Survivor's Law II (2007)

Rewriting Characters, Ruining the Story

This is a drama that never deserved to be written if the original cast wasn't going to return in full. Sammul can't even carry this drama. If anything, Kenneth Ma stood out, as he's a much more versatile actor.

Sammul Chan as Vincent remained the least interesting character to me. While the first installment added some depth to him, in this sequel his acting stayed the same, and if anything his character appeared less confident. If that was intentional, okay, props to him.

I have a major bone to pick with the writers. First, what were they thinking with Jessica and Vincent’s relationship? Jessica’s portrayal in this installment was completely unrecognizable, even in a cameo. I don't mean her physical appearance; I mean her personality. It felt like the writers simply threw in a familiar character from the first installment just to tie up loose ends.

Vincent decides to go to another firm due to his ego, which is understandable. We know he was struggling to find a new firm, but this self-imposed pressure was unnecessary. Back at H K Firm, they had welcomed him with open arms despite his license suspension. Letting his ego once again dictate his decisions completely undermines the character development he achieved in the first installment. In the original series, Vincent learned to let go of his ego and accept help.

Vincent has always been extremely career driven, and this was established clearly in the first installment. Given his suspension, we knew he'd work even harder to prove himself. This scene in Survivor’s Law 2 therefore felt completely out of character for me.

Here’s the phone conversation between Jessica and Vincent:

Vincent: Jessica,
Jessica: Hello, Vincent? If I told you the person I often mentioned, Professor Jackson, proposed to me, would you fly out to London immediately? Even though I'm asking, you still wouldn't come?
Vincent: To be honest, my license was suspended, and it took half a year to find this new firm. I don't think I could step away.
Jessica: If that's the case, let's break up.

This is one of the most confusing and frustrating moments I’ve ever seen in a TVB drama. If you remember Jessica from the first installment, she was extremely naive but loyal, wore her heart on her sleeve, and would stand by the people she loved. Yes, people can change, but who is this Jessica now? I can't imagine her being so inconsiderate. She stood by Vincent while he was on trial. She knew from the very beginning that Vincent valued his career, and that was part of why she fell in love with him. For her to suddenly feel insecure and force a choice between him and his career completely contradicts her established personality.

After the second episode I was done, the people who carried the first installment was really Raymond Lam and Myolie Wu.

Lire davantage