News 
All in all, if you are a fan of CSI type crime shows, this one is likely to engage your interest. The various crimes solved actually occurred, which makes them more interesting than so many of the fictional, contrived murders littering the drama landscape.
Was this review helpful to you?
I'm like a little obsessed with crime shows and stuff so I'm being a little harsh. Overall, if this was the first time I saw a crime show, this would blow my mind. But alas, I've seen a few good ones so this doesn't really compare that well.
The story was good in the sense that most questions got answered. You find out who almost everyone is at the end. But what bothered me was that the story wasn't really tightly connected. The overarching theme was really loose and it felt a little bit forced, like parts of it was inserted just because it'll add suspense but it didn't really relate to anything too significant.
The overarching plot was predictable and too typical. I mean it's still a decent drama, I would definitely recommend, but it was a *little* disappointing.
But the individual crimes and stuff, that was kinda neat. Props.
What I appreciated was the comedic relief, they were inserted a really good times so you're not psychologically stressed the entire show. And it really builds on character development.
Acting: 8/10
The main characters really worked well together, not to mention the male leads were definitely eye candy ^^ Character development only really happened for Dr. Qin, the rest kinda helped him a long with it. Which was cute. But development was pretty typical and expected. At least the acting was professional.
Music: 6.5/10
There were not really a lot of memorable OST parts that I could remember. I'm pretty good aurally so I would remember a song that relates a certain scene or whatever. The only vaguely good parts I remember is the quirky tune during comedic relief parts. When ever that music came on, I just felp more relaxed because nothing bad is happening.
Rewatch: 5/10
I don't typically rewatch dramas, but this was short and sweet enough to maybe go and pick out my favorite episodes. What I love about these dramas are that the beginnings are individual crimes and stories so you can watch it separately.
Overall: 7/10
It was a little disappointing that the overarching theme was too loose and typical. It was too predictable and thus a little anti-climatic. But the individual crimes were pretty decent and enjoyable.
If anyone is looking for a good crime show starter or just a laid back drama, this is definitely a good one.
Was this review helpful to you?
An Enjoyable Mystery Series That Almost Had It All
Yay!! I finally managed to get my hands on the 2016 version of Medical Examiner Dr. Qin, starring Zhang Ruo Yun and Li Xian! I've been searching for this drama for so long, and I'm so happy I can finally watch it. I've wanted to see this version for ages! ❤️I've tried watching the other adaptations before, but unfortunately, the characterisation didn't quite click with me. The characters often came across as a little too young, immature, or overly playful for the kind of investigative drama I was looking for. I ended up dropping them around episode 2 or 3 because I couldn't quite get into the story.
It's not that I dislike humour or playful interactions between characters. In fact, I enjoy them when they're done well! However, when the playfulness becomes excessive or the characters seem to disregard one another's boundaries too often, it can take away from the seriousness of the cases. The 2016 version strikes a better balance for my taste, with characters whose personalities and interactions feel more fitting for the nature of the story.
And then there's Qin Ming himself! I personally think Zhang Ruo Yun is particularly well-suited to the role. There's something about his gaze, facial expressions, and overall demeanour that makes his portrayal so convincing. He manages to capture Qin Ming's eccentricities and slightly peculiar mannerisms without making them feel exaggerated or unnatural. He has just the right presence for a character who is intelligent, particular about his work, and not exactly the easiest person to deal with. 😂
Of course, Da Bao and Lin Tao make things even more enjoyable. I love how they take every opportunity to tease Qin Ming, often so casually that you'd think it was simply part of their everyday routine. And whenever the two try to tease him or get the better of him, Qin Ming is never one to let them have the last word! He'll often retort with some logical reasoning or scientific explanation, as though he simply cannot resist correcting them or pointing out the facts. 😂 His responses are very much in character, and it's amusing to see how he uses his knowledge and matter-of-fact logic to counter their playful remarks. Their interactions bring a lightheartedness to the drama without turning it into a comedy. It's especially amusing to watch Qin Ming being his usual eccentric self while the other two react to him in their own ways. These little moments add warmth to the trio's dynamic and make their relationships just as enjoyable to follow as the cases themselves.
One thing I appreciate about this drama is how clues and subtle hints are scattered throughout the cases, giving viewers something to pay attention to and piece together as the investigations progress. I also like how the cases allow us to see the characters working together and developing a better understanding of one another along the way. The investigations aren't just there to provide mysteries to solve; they also give the trio opportunities to interact, work through situations together, and reveal more of their individual personalities.
The investigative details also make the cases feel relatively realistic, even though I do think some aspects of the investigative process could have been explored in greater depth. It's a drama that rewards paying attention to what's happening, particularly when it comes to the clues and forensic details.
My one real criticism is that the cases tend to conclude rather quickly, usually within 1.5 to 2 episodes. Since each episode is only around 30 minutes long, some investigations feel rushed. The clues often appear conveniently, certain parts of the investigative process are glossed over, and we don't always get to see enough of the forensic analysis. The cases don't always feel challenging enough, and I sometimes wish the investigators had to work harder to examine the evidence, connect the dots, or consider more possibilities before arriving at the truth.
And then there are the suspects who seem to admit to their crimes surprisingly quickly once they're confronted! Sometimes, their confessions come so easily that I can't help finding it a little amusing. It's almost as though confronting them is all it takes to get the truth out of them! While I understand that the brisk pacing helps keep the story moving, I would have loved to see some cases develop more gradually, with more complicated evidence, unexpected twists, and greater emphasis on the forensic procedures. After all, the more effort it takes to piece together the clues and establish what really happened, the more satisfying it feels when the investigators finally arrive at the truth.
I was kinda disappointed with the last case, though. It wasn't particularly impactful, and the whole thing felt a little underwhelming. Everything was so predictable, and I was hoping for something a little more unexpected or exciting, especially for the ending. 🥲
Another reason the drama feels so short and quick is that it focuses almost entirely on the trio. Qin Ming, Da Bao, and Lin Tao are at the centre of nearly everything, while most of the other characters remain in the background, appearing mainly as suspects, victims, or police officers involved in the cases. The other police officers sometimes feel more like background characters who accompany the trio or fill the scenes when additional people are needed, rather than investigators who make substantial contributions of their own. We rarely get to know them beyond their immediate roles in the cases, so the investigations tend to revolve around the trio's findings and interactions. While I do enjoy watching the three of them work together, I sometimes wish the supporting characters had been given more room to contribute meaningfully to the investigations. Allowing other investigators to offer their own observations, examine evidence, or help connect the dots could have made the investigative team feel more fully developed. It might also have added more depth to the cases instead of having so much of the investigative work revolve around the main trio.
Still, I don't think every investigative drama needs to follow the same investigative style or process. If every drama approached its cases in exactly the same way, wouldn't that get a little boring? 😂 Each drama has its own approach, strengths, weaknesses, and unique charm. Some may place greater emphasis on forensic analysis and investigative procedures, while others may simplify certain aspects to keep the story moving or focus more on the characters and their relationships. My criticism of the investigations in this drama doesn't mean I expect every investigative drama to follow the same formula. I can appreciate that different approaches work for different stories, even if some suit my personal preferences better than others. After all, no drama is perfect, and each has its own qualities and shortcomings that make it distinctive.
Despite a few shortcomings, I'm thoroughly enjoying this version. What appeals to me most is how it combines interesting cases with convincing characterisation and just enough humour to keep the story from feeling too heavy. Although the investigations could have been more challenging and the supporting characters could have been more involved, I still enjoy following the clues and seeing how the cases unfold, even when some of the resolutions feel a little too straightforward.
Ultimately, what keeps me invested is the combination of the investigative elements and the trio's chemistry. Zhang Ruo Yun captures the essence of Qin Ming especially well, while Da Bao and Lin Tao bring out different sides of his personality through their interactions with him. Their dynamic adds warmth and humour to the story without undermining its investigative tone. Even when a case doesn't feel particularly complex, watching the three of them work together makes the journey enjoyable in its own way.
While the different adaptations each have their own interpretations of the story, I personally find that the 2016 version has a particular charm that makes it stand out. For me, it's the combination of Zhang Ruo Yun's convincing portrayal of Qin Ming, the trio's chemistry, and the drama's overall atmosphere that makes this version especially appealing. I'm so glad I finally got to watch it after searching for it for so long. Although the investigations and supporting characters could have been developed further, the drama still offers the balance of mystery, character dynamics, and humour that I was hoping for.
The 2016 version is definitely my cup of tea! ❤️
Mild Reminder: please think twice before watching this drama right before a meal or immediately after eating! The forensic details and crime scenes can be pretty graphic, so some scenes might not be the most appetising viewing experience. It's a good show, but definitely not the one to put on while you're enjoying your lunch or dinner! 🤭
Was this review helpful to you?
This is basically a case by case show. The focus on the cases is really the entire show. It doesn't really showcase any background information of the characters. There is a bit of humor like small jokes, jabs and sarcastic scenes between the characters, but like I said, it revolves solely around the different cases. I thought the main mc, Qin, would be like those genius characters I mentioned before but he really is just displays his socially awkwardness and that's it. You don't really get the full extent and knowledge of the personalities of any one of the characters. It really is based on your own interpretation of what the characters are like. There is no romance, no background struggles besides from solving the cases. Episodic. Like I mentioned, besides from a little humor here and there, nothing else. Acting wise, I have no compliments or complaints. I don't think I'm going to rewatch this show. It really is kinda dull and one sided when telling the story of the cases. The cases though, are somewhat interesting. The gruesomeness of the forensic investigations aren't especially high but to people that are weak to even just seeing somebody cut open a cadaver or seeing large amounts of blood, then it is on the slightly grisly side.
If you are solely interested in a mystery and like watching how cases are being solved, then this show is for you. It cuts out all the fluff of the character relationships, backgrounds, etc and focuses on the process of how the police force and forensics professionals solve the cases.
Was this review helpful to you?
The plots are pretty interesting (not mind-blowing, but interesting enough that you'll want to continue watching). There isn't anything I haven't seen before on any other show, but the show was medically educational. I actually learned a few very interesting facts about the human body and general function of things. The scenes were also pretty streamlined and played with your emotions pretty well. There wasn't a single boring moment.
My only nitpick is that the actors/actresses have a habit of touching their face all the time... including during an autopsy or while examining a corpse. So they'll be prodding a bloated and rotten corpse with their gloved hands, and then wipe sweat from their face in the next second. Okaaay.
Was this review helpful to you?
Dont waste your time to watch this
"Medical Examiner Dr. Qin" disappoints with its final case, a ludicrous plotline that renders the entire episode pointless. Despite promising comedy early on, the series quickly loses steam, offering tedious and uninspiring cases. Don't bother watching for Zhang Ruo Yun or Li Xian's acting; it's simply not worth your time. The existence of a second season is truly surprising. Save yourself the disappointment and skip this one altogether. The lack of character development and repetitive nature of the cases make it hard to invest in the show, leaving viewers feeling unsatisfied and unengaged. It's a regrettable waste of potential.Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
I watch this because of Li Xian, but then I really love the story and all the casts. This drama is just like TV Series CSI, and since I love that series, I also love this. But I think I must warn you because the first 2 episodes really shake my stomach in the level I want to throw up. They really explicit about the corpse (or the remaining of it), that’s why I put ‘18+’ sign here. What relieved me was that in the following episodes, they censored the corpse with whatever their conditions.The story was great. It seems that the cases are stands alone, but then they’re related to the one Qin Ming’s old case. Those case also reveal Qin Ming’s past and his father’s case. Too bad they didn’t show or explain the detail of Qin Ming’s old case which became the background of some case.
As for the casts, they’re really did a great job.
Zhan Ruo Yun did a great job of portray Qin Ming’s stoic and systematic personality.
Jiao Jun Yan also great at portray Li Da Bao’s character. It’s so funny to watch how brave she is when facing Qin Ming at his territory, a morgue (o＾▽＾o)
Li Xian as Lin Tao is also great. He can be serious at some time and be silly in the very next second. But I think he still a bit clumsy when he hold a weapon (^_^;)
Was this review helpful to you?
I came here because Zhang Ruo Yun (def eye candy) was in it! He was quite good in this drama... all though I am very biased in that manner :P
Was this review helpful to you?
Overall the story was well done. They did a great job explaining everything and introducing you to all the right characters. My only issue is that the beginning felt really loose. It didn't tie into the rest of the story as tightly as I would have liked. The later half of Medical Examiner Dr. Qin was the better half in my opinion. Each episode furthered the plot along and answered more questions.
The ending was great! The dynamics among the three main characters was great throughout the show so it was so nice to see a happy ending for them.
I'm not sure I would watch this again but I definitely wouldn't mind a second season.
Was this review helpful to you?
Mystery Theatre at its best
Qin, Medical Examiner is a very tense drama, with suspense and sporadic comedic dialog to alleviate the tension. The autopsy scenes are very graphic.Zhang Ruo Yun, Jiao Jun Yan and Li Xian created the best forensic TV drama team. Every case was tense, as the subplot unfolded. The supporting actors also did a very good job.
Directing and editing were done well, except for the constant shaky camera that caused motion sickness. The director could have invested a few budget dollars in a tripod for the cameraman. Music was very good, and fit the mood of the scenes. Overall, a well done drama, similar in style to the British detective dramas!
Was this review helpful to you?
You guys should give this a try!! I swear you won't regret it.
PS: I don't usually re-watch a drama (except Ten Miles of Peach Blossom LOL , so I rated it pretty low.
Was this review helpful to you?
Was this review helpful to you?
