News
I had high expectations for this BL and, it fell extremely short on almost everything.
First things first, the plot is not super fresh as there have been other BLs about the entertainment industry before. However, Mr Fanboy seemed to go on a direction that no other had yet: the fixed CPs, the drama behind the scenes and the possible secret relationships that can happen when the cameras are off.It started off on a high with great world building and character construction. However, as time passed, Mr Fanboy became a desperate attempt at cleaning James’ and Ker’s image and making it seem like the two of them are victims of the circumstances and that people fighting back was putting them at the same level as those two. The whole thing of making Wan and Time experience things that JJ truly did with the audience and that woman, plus the usage of @ from his haters just made the whole thing even more obvious and more despicable.
Then there was the shade with the scenes of the companies’ CEOs. Why would they spend so much time bickering instead of working the main narrative? But still, as many other things in the BL, I brushed it off as it being necessary for the main plot. However, was it really? Because it all felt like a desperate attempt at building a side narrative where some companies are great (like Wan’s) and others are toxic and create monsters (like Nine’s). At no point do these people take any real accountability for their individual actions. Sunny only apologises to Wan because he saves Nine and let’s not even get on how Nine just came off as a pitiful character that we should understand and feel sorry for, especially with the scenes in the final episode. At the beginning, it seemed like they were shading themselves and there were several memes of “the subject has become too self-aware” but self-awareness without change is simply bs.
In spite of all the bad things about this show, the worst of it all is that the main characters and their story were completely sidelined in detriment of these nonsensical subplots. AuauSave delivered great chemistry as expected but chemistry alone isn’t enough and Wan’s blind kindness to an undeserving Nine and Third’s weird personality shifts were very off-putting and unrealistic, making the characters feel flat instead of complex and human as the company clearly wanted them to come off as.
Out of all the subplots, the one with the most potential was RenjiTime. Everyone had high expectations to see what DMD would do with these characters now that RyuijinPatji are an official CP and they fumbled that so badly. If ThirdWan fell flat, RenjiTime managed to outdo them by a hundred. There was no storyline, no plot, no character development and they seemed like crazy people who were playing with puppets and seeing if things would go the way they thought or not. When they got involved, it all seemed to be about a feeling of hatred towards Nine that was never truly addressed and because they just found everything to be really amusing.
Overall, Mr Fanboy ended the same way it started and in every sense of it. The whole, “back to the beginning” thing was purely lazy writing and the attempt of fanservice with the whole “we don’t have to fake it, we’re a real couple” thing was just ridiculously boring. The acting was the only thing that carried this show and although I love AuauSave and RyujinPatji, it was absolutely not enough to make me enjoy it. I pushed through for them and will continue to support the actors but to anyone asking themselves if it’s worth the watch, I would say it isn’t, which is quite unfortunate considering how long I waited for this show to come out.
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
Boring from start to finish
Keeping my expectations low was probably what helped me make it to the end. And if you’re thinking of giving it a try, please think again.Firstly, my biggest ick regarding the show is probably the lack of time given to the viewers to get properly attached to these characters. Anda is supposed to be a key part as the typical character who dies and haunts the narrative, but the delivery was mid and there was absolutely nothing to justify the viewer getting invested on what was meant to be the main plot besides the romance. And that logic applies to every single character and every single relationship, which makes things so much worse and boring.
The thing that was supposed to be the biggest mystery in this BL is the most obvious plot ever because from the moment the brother shows up, every viewer experienced the “it was definitely him”, and that is yet another gigantic narrative flaw. Worst part? They still tried to redeem the bad guy in the end and the explanation behind his decisions was nonsensical and even insulting to the viewers who were expecting some big plot twist at the end after being played with a boring narrative for nine episodes.
But let’s address the biggest elephant in the room: why give us so many useless side characters? I get what they were trying to do but it clearly didn’t work. I don’t remember the name of Jin’s friends because they are extremely forgettable and the straight couple was always annoying to look at after literally episode one with their stupid relationship reveal on Pod’s birthday, while they both knew he was attracted to the guy. Talk about self-centred people, huh? Couldn’t even let their so-called best friend enjoy a day that was supposed to be all about him. Plus, the acting was stiff as heck for all of them; the friends, the brothers, the neighbour. It was truly quite baffling to watch since all of them had subpar skills.
Now onto the romance, it was very weak. With the whole Anda subplot, there was barely any real expectations set about these characters, and it was yet again another thing that felt underdeveloped. The chemistry was good for a new couple working together for the first time and they look great together aesthetically. But other than that, the characters have absolutely zero depth to them and it’s way too hard to look forward to seeing more of them as a couple. The NC scenes were good and had a delivery beyond expectations but the mid acting in every other moment added to the lack of substance given to these characters made the couple slightly unlikeable.
In the end, everything was shallowly explained, underdeveloped and underwhelming, with very few good things to talk about. I do hope to see NamnaPK in another BL with better storytelling because it would be a waste to let all this potential go to waste with only this BL on their resume but that’s pretty much it.
Was this review helpful to you?
