Amazing story
I've seen numerous thriller K-dramas, but this one stands out due to its exceptional acting and emotional balance. Each episode offers a thrilling mix of suspense, humor, and witty dialogueThe supporting cast delivers remarkably realistic performances, immersing viewers in the scenes. The drama masterfully captures the emotions of both the criminal and the supporting characters. The lead actors' performances are outstanding. The first two episodes will leave you wanting more, and by the end of the third, you'll be completely captivated by the story.
The music complements the story perfectly, and the subtle use of background music enhances the viewing experience.
This drama is a must-watch for fans of thrilling K-dramas. It reminds me of my favorite, "The Glory," and I appreciate the slow, organic development of the romantic relationship between the leads.
Was this review helpful to you?
Great drama exellent story outstanding acting so far greatly recommended.
This is one of the best k drama so far I have watched. The writing of the story is really good. It is not typical romantic drama. It also have a bit of humor touch. It is also emotional and have good editing and VFX. The acting is awesome. I hope that end it good. All I can say now is don't read the reviews just "wattttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttchittttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttt "
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
AN INSANE KDRAMA but
Here's my rant about *The Judge From Hell* since EVERYONE seems to love it:- Why didn’t Mando just say that Arong asked him to keep an eye on Bitna’s outbursts and not just hint that “maybe she’ll betray us”?
- How is it that the place where Bitna was murdered can be rented so easily? Or is it because it’s in an amusement park that nobody heard anything?
- Where was the cleaning staff when Bitna got caught by Daon?
- If Justitia dies or turns human, then who’s going to be the judge in hell?
- If demons age, does that mean there’s a “before” and “after” version of them?
- Are Justitia, Gremory, and Paimon titles or names? Like, if one of them is missing or dead, who takes over their job?
- How does Bael know about Bitna’s verdict but somehow doesn’t know which demons have turned “human” (i.e., developed emotions)?
- HOW DID DAON EVEN FIND THE PLACE WHERE BITNA GOT STABBED?!
IF YOU WANT TO FREE PEOPLE FROM "POVERTY," YOU SHOULD GO AFTER ACTUAL POOR PEOPLE WHO MIGHT PREFER TO BE DEAD RATHER THAN ALIVE! (Take *ML Death’s Game* or *The 8 Show* as an example—they would definitely choose death over having to live another day!!) BECAUSE SERIOUSLY, YOU KILLED A BUNCH OF MIDDLE-CLASS PEOPLE?! (Daon’s family even has a house, and the single parent lady is literally having an apartments!)
Honestly, the whole storyline with the detective and killer is not well thought out.
*The sudden change in tension between Daon and Donghoon feels weird and rushed.
*HOW CAN A DETECTIVE RELY ON A JOURNALIST?!
*All the detective ever does is wait for results!
Was this review helpful to you?
Killer story, but the ending was just okay.
Things I liked: the cast was wonderful, the storyline was fresh and exciting, the music was hauntingly beautiful and thriller/supernatural element was awesome.Things I didn't love: the romance subplot. Honestly, I would've preferred the drama without romance between the main leads—they really didn't have the best chemistry and the story was so much stronger without it!! I normally am the first person to uplift a romcom (or action/thriller/romcom in this case) but I could not get myself to enjoy that part. Maybe that's just me.
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
Hell to Earth, Good and Evil - you choose! Should you skip? Watch Now? Watch Later?
Park Shin-hye's Devilish TransformationThe Judge From Hell offers a unique blend of fantasy, mystery, and thriller, setting itself apart from the usual Korean drama fare. The premise is intriguing: a demon, sentenced to a mortal punishment, takes on the role of a judge to mete out justice to ten sinners. This unconventional plot, coupled with Park Shin-hye's fierce portrayal of the devilish judge, makes for a compelling watch.
A Clash of Good and Evil
The drama effectively explores the eternal battle between good and evil, albeit in a somewhat clichéd manner. However, the seamless integration of heavenly and hellish elements, including the granting of wishes and the execution of punishments, adds a element to the narrative.
A Stellar Performance of FL, A Flawed ML character, Fun Supporting Cast
Park Shin-hye delivers a standout performance, breathing life into the character of the vengeful demon. Her transformation into a badass, vicious judge is both captivating and refreshing. Unfortunately, the male lead, while competent, lacks the depth and charisma to truly shine. The supporting cast, however, adds a much-needed dose of humor and intrigue, elevating the overall viewing experience.
A Missed Opportunity for a Powerful Showdown
One of the biggest disappointments lies in the underutilized character of Satan. Despite being a pivotal figure, the character's power and influence feel somewhat diminished. The anticipated climactic showdown between the demon judge and Satan falls flat, lacking the intensity and grandeur that such a confrontation deserves.
A Forced Romance
The inclusion of a romantic subplot, while not entirely detrimental, feels unnecessary and forced. The budding romance between the demon judge and the male lead distracts from the core narrative and hinders the development of more meaningful relationships, such as the camaraderie between the judge and her celestial assistant.
A Solid Soundtrack and a Convincing Villain
The drama's soundtrack, particularly "Crossroad," enhances the overall atmosphere. Additionally, the portrayal of the serial killer is both chilling and convincing, adding a layer of suspense to the plot.
In conclusion - A must-watch drama. The Judge From Hell is a bold experiment that, while not flawless, offers a unique and entertaining viewing experience. Park Shin-hye's exceptional performance and the intriguing premise make it a worthwhile watch, despite its shortcomings.
Was this review helpful to you?
it's a revenge type comedy genre
After all the rom com dramas of 2024 this drama is must watch anybody liking revenge genre and badass woman character will surely like this drama. currently it's on 3rd episode but i am already liking the show . seems like it's going to be very interesting seeing park shin hye in this kind of rule is already good and the lead actor is also too handsome overall the casting acting is also good . so it's a must watch for all.Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
Some one should release a cut without the male lead
Who wrote such a whiny ass hypocritical kid. The male lead character is unbearable to watch. The romance didn't work for me. what she fell in love in because of hormones? because the body acted on its own , her heat skipped a beat without feeling an ounce of emotion? A being who is alien to human feelings experiencing them could have been written better.Was this review helpful to you?
I really felt a connection with the main character
Justice represents someone who has the power to judge others, when getting involved with the police stopped being as superficial as it once was, and he put his ego aside. I liked that he never stopped in front of a bad person, she gave them the same treatment they gave to others. And less importantly, as an arcane 11 I am happy with the character. It took me a few days to process The Judge from Hell. It’s the kind of show that initially grabs you with its high-concept, almost lurid premise, but then leaves you contemplating the smaller, thornier questions it raises about justice, which is where it truly shines.The core idea is, admittedly, irresistible: a high-ranking demon, Justitia, gets exiled to Earth as penance for a mistake in the Underworld's judgment. Her task? Possess the body of a murdered, elite human judge, Kang Bit-na, and hunt down a list of unrepentant murderers who slipped through the legal cracks, sending their souls straight to Hell. It’s essentially a 'dark-fantasy legal thriller,' and for the first several episodes, it’s a supremely satisfying, almost episodic feast of vigilante catharsis. Watching Bit-na—or rather, Justitia—use her position and demonic powers to deliver punishments that are a literal 'eye for an eye' is incredibly compelling. The show doesn't shy away from the brutality of the criminals, which makes the poetic, if gory, payback feel well-earned.
Park Shin-hye, in a wonderfully transformative role, is the entire anchor. Her Kang Bit-na is a magnificent, arrogant, and stylish antiheroine. She carries an air of bored disdain for humanity, yet is simultaneously obsessed with trivial human pleasures like soda and high-fashion outfits. It’s a delightful performance, perfectly balancing the cold, ancient demon with the subtle, often hilarious, struggles of adapting to a new body and its messy human connections. Her transition from a purely transactional executioner to someone who slowly, begrudgingly, starts to feel something akin to human empathy is the show's most nuanced arc.
The 'legal' part of the thriller is really just a convenient stage for the moral drama. It quickly becomes clear that the show isn't here to offer a critique of legal procedure, but a meditation on the failure of human systems. When the law is impotent against the truly evil and remorseless, what's the difference between justice and vengeance? Bit-na’s methods are extreme, but they force the righteous Detective Han Da-on (Kim Jae-young) to wrestle with his own trauma and principled belief in the system. Their dynamic—the pragmatic, justice-above-all demon and the wounded, methodical detective—is a fantastic setup.
However, the show is not without its flaws, particularly in the later stretch. The initial tight, almost case-of-the-week structure gradually gives way to a broader, more intricate plot involving Hell's politics, a missing artifact, and a grander villain. While it attempts to build a more comprehensive fantasy world with other demons and an angel, the narrative focus becomes a little scattered. The romance, while sweet and integral to Bit-na’s character development, felt more like a gentle, slow-burn consequence of her humanity blooming than a scorching, undeniable chemistry, which may disappoint viewers looking for an intense romantic payoff. Overall, The Judge from Hell is a captivating watch. It succeeds wildly as a fantasy vehicle for wish fulfillment—seeing irredeemable criminals get their just desserts is profoundly satisfying—and as a showcase for Park Shin-hye’s brilliant shift into a morally gray lead. It's a dark ride with plenty of bite, held together by a compelling central performance and a persistent, uncomfortable question about whether true justice can ever be subtle. It’s a messy, but highly entertaining, blend of genres that, despite a slight dip in intensity, delivers a truly unique take on cosmic retribution.
Was this review helpful to you?
I wrote this for myself
the biggest demon in this show was the chemistry between the FL and ML.loved the FL's character and the suprisigly the actress too (her acting in doctor slump still traumatizes me).
the ML is a bit hypocritical. his acting is also dead. what a waste of a pretty face.
Bael should sybau himself.
as much as i liked this series, i hope there's no season 2. can't sit through this concept again. it's a good one-time watch. no more, no less.
also might be a hot take but my favourite character was gregmory (or whatever was her name).
Was this review helpful to you?
Falling for Demons Again – Judge from Hell Had Me Hooked!
Damn, I absolutely loved it! Why do I always end up falling for demons, whether it’s Guwon or Kang Bitna? 😅 This drama had me hooked from the start. My adrenaline spiked every time she punished sinners in the exact way they killed their victims—it really made them realize how painful their actions were.The male lead also did his part so well. Even though he didn’t do anything “cute” in the drama, I still found him adorable—just like the female lead. Their dynamic worked perfectly.
That cliffhanger ending though! Totally unexpected, and now I can’t stop wishing for a Season 2. Fingers crossed they give us one! 🙏✨
Was this review helpful to you?
whats with that ending?
first of all, i wouldnt say i didnt enjoy this drama. it was interesting, and kept getting me hooked during the episodes, curious by justitia and police trying to catch the serial killer but ngl i at first, stopped watching it for a few weeks after the first episode. having justitia to kill the murderers while the police wanted to catch them, made me feel a little bit weird (?) even tho i knew it was justitia' job lol (and the fact that police didnt know the person who was killing them)the romance wasnt bad nor good. it was okay, i wouldnt say it was unnecessary but neither necessary as some people here says. it wouldve worked any way.
i wanna talk about the ending because even tho i dont hate open endings, this was pretty open to me and i didnt like it at all, at least i wanted to see what was her choice. if she would take bael' place as his heir or lucifer' offer idk i wouldve like that.
Was this review helpful to you?
Overall average
Hi, romance enjoyer here. If you consider watching this show and count on a good combination of romance and thriller/action you are going to probably be disappointed. Show is very emotional, but these emotions usually include grief, pain and suffering more than love. Actors give great performances, however show lacks logic when it comes to reasoning of certain behaviours. I have seen shows with romance that also focus more on action/drama, like for example Healer or Mask and they were in my opinion better when it comes to combining plot with love, this one left me wanting something more, sadly.Was this review helpful to you?
