I love PBY so much and I absolutely trust her choices, I have yet to dislike anything she's involved in. Cable dramas are mostly better quality lately, so there's another plus.
Both Reply cases weren't really surprises, the confusion and anger just came from overly attached shippers who couldn't take off their shipper goggles and WAY was just a case of really bad writing, I was 100% team Tae Kwang and I admit I held a tiny bit of hope this drama would be different until the end, but from the first episode, Yi An was clearly set as the main lead and the end, however frustrating, didn't come as a real shock to me.
I can't say anything about DH as I haven't seen it, but I think from this list, The Producers did a good job at keeping the suspense alive until the end without going into unbelievable or ass-pull territory (looking at you, WAY).
I can't say anything about DH as I haven't seen it, but I think from this list, The Producers did a good job at keeping the suspense alive until the end without going into unbelievable or ass-pull territory (looking at you, WAY).