1. When the initial trailer for this drama appeared and some people said they felt the chinese drama vibes in AOS dramas, kdrama fans refused to admit it and kept saying it doesn't have a cdrama vibe at all and instead said cdrama is a ridiculous drama where actresses and actors wearing excessive makeup in the ancient era, thought magic and flying scenes were ridiculous.
2. The costumes of the players compared to hanbok, even more resembled Chinese hanfu which netizens really hated.
3. When this drama finally aired and more and more people said it was similar to a cdrama and maybe kdrama fans also felt the same way, they started to demean the cdrama by saying this one is better, the plot is more solid and makes sense, the cgi is more natural , unlike cdrama which is boring, senseless and low quality cgi.
4. At first they denied that what the players were wearing was more like hanfu than hanbok, but when they finally realized it was true, they started to say it's a normal thing. This is a natural thing, while they once blasphemed cdrama because the costumes of the players they wore were similar to what they had worn in kdrama. They even started accusing China of wanting to steal Korean culture.
Meanwhile, the writers here make their style similar to the Chinese style, starting from: Ming dynasty hanfu, and hair style.
Isn't that just clothes?
5. Similar scans, posters, and CGI. Kdrama fans reject it as plagiarism, but if a cdrama does that, they will immediately say it's plagiarism. An example is the case of a poster of a cdrama which is said to be similar to a poster of a famous cdrama.
Isn't that just posters and cutscenes?
6. HONG SISTER was caught in a plagiarism case, not this time. They've often used other cultures, storylines from other countries as inspiration, but didn't say it and made fans think it was their original idea.
hm there's a whole list of stuff they have plagiarized https://www.douyin.com/video/7110952473136844040https://www.douyin.com/video/7111221283815181604Clearly…
It's just a drama, fiction, fantasy."
"There is no limit to the work."
"They deserve to be 'inspired' from many places and cultures to make better and more amazing stories."
Is this where the problem is , so if they state where they got inspiration from the issue would be solved right?
Well, at least they won't misunderstand their people/fans, assume it's purely their idea, and instead accuse others of copying them (this is like what happened to the cdrama entitled "Rattan" which was accused of imitating "hotel delluna")
for people who say it's just a costume, a hairstyle, why the fuss? Is it because they are not Chinese that they can't wear hanfu? There are also those who say he wears qipao to work, is that also forbidden? the answer is NO!!! Nothing forbids you from wearing traditional clothes from any country as long as you don't trick people into believing them to be yours.
This writer is indeed extraordinary, after being caught in plagiarism at Hotel Del Luna (the scan and cinematography of goodbye my princess, and the plot of the cnovel Rattan), they also do this here. It's amazing how they can be inspired from so many places without admitting it and make their fans think the original owner is a plagiarist. Give this writer a round of applause
If cdrama fans are considered unreasonable because they think this drama has a cdrama vibe, and think they are exaggerating because they judge the costumes and styles that the actors and actresses wear here are like the style in a cdrama, then what about kdrama fans who blaspheme and raise the hashtag #hanfuisnothanbok for reasons the same one?
I've been saying from the start if they just wear, get inspired and don't claim it as their own, it'll be fine. But you guys keep circling in one place.
from the start, what I highlighted was their dress style which leans more towards hanfu than hanbok. That's the main part that makes me feel the cdrama vibes besides the trailer and story theme
What's up with the rating? This drama is too good to be 6.8 (rating)I'm honestly loving this drama so far and…
This gives off a cdrama vibe, and Hong Sister is not the only time this time she has been involved in a cdrama/cnovel plagiarism case.
The costumes they wear are more like hanfu than hanbok, as is the hairstyle. for example is the oh nara style. rather than a hanbok, the costume is more like a ming dynasty hanfu and so is the hairstyle.
There are also those who think this is similar to a wuxia/xianxia drama.
Some feel that some of the scenes and cgi are imitating a cdrama
it's okay if you just use it. I will also be happy if more people like my country's traditional clothes and wear them. But if they claim it as their own, I certainly won't be happy.
Wasn't at first cnetz was also okay with kdrama using something similar to hanfu and hairstyles that resembled their hairstyles? but what happened? When a cdrama uses their own traditional style (a style that has been used in kdrama), they are blasphemed and perceived as imitating, trying to recognize the hanbok as their attire.
this is no longer about writers taking on story cliches, but in the realm of culture. okay? Did you see the costume that oh nara is wearing? rather than hanbok, isn't it more like ming dynasty hanfu? If you don't believe me, take a look at the drama the sword and the brocade.
oh, then I can't say anything more with people who can't appreciate their own history and culture. Do you know the difference between claiming and defending?
Your impression belongs to you only. It does not mean it is the reality. This drama has:- No guy from poor condition…
they certainly wouldn't be entirely 'inspired' by a Chinese element, would they? the two countries are at loggerheads. So if they did, wouldn't that be suicide?
And from the start what netizens said was a similar vibe, no plagiarism. Only after this drama was aired, there were some netizens claiming plagiarism.
oh, then show me. Will people who wear suits admit that suits come from their country? Traditional clothing is the identity, cultural heritage of the nation. Will you be silent if another country wears your country's traditional clothes and admits it's theirs? For example, if kebaya and batik are claimed by Malaysia as their cultural heritage, their property, will Indonesians also be silent?
1. When the initial trailer for this drama appeared and some people said they felt the chinese drama vibes in AOS dramas, kdrama fans refused to admit it and kept saying it doesn't have a cdrama vibe at all and instead said cdrama is a ridiculous drama where actresses and actors wearing excessive makeup in the ancient era, thought magic and flying scenes were ridiculous.
2. The costumes of the players compared to hanbok, even more resembled Chinese hanfu which netizens really hated.
3. When this drama finally aired and more and more people said it was similar to a cdrama and maybe kdrama fans also felt the same way, they started to demean the cdrama by saying this one is better, the plot is more solid and makes sense, the cgi is more natural , unlike cdrama which is boring, senseless and low quality cgi.
4. At first they denied that what the players were wearing was more like hanfu than hanbok, but when they finally realized it was true, they started to say it's a normal thing. This is a natural thing, while they once blasphemed cdrama because the costumes of the players they wore were similar to what they had worn in kdrama. They even started accusing China of wanting to steal Korean culture.
Meanwhile, the writers here make their style similar to the Chinese style, starting from: Ming dynasty hanfu, and hair style.
Isn't that just clothes?
5. Similar scans, posters, and CGI. Kdrama fans reject it as plagiarism, but if a cdrama does that, they will immediately say it's plagiarism. An example is the case of a poster of a cdrama which is said to be similar to a poster of a famous cdrama.
Isn't that just posters and cutscenes?
6. HONG SISTER was caught in a plagiarism case, not this time. They've often used other cultures, storylines from other countries as inspiration, but didn't say it and made fans think it was their original idea.
"There is no limit to the work."
"They deserve to be 'inspired' from many places and cultures to make better and more amazing stories."
"IT'S JUST A CLOTHING!!"
Then how about this one?
http://naver.me/GFDPHMKo
"There is no limit to the work."
"They deserve to be 'inspired' from many places and cultures to make better and more amazing stories."
"IT'S JUST A CLOTHING!!"
Then how about this one?
http://naver.me/GFDPHMKo
https://www.koreaboo.com/news/vogue-mislabelling-chinese-hanfu-korean-netizens-hanbok/
I've been saying from the start if they just wear, get inspired and don't claim it as their own, it'll be fine. But you guys keep circling in one place.
The costumes they wear are more like hanfu than hanbok, as is the hairstyle. for example is the oh nara style. rather than a hanbok, the costume is more like a ming dynasty hanfu and so is the hairstyle.
There are also those who think this is similar to a wuxia/xianxia drama.
Some feel that some of the scenes and cgi are imitating a cdrama
Wasn't at first cnetz was also okay with kdrama using something similar to hanfu and hairstyles that resembled their hairstyles? but what happened? When a cdrama uses their own traditional style (a style that has been used in kdrama), they are blasphemed and perceived as imitating, trying to recognize the hanbok as their attire.
Do you know the difference between claiming and defending?
And from the start what netizens said was a similar vibe, no plagiarism. Only after this drama was aired, there were some netizens claiming plagiarism.
Will people who wear suits admit that suits come from their country? Traditional clothing is the identity, cultural heritage of the nation. Will you be silent if another country wears your country's traditional clothes and admits it's theirs? For example, if kebaya and batik are claimed by Malaysia as their cultural heritage, their property, will Indonesians also be silent?