Was this review helpful to you?
Oh! And it's nice that Nishikado and Akira have their good share of spotlight in the series. The friendship between the four is good to see.
In my opinion, Inoue Mao did a great job portraying Tsukushi Makino. She didn't need to act too cutesy since she's naturally cute. Pretty, even. Her fierce look suits her, too! The four guys did great, too! It's funny to think that the "stupid Domyouji" role fits Jun Matsumoto. Anyway, he and Inoue Mao have chemistry and that's good. I was amused by the fact that Oguri Shun's good at acting like some sleepyhead. In my opinion, the cast is well-selected. All of them did great.
The music is lovable. I especially liked the opening song.
I would definitely want to re-watch this someday.
Overall, I give this a 9 because I really do believe that it's great. I recommend this to:
- people who love rom-com
- people who want to watch a series who isn't too long but is still good
- fans of the manga and anime which go by the same title
- fans of the Chinese, Taiwanese, and Korean versions ('cause of the differences made)
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
I want what Domyoji and Makino have
It has to be one of my favorite ones of the boys over flowers adaptations. It’s so funny and enjoyable. I really want what Domyoji and Makino have their so cute. Once Domyoji did his little head spin after getting off the phone with her I was hooked on this drama. I loved that ending with Makino being her amazing self I wish to be her so badly with her confidence and her fighting skills. I loved the relationship between Makino and Todo Shizuka I think they were my favorite from the adaptions because they seemed like they were super close right when they met each other. Also the younger them were so cute!! Also this is the famous seventeen scene with Jun and Joshua with Domyoji pushing yuriko to the floor at the cafeteria. Sakurako kind of scared me with stalking Domyoji, but once she changed and helped Makino with her English speech because she lived aboard I had a change of heart for her. Also Makino’s outfit for the fashion show was actually fire for being under “1 minute” that even the French guy with taste for fashion was stunned like me. Anyways I really love this drama with my whole heart and really recommend this one!Was this review helpful to you?
Was this review helpful to you?
I can't even put into words on how much I loved watching this series and I still come back to this to watch every now and again.
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
I give the lowest score for the korean version. I thought i will give this one the same score since it older than korean.But it beyond my expectation. I give this drama the highest score..
Story : this is what i like from japanese dramas. they are short but straight to the point. so every seconds in this drama is very important, interesting, and not wasting my time. The love story, I understand the reason why the falling in love. I understand why the event happen. And I understand about their feelings.
Acting/Cast : unlike korean version, I dont hate any character in this drama. I feel annoyed by main character in korean version, but it shocked me that I like the main character in this drama. The girl and shun oguri in first episode is the best part.
Music : I always like Japanese Music, Including this one.
Rewatch Value : After I finish of all season in this version, I think its fine for me to re-wacth it again..
Overall : This is how it should look like.
Was this review helpful to you?
Even though it's the same plot, the feeling is completely different, I feel like they picked up Hana Yori dango and mixed up the most annoying korean cliches in it, put a lot of filling episodes, again, filled with korean cliches and ta-da. Boys over flowers. Sorry if I'm comparing too much these two versions, is just that, I'm surprised that this one turned out to be good, out of my expectations.
The main male lead was cute, as if he was hiding his true heart and that was pretty clear, unlike the Korean version. The Korean version, from what I could tell, he was just a bully mean guy that have fallen in love with a girl and that was it. I just couldn't like him. The whole point was lost. Hana Yori Dango made it clear, that inside that scary guy lies a cute spoiled boy.
The main girl, she played strong and played well, the acting, I must say, way, but way, but waaaaaaay much better than the Korean's which didn't had that strong concept Hana Yori Dango had, it was mostly like she was somehow random, crying whatever. Let's not talk about her goofy acting. Ugh
And the best thing in comparision to the korean version, was that there was no actually space in the story for the damn second lead syndrome. Sure Rui had a crush on her, but his role, spacing and development was nothing compared the main lead, which get us rid of those hated love triangles, that we always end up shipping wrong. So, one more point to the script. It was well written. Good.
Was this review helpful to you?
And to be perfectly honest, I DO still adore this show. Also, this review is based purely on my re-watch of the first season as I have not gotten to the second season or movie yet.
Hana Yori Dango has a special place in my heart for two reasons:
1. It was the first Japanese drama I ever watched (along with "Nobuta wo Produce" as they were airing at the same time) and
2. I watched this while I was studying abroad in Japan, as it was airing.
Since then, I have re-watched the series a few times but it's been years now since my last re-watch and I definitely notice some glaringly poorly executed qualities.
To explain--I have had this idea for a while now that Japanese dramas are not what they used to be. I always refer back to Hana Yori Dango as kind-of being the headliner for the "golden" days of J-Dramas. They were SO good...and then they were not. And I could never really put my finger on why.
After re-watching HYD, I have come to the realization that it's not necessarily the fact that Japanese dramas have changed for the worst so much as I have just out-grown them. This is because many of the issues that I have when watching Japanese dramas nowadays (inconsistent story, silly and unrealistic characters, over-done humor) are all present in HYD, and I think at the time I initially watched it, I just didn't care...or know any better.
So, because of nostalgia, HYD still makes me "EEK" like a silly fangirl. It's still epic in my heart. However, if I were to watch it now without the memories and attachment I have associated with it I think I would not have enjoyed it nearly as much.
Was this review helpful to you?
This is actually the show that pulled me out of my Korean series comfort zone and pushed me to the Japanese one.
The story line was good. It did lack in the romance department, but in a way that's understandable since they were still trying to build the foundation of Tsukushi and Tsukasa's relationship. Additional points also for tackling issues such as bullying, violence, high school hierarchy, and such, although this may be credited to the original manga rather than the series itself. The actors weren't as good-looking as that of the Korean version, yes, but their protrayal of their characters are outstanding. I'd say there was no one who could play Makino Tsukushi better than Inoue Mao. She was perfect for the role! And Shun Oguri was also the right choice for Hanazawa Rui. At first I was a bit hesitant with Matsumoto Jun being Domyouji Tsukasa (prolly because of that perm, lol) but as the series developed I couldn't imagine any other Domyouji other than him. It probably did help that Inoue Mao and Matsumoto Jun has this undying chemistry that was enough to keep me watching (I told you guys, I'm biased towards these two). I have to be honest, you know how there are series that that you like more and more because of the main characters? That's how this is to me. The series was good and worth watching, but it grew on me more and more because of these two actors. If they weren't the couple that portrayed Tsukushi and Tsukasa, I might give off a different response. I might have still loved it, but probably not up to the extent I am in now, so it's a good thing that it was them who portrayed Makino and Domyouji.
As for what version is the best, I don't think there's such a thing as 'better' than the other. It all just depends on people's preference to be honest. As for me, I've seen the different versions in varying timelines. The first one I saw was the Taiwanese version. It was during the peak of the series, and the hype was just insane. So if we're basing it on the excitement I felt to watch the series, the Taiwanese version wins. It's the biggest hit, imo. If I haven't seen all the versions yet and I'd try to watch them now, I believe I'd like the Korean version best. It came out way after the Taiwanese and Japanese versions, which explains why the series is definitely favorable to the current audience (eye candy guys, beautiful sceneries, romantic-comedy genre... at this time, who wouldn't love that, right?) However, up to this date, the only series that I had watched for countless times and never got tired of was the Japanese version. I've grown to love this series more than I'd ever imagine.
Furthermore, I gave it a 10/10 rewatch value because once you've loved this show and the actors, you'd love it for the rest of your life. I've seen it for more than 10 times already and I still enjoy watching it every single time.
P.S. You definitely should proceed to Part 2 ASAP once you finish this.
Was this review helpful to you?
How to bully a girl into falling in love
Hana Yori Dango was my first contact with Asian dramas, and I was not ready for this type of silly, over-the-top manga/anime live-action adaptation. I did not watch the anime or read the manga, so I really cannot compare how faithful to the source material this drama is. I went into this while I was looking for something to immerse myself in the Japanese language. As the reviews were good and it seemed popular I thought it would be a good choice. That was not so.This seems to be your typical rich boy who falls in love with a poor girl story, but only worse. The female lead is at first portrayed as this strong, both mentally and physically type of person, that is not about to be pushed around by the school bullies. But turns out that she is actually this naive and gullible girl that is constantly harassed and mistreated by the male lead. And we, the audience, is somehow made to have empathy for this person, because he, as it turns out, really likes her. There is little to no character growth for the male lead aside from this poor attempt at a sad backstory, and he is never held accountable for his actions. Unless you are really a fan of the manga/anime or the actors, you can skip this.
Was this review helpful to you?
I think all the other reviews are blinded by their nostalgia
I watched the korean adaption in 2010. As a kid I fell in love with it and all of its weird cliches. People always talked about how the Japanese version was superior and as someone who has recently fallen into this hole of watching japanese dramas, I had to check out Hana Yori Dango.Strong Parts:
This is a VASTLY superior version than the Korean Boys Over Flowers. Why? The acting and the chemistry between the two leads were off the charts. It was wild, they were electric whenever they were on screen. The ML's acting was pretty damn impressive, making you actually grow to love such a jerk of a character. The FL is awesome. What complaints could I give? She's not whiny or annoying. I found her to be pretty honest and extremely lovable. The acting was natural and not over dramatic.
This version has only 9 episodes while the original has like 20+ so it doesn't have that much filler in comparison. The Their hair was also better lol.
The family is also hilarious and has clever writing whenever they were involved. I loved them.
Negatives:
This plot is kind of ass, I mean it's a drama from 2005 so I'm not expecting a masterpiece nor is the original manga a masterful plot so what am I expecting. However, if I'm putting time to watch a drama, I have to keep the story in mind. It's a plot full of tropes left and right. And as someone who watched the BOF version, I remember everything so I just ended up bored. But I did laugh whenever there was something absolutely ridiculous happening.
Overall:
Better than BOF but was it worth it? No.
Was this review helpful to you?
Where it All Began
Usually I don't like watching school drama's but since this series was popular enough for two other remakes, I needed to find out why it was so appealing. I suppose if you are a young, 15 year old girl, this would have some kind of appeal. However, I have always thought that any girl who picks a bad boy over the one that treats her like a queen deserves whatever she gets. Luckily this is done in an entertaining, albeit, cliched way.The entire premise is completely implausible, the characters one-dimensional, and the storylines contrived. The cast is cute but it isn't enough to save the stinky plot and the acting is atrocious. Makino is a really sweet girl, but she is a doormat when girls bully her, yet tough when boys are the bullies. Perhaps she has figured out just how demented mean girls can be, and far more evil. I think the worst message this show can have is to make young ladies believe that they can change a bad boy with just a little TLC. People like Domyogi don't change.
It has entertainment value to some degree, but everything is on the surface. The characters were just not believable enough. All I know is that everyone is shallow and crazy with the exception of Makino. The bullying is way over the top here and just not realistic. There is a lack of authority, but perhaps this is the way the manga is written. It is definitely better than Meteor Garden, so thank God for small wonders.
Was this review helpful to you?
