AsianDramaLover

@Reset: This is a very interesting way of watching the two seasons. I might have to give it a try :) . The logical person in me is saying with episode 1, because it is in order for a reason.

But I can see your angle also. I might have to try.

Also, thank you for introducing me to Douban. Is there an English version of the app? I am an iPhone user and when I downloaded the app last night, it was all Simplified Chinese. I wished I spoke Mandarin, but alas.

Thank you for the feedback. I have not watched it yet. But excited to do so. I need to watch Season 1 first.

I have not started this drama yet but based on your description, this is right down my alley.

Thank you for the feedback. I definitely plan to take a look.

Thank you for the feedback. I am glad we were able to move beyond our initial misunderstanding because I would have missed the opportunity to interact with you. You are indeed very kind and I can tell.

I am definitely going to give this drama a try.

You have a great weekend also.

PS: I deleted my post in response to yours. It was mean and I should have been better.

You know what text does a poor job of communicating true intent.

I apologize if I read your feedback the wrong way. I was not mad but more annoyed than anything. I appreciate your clarification and I think we can all be so much better if we learn to respect other’s opinions even if it differs from our own.


BTW, I do agree that ratings here can be really subjective as you mentioned. I have dropped some high rating shows in favor for some lower rating.

For example the rise of the Phoenix top 10 on my list, but it does not have the highest rating.

I am thinking about watching this. Is it worth the watch? 8.3 overall rating is not that impressive.

Love this. Really poignant and heart felt. A sad and yet beautiful story about the power of love and friendship. Oh Jung Se/Moon Sang Tae's nailed his character but it is still not in my top KDramas.

I guess, I have seen too many good ones. :)

Amazing.. One of the best dramas I have ever watched.

Season 2 was just as good as season 1. I am excited for season 3!

Loved and Loved this show. I highly recommend it.

I think this is a bit underrated.

If you like season 1, you will definitely enjoy season 2. I am of the belief that season 2 was just as good as season 1. I guess you will have to judge it for yourself.

I agree. The change of characters this season should have prompted them to film both seasons back to back. Why take the risk of current cast members not being available?

Cast members such as the Emperor and Chen ping ping are only getting older... you think they would want the transition between seasons to be as seamless as possible.

@PeachBlossomGoddess: I simply love your reviews. You are amazing at it. Is this what you do for a living?

Anyway I just completed season 2 and I loved it just as much as the second. I agree with the all the points that you made. Too many open plots and I am unsure how they are going to close them out in just 36-40 episodes.

Unlike, you however, I still rated season 2 at 9.5 simply because it's so hard to achieve consistencies with sequels. I thought season 2 started slow; it's like they were trying too hard in the beginning to recreate the magic they had in season 1. However, as the series progressed, everyone started to fall back into their roles and created a new magical season.. :)

haha , I can do 2 years. but anymore than that, I will need to go to China and have a talk with the screenwriter. :)

I hope they already filmed season 3 and are just waiting for 2026 to release it. It makes for a smoother transition to season 3. Both the Emperor and CPP are not getting any younger.

Thank you for well conceived response. I found season highly entertaining and just as good as season 1. I love where the plot is heading. I still have a lot of questions, but that's what makes it fun.

At the very least, this is a highly engaging drama.

I just completed Season 2 and I came away impressed. While I was worried with the early episodes, and while there were a lot twist and turns that are yet to be fully explained, I found JOL2 as exciting and entertaining as JOL1..

Very often in the drama world where sequels are often a big let down. JOL2, in my opinion, was just as good if not better than JOL1. Now, I cannot wait for season 3. I just hope that I don't have to wait another 5 years.

Does anyone know if they filmed season 3, the same time as season 2?

I don't understand how this drama overall rating is 8.4. It should be at the very least rated at 9 or higher. To me, it is equivalent if not better than NIF. The plot, acting, pace, conversation, the elaborate costumes, and the music are all elite. I have watched this drama about 3 years ago and I still cannot get it out of my mind. It is the standard by which I judge other CDramas.

It's one of the few times I watched a drama where I felt completely immersed in the show. It's almost like I was transported in that fictional world as a bug on the wall listening to every conversation between the cast.

I will not be watching if Zhang Ruo Yun is not in it.

It was simply amazing. Great acting, especially from the female lead. Great plot, superbly executed. Very well done.

I was not defending anyone in particular. I was just calling us to be more civilized toward one another. If you look at my post, I said both sides are entitled to their own opinions. If you disagree with someone; just ignore them and move on with your life.

People are quick to use adjectives to describe someone they disagree with. I agree original poster was a bit tactless; but neither were those who responded.

If you are getting insulted, and have to retort back because someone calls you a 13 year old; then you just prove the original poster’s point.

I will not post again on this subject ;; it was just sad to see how immature folks can be about a fictional drama.