Quantcast

Details

  • Last Online: 3 hours ago
  • Gender: Female
  • Location:
  • Contribution Points: 2 LV1
  • Roles:
  • Join Date: September 23, 2025
  • Awards Received: Flower Award1 Dumpster Fire Award1 Reply Hugger1
The Lament of Autumn chinese drama review
Dropped 25/40
The Lament of Autumn
1 people found this review helpful
by WingedBean
10 days ago
25 of 40 episodes seen
Dropped
Overall 7.0
Story 7.0
Acting/Cast 10.0
Music 8.0
Rewatch Value 1.0
This review may contain spoilers

Mid Plot Amnesia: The Bane of My Existence

It is with a heavy heart that I have to drop this drama. If you'd asked me a mere 3 weeks ago (back when I was on ep 18) if I thought I'd drop this show, I'd have told you a resounding 'Fuck No.'

I bloody loved this dark romance. Changxuan's obsession and wrapped devotion, PingJun's stubbornness despite an underlying attraction, the backdrop of the war, and the 2 suspicious siblings in their house. All this had me in a chokehold despite the ever-looming warning from more experienced drama watchers that all Republican-era dramas end in tragedy.

I was determined to see it to the end. I wanted to see how these two people who constantly clashed would end up together. How would they change each other? How would they overcome everything standing in the way of their love? Ugh, the promise of that development was so good!

And then they went and hit me with fucking amnesia halfway through the plot. Honestly. WTF?!?!? To me, amnesia only works when it's at the beginning of the story. Where the character in question and I have no clue what's going on. We're both fucking around and finding out together. Well, they are; I'm just in the background learning and finding out.

But halfway through the plot? Hell nah. All this trope does is stall the plot and turn a character I knew and appreciated into bland cardboard.

I was already having beef with the author for making PingJun too stubborn—keeping her so high on her moral high horse that she couldn't even see the ground anymore. She was too unwilling to admit and accept that she was actually attracted to this evil man, all while giving her emotionally cheating, traitorous, and treasonous ex-boyfriend chances he absolutely did not deserve. Then they made her lose her memory 🙄.

PS: I genuinely suspect the author realized too late in the story that they’d made PingJun so stubborn there was no realistic way to get her and ChangXuan together. In a panic, they gave her amnesia just to keep her in Nanhuai and force a path for the romance

As of episode 25, Changxuan is still in love and devoted, while PingJun is slowly coming around. They seem to be heading for their romantic era. But despite my desire to see that—and trust me, I have seen all the spicy edits and tweets—I can't help but feel empty when I see them get close. I am too aware that this isn't real. No matter how much I try, I cannot get myself to enjoy it.

The point of a dark romance, IMO, is to make both characters fall in love with full awareness of exactly who they are choosing. They know this person isn't the best; they know all their fucked-up sides, yet they willingly choose to walk into the fire. Making a character lose their memory to clear a path for the romance feels like a total cop-out.
Because of that, I cannot bring myself to continue. I shall be bowing out here. Unfortunately.
Was this review helpful to you?