Very controversial review ..
Ok so, this review will be very controversial… I didn’t """love """" this K-drama.It was good, I cried during the first episodes, but I struggled to finish it… When they grow old and have children, everything fell apart for me. I found it repetitive — always the same struggles, whining and crying… and now they are even suffering because of their child.
I rushed through the end just to finish it… I’m really sad I wasn’t more into it.
But of course, you should watch it to make your own opinion!
Was this review helpful to you?
a love letter
No words, I have no words…I probably cried well over 17 times. And I don’t talk about tearing up, I mean bawling my eyes out. The only reason I put off watching each episode is because I feared it would wreck me (which it did). It’s tiring to cry you know.
Each episode had at least this one line that just felt like a total gut punch. On top of the music, the
cinematography, and the actors’ stunning
performances. These few words just made me ugly cry. There are few shows and movies out there
that are this well-written, it makes it all feel so
real, and it is in so many way. A one in a lifetime kind of drama.
This feels like a love letter to all women,
mothers and daughters, and just families. So many times it had me saying yes yes yes. I wish I had written down some of the lines that struck hard, but I was too emerald to think of that. I guess I’ll have to rewatch. *sigh*
I can’t find a single flaw in this drama even if a
wanted to and I’m a real nitpicker.
Ae Sun in my heart forever <3
Was this review helpful to you?
What stands out most is the message — that kindness, courage, and love still matter even in a complicated world. The cast brings warmth and depth to every moment. The chemistry between characters feels effortless, and their interactions often made me smile without realizing it.
The cinematography and background music create a soft, immersive atmosphere that calms you down while keeping you emotionally engaged. It’s one of those shows you can watch after a long day and instantly feel better.
By the end, I didn’t just enjoy the story — I felt comforted, inspired, and strangely peaceful. It’s rare to find something that feels this genuine. This drama is a gentle reminder that sometimes, simple stories can touch us the deepest.
Was this review helpful to you?
Beautiful, Deep, but Not Something I’d Rewatch
When Life Gives You Tangerines is honestly a really good drama—deep, meaningful, and emotionally rich.As a slice-of-life story, it focuses on everyday experiences and personal growth, which makes it feel very real and relatable. The writing is strong, and you can tell that a lot of thought was put into delivering a meaningful story.
However, some parts felt quite slow and even boring to me. In fact, I actually dropped the drama at one point and only continued it again after a few months. That alone says a lot about how the pacing didn’t fully keep me engaged.
Surprisingly, I didn’t find it as sad as I expected. Even though many people describe it as emotional, I personally didn’t cry while watching it. The story is touching, but it didn’t hit me that deeply on an emotional level.
Overall, I still think this is a great drama, which is why I’d give it a 9/10. But at the same time, it’s not something I truly enjoyed watching throughout, and it’s probably not a drama I would rewatch.
Was this review helpful to you?
When Life Gives You Tangerines invites the viewer to slow down and reflect on life, change and love across time. Some questions to keep in mind while watching:
How do Ae-sun and Gwan-sik change not just because of each other, but because of the world around them?
How does the Jeju setting influence their identity, dreams and decisions?
Does the series successfully balance romantic narrative with the broader socio-historical backdrop?
Was this review helpful to you?
A MUST WATCH MASTERPIECE
This is by far the best drama I have ever seen in my whole life, EVERYTHING and I mean EVERYTHING is done perfectly. They give you story, they give you music, they make you cry, laugh, fall in love, get angry, get frustrated. You can almost feel like you are living through them and the acting, don’t get me started on that one. Every one of them is such an amazing actor and actress, you genuinely forget you are watching something that it’s not real because it feels so warming, so genuine. Absolutely incredible job to everyone here, I have seen it 3 times and have cried on each as if it’s the first time, you never regret watching it again and discovering new things ♥️Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
Drama of the Decade - an Evergreen Masterpiece
I have never been a fan of practical dramas, ones that portray raw emotions, real life hardships and just reality at its harshest. I was always of the opinion that entertainment was an escape so seeing characters suffer didn't help. But this drama changed my outlook on life completely. I know a drama cannot mature a person but this did. When life gives you tangerines, God, will there be another as beautifully heartwrenching as this?A drama where no one is a villain, just life itself. The iron heart Yang Gwansik and the resilient Oh Aesun, navigating the sea of life, keeping on swimming. They shall forever live in my heart till the end. Each character had their own story. And everything woven together into this masterpiece, it was nothing less than perfect. The plot is so crisp and one can never get the feeling of the drama being dragged for long. Not even once. The way they divided the drama into 4 sections, man that was genius.
The casting is on another level. IU literally deserves an Oscar for this. The variety of roles - teenage Oh Aesun, Oh Aesun in her twenties into thirties, teen Yang Geummyeong and adult Geummyeong...that is a lot of to be and do. But the difference between her as Aesun and Geummyeong is so obvious, we don't feel it's the same person, just a daughter with her mother's face. When she cries, we cry, when she smiles, we smile. A truly outstanding actress! And then there is Park Bogum. Do we even need another example of eyes that speak? Park Bogum has that skill to make you wonder if he is actually alright because he becomes the character to an extent where it blurs reality and fiction. Every emotion is portrayed soooo well, one cannot deny the fact that he's a maestro at what he does. The character of Yang Gwansik itself is so well written, Park Bogum does not let him down. Then there are the other favourites of mine - Choi Daehoon as Bu Sanggil, Moon Sori as old Aesun, Park Haejoon as old Yang Gwansik, Yeom Hyeran as Aesun's mother, Kang Youseok as Yang Eunmyeong - they are literally people I know, that's how close I feel to all of them. Really really amazing.
The music is just beautiful. Starting from the intro to the instrument in the last scene of the last episode, nothing beats this layout.
Everything is just so good, yet I cannot express them in better words 😭 It's more like something the heart understands beyond human language. This drama taught me two main things I'd say. One - your parents would literally break their back just to give you the best they can and two - time as a human is very short. So living your best life and not waiting for the perfect moment is the best we can do. Also two lines really stuck with me. 1) "One day life might get so tough that you feel like you can't go on. Don't lie still. Struggle with all your might...Tell yourself you won't die and must survive, no matter what. Paddle your arms and legs like crazy. You'll get through the dark waters and see the sky." Oh Aesun's mother to her- 2) "There might have been nights I went to sleep hungry. But there was never a night that I was alone."- Oh Aesun about Yang Gwansik.
How can a drama be this good yet this heartbreaking; I just cannot make sense. Yet I feel if our stories were a series, won't we see the rawness of pain and sweetness of happiness in it too? Also, Alec Benjamin's 'If we have each other' is a song I will forever associate this drama, the lines about the lovers (iykyk). Rewatch if you want to rip your heart out again and again 😭 Evrything is just Uhhh!!! Crazy in the best way. This drama truly deserves the hype and it is a MUST WATCH, no matter what your preferred genre is. Thank you Baek Sangchoon for writing this great story and thank you Kim Wonseok and all the cast and crew members for breathing in life to it! 🌊🌼❤️
Was this review helpful to you?
Simple yet Epic
Other (awesome) reviews on this site have gone into great detail. I’ll be brief:This show depicts the extraordinariness of the ordinary.
Across multiple generations, these characters live normal, simple lives, that are (of course) anything but simple, or ordinary.
So beautiful. So real. So painful. So full of joy.
I love everything about this.
—————————————————
That is where I wanted my review to end, so you can stop reading now. However, I have to hit 500 characters, so let me just praise IU by saying I’ve loved her in everything I’ve seen her in.
My Mister and now When Life Gives You Tangerines are both on my list of most loved, most moving, most thought-provoking K-dramas of ALL TIME.
Was this review helpful to you?
Brilliant! Nothing but brilliant.
From the production to the acting, the storytelling, and the soundtrack—every aspect of When Life Gives You Tangerines is breathtaking. The cinematography is visually stunning, capturing every emotion with precision, while the music weaves seamlessly into the narrative, elevating every moment.The casting is nothing short of perfect. Each actor embodies their character so naturally that it’s impossible to imagine anyone else in their roles. Their chemistry is undeniable, making every interaction feel raw and authentic. Whether it's the heart-wrenching emotional moments or the lighthearted, charming scenes, the cast delivers with absolute brilliance.
The story itself is a beautifully crafted rollercoaster of emotions—one that made me laugh, cry, and reflect long after the credits rolled. It’s rare for a show to strike such a perfect balance between emotional depth and entertainment, but this one does it effortlessly.
A must-watch, without a doubt. If you're looking for something that will move you, challenge you, and stay with you long after it's over, this is it.
Was this review helpful to you?
When Life Gives You TEARS
This drama is a MASTERPIECE! The actors, the plot, storyline, everything! This drama didn't just make me cry- it absolutely WRECKED me. But this drama is just so beautiful, the love they had for each other, the hardships they went through.IU and Park Bo-gum didn't act their roles; they became them. Their acting was amazing, the fact that you could feel and see how genuine their emotions were. It felt too real.
This drama was soul crushing in the most beautiful way.
DEFINITELY WATCH THIS RN!
Was this review helpful to you?
Truly a love letter to the older generation
When Life Gives You Tangerine surprised me with its powerful depiction of 1960s in South Korea, a reality that mirrors what many Asian cultures have experienced. The struggles of women of that time, the weight of traditions favoring men, the hardships of balancing dreams with harsh realities, and the importance of community.Ae-sun’s story echoes the lives of many women in her generation, my grandmother’s generation, maybe even yours. The drama powerfully explores how generational trauma and inherited dreams shape families, particularly mother-daughter relationships. Gwang-rye, pushed Ae-sun to escape her own fate. Ae-sun, in turn, worked tirelessly to give Geum-myeong a different life. Yet Geum-myeong’s resentment reveals how well-meaning sacrifices can sometimes create unintended consequences. Poverty and unfulfilled dreams hardened her, making her sharp-tongued, cynical, and distant. Even when her heart longed to show affection, her attempts to express gratitude often emerged as frustration and barbs. Meanwhile, Ae-sun’s focus on her daughter’s future left her brother feeling overlooked, as if he were an afterthought.
But what struck me most was how Ae-sun’s and Geum-myeong’s love lives mirrored each other, like a parallel, both faced difficult choices between love and self-preservation. Yet Geum-myeong, after witnessing her mother’s struggles firsthand, ultimately rejected her mother’s path. Just like how Ae-sun rejected her own mother’s path. Because that's how they were raised, to not walk the same path as their mother.
"I love my mom, but I don't want to live like her." "She gave everything for me, but at what cost?" "I don't want to tolerate what she did."
These are thoughts many daughters quietly wrestle with, loving their mothers yet fearing they may repeat their struggles. But to Gwang-rye and Ae-sun, their sacrifices were worth it. Some women surrender to fate and quietly plant trees whose shade they know they will never sit under, yet their efforts pave the way for their future generations to thrive. Ae-sun may have accepted her fate, but her determination ensured Geum-myeong could choose her own path. For that parallel, I commend the production team and writer for making IU play both Ae-sun and Geum-myeong. I must give it to the writer, every single character is so well crafted. Everyone played their role well, but IU's performance as Ae-sun truly defined the show. IU goes above and beyond, bringing such depth to Ae-sun’s character that her burdens, loneliness, poverty, and determination felt palpable through the screen. Special mention goes to Yeom Hye-ran for her short yet scene-stealing performances.
This is a powerful and deeply emotional story about love, loss, and RESILIENCE. And that’s what stayed with me most: even when life feels unbearable, and though you don't know how, somehow... life goes on.
And to anyone reading this...whoever, whenever, and wherever you are...you have done well.
Highly recommended.
Was this review helpful to you?
A Drama With a Strong Pulse on Life
This drama encapsulates life in a way that is so attentive and personal that it almost fills you with dread from the introspection you're forced to engage in. It is a beautiful and very necessary ode to women at all levels of society. This drama embodies and even breathes new energy into the slice-of-life genre by intricately weaving through the life of a small-town couple in a way that seems straightforward, almost aimless, but is, in fact, very precise.The acting is phenomenal, as expected from such a cast. I'm pleasantly surprised that I'm not jarred by the use of IU for both mother and daughter; her clear distinction makes for an enjoyable and even technically impressive viewing experience. Park Bo Gum excels as usual, showing a side I've not seen before. The acting is really the driving force for the tsunami of emotions this project explodes with.
The writing is so worthy of praise and mention, especially contrasted with the current drama landscape. I can only describe it as beautiful and incredibly penetrating. To be so true to life's nuances without convolution or rudimentary language is a feat. There are so many aspects of life so accurately depicted and given life through words that it's almost unsettling, yet ultimately moving. A standout drama through and through.
Was this review helpful to you?
