This review may contain spoilers
A nice adaptation but could be better ??
✨ Spoiler Alert ✨As someone who absolutely loves the Japanese adaptation, I could not help myself by comparing every nanosecond of the Thai adaptation to the Japanese one because for me the Japanese version is pure perfection. While it is unfair for them that I am comparing the two adaptations, I know they mostly based the series from the manga which is the original source and I kept trying to remind myself that while watching this series because some elements and decision makings in the Thai version I am not that fond off that the Japanese adaptation did better. 💁♂️
Let's start with what I like: 🙃
GMMTV choosing Tay and New as the pairing for this version and for me that's probably the smartest because the pairing has the this kind of faces that just suitable for office set up/environment (and if not them, the second pairing I can see is Jimmysea but that's just me). New's acting here is not his best acting to be honest but he did a really good job portraying Achi's clueless and innocent expression and Tay as Karan is where I am a bit confused with because Tay looked like he held back a lot from doing so much more but that is probably just me because I knew what Tay is capable off.
The adding of the much more side characters (the boss and the female manager(?) really bring the office environment much more livelier than the Japanese version and I appreciate that even though the characters are not necessary at all for plot in my opinion.
The casting of Junior and Mark as the second couple. this for me is probably my favourite part of the whole series because I have mixed feeling of the casting they did for the second couple for the JPN version. their chemistry is really nice to see as a couple and not realizing it, I mostly stay for them instead of the main couple.
Let's move on to the what I dislike: 😔
One main problem of this series is the pacing, watching it, I did not expect them to cram the plot where Achi had to go to another department and Achi and Karan getting married because the JPN production made a whole movie for that. This is a problem because for some reason Achi's character development in this version is much more tone down for my liking. this is just a miss opportunity because they didn't need to cram the whole plot in 12 episodes that some characters' growth are cut short. The pacing was really nice until episode 7 I believe where every drama and climax got thrown at the same time.
talking about cramming, I HATE the choices to make Rock and Pai a thing because in the JPN version Fujisaki(which is JPN version of Pai) decided to be single because that is what best for her and that idea alone is such a fresh air in this story where everyone ended up with someone. one thing about gmmtv I don't like is they keep making having a partner is the end off all thing, which is stupid. This whole subplot of Rock and Pai is just so unnecessary personally because they could have spend those time improving Achi's growth as a person instead
one finale little thing is how Karan(Tay) somehow got overshadow a lot in this series by other characters, maybe it is a me problem but I just can't get involved with his as a character which is weird because he's there for like every second of the series.
Personally, I prefer the JPN version and if you never watch it, I highly recommend it BUT this version also is nice even though there are a lot of improvement that could've been made which is a bummer because this is like first TayNew BL series in three years I believe since Dark Blue Kiss. my final say is it is a cute adaptation and they did a fine job with what was given (the time limit, the script, and stuff). would I recommend, sure if you are curious, watch it but if you are someone like me who adores the JPN version, do not expect much. 👔🐳
Was this review helpful to you?
I didn't have faith in TayNew and I was wrong to doubt them
A soft charming warm hug of a show about crushes and mind reading and self worth that really worked for me. With no-fuss execution from a consummate team and an OG lead pair (proving why they remain eternal and deserve to grow up).Look, here’s the thing, Cherry Magic is a great Thai BL in its own right - not comparing it to any other iteration. But even when I do compare (and I've seen all the Cherries and read the manga) it stands strong.
I, personally, like the Thai BL slightly better than the Japanese live action yaoi, but I think that’s because I just really enjoy Thai BL's style and I LOVE TayNew (who may be my favorite OG branded pair still in operation). Also all the kissing was both present and better in this version. As it should be from Thailand.
Highly recommended.
Was this review helpful to you?
TAYNEW IN A PERFECT ADAPTATION
This series is really cute. Super comfort and sweet❤️ I loved everything about it and it has definitely become one of my favorite thai shows!I didn’t have high expectations, but I was wrong, it’s really a good adaptation of the manga and the japanese version. Personally, I like this one more than the japanese one, that I found cute but nothing more. Karan and Achi will always be in my heart❤️their relationship is so sweet and cute and Karan is really a green flag, I couldn’t stop smiling the whole time.
It's also a really funny series, as well as sweet, and it's really worth watching!
AND I LOVE TAYNEW SO MUCH, I fell in love with them with this series. Thank you, Cherry Magic.
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
Such a Cute & Comfortable BL Series
I think that everyone knows Cherry Magic from Japan because of how popular it was. Recently, I knew about the Thailand adaptation and it was portrayed by the popular BL couple, Tay & New.Since I already knew and watched the original series for a multiple times already, I know the things I need to expect and the standard that must be met. Watching this Thailand adaptation made me feel good. They met and exceeded the standard of Cherry Magic that I set. In the story, there were some alterations, and I felt like this adaptation is more light than the Japanese adaptation. Both Tay and New are great portrayers of the main characters. Frankly, there were moments wherein I felt like they became monotonous on their acting, but regardless, did a great job. Junior and Mark also did great as the second characters of this film. Their own story added an extra flavor to the whole series. Jang and Sing's story as a couple is also good and added an extra juice to the plot of this series.
In totality, the Thailand adaptation of Cherry Magic was satisfying. Yes, no one can beat the Japanese adaptation because the chemistry of the main characters there was extraordinary, but this adaptation served what they need to serve and did their best in their own accordance.
Was this review helpful to you?
LOVE THIS BUT NOT OBSESSED! (Unlike JDrama version)
I'm obsessed with JDrama live action version.LOVE THIS BUT NOT OBSESSED!
Maybe that's bcz I watched JD live actn first, Anime next n then this.
For me, JD live actn had set up a high mark for KuroAda's story already n so makes me to compare any other adaptations with it as a reference.
I'm a FAN of TAY n NEW individually or as a couple n watch almost every work of them, even when they do a cameo :)
But somehow I DIDN'T FIND THE SPARK of Kurosawa's story in this.
To be honest, sometimes I get a vibe that this is a different BL, not KuroAda's magical story :|
n so I treat this as a separate work n then LOVED it, haha
One thing I LOVE about this is, it introduced me to the wonderful actor, JUNIOR :)
He SLAYED character JINTA (Tsuge's counterpart)
While Tsuge didn't impress me at all in JD live actn.
I loved Junior - Mark couple more than its JDrama counterpart :)
DON'T MISS TO WATCH THIS, it covers the scenes which are not adapted in JD live action and U FIND THOSE LOVELY!! :)
Whatever JD live action n Thai versions didn't cover, Anime covered.
Currently reading the Ongoing Manga, found that JD live action drama, Anime and Thai version TOGETHER covered everything from the manga.
Was this review helpful to you?
I was pushing this one away and I regret it.
Alright, this was soooo good, but really different than I expected. I was afraid it was gonna be to sexual, due to the title of this series. But it really wasn't. The whole thing was super cozy and cute, I really like how sweet their relationship was and how caring they were over each other, I don't really like how rushed everything became at the ending but that's alright, it's just a series anyways. I'd definitely recommend this and I personally regret waiting to watch this one!Originally I didn't think I would enjoy the concept but the power was not as cringy as I expected, and they also didn't make the power thing look low budget, what a lot of 'power' bl's do have.
Was this review helpful to you?
very heartwarming
I loved the Japanese drama and immediately wanted to watch the Thai version too. I love how it stays true to the original story in many ways while also putting it's own spin on it, and framing it from a Thai cultural point of view. It even pays homage to its Japanese routes in many cute ways.There are some useless additional plots that are skippable in my opinion, it feels like they were just added as filler. I also didn't love Pai anywhere near as much as Fujisaki because she was just a creepy BL fan stand-in half the time instead of a real person within the universe. When she was just herself she was fine though.
The main and secondary couple are both adorable and the final episode was especially sweet. I also loved the friendships between all the office workers, there were so many cute friendship moments which I really appreciated. Highly recommend if you like wholesome, fluffy romances with happy endings.
Was this review helpful to you?
Not bad but too stretchy
I have to admit two things.First: I have yet to find a re-adaptation from another country that is better than the first adaptation of any source material be it a mange web toon ... Etc. especially if the first adaptation is done pretty well.
Second: I love Cherry magic Jap. ver. So freaking much and I only watched this ver. Because I love the cast and I saw many good reviews but tbh I know for sure it won't raise to the bar of the original but I'll not hold this against it by any means.
So long story short, despite knowing that it's lacking as a re-adaptation, I'll try to judge it as a drama by itself without comparing it to the original.
Now like most Thai dramas, the main problem I have with them is that they drag at the end, and this one is no exception, I enjoyed till about ep7... Maybe 8... Let's say 9 to be fair, but the last 3 ep were completely unnecessary for me, I was skipping a lot, and not because it's bad or anything, but the story got boring I loved some scenes but they weren't enough to entertain me for the last 3 eps. The only reason that kept me going was PaiRock and if the only reason I continue watching a BL is the straight couple in it, then something is wrong 😂
The main couple are gorgeous, I loved them together.. TayNew never disappoint, Jan and Sing were adorable too and I love Jan so much that I wanted to see her more and more here, Song's character Rock is also fun to watch, but sadly the second couple were too lame, I didn't like Jintha, not because of anything but I couldn't see why he fell in love with Min Like, what happened you blink and they are together, with no reason at all, also I didn't think he was "cute" or adorable with his nervous introverted personality. Also Mark did his best and I love him for that but by no means he fits the character IMO.
Now I like this drama generally and I loved TayNew ver. Of the characters but I wish it was a little shorter.
But to be completely honest, if I ever needed to suggest Cherry magic, I'd definitely go for the Japanese ver. Not this one.
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
O Poder de Decifrar o Amor
Um "sopro de ar fresco" define esta obra. Em um gênero marcado por toxicidade, o enredo foi subvertido de forma madura e respeitosa, detalhes que se refletem na relação de Achi e Karan. Aqui a magia não é utilizada não como um truque barato, mas como uma ferramenta sensível que explora as inseguranças reais, o medo da rejeição e a ansiedade social. A delicadeza em utilizar o poder para entender os sentimentos do parceiro, em vez de explorá-lo negativamente, é fantástica. Apesar de não sentir aquele "algo a mais" cinematográfico que me fizesse pausar a cena para admirar, a história foi quase que terapêutica; me fez refletir sobre a coragem necessária para ser vulnerável.Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
Most feel good BL so far. Lol
Mygosh, coming from DBK, Tay here is totally flippin 180 degree change from Pete. Lol. Karan is basically the epitome of greenest amazon forest. Lol. And Tay and New’s acting matured so much compared to DBK era for me, especially Tay’s (even though i think my bias is New. I can tell you this). Karan is such a green flag, nothing about him irks me at all. New is adorbs (how is that guy’s skin so fairrrrrr like howww. And having him in such a close up distance with Tay made that even more obvious).The plot is well thought out and well executed imo. Sometimes, i have problem with certain BL’s plot (like they just want to promote BL that the plot doesnt matter much to them sometimes. The comedy factor rings well with me, i found myself laughing out loud at them. Achi’s monologue while listening in to other people’s mind, esp Karan’s in the beginning totally had me LoL High rewatch value what with all the whumps scenes and Achi’s fainting left and right (i legitly thought they would do us a flip and had that guy be down with terminal illness or something what with how many times he faints lol. Luckily they end it with HE instead of going down the sadist route. Other couples’ story were also interesting enough not to make me annoyed with too much screentime given to them. Pai and Rock’s relationship is a good heterocouple representation.
OSTs are fine (is the last song at the wedding a solo OST from New?) All in all, i am soooo looking forward to watching more of TayNew after watching this.
Was this review helpful to you?
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
Everyone's chemistry all are so good!
I love all TayNew series, but this is soooo much better than DBK. Dont get me wrong i love dbk, still re-watching it. But a series with so much understanding with each other, No unnecessary drama just.. *chefkiss*. It's a love story that we all can relate in real life. Having a crush, and how excited we'll be if that person is so close to us. Eyeing our crush in the office bcoz we find her/him so cute! lol. There's no outrageous scene we can't relate... Well except their first date probably. lol.And TayNew's acting improved so much! TayNew worked their butt off for the last 2 years for their own solo development really paid off!
Juju, Min, Jan and Ssing all are great. JanSsing is so cute! Their chemistry also on point! The boss, P'Duj. Gosh everyone is so good!
Kudos to their original author, Toyota Sensei for creating such a lovely story <3
Kudos to P'X, for making this happen for TayNew and Polca.
Kudos to all cast and crew for working so hard for this series.
I know, this is not everyone's cup of tea. It's okay. You can try watching it with open mind, and if it's still bad for you it's okay, leave it. No need to spread hate :) thank you.
Was this review helpful to you?
