This review may contain spoilers
My fault for picking it ig
We are witnessing a genuine K-drama epidemic. As the traditional 16-episode format vanishes in favor of shorter streaming seasons, the writing is clearly suffering. While we don't always need 16 episodes, this new trend of 12 - 14 episode runs is leaving plots feeling hollow and rushed.
Wasted Potential and Shallow Themes
On paper, this drama was a goldmine. It raised heavy, classic questions: Mortality vs. Immortality, the corrosive nature of Human Greed, and the age-old debate of Money vs. Happiness. The tragedy is that the show raised these issues only to abandon them. It never truly explored the philosophy behind these themes, leaving us with a surface-level experience instead of a meaningful, coherent emotional journey.
Kim Hyeyoon Deserved Better
It is devastating to see such incredible leads, like Kim Hyeyoon, stuck in a project that doesn't do them justice. People are criticizing the acting, but the reality is that no actor can save a script that lacks character depth and logical progression. Hyeyoon is a powerhouse, and this project is a poor representation of what she can do. Since "re-pairings" are so rare in this industry, it’s a shame this was the project they were given. I will not stand for the hate against her based on just this drama.
Choice: The Subverted Trope
To give credit for a "first," the show subverted the standard Gumiho trope. Usually, the immortal sacrifices their divinity to grow old with their human partner. In a controversial twist, the FL chose to remain immortal. While this is "new," it ultimately feels shallow. By refusing to make that sacrifice, it makes the central romance feel surface-level—as if their love wasn't worth the weight of a human life and the difficulties it brings. I dont understand what message they were trying to send with that.
When a drama feels more like a collection of "cool ideas" but there is no follow-through on the themes, it just becomes a frustrating waste of time.
Wasted Potential and Shallow Themes
On paper, this drama was a goldmine. It raised heavy, classic questions: Mortality vs. Immortality, the corrosive nature of Human Greed, and the age-old debate of Money vs. Happiness. The tragedy is that the show raised these issues only to abandon them. It never truly explored the philosophy behind these themes, leaving us with a surface-level experience instead of a meaningful, coherent emotional journey.
Kim Hyeyoon Deserved Better
It is devastating to see such incredible leads, like Kim Hyeyoon, stuck in a project that doesn't do them justice. People are criticizing the acting, but the reality is that no actor can save a script that lacks character depth and logical progression. Hyeyoon is a powerhouse, and this project is a poor representation of what she can do. Since "re-pairings" are so rare in this industry, it’s a shame this was the project they were given. I will not stand for the hate against her based on just this drama.
Choice: The Subverted Trope
To give credit for a "first," the show subverted the standard Gumiho trope. Usually, the immortal sacrifices their divinity to grow old with their human partner. In a controversial twist, the FL chose to remain immortal. While this is "new," it ultimately feels shallow. By refusing to make that sacrifice, it makes the central romance feel surface-level—as if their love wasn't worth the weight of a human life and the difficulties it brings. I dont understand what message they were trying to send with that.
When a drama feels more like a collection of "cool ideas" but there is no follow-through on the themes, it just becomes a frustrating waste of time.
Was this review helpful to you?
