This review may contain spoilers
SEASON 2 IS BETTER IN EVERY WAY
I done get it, how most of the people here are giving bad reviews to this masterpiece of a season. This new actress is better in every way and I loved the chemistry between Jang uk and her way better than the chemistry between Jang uk and Mudoek....The main antagonist Jin mu had a better role here than the season1, overall this season is better in every way...It felt really good to see how Jang uk has become the most powerful mage here...
Sometimes the reviews of this site confuse me, people only focus on the romance here instead of the entire story and they give their biased ludicrous opinion based on that only...
It's very misleading for new kdrama watchers like me to get into a series like this...
So my advice to the people who will be reading this review of mine- "Ignore the negative reviews here and continue watching the series, done drop it just after watching the season 1"
I ENJOYED SEASONS 2 WAY MORE THAN SEASON 1
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
GOAT!!!
Alchemy of souls probably is my fav kdrama of all time rn! it hooked me up from the first episode like i immadietly got into it just watching it for a few seconds lol. like second season more and im so so glad that it ended with a happy ending. the plot twist was insane like i would never imagine the ending. if you are still doubting whether to watch or not my answer is absolutely yes! it basically has all genres like action, romance, history, fantasy, comedy... so anyone can like it tbh! plus the osts were amazing listening 7/24Was this review helpful to you?
Loving someone without basing their appearance
One of the best kdrama I've watched. The best decision that I made. This series made me laugh fell in love and also made me cry, but it was all worth it, the late night sleep is all worth it. Thank to Hong sisters and also the production team for making this master piece. Alchemy of souls thought me to love someone based on their soul not in their appearance. I don't know how to moved on, everytime I watch some dramas at the same time it reminds me of AOS. THANK YOU AGAIN TO ALCHEMY OF SOULS PRODUCTION TEAM!Was this review helpful to you?
LEGIT SOLID 10/10
OKAYYY!!! this drama is legit SOOOO good. i love season 2 more than season 1 mainly bc i enjoyed the tension between ml and fl. also ml's reaction when he finds out who she actually is was so good. overall casting is 10/10 my first drama of go youn jung and i seriously loved her acting in this drama and it even led me to watch other dramas with her. i already rewatched this TWICE. this drama is so deserving of getting raved i understand all the hype going on alright! anyways the outfits were so pretty and ost was good too! MY FAVOURITE KDRAMA EVER!!!Was this review helpful to you?
um amor para além da carne: um amor de almas.
essa é uma história que vai além dos romances tradicionais. a segunda temporada aprofundou muito a personalidade do protagonista masculino, e de maneira geral foi melhor que a primeira. é impressionante também como a Naksu modifica sua atuação antes/depois dela descobrir quem ela é.Para aqueles resistentes em assistir esse drama devido a mudança da atriz, digo uma coisa: Naksu na primeira temporada estava em um corpo que não era dela. nesta temporada, ela agora está em um corpo que tem sua aparência. fico feliz até, pois ela merece se sentir bem dentro do corpo que está.
claro, Jang Uk um perfeito apaixonado: consegue amar repetidamente a mesma mulher, independente de sua aparência ou de mudanças de personalidade.
de fato, um amor para além da carne um amor dr almas.
Was this review helpful to you?
Lee Jae Wook & Go Youn Jung has a great chemistry.
I liked it. But my biggest complaint is they should've shown Jang Uk & Jin Bu Yeon more screen time in the last few minutes. I wanted more stories about them in the end & also how they cured Jin Bu Yeon getting wild.At first, I thought they'd not show flashbacks of Mu Doek with Jang Uk whenever he was heartbroken or missing him. Thank God they started showing Mu Deok flashbacks from Season 1.
Jang Uk is a lot more mature this season he still has humor, but also has arrogance, which is for those who deserve it. He has a lot of grief, hate & rage within himself. His looks changed this season. He wears black & has short hair. He looks smoking hot. I just loved seeing him using power & going into killer mode.
Jang Uk never forgot about Mu Deok. He always remembered her. In a review someone said that he forgot about her & quickly fell in love with Jin Bu Yeon but that’s not true. Firstly, it’s a 10-episode series. They need to show his heartbreak as well as falling for her in a short period of time. Maybe that is why people think he forgot about her & fell in love quickly.
Jin Bu Yeon is changed because you need to remember that she was captivated in a room for 3 years. She is bound to be depressed & thinks that no one loves her, which may lead to her change. If she also starts acting the same way the FL of S1 did, then you will all be blaming her for copying. I think it was refreshing. She didn't try to do the same thing which the S1 FL did. I liked how the memory loss part when so long. It would've been better if she remembered evrything in the first few episodes.
The horrible faces of Jang Uk, Park Dang Gu & Seo Yul after tasting Park Jin’s cooking. Please someone stop this man from cooking. The boys are suffering.
The sudden hug Jin Bu Yeon gave to Jang Uk.
Jang Uk’s reaction after hearing Jin Bu Yeon saying that she is pregnant.
It's sweet how Jang Uk was following Jin Bu Yeon in the middle of the night without her knowledge.
The way Jin Bu Yeon ate all the honey biscuits at once due to being jealous of Mu Deok. Jang Uk is also jealous of Jin Bin Yeon love for someone.
History repeats itself of not being able to climb the bridge. 🤣🤣
Laughed when Park Jin is jealous of Jang Uk because he is always the first priority of Maidservant Kim.
Loved it when Jang Uk said that “Not a single person will be able to walk out of here alive”. Uff The way he killed everyone, made everyone fear him.
I think I'm the only one who didn't like Crown Price. He is a kind-hearted person but foolish. He got easily manipulated by Jin Mu. He is someone craving power, but in the end, he realizes that he is wrong.
Jang Uk, Jin Bu Yeon & Crown Price turtle story. 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
Love Master Lee. How he always helps Jang Uk & Jin Bu Yeon.
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
ONLY A SHADOW OF S1
I really tried to give this season a fair chance. I came into it with no expectations, yet it still failed to keep me interested in so many ways.First of all, while I understand the soul-shifting concept, I still think replacing the main FL (JSM) with GYJ was a huge mistake. I know GYJ is technically the real Naksu from the beginning of Season 1, and I understand what the writers were trying to do. What I don't understand is how Bu Yeon's body suddenly transformed into Naksu's physical appearance. Throughout the series, soul shifters retained the appearance of the body they inhabited. That was one of the established rules. Then suddenly, for this season, the body itself changes to match the soul? Even for a fantasy drama, that was a stretch beyond a stretch. Soul shifting was already confusing enough from a viewer's perspective, but now we're adding body transformation into the mix? It just made the whole explanation even harder to accept.
What disappointed me the most, however, was the chemistry. Everyone kept talking about how amazing it was, but... where exactly? I genuinely could not feel it. No offense to GYJ, but her performance felt too restrained for my taste. She came across as emotionally detached, making it difficult for me to connect with her character. Every time she was on screen, I found myself more confused than she was supposed to be. 😭
It genuinely felt like ten years had passed between Season 1 and Season 2. I watched Season 1 and immediately started Season 2, yet I still felt so disconnected from the story. Everything suddenly felt unfamiliar and confusing. The warmth, humor, lively cast dynamics, and emotional spark that made me fall in love with Season 1 were gone, replaced by a much gloomier tone. I understand that the title is Light and Shadow, but for me, all I could see was the shadow. It honestly felt like I was watching an entirely different drama.
I am very picky about the dramas I watch. I look for emotional value, engaging characters, and a story that hooks me from the very first episode. Season 1 did exactly that. It immediately pulled me in and never let go. Unfortunately, Season 2 failed to capture that same magic.
Of course, I understand that many viewers loved this season, and I completely respect that. This is simply my personal experience. Because Season 1 set such a high standard, I could not help but compare the two, and for me, Season 2 fell short in almost every aspect. Hence, I dropped it.
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
The best kdrama of all time
This drama is exciting and little bet confuse all the time the actor and actress portrayed very well.I like the music because the singer give her best and very emotional of deliberation ....
The Gendre has full of mystery but the writer has a bright idea to deliver easy to the viewer....
Watch this drama you will never be disappointed the plot is good and the editing skill is good.
AOS IS VERY UNIQUE DRAMA THAT IVE SEEN SO MUCH EFFORT...
Just watch and enjoy
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
SO SO GOOD. I can't get over it.
This is my first time writing a review, and I know I'm kinda late, but I just had to write one. Before watching S2, I saw a lot of people comment about how much they disliked it. I also thought S2 would be bad because I found out the actress of the FL changed. Obviously I was biased about S1 at the time but I decided to watch S2 just out of loyalty for AOS.I gotta say I had little to no expectations for S2 but watching it completely changed my mind. Maybe it's because I'm a romance girlie at heart but in my opinion I like it way better than S1. In S1, it introduced the world of AOS focusing on more of the character development and world building, but this season tied everything together, focusing more on the romance between Jang Uk and Cho Yeong/Naksu.I know people were not happy about the change of the FL, but it makes sense as in the start of S1, GYJ originally acted as Naksu. I've also seen others complain about how they didn't like this season as Naksu's personality completely changed due to the amnesia element. But in my opinion, what we saw was the true side of Cho Yeong, the girl she would've been if she weren't trained to be Naksu. We have to keep in mind that she was only guarded like that because she was trained to be. I like how this was 10 episodes (although it would've been nice if it was longer) because it was more fast paced and I also like how we got to see a different side of Jang Uk. All the heartbreak just made it better. Or maybe it's just because I love angst.
This drama was DEFINITELY worth watching, and it's so good that I'm rewatching it. If you're hesitant about watching it, you guys have to give it a go.
Was this review helpful to you?
Great but missing our cold blooded assassin Naksu.
When I first started watching season 2 I tried super hard to make myself like it since I was a big fan of Mu Deok. I find it difficult to adapt to Naksu's new character + the new actress. Naksu was a completely different person at the start of s2. One thing is for sure, they dragged the amnesia plot for far too long and they filled it up with wattpad level romance. So you ask why my rating is still so high. I liked s1 so much, and I just wanted everything to be wrapped up well in s2, and it was wrapped up well. I also have a lot of love for all the characters like Park Jin, Kim Do Ju, Master Lee, Dang Gu, Crown prince and Cho Yeon too. So I got my well wrapped happy ending.It is however disappointing that there are no more Naksu fight scenes or even her being 'cool'.
Was this review helpful to you?
O que mais me vidrou nesse dorama é que ele consegue tá prender rapidamente na história.
Um dorama muito bom e muito bem feito em todos os sentidos, te faz sofrer juntos com os personagens e no final seu coração fica quentinho, recomendo esse dorama.Você pensa que vai dar tudo errado e dá e depois não dá mais fica tudo bem, o que mais me prendeu era saber o que ia acontecer com o Jang Uk com a pedra de gelo, o que o Jin Mu ia fazer pra ficar no poder e quando iam descobrir a patifaria que ele tava fazendo, e se a Bu-yeon ia expulsar a Naksu do corpo dela.
Você não sabe quem é o vilão e quem não é, a história tem um plot muito bom e o Jin Mu parece imortal, não posso falar mais se não vou contar toda a história.
Was this review helpful to you?
I loved it
Kept me on edge. I loved the ending it was worth waiting for and watching. Thank you and well done :) xxxKept me on edge. I loved the ending it was worth waiting for and watching. Thank you and well done :) xxx
Kept me on edge. I loved the ending it was worth waiting for and watching. Thank you and well done :) xxx
Kept me on edge. I loved the ending it was worth waiting for and watching. Thank you and well done :) xxx
Kept me on edge. I loved the ending it was worth waiting for and watching. Thank you and well done :) xxx
Kept me on edge. I loved the ending it was worth waiting for and watching. Thank you and well done :) xxx
Was this review helpful to you?



