
SeoInGukSaranghae:
-My Personal Weatherman
-Captivated by You (Muchuu-sa, Kimi ni)
-Old Fashion Cupcake
Which one do you recommend I should go with first?
I really liked all three - but they're very different from each other. All three are very well conceived, constructed and executed, with Japanese creativity and originality along with good acting.
"Old Fashion Cupcake" is an uplifting office BL with two engaging protagonists. That being said, I didn't love it quite as much as most, maybe because I'm not so into corporate types in suits - or maybe because of Nozue's smoking (ick!). There's also a three-minute "Old Fashion Cupcake Epilogue: Apple Pie" (I watched it on Bilibili.tv because I didn't know where to find it), but to be honest, it doesn't add much.
Like many others in this group, I really loved "My Personal Weatherman" with its unique sexual electricity. One might even call this a sort of master-slave relationship - although that might make this series sound lurid, which it is not. It's about the psychology - often unspoken - between the protagonists and about the complicated love between them. It's very much a love story, even if it may seem toxic at first. (@American Fan, maybe this is why you dropped it? We usually have fairly similar tastes and likes, so if you watched it to the end, you might have a different opinion?)
I originally decided to watch "Captivated by You" because of my beloved and most adorable Onishi Ryusei (of Naniwa Danshi). It's not at all a BL (at most a bromance between two of the characters), but I really liked it. It's a bit weird/quirky, but in a sweet way. Very well edited, especially the way it reveals through different views of the same scene. It's also short, so not much of a time investment.