This review may contain spoilers
Female leads confusion takes away the build up to the conclusion
The transition to movie felt lacking. Although acting was solid and the new soundtrack made it feel more like an original interpretation of the original anime.Mostly felt certain strong feelings were missing , which made the anime memorable imo
Such as the numb feeling the MC got after working many years without any passion and seeking for “something” that makes him feel alive.
The other strong feeling and essence of the story was the unrequited love. The build up was there, but not impactful enough when the most important seen where both adults passing each other…
All in all I would only recommend this movie to Makoto Shinkai fans that are interested to see how the live action turned out.
But for others…. It is a lacklustre movie that is not very interesting for the general audience. My mother was confused at times… even me when we both were unsure who was the surf girl or the girl from primary school….
And the unrequited love part was kinda overshadowed by the confusion who is who….
I think this issue could be solved by focusing only on 1 couple. The surfing girl felt a bit
unnecessary. It didn’t add much to the story, except that MC is missed the mark/timing from small till now and has sort of grown/learned from his first love… it might be important to his character growth, but in the red line of the story it was more of a nuisance to me and source of confusion.
Was this review helpful to you?
song, "One More Time, One More Chance
It was more than just wonderful. At first, I didn't quite grasp it, but later I understood—and I cried so much. I really wanted them to end up together, but honestly, when I thought about it, the male lead was a bit selfish—or perhaps just a strange character. He was deeply preoccupied with the world and the cosmos, far more than he was with the female lead. Even when she cried in front of him, he was focused on the rocket and ignored her distress; he would dodge her confessions and run away, thinking he was unworthy or that the situation was awkward. I think he realized he loved her the right way, but at the wrong time. Clinging to the past is futile unless you actively engage with it—meaning, he should have put in the effort for her, searched for her, and strived for something beyond himself. She was truly exhausted by him; these were memories spanning from when she was 12 and 18, and now she is 30. That kind of dynamic just doesn't work for someone like her—someone who wants a comfortable, bright lifeShe speaks to me in a smooth, friendly manner. She has come to view their shared memories as an integral part of her life experience—moving past the fact that he was once harsh toward her. I’m not sure why his personality changed so drastically in high school; he became very quiet and acted as though he didn't understand her indirect confessions of love. I really loved the atmosphere—it was wonderful. The characters aren't perfect; they are flawed, just like real people. Take the guy, for instance: he has a good job at a company, goes about his daily routine—talking, eating, and doing everything else—yet deep down, he doesn't truly know what he wants or if he is actually satisfied with himself. Anyway, I just wanted to share my thoughts on the movie while listening to its theme song, "One More Time, One More Chance."
Was this review helpful to you?
Il filo conduttore che descrive la vita del personaggio resta quello dei treni, spesso in ritardo, e dei passaggi a livello che sembrano allontanarlo sempre di più dalle relazioni.
Se nell’anime domina l’angoscia costruita attorno all’attesa di un incontro destinato a non avverarsi, nel live‑action questa tensione emotiva è presente, ma in maniera più attenuata.
Anche il finale trasmette sensazioni leggermente differenti. Nell’anime permane un senso di tristezza e rammarico per un ragazzo che non è riuscito a lasciarsi alle spalle il passato, che si è chiuso in sé stesso per non soffrire nuovamente e che finisce per sprecare rapporti e occasioni inseguendo il ricordo di un amore perduto.
Nel film, invece, la stessa identica conclusione — ambientata sempre in prossimità di un passaggio a livello — lascia intravedere una nota di speranza, grazie all’espressione finale del protagonista.
Was this review helpful to you?
