AnotherSeason

This show is built on this. Most of these daily revenges do this but I've never seen one do it soooo much. Jae Kyung gets her information from pure coincidence or from the Seon Hwa telling her everything.

That's a good point. It's for them to decide that. From my perspective I don't see a distortion of history or it being handled poorly comparing the information I have had access to. It doesn't mean that I'm not listening. Still, at this point, I think it's okay to engage with the story.

For what it's worth, here are my two cents. I started watching this show without knowing there was an issue and then came across the comments here. I just read the a couple of articles as well as the twitter posts from that link provided below and, so far, I don't see any indication from the show that it is handling the historical situation poorly ... we have no idea what direction the show is going to take. I recently watched Youth of May and ended up doing some research on the incident, and being someone who is pretty sensitive to social injustice, I still think it okay to engage with this work.

it would go a long way if, instead of condemning people for not having morals, you take the time to foster understanding, so people might weigh the issue better.

i also question if this is a real enough portrayal. i think it's pretty idealized and romanticized and for the umpteenth time showing the privileged tiny portion of the society.

i also question if this is a real enough portrayal. i think it's pretty idealized and romanticized and for the umpteenth time showing the privileged tiny portion of the society.

shouldn't modern sensibilities towards injustice allow these reactions while understanding the that it's historical and that they were supposedly good husbands according to the social conventions? i would also say that structural inequality based on gender is ongoing in every society and that improvements need to continue to take place.

why does it seem like 17 is the lead character here?

I watched ep. 10 and my heart just breaks for your heroine.

Wow. The Ren men make my blood boil. These incredibly capable women wasting their energies for what.

Seriously not interested in wasting my time on that since I'm not on a mission to have anyone believe me or share the same thoughts or agree with me, but thanks.

I think she sees his capacity and wants to nurture this as well as his suppressed love for Math that she sees. I believe she would do this for any student. As for her feelings, I can't tell though precedence tells me that she won't go there before 4 years pass.

I don't think they will cross any boundaries as teacher and student and I cannot fathom any PD putting forward that kind of a relationship as a romance. They would be roasted.

I'm sorry, I wasn't trying to convince you.

agree

disclaimer: calling the relationship in MnJ one of respect and admiration is for lack of better words. I am aware that such a relationship, where there is a breach of trust, cannot really be described in these terms.

You can read the above if you would like. Anyway, I agree with you to see how it goes.

Okay. So, in MnJ the leads meet on the road where they crash she has his cell, he has her ring. She first sees him at school lying on a tree (if I remember well) and invites him to be interested in his studies. In M, they meet on the train and there is an exchange of bags and she finds him lying on a bench listening to music and she is to interest him in Math. In MnJ, she has a fiance who is an office worker and mother stays at home with father a retired educator who has a reputation and holds sway in the field. She has a best friend which is not in M. In M, she has fiance who works for the ministry of education and holds sway. In MnJ, he has a mother who drives him and corners him in his studies which makes him loose his interest. In M, he has a father (and mother too) who drives him and corners him in his studies that makes him loose interest. In MnJ, he has a fascination with art they share, in M it's a fascination with Math which they share. Of course, there is always the second female lead student with here bag of troubles in both. There is his upcoming fight, connection with books, library scene, beach/listening to music scene, and her leaving the marriage talks for the sake of the student mirror each other in MnJ and M.
I know some of these elements are in CN. I also see that the personalities are different in all three shows actually due to their different personality/background setups. The relationship of mutual respect and admiration unfolds similarly in MnJ (sexual and taboo from the beginning) and M, where it isn't in CN. They male student in CN is attracted to his teacher and ends up slapping her and everything else that unfolds.

See my above response and go back and watch MnJ, if you have seen it before, and you will see what I mean. CN had a similar set up but MnJ is closer to this than it is. IMO Japanese dramas of the early 2000's had more licence to tell a taboo story than today, hence, again imo, the controversy with CN and the nature of this story (K audience as well). Still, it comes across as remake, albeit an updated and sketched out version.

So the story is updated and fleshed and more conservative but the story unravels the same way with almost parallel setups in the relationships and looking at the preview for ep 3 I'm even more convinced.