This review may contain spoilers
Terribe comic adaptation
[Minor spoilers for comic]As someone who’s read the webcomic after watching both tv seasons, the show is bad as both an adaptation and on its own. There are many more counters in the comic. Comic actually has two Korean teams, and they both work together to defeat Ji Chungshin. Yujin, Hansuk, and Beomchan are no where to be seen in the show. I would’ve loved to see more counters besides the main cast. The other counters they have in the show get killed off immediately. In the comics, two Chinese counters survive instead of all of them dying.
The counters are also much weaker in the show than in the comics. Motak is the strongest counter in all of Asia, and Ms. Chu is one of 5 healers in the world. All of the Korean counters have psychokinesis by the end of season 2 in the comics. Counters only need an hour of sleep a day. They don’t need to sleep all night.
A bunch of storylines in the comic are resolved much more quickly than the show. The show stretches out stuff for so long, and even add pointless storylines.
- Motak doesn’t have a girlfriend in the comic, she was added to the show to be fridged.
- So Mun immediately decided to be a counter in the comic, show So Mun had to sleep on it. Comic Wigen immediately offers to let So Mun see his parents in Yung
- Motak never goes back to being a cop, he has the captain just give him info on cases.
- There are 8 Korean counters in the comic, not just 5
- Evil spirits cannot transfer to new bodies in the comics, that was dumb of the show to do.
- Ji Chungshin is a villain all throughout Season 1 of the comic, and he’s much more ruthless and scary.
- Pilkwang is only a minor villain in the comic, but the show makes him a main villain in season 2.
- Ma Juseok is actually introduced in the comics much earlier than the show. He’s also not a family friend of So Mun, they don’t know each other in the comics. His wife and kid died 7 years before the comic started, not during the story. Comic Juseok was already in prison for killing two scammers
- Hana’s family died because her mom got scammed by the Baekdoo real estate scam in season 2, just like Ma Juseok
The Yung spirits that the counters work with are all different races and ethnicities. Wigen is supposed to be German, and speaks German in Yung and So Mun can understand her. All spirits can talk to each other no matter the language they speak. Wigen speaks German, but So Mun hears it as Korean.
They made So Mun such an arrogant prick in this show. So Mun in the comic is actually pretty humble, and he usually only fights when he has to. Comic So Mun actually apologizes to hosts when he hits them too hard, or he accidentally gets thugs to shoot each other.
So Mun’s friends have bigger roles in the comic, and they actually find out that So Mun is a counter and Ms. Choo doesn’t erase their memories.
The comic is also much more violent and the injures are brutal. So Mun even gets his hand chopped off by Ji Chungshin, and So Mun throws a knife into his Chungshin’s eye. People lose limbs, break their arms and legs backwards, get their eyes gouged out, etc. The violence in the show is so tame.
So Mun’s CD player in season 1 has a payoff in the comic. In the show, it’s just something for the bullies to steal from him.
Jeokbong in the comic was actually useful and immediately agreed to be a counter, show Jeokbong is so annoying and useless. In the comic, Jeokbong was just as fast and strong as So Mun. But the show made him the weakest one.
The comic has such good build up and is suspenseful throughout. So many twists and stuff that I didn’t see coming. The show is so predictable and boring. I can’t wait for Season 3 of the comic to finish so I can read it.
Was this review helpful to you?
Peak Fiction.
listen chat this is peak fiction i cant even lie to you everything about this show is straight heat. there were ups there were downs i was all around town but i was soooooo here for it. i cant lie to you tho this was hitting my emotions hard and as an infp yk i felt it fahrealll/j but on a more serious note there was not a single boring moment, snoozefest :undetectable this kept me on my toes and judging by my user i imagine you can understand exactly what that means to me. I have said it once before and i will say it again kim sejong is a ten out of ten, who doing it like my girl...ill wait. 10s across the board argue with the wall and lmk what it says XD. anywho def give it a watch bring your tissues and your popcorn and enjoy the rideWas this review helpful to you?
If your into action, you’ll like this very much
I am in love with this story plot. Not only did he transform from someone who thinks he’s weak to someone who finally knows how to control his self. He gains family along the way and a potential love interest. He helps those who aren’t entirely bad become a better version of themselves. It gives you a drama you wanna watch over and over and over again. I’ve watched it 4 times over. You may experience a few tears but, it’s enough where it’s not overwhelming. It also has comedic parts to it, that will make your stomach hurt from laughing to hard. It can also teach you about controlling your emotions for the better of yourself in the future. Don’t let anger drive you to danger, use your anger to help defeat evil.Was this review helpful to you?
Managed to get into my top 5 kdramas!!
I cannot explain just how good this drama is, i finished it yesterday and just had to come review it. Everything from the plot, to the cast to the music is absolute perfection in my opinion. Not only did this drama manage to combine comedy, action, mystery and thriller, it did so without making it feel rushed or incomplete.I have to first applaud the acting here: I've always loved seeing Yeom Hyeran in supporting roles before and her being a main role here made me so happy and after watching it all i can safely say there is no better to play Choo Maeok. She really brings out this character to the best it can be and really portrays how strong Choo Maeok is, especially in front of her squad. Do Hana was probably one of my favourite characters on the show alongside a few others and Sejeong's performance was top-notch here. She conveyed how complex Hana's emotions are whilst showing how collected and calm she is on the outside. Jo Byunggyu playing So Mun is all i ever wanted because he really brings the character to life, and i'd be lying if i said the crying scenes didn't make me cry as well. Ga Motak is quite literally the epitome of strength, both physically and mentally and the bond between Motak and So Mun is so heartwarming. The Counters are amazing but i think the evil spirits deserve all the recognition too, especially Baek Hyanghee who i loved, perhaps even more than the main evil spirit Ji Chungsin.
The action scenes keep you at the edge of your seat whilst the scenes between So Mun and his friends and the dynamic between the Counters make you laugh and that is the best part about the drama.
The story is so well thought out that you can't really fault it and i love how the drama doesn't just show Chungsin as a 2D evil character but shows his story and makes him much more interesting.
All in all, i recommend everyone to watch it, you won't regret it!! And i'm so happy that season 2 is coming!!
Was this review helpful to you?
An Enjoyable Encounter
I thoroughly enjoyed this show. I managed to finish this in two days, which only means that I loved the different emotions it brought me. It’s been a while since a show was this successful in mixing different theme and genre in one. This show brilliantly presented and successfully intertwined reality, fantasy, politics, exorcism, family, friendship, afterlife, and so much more.I won’t mind another season of this show. I really loved it! Kudos to all who brought Uncanny Encounter to life. This is one of the best shows I watched so far this year!
Was this review helpful to you?
Action packed, emotional and funny
The Uncanny Counter is an action-filled drama, having both emotional and light-hearted moments.I really liked the relationships between the Counters. They're a found family - they bicker and banter, but in the end they have each other's backs. I wish the show explored more about their partners in Yung. I liked Mae-ok's backstory about her son, which played a big role in the communication between Yung and the Counters. I felt like Ha-na and her partner rarely got any screen time, so I'm not that sure about their relationship. I really liked Mo-tak's backstory and his involvement in the police force. I think it really gave more depth to his character. My favourite thing was how So Mun didn't abandon his friends the moment he gained his Counter powers. He still stands up for them and hangs out with them, which was really sweet. A shame he has to hide a lot of what he does, but at least there are people who care.
I really enjoyed the first half of the show, but after episode 12, the plot really began to drag on. There was a lot of unnecessary exposition and the show seemed to lose its direction in the second half. I really didn't like how they randomly introduced a character only to kill him off half an hour later. It seemed like the show writers were trying to elongate the show just for the sake of it. I read that they had to change writers halfway through filming, so that could have contributed to this problem.
Overall, this show is definitely worth watching. Although it does get a bit boring and strays away from its roots, the emotional finale makes up for it.
Was this review helpful to you?
A drama that will hold a special place in your heart. / Deep, Beautiful and Funny.
I began watching TUC without any expectations, since at that point I've never heard of it before and it wasn't that popular in my area. However, it became my favorite kdrama of all times and the counters hold now a special place in my heart.The story was beautifully written with lots of emotion and depth. Each counter has its traumatic past that was amazingly written without making it feel ankward like in many other dramas. The character development was there and their growth was really beautiful to watch.
Acting was done right. We have 4 leads with impressive backgrounds behind : Jo ByeongKyu, Kim Sejeong, Yeom Hyeran and Yoo Junsang. Honorable mentions to Lee HongNae. - played Ji Cheongsin I think it was ByeongKyu's first lead role and he did an exceptional job.
OST : I'd like to recommend Sejeong's OST "Meet Again", an emotional song written by her that will deeply touch your heart.
The rest of the OST was really cool as well.
So yes. TUC is a must watch, deep with many lessons, but also funny that will heal you in the end.
Was this review helpful to you?
A solid storyline with memorable characters and fantastic acting
This was my first time watching a superhero -style drama, and it definitely set a high bar for me. The writing was exceptionally good, focusing more on the relationships between the characters, as well as individual development not just for the sake of the plot, but for better understanding of each character's actions and motives.Ji Cheong Sin stood out as a memorable antagonist, with the actor's creepy rendition of his final struggle between himself and the spirit that possessed him. His arc was well paced and as a viewer, I was thoroughly invested in the whole thing. Baek Hyang Hee, as well, was a formidable antagonist that carried her own weight, even though she was a minor character. Her struggle with Hana was well thought out, with the two as polar opposites but evenly matched.
Each of the Counters had their own stories, and losses, which were introduced in a heartfelt way. From Mo-tak's heartbreak, Ms. Chu's grief, and Ha-na's guilt, each time we learned more about them my heart broke even more.
The mayor's drama was a little too drawn out, in my opinion. Towards the end, I started getting bored with Noh Chang-gyu and Cho Tae-sin's infighting, though the scene with the water bottles was one of my favorites. I liked that the serious tone of the story was sprinkled with some absurd humor to lighten the mood and remind us that all is not lost.
Was this review helpful to you?
enjoyable and entertaining
i mainly watch this because there's so much hype over this drama. overall it's a good drama, have enough suspense to keep you interested. all the actors did a very good job portraying their character. the story line however is not as good as the acting. There's so much backstory for each characters that's not being explain very well. I would give it better rating, if they cut unnecessary slow motion repetitive scene, and give better indepth explanation on each characters story. But as it was adapted from a comic, what can you expect.Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
Great TV series
Finished watching this TV series a few weeks ago and I loved every episodes. The main character was so loveable and I was rooting for a happy ending for him. Certainly felt every emotions he went through in his journey to get a closure about his parents death.Each main character is unique and they made watching the program enjoyable with their sense of humour and character. The badass character was really good looking and played his part really well. Good looking bad boy!!
Exciting program which makes you want to binge watching until the end just to see the good triumph over evil. Definitely rewatchable as well. Loved it 🥰😍
Was this review helpful to you?
It's Just A Masterpiece.
The overall script is perfect . The way the story line carry from start to the end is just AMAZING.!!!!!And the Acting of all actors and actress is perfect.
Especially , Jo Byung Kyoo who played as soo mo , his acting is really skillful.
I become a fan of him from now on..
If you like fantasy , superpowers and investigation, just try this drama. It's amazing!!!!
At first, I didn't expect anyting from this. But after I just finished Episode 1, I attached to it. This drama makes me excited just from the start. And I really love the friendship between Soo Mo and his childhood friends.
And I also love the bond between soo mo and counters.
It makes me feel warm.
Some scene , it makes me emotional and cry with the actors. I want to say the actors did really great job.
I get the emotions they sent. I really enjoy this.
I want to say that agian. This Drama is a Masterpiece.
Was this review helpful to you?
Must watch. Its amazing
Am English and I dont normal watch shows with subtitles but coming across the trailer to this epic kdrama was mind blowing. From the first to the last episode it grips you and keeps you amazed and hooked the whole way through, not only with an amazing storyline and music but the cast was perfect. I've honestly watch it so many times and would happily go back to the beginning and watch it all over againWas this review helpful to you?
`
