Marshmallow

That was a lie. Because he was confused too and didn't know what's happening in the beginning. He thought what he dreamt was him in another world. But that's another Cirrus (Black Cirrus) with his boyfriend Phu). So the Cir we saw from the beginning is the original world Cir. He never switched worlds until Episode 7 end. And throughout the episode 8 he was stuck in the white room.

Okay so we haven't seen episode 9 yet. I think you meant episode 8 so I am gonna answer this way to make it easier for you. At the end of the episode Both Cirrus have returned to their own worlds.

-Original Cir with Original Phu in the road.
-Man bun hair tied Cir with Nerdy spectacles wearing Phu in front of the apartment.

I think every Black Cir's responsibility is to have another Cir world's Cir and Phu fall in love. That's why he told "it'll be your duty to make the next Cirrus see it too" So yes I guess.. sometimes there can be a person in the white room, sometimes they can be in a different world and sometimes they can be in a brain concussion and think it's a dream they saw. I don't think they forget what happened though..

Parallel worlds are real. Just pay a little bit more attention on what the black Cir says, then it will be less confusing for you.. :)

Cir he (Original Cir) switched with didn't notice his world Phu, that's the reason he switched with original world Cir. So that he can get to know Phu, because his world Phu already knows him and seems like crushing on him while he doesn't know about that Phu. That's why before the end credit we could see that Cir confronting that Phu because he get to know Phu from the original world. And meanwhile Original Cir returned back to the original world in the end. You can see him stopping original Phu on the road.

Yes we can assume that because Thorn didn't know who Cirrus is.. And he already knows him in TharnType.

OMG you're so sweet you made me blush ☺️ Just let me know if you have anymore questions I'll always be here to answer you ♡ Boss is shy sometimes 🤭 I think that's why he played in a corner.

And that's simple as that :) I'm still wondering why people are confused 😅 No offence to them though..

🥹🫶

18.17 is the time mark :) Look how excited he is to play it, I hope it makes you happy as a flutist too.

https://youtu.be/bxRxTCSIWHA?feature=shared

I know what you meant.. My sister is a musician too so she and I had a discussion on this scene just yesterday. She was the one who told me that they have added keyboard notes, it was their fault coz she also agreed that the version Boss played was better than the one they included in the series. You'd know if you watch the clip Boss posted and the BTS. My point is, only a musician will figure it out though.. so I think we as viewers can just praise him for his effort without making 'Fun' of the scene he worked hard for.. That's what I feel and you can disagree of course. And he is a musician actually.. he plays Guitar, he just said he hasn't played a wind instrument before.

He actually played it.. you can see in the BTS clip they posted today. And he had workshops specially for this scene.. He also mentioned that he has never played a wind instrument before, so he was trying his best to make it perfect. I know they might have added the sounds through keyboard notes when they are editing it for us, but I just wanted to tell that Boss really made a huge effort on it and he really played it for the scene. Kudos for him. ♡

Lol I wonder too at times.. 😂And I don't like her putting trauma on everything too. To be honest TBNW is way more better than her previous works.

I totally get what you mean.. That's why I even decided to reply your comment. It's sad they are cutting those type of scenes thinking it's not that important when it's actually important for the plot. I can assure you that Phu specifically tells Cir after the call "Mom cried too" so they kinda have an emotional conversation together. I think Phu's mom has left him because Phu reminds her so much of Phu's dad. I know that's no excuse to leave her child to suffer alone like that. But that's how her character was made.

Actually in the book she calls Phu. They have a conversation while Cir is talking in front of Phu's dad. So Phu listens to Cir confessing his love for Phu, but Cir doesn't know Phu is there when he talked to his dad. They changed that part in the series. But I have a feeling that some of the clips are not included in the series coz BossNoeul mentioned that it will be added to the boxset. For an example they mentioned the nightmare Phu had in Episode 6 related to his dad will be shown to us. Since Phu's phone call conversation with his mom is included in the book, I have a feeling that it might be included in the boxset too. I might be wrong.. but I wanted to let you know that she called Phu that day. :)

I feel like they kinda confirmed the parallel world existence from Ep 8 preview.. Black Cir literally said "You can't go anywhere, you have to wait until the other Cirrus go back to his world"

https://x.com/Bossckm_/status/1891489303097713149?t=x675Of7g84duTlymVehcwQ&s=19

Boss practicing the Flute ♡

Oh okay.. makes sense 😊

So I am from BossNoeul fandom. I love them both since LITA days and I've been following their works. So I have read the book, we witnessed the filming days too. I watch BTS and gather information from there. Also, we dissect every scene to the bits as a fandom, so it makes me knowledgeable on the series more. Which is why I am happy to answer questions like yours, without spoiling the story of course. ☺️

I am curious about what made you confirm Cir is a 'Crazy stalker' (according to your words) after episode 7.. If you see till the end you can see the next episode preview shows 3 Cirrus.

And Boss did play the flute for real. He had to take lessons for that separately because he had never played a wind instrument before. He had workshops alone for that. He just said yesterday after the episode that they recorded the sound separately and added because they wanted to make it perfect.

Yesss possible!! I was thinking 3 with this world coz the dream world where Cir and Phu are together, This world and the one where 3rd Cirrus came from. But there can be another world like you said because I have no idea who that Cir with spectacles is.. 😅

Please don't think that way.. 🤗 That confusion is the whole reason we are having discussions like this. Just ask if you have any more confusions. I am sure someone will answer ☺️