I was genuinely impressed by its premise, the story setup, and especially the casting. Moon Sang-min caught my attention immediately, and Nam Ji-hyun—a personal favorite of mine—was a major reason I tuned in. Up until episode 4, the drama was genuinely enjoyable. The storytelling felt engaging, the pacing was decent, and the chemistry between the leads was believable and natural.
Then came the soul swap (or body swap—call it what you want), and everything slowly fell apart.
To be clear, I don’t think the concept itself was bad. In fact, the writers could have taken the story in a fun, emotionally rich direction. On paper, the idea still worked. But in execution, the drama completely failed—and the biggest reason was the acting, direction, and script handling after the swap.
Nam Ji-hyun’s performance was, frankly, shocking.
Once the souls are swapped, Nam Ji-hyun is supposed to portray the male lead’s soul inside her body, effectively becoming the male lead in a female body. However, she utterly fails to sell this transformation. There is no physicality, no change in speech, posture, or emotional rhythm that suggests a man inhabiting a woman’s body. Most of the time, she continues to act exactly like the female lead, making the entire soul-swap concept feel pointless.
It’s impossible not to compare this to Mr. Queen.
Shin Hye-sun’s legendary performance in Mr. Queen set the gold standard for this trope—a male soul convincingly living inside a female body. That drama became a massive commercial and cultural success, breaking records on tvN and Netflix. Shin Hye-sun didn’t just “act”; she transformed. Any drama attempting a similar concept will inevitably be compared to Mr. Queen, and unfortunately, To My Beloved Thief loses that comparison by an overwhelming margin—honestly, a 100-to-1 situation.
That said, the male lead doesn’t escape criticism either. Even after the soul swap, he continues to act like the same male prince as before, despite supposedly having a woman’s soul inside him. His behavior, reactions, and emotional choices don’t reflect the swap at all.
Several scenes make absolutely no sense:
Why does he hug Nam Ji-hyun first when he is now the female lead, who had already rejected him?
Why do the dialogues not reflect even the slightest confusion or internal conflict from the soul swap?
Why do both characters continue behaving exactly as they did before, as if nothing changed?
The result is deeply frustrating. The male lead still acts like the male lead, the female lead still acts like the female lead, and the soul swap becomes nothing more than a lazy plot gimmick. The performances feel mismatched, confused, and emotionally hollow.
What hurts the most is that this drama could have been great.
It had a fun, creative story. It had early momentum. It had chemistry. But all of it was ruined by weak acting choices, poor direction, and a script that failed to commit to its own concept. What should have been an entertaining and memorable drama instead turned into a disappointing mess.
In the end, To My Beloved Thief stands as an example of how even an incredible idea can be completely destroyed by pathetic execution and miserably mishandled performances.
Then came the soul swap (or body swap—call it what you want), and everything slowly fell apart.
To be clear, I don’t think the concept itself was bad. In fact, the writers could have taken the story in a fun, emotionally rich direction. On paper, the idea still worked. But in execution, the drama completely failed—and the biggest reason was the acting, direction, and script handling after the swap.
Nam Ji-hyun’s performance was, frankly, shocking.
Once the souls are swapped, Nam Ji-hyun is supposed to portray the male lead’s soul inside her body, effectively becoming the male lead in a female body. However, she utterly fails to sell this transformation. There is no physicality, no change in speech, posture, or emotional rhythm that suggests a man inhabiting a woman’s body. Most of the time, she continues to act exactly like the female lead, making the entire soul-swap concept feel pointless.
It’s impossible not to compare this to Mr. Queen.
Shin Hye-sun’s legendary performance in Mr. Queen set the gold standard for this trope—a male soul convincingly living inside a female body. That drama became a massive commercial and cultural success, breaking records on tvN and Netflix. Shin Hye-sun didn’t just “act”; she transformed. Any drama attempting a similar concept will inevitably be compared to Mr. Queen, and unfortunately, To My Beloved Thief loses that comparison by an overwhelming margin—honestly, a 100-to-1 situation.
That said, the male lead doesn’t escape criticism either. Even after the soul swap, he continues to act like the same male prince as before, despite supposedly having a woman’s soul inside him. His behavior, reactions, and emotional choices don’t reflect the swap at all.
Several scenes make absolutely no sense:
Why does he hug Nam Ji-hyun first when he is now the female lead, who had already rejected him?
Why do the dialogues not reflect even the slightest confusion or internal conflict from the soul swap?
Why do both characters continue behaving exactly as they did before, as if nothing changed?
The result is deeply frustrating. The male lead still acts like the male lead, the female lead still acts like the female lead, and the soul swap becomes nothing more than a lazy plot gimmick. The performances feel mismatched, confused, and emotionally hollow.
What hurts the most is that this drama could have been great.
It had a fun, creative story. It had early momentum. It had chemistry. But all of it was ruined by weak acting choices, poor direction, and a script that failed to commit to its own concept. What should have been an entertaining and memorable drama instead turned into a disappointing mess.
In the end, To My Beloved Thief stands as an example of how even an incredible idea can be completely destroyed by pathetic execution and miserably mishandled performances.
Was this review helpful to you?
