Saving General Yang (2013)

A man's temperament determines his fate

Saving General Yang is based on the famous story of General Yang Ye and his seven sons during the Song Dynasty. A better than average film that martial arts movie lovers should enjoy.

The Yang family's fate was thrown into turmoil when the youngest son killed a rival family's son in a tournament to win the princess' hand in marriage. As the Pan family was demanding justice the Khitan army attacked. Lord Pan was chosen as the supreme commander of the army who took the opportunity to betray General Yang and his men during a vicious battle. Yang was hit with a poison arrow as Pan's troops retreated leaving him and his men at the mercy of the cruel Khitan general Yelu Yuan. Yang and his men were allowed to live in an old ruins setting a trap for his sons. Out of love and loyalty his sons set out with a small band of men to rescue their father. A seer gave their mother a dire warning, "Seven sons will go out, six will come back". Interpreting soothsaying can be tricky.

The cast was huge and with the movie clocking in at a scant 100 minutes there wasn't much time for character development. Director Yu threw in a few flashbacks and enough comments to glean the bare basic characteristics of each brother. The brothers were led by the stalwart eldest, Ekin Cheng. Vic Chou played the supreme archer of the group and Wu Chun played the pivotal 6th brother. Adam Cheng did well as the stoic and loyal general resigned to his fate. Shao Bing gave enough menace to his vengeful general to make him a proper threat. And Bryan Leung ("Beardy!"), familiar to martial arts movie fans, rounded out the male cast as the treacherous Pan Ren Mei. Xu Fan as the General's wife and Ady An as Princess Chai Mei Rong were the small female presence in the movie.

This was not a personality and character driven movie, though stylish, it lacked in substance on occasion. This was bloody battle upon bloody battle as the brothers fought their way into enemy territory and then turned around to fight their way out. A devastating catapult/trebuchet assault and a thrilling archer battle in the tall grass were two of the creative highlights. Even with the modicum of character development I admit to getting choked up in a few scenes.

The costumes, sets, and CGI were all stellar. The battles contained the right amount of gravitas and high stakes. Stephen Tung Wai choreographed some amazing and cruel fight scenes. The brothers were outnumbered in every fight and the choreography showed the brutal reality of close quarters confrontations with sharp weapons complete with heroics and desperation. Wu could lay the family fidelity and heroism on a little thick at times, but given their dire situations and commitment to each other, I could overlook some heavy-handed moments. There were a couple of scenes that didn't work very well, but for the most part the movie flowed and usually at breakneck speed. The OST bordered on over-wrought but for me managed to err more on the side of rousing.

Saving General Yang would have benefited from greater character development, but as a perilous story of 7 brothers facing overwhelming odds to bring their father home, it mostly succeeded. Not everyone will like this movie, but I found it gripping and entertaining.

7/19/22

Read More

Better as a drama than movie

Saving General Yang is a film based on the Yang family legend, where the sons set out on a dangerous mission to rescue their father, General Yang, after he is ambushed and captured. It highlights loyalty, sacrifice, and brotherhood, and the action scenes are beautifully executed with a strong sense of scale and intensity.

The father figure is presented as a symbol of honor and duty, but because he is absent for much of the story, it’s hard to fully feel the emotional urgency behind the rescue. I did wish we had more time early on to see the relationship between him and his sons, since that would’ve made their mission hit harder emotionally. Still, I understand the film likely had to move quickly due to runtime constraints. I also watched this mainly because of Raymond Lam, and while he was good, I did wish he had more screen time to really shine.

What stood out most was the brothers and their dynamic throughout the mission. Even though they aren’t deeply developed as individuals, their bond comes through strongly in how they fight and support each other. Each brother has a distinct fighting style, and the way they coordinate in battle gives the film its strongest emotional and narrative momentum. It’s less about individual character arcs and more about unity under pressure, which surprisingly works well in an action driven story like this.

The action is undeniably the highlight. The sequences are intense, fast paced, and at times surprisingly brutal, which keeps the film consistently engaging even when the emotional depth feels limited. The choreography is clean and creative, especially in the larger set pieces where teamwork becomes crucial. The final stretches of the mission carry a solid sense of tension and sacrifice, even though the outcome feels inevitable.

Overall, Saving General Yang works best as a visually striking, action focused historical drama rather than a deeply emotional family epic. While the story didn’t fully land for me, the brotherhood, choreography, and relentless action made it a compelling watch. I do think it would’ve worked better as a drama series to properly build up the characters and emotional stakes.

Read More