News This review may contain spoilers
It was okay....
I went in with no expectations. I haven't watched the original Japanese Doctor X, so I went in completely blind and had nothing to compare it to. It was an okay watch, but I wouldn't say it was anything particularly special.
Kim Ji Won was probably one of the biggest reasons I stuck with it. Gye Su Jeong is brilliant, confident, unapologetic, and doesn't care about hospital hierarchy or who's sitting in the big chair. She knows what she's doing and isn't afraid to challenge people who abuse their power. I enjoy a female lead who doesn't need to constantly prove herself to others, and watching her go against the hospital's corruption and power games was satisfying.
However, I struggled with Gye Su Jeong as a character. I understand her trauma and why she became so guarded, but I felt like she was a little too one-dimensional. Her entire personality seemed to revolve around being stoic, brilliant, and repeating some variation of “I never fail.” Girl, we get it. You're a genius surgeon. 😂 But what else is there? I wanted more personality, more vulnerability, more emotion, and more depth. Her trauma explains why she is the way she is, but I don't think the drama did enough to make her feel like a fully fleshed-out character. I admired her more than I connected with her, and that made it difficult for me to become invested in her as the lead.
The overall premise was interesting, though. The concept of exposing doctors who abuse their positions for money, power, and status had potential. The hospital politics and corruption gave the drama something to work with, and there were moments of satisfaction watching Su Jeong challenge people who clearly needed to be taken down a peg. But I don't think the writing always delivered on that potential.
The supporting cast was probably more memorable to me in some ways. Park Tae Gyeong's storyline was more emotional than I expected. Some of the patient stories were genuinely heartbreaking, and I appreciated the moments where the drama highlighted how patients and ordinary medical staff get caught up in a system driven by greed, power, and politics.
Unfortunately, the drama also started losing steam as it went along. Some storylines felt repetitive, others felt disconnected, and the darker plot developments toward the end didn't feel as well developed as they should have been. The final stretch felt rushed, and I wasn't particularly satisfied with how everything wrapped up. There were moments where I was wondering where the story was going and how certain plotlines even fit into the bigger picture. It felt like the drama wanted to say a lot but didn't always know how to get there.
The medical scenes also had moments that made me question what I was watching. I'm not expecting a documentary, but there were definitely scenes where I sat there thinking, “Wait, what?” 😂
Overall, Doctor X: Mafia in White was an okay drama. It had an interesting premise, some entertaining characters, and Kim Ji Won is always enjoyable to watch, but the writing, character development, and pacing kept it from being something I genuinely loved. I never watched the Japanese original, so I can't comment on how this adaptation compares, but as a standalone drama, it was just average for me.
A 6/10. I don't regret watching it, but I probably won't be thinking about it for very long either. I came for Kim Ji Won, stayed to see where the story was going, and left feeling... well, that was fine. 😂
Kim Ji Won was probably one of the biggest reasons I stuck with it. Gye Su Jeong is brilliant, confident, unapologetic, and doesn't care about hospital hierarchy or who's sitting in the big chair. She knows what she's doing and isn't afraid to challenge people who abuse their power. I enjoy a female lead who doesn't need to constantly prove herself to others, and watching her go against the hospital's corruption and power games was satisfying.
However, I struggled with Gye Su Jeong as a character. I understand her trauma and why she became so guarded, but I felt like she was a little too one-dimensional. Her entire personality seemed to revolve around being stoic, brilliant, and repeating some variation of “I never fail.” Girl, we get it. You're a genius surgeon. 😂 But what else is there? I wanted more personality, more vulnerability, more emotion, and more depth. Her trauma explains why she is the way she is, but I don't think the drama did enough to make her feel like a fully fleshed-out character. I admired her more than I connected with her, and that made it difficult for me to become invested in her as the lead.
The overall premise was interesting, though. The concept of exposing doctors who abuse their positions for money, power, and status had potential. The hospital politics and corruption gave the drama something to work with, and there were moments of satisfaction watching Su Jeong challenge people who clearly needed to be taken down a peg. But I don't think the writing always delivered on that potential.
The supporting cast was probably more memorable to me in some ways. Park Tae Gyeong's storyline was more emotional than I expected. Some of the patient stories were genuinely heartbreaking, and I appreciated the moments where the drama highlighted how patients and ordinary medical staff get caught up in a system driven by greed, power, and politics.
Unfortunately, the drama also started losing steam as it went along. Some storylines felt repetitive, others felt disconnected, and the darker plot developments toward the end didn't feel as well developed as they should have been. The final stretch felt rushed, and I wasn't particularly satisfied with how everything wrapped up. There were moments where I was wondering where the story was going and how certain plotlines even fit into the bigger picture. It felt like the drama wanted to say a lot but didn't always know how to get there.
The medical scenes also had moments that made me question what I was watching. I'm not expecting a documentary, but there were definitely scenes where I sat there thinking, “Wait, what?” 😂
Overall, Doctor X: Mafia in White was an okay drama. It had an interesting premise, some entertaining characters, and Kim Ji Won is always enjoyable to watch, but the writing, character development, and pacing kept it from being something I genuinely loved. I never watched the Japanese original, so I can't comment on how this adaptation compares, but as a standalone drama, it was just average for me.
A 6/10. I don't regret watching it, but I probably won't be thinking about it for very long either. I came for Kim Ji Won, stayed to see where the story was going, and left feeling... well, that was fine. 😂
Was this review helpful to you?
1
1
