The One Fatal Flaw is the FL's Acting
This was another perfect, well crafted story written by the masterful author, Mo Shu Bai.
This is the first adaptation of a Mo Shu Bai work where the main CP has not already been married for years before the drama begins (The Princess Royal, Light Beyond the Reed), or is not forced into a marriage by the end of the first episode (Destined). For once, we're not seeing a married couple learn to fall in love again (or for the first time), but we're seeing two individuals who have no ties to each other weighing the costs and benefits of letting a little stirring of emotions turn into a lifelong commitment.
While fundamentally different from the past works, it is a love story could have worked if executed well. And while Mo Shu Bai set up this couple perfectly to be successful, Victoria Song's basic lack of understanding of the character caused the main CP to crash and burn in a way such that even Ding Yuxi's acting couldn't save it.
CONS
The main CP was the worst, most uninteresting couple to watch and it was entirely Victoria's fault. Honestly their romance peaked when it was just a one-sided love from DYX, but once she started reciprocate his feelings and they tried to "Fight For Love", I was annoyed with them. The main flaw was that Victoria misunderstood CY's character entirely, and instead of acting as a mature, complex woman, she acted like a child blind-sided by a love confession, and then later blindly motivated by love without any plausible reason for romance to be blossoming. They truly had almost no chemistry (I say "almost" b/c DYX can truly have chemistry with a broomstick). And their "love above all else" attitude was infuriating at times, because in reality their love was not so great, was not worth fighting for, and should not have gotten so in the way of the bigger picture like it did.
PROS
EVERY SINGLE CHARACTER had depth, had a purpose, was never tiring to watch. Every side story, side romance, side conflict, was intriguing and worth slowing down for. And I loved every choice made by every character (except for the main CP when it came to choices made regarding their relationship). The story was constantly subverting my expectations with how great these characters could be. And I've watched enough C-dramas to see supporting characters, SMLs, side couples, etc. make infuriating, choices or "noble idiocy" moves or irrationally villainous choices that I was constantly expecting them, but every single time it didn't happen! I felt like I was constantly waiting to get betrayed by characters that I was growing fond of and that never happened (Song Shilan, I am so glad that I was able to root for you until the end, you had all the makings to become a villain or a backstabber, but you were not).
The politics were also great! Every time I avoided picking up the show again for fear of being disappointed by the main CP, we actually shifted focus to the war, to politics, to the bromances, to the great virtues of every side character, and I was pleasantly surprised and not disappointed after all.
I cannot give it more than a 9/10 b/c the show is called "Fight For Love" and that is essentially the only plot line that I hated, but everything else I loved and every actor was a rockstar (except for Victoria). Even though this is the lowest score I've ever given to a Mo Shu Bai work, all of the redeeming qualities came from the additional characters that she wrote, and I can tell that this drama might have even been a 10 out of 10 if 1) The FL was differently cast, and 2) the drama was allowed to do the original rebirth/reincarnation plot line that was in the book (which unfortunately had to be dropped from the drama adaptation due to China's outlaw of reincarnation plots in C-dramas). So I have no doubt that she is still a Top Tier writer and will only produce 10/10 works in the future.
This is the first adaptation of a Mo Shu Bai work where the main CP has not already been married for years before the drama begins (The Princess Royal, Light Beyond the Reed), or is not forced into a marriage by the end of the first episode (Destined). For once, we're not seeing a married couple learn to fall in love again (or for the first time), but we're seeing two individuals who have no ties to each other weighing the costs and benefits of letting a little stirring of emotions turn into a lifelong commitment.
While fundamentally different from the past works, it is a love story could have worked if executed well. And while Mo Shu Bai set up this couple perfectly to be successful, Victoria Song's basic lack of understanding of the character caused the main CP to crash and burn in a way such that even Ding Yuxi's acting couldn't save it.
CONS
The main CP was the worst, most uninteresting couple to watch and it was entirely Victoria's fault. Honestly their romance peaked when it was just a one-sided love from DYX, but once she started reciprocate his feelings and they tried to "Fight For Love", I was annoyed with them. The main flaw was that Victoria misunderstood CY's character entirely, and instead of acting as a mature, complex woman, she acted like a child blind-sided by a love confession, and then later blindly motivated by love without any plausible reason for romance to be blossoming. They truly had almost no chemistry (I say "almost" b/c DYX can truly have chemistry with a broomstick). And their "love above all else" attitude was infuriating at times, because in reality their love was not so great, was not worth fighting for, and should not have gotten so in the way of the bigger picture like it did.
PROS
EVERY SINGLE CHARACTER had depth, had a purpose, was never tiring to watch. Every side story, side romance, side conflict, was intriguing and worth slowing down for. And I loved every choice made by every character (except for the main CP when it came to choices made regarding their relationship). The story was constantly subverting my expectations with how great these characters could be. And I've watched enough C-dramas to see supporting characters, SMLs, side couples, etc. make infuriating, choices or "noble idiocy" moves or irrationally villainous choices that I was constantly expecting them, but every single time it didn't happen! I felt like I was constantly waiting to get betrayed by characters that I was growing fond of and that never happened (Song Shilan, I am so glad that I was able to root for you until the end, you had all the makings to become a villain or a backstabber, but you were not).
The politics were also great! Every time I avoided picking up the show again for fear of being disappointed by the main CP, we actually shifted focus to the war, to politics, to the bromances, to the great virtues of every side character, and I was pleasantly surprised and not disappointed after all.
I cannot give it more than a 9/10 b/c the show is called "Fight For Love" and that is essentially the only plot line that I hated, but everything else I loved and every actor was a rockstar (except for Victoria). Even though this is the lowest score I've ever given to a Mo Shu Bai work, all of the redeeming qualities came from the additional characters that she wrote, and I can tell that this drama might have even been a 10 out of 10 if 1) The FL was differently cast, and 2) the drama was allowed to do the original rebirth/reincarnation plot line that was in the book (which unfortunately had to be dropped from the drama adaptation due to China's outlaw of reincarnation plots in C-dramas). So I have no doubt that she is still a Top Tier writer and will only produce 10/10 works in the future.
Was this review helpful to you?
