This review may contain spoilers
Empresses in the Palace crawled so that The Story of Yanxi Palace could run
A disclaimer before I start the review: I watched this series a few months after I finished the Story of Yanxi Palace, so it is inevitable that I will compare the two a lot in this review. I understand that though they are set in damn near the same setting and have similarities in their stories, they are two very different stories told in an entirely different tone. However, I couldn't help but compare the two because of how many people recommended this show if someone liked Story of Yanxi Palace. Also, I enjoyed the Story of Yanxi Palace way more; just in case anyone won't be able to tell by the end of this review.
I started EitP (Empresses in the Palace) with high expectations. The description seemed to promise a palace intrigue story with a protagonist of questionable morals to boot. And I looove morally gray protagonists (Dexter fan here), and the comments I'd seen spoke of Zhen Huan's "darkening" that greatly contrasts her personality from the earlier episodes and the later ones. This excited me greatly and the outro of the show only made it seem more intense and brutal; I was speculating who it was in the cutscenes that were suffering and hitting rock bottom. However, I as of one day after finishing this show, I find myself feeling extremely disappointed and honestly frustrated with EitP. I'll start with a pros and cons list:
Pros:
-The outro was pretty cool; both music-wise and presentation of cutscenes. It's a shame that those scenes shown would be the only highlights in the entire show for me.
-The main actress did well in her role and I was honestly shocked by her age because of how young she looks (especially when next to the Emperor).
- The actor that plays the Emperor does actually look old af.
- The costumes were nice to look at and I couldn't help but want to overanalyze them and how sweaty it must've been to wear them in the beating sun.
- I liked how the story didn't seem to slut shame Meizhuang and Zhen Huan despite them having children with other men that the Emperor yet passing them off as his.
- Truly did have diverse personalities for the female characters and could show their fierceness whilst still maintaining their femininity.
- The older concubines were gorgeous and I have no idea why the Emperor avoided them for the new ones so much. He really fumbled the bag on that one.
- The Emperor is actually portrayed as a terrible person and gets his comeuppance in the end. Hated that guy.
- When the turning point of the story was Zhen Huan realizing she was just a stand-in for Premiere and that how the Emperor had a whole Sangwoo moment of snapping at her when she didn't live up to his expectations of being someone else. That was probably the most intriguing part of the show.
- The show was easily accessible because it was on Youtube. I know this has nothing to do with the writing or design or anything, but I just really appreciate the easy accessibility for all episodes. Though, it may have been better had I not gotten my hands on this series.
- Hongli and Zhen Huan's adopted family relationship at first.
Cons: Oh boy here we go-
- They overuse some music to the point that I could predict the exact sound track that would play the moment a "shocking" or "intense" scene came on. It also didn't help that the music wasn't all that titillating to begin with.
- The settings were interesting at first, but quickly become overused and stale to look as you see the same ochres and reds all over again.
- So many things are so exaggerated to the point that it takes me out of the show. How come the slightest of things cause the women in this show to have miscarriages? I swear a slight breeze will make them topple over and bleed everywhere. Also, I couldn't take their extreme fear over house cats seriously either. I was having to stop myself from laughing over the CG cat that was attracted to face cream or whatever because I knew some outrageous nonsense was about to happen that would cause people to topple over and have miscarriages left and right. It annoyed me so much by the sixth miscarriage.....
- The medicine and medical explanations were too drawn out and ridiculous that I couldn't take any of the ailments seriously. They literally blame people almost having miscarriages on some "cold air" and summer colds that seem to last three months long each. They also used a bunch of those old terms like "qi" and "yin and yang". I also couldn't believe how they could tell literally everything wrong with a person from their pulse.....like come on, people can have a heightened pulse due to a number of reasons that doesn't necessarily mean they are about to have a miscarriage or terminal illness.
- The actress for Yu Rao was terrible. Like, some of the worst acting I have ever seen in a period piece.
- How come they keep saying how characters look sooo much like each other like Jade to Zhen Huan and Noble Prince Guo's two sons? These characters don't really share a resemblance. The two sons looking alike can be explained away easily by the fact that their fathers are brothers. Oh, and a lot of kids tend to look similar before their features mature. And don't even get me started on the nonsense of how Jade and Zhen Huan look supposedly very similar because I have never seen two women look less alike. Zhen Huan looks more like Consort Fleur that she looks like Jade. Every single time they used the look-alike plot to further whatever agenda they had going on I just felt myself lose more and more braincells. It must be an adaptation issue because it could be accepted were it just in a novel, but seeing real life people next to each other that have nothing to do with each other and claiming they look like "sisters" or "brothers" is really pushing it beyond the real of disbelief.
- Noble Prince Guo's wife literally date raped him. She got him drunk on purpose and assaulted him when he was inebriated. Then they just treat this as a little woman's melancholic romantic moment. WTF????
-Long-winded dialogue even for a harem story. Dear god the urge I had to fast forward so many conversations just to get to the good bit. And I know it being a harem story isn't the issue because the Story of Yanxi Palace didn't evoke this feeling in me.
- The Empress' speaking looked off or something. Was there a voice-over done?
- This is entirely just a matter of preference but I wasn't quite behind how they treated Zhen Huan like the most remarkable beauty that no other woman in the harem could even hold a candle to. I personally thought Consort Honnette, Consort Fleur, Ling Rong, Attendant Joie, Consort Estime, Jinxi, and Noble Lady Guwalgiya were just as much, if not more better than her. This man had a whole treasure chest of gorgeous women and yet Zhen Huan is the only one really treated as a beauty except for maybe Consort Fleur.
- Now, for what might be my biggest issue: the plot points that seem to lead nowhere and the terrible "resolutions" to the plots that do have an ending. Good golly Miss Molly this pissed me off so much. So much feels like it was added just to fill time and to lead nowhere by the end. I am a firm believer in making plots link in one way or another and to have resolutions for as many as possible by the end of air time. This show, however, lacked this to the extreme. Also, why does almost everyone have such an anticlimactic and unsatisfying ending? Consort Fleur, Meizhuang, Empress Yixiu, Empress Dowager, Noble Prince Guo, Shen Shichu, Noble Lady Cao, Noble Lady Paix, Ling Rong, Concubine Beaute, Vermilion, and Third Prince Hongshi. The only endings I did actually kind of like were those of Noble Lady Guwalgiya, (maybe) Attendant Chun, and The Emperor. I deadass liked no one else's by the end.
- Bitches be dropping left and right yet I still don't feel any tension 9/10 of the time. Such a let down.
- Also, where the fuck did Wenyi and Jinghe disappear off to? They are also the Emperor's children yet I swear I couldn't even see them on screen later on.....
- Not enough Hongli and Zhen Huan interactions which soured her becoming Empress Dowager for me. It also kind of ruined the moment for me when Zhen Huan noted Hongli's tenseness over the sixth prince and how Zhen Huan seems distant from him because she isn't his "birth mother". Ruined the found family vibe for me.
- Creepy Mongol guy that gave rapist vibes.
- That excruciatingly long trip to the Buddhist mountains that I wanted to fast forward soooo baaaaad.
The Characters: I'll sum up how I felt towards each important one by the end here:
Zhen Huan: Overhyped and underwhelming, but still intelligent; which I appreciated.
The Emperor: Extreme asshole that deserved to suffer in his last moments after being poisoned. Served his role as an antagonist well.
The Empress: Underwhelming and frankly not intimidating at all. She never exuded regal vibes to me. Her scheming was also kind of weak. Empress Nara from Yanxi Palace did it way better. She stays ON TOP!!!
Noble Prince Guo: One dimensional and too idealistic for me to be invested in. So clearly written by a shoujo enthusiast.
Jade: So annoying and selfish. Couldn't stand her at all.
Jingxi: Loved her. She was just great all around. Loved her motherly vibes.
Fleur: Entertaining but underused by the end. I could have almost felt sympathy for her if they gave her more backstory and fleshed her character out a bit more. She got more screwed over than Noble Consort Gao in Yanxi Palace.
Meizhuang: Liked her but I have to admit that she just felt like background dressing in Zhen Huan's story (also I know this is called "The Legend of Zhen Huan" so don't come at me for disliking the intense focus on her, okay?)
Shen Shichu: Another background dressing that honestly annoyed me with his simping. Take a hint, mate.
Ling Rong: Bitch that was so insecure and took it out on everyone around her and lived her days being a pawn to someone else. I hated her ending so much like the most anticlimactic thing ever, man.........
Honnette: I liked her <3
Estime: I liked her :)
Joie: Deserved more time to shine. Unfortunate because I can tell I would have really liked her had she been put in a better show.
Empress Dowager: She existed, I guess? I liked her actress but her character barely did much for me to be excited about so she ended up dying pretty forgettably. She also didn't seem even slightly shaken up Meizhuang's untimely demise. That threw me off big time.
Everyone else: probably forgettable idk I'm getting tired of typing lmao.
In conclusion: Go watch the Story of Yanxi Palace instead <3 (which I'd rate a 7.5-8.0 btw if anyone was wondering).
I started EitP (Empresses in the Palace) with high expectations. The description seemed to promise a palace intrigue story with a protagonist of questionable morals to boot. And I looove morally gray protagonists (Dexter fan here), and the comments I'd seen spoke of Zhen Huan's "darkening" that greatly contrasts her personality from the earlier episodes and the later ones. This excited me greatly and the outro of the show only made it seem more intense and brutal; I was speculating who it was in the cutscenes that were suffering and hitting rock bottom. However, I as of one day after finishing this show, I find myself feeling extremely disappointed and honestly frustrated with EitP. I'll start with a pros and cons list:
Pros:
-The outro was pretty cool; both music-wise and presentation of cutscenes. It's a shame that those scenes shown would be the only highlights in the entire show for me.
-The main actress did well in her role and I was honestly shocked by her age because of how young she looks (especially when next to the Emperor).
- The actor that plays the Emperor does actually look old af.
- The costumes were nice to look at and I couldn't help but want to overanalyze them and how sweaty it must've been to wear them in the beating sun.
- I liked how the story didn't seem to slut shame Meizhuang and Zhen Huan despite them having children with other men that the Emperor yet passing them off as his.
- Truly did have diverse personalities for the female characters and could show their fierceness whilst still maintaining their femininity.
- The older concubines were gorgeous and I have no idea why the Emperor avoided them for the new ones so much. He really fumbled the bag on that one.
- The Emperor is actually portrayed as a terrible person and gets his comeuppance in the end. Hated that guy.
- When the turning point of the story was Zhen Huan realizing she was just a stand-in for Premiere and that how the Emperor had a whole Sangwoo moment of snapping at her when she didn't live up to his expectations of being someone else. That was probably the most intriguing part of the show.
- The show was easily accessible because it was on Youtube. I know this has nothing to do with the writing or design or anything, but I just really appreciate the easy accessibility for all episodes. Though, it may have been better had I not gotten my hands on this series.
- Hongli and Zhen Huan's adopted family relationship at first.
Cons: Oh boy here we go-
- They overuse some music to the point that I could predict the exact sound track that would play the moment a "shocking" or "intense" scene came on. It also didn't help that the music wasn't all that titillating to begin with.
- The settings were interesting at first, but quickly become overused and stale to look as you see the same ochres and reds all over again.
- So many things are so exaggerated to the point that it takes me out of the show. How come the slightest of things cause the women in this show to have miscarriages? I swear a slight breeze will make them topple over and bleed everywhere. Also, I couldn't take their extreme fear over house cats seriously either. I was having to stop myself from laughing over the CG cat that was attracted to face cream or whatever because I knew some outrageous nonsense was about to happen that would cause people to topple over and have miscarriages left and right. It annoyed me so much by the sixth miscarriage.....
- The medicine and medical explanations were too drawn out and ridiculous that I couldn't take any of the ailments seriously. They literally blame people almost having miscarriages on some "cold air" and summer colds that seem to last three months long each. They also used a bunch of those old terms like "qi" and "yin and yang". I also couldn't believe how they could tell literally everything wrong with a person from their pulse.....like come on, people can have a heightened pulse due to a number of reasons that doesn't necessarily mean they are about to have a miscarriage or terminal illness.
- The actress for Yu Rao was terrible. Like, some of the worst acting I have ever seen in a period piece.
- How come they keep saying how characters look sooo much like each other like Jade to Zhen Huan and Noble Prince Guo's two sons? These characters don't really share a resemblance. The two sons looking alike can be explained away easily by the fact that their fathers are brothers. Oh, and a lot of kids tend to look similar before their features mature. And don't even get me started on the nonsense of how Jade and Zhen Huan look supposedly very similar because I have never seen two women look less alike. Zhen Huan looks more like Consort Fleur that she looks like Jade. Every single time they used the look-alike plot to further whatever agenda they had going on I just felt myself lose more and more braincells. It must be an adaptation issue because it could be accepted were it just in a novel, but seeing real life people next to each other that have nothing to do with each other and claiming they look like "sisters" or "brothers" is really pushing it beyond the real of disbelief.
- Noble Prince Guo's wife literally date raped him. She got him drunk on purpose and assaulted him when he was inebriated. Then they just treat this as a little woman's melancholic romantic moment. WTF????
-Long-winded dialogue even for a harem story. Dear god the urge I had to fast forward so many conversations just to get to the good bit. And I know it being a harem story isn't the issue because the Story of Yanxi Palace didn't evoke this feeling in me.
- The Empress' speaking looked off or something. Was there a voice-over done?
- This is entirely just a matter of preference but I wasn't quite behind how they treated Zhen Huan like the most remarkable beauty that no other woman in the harem could even hold a candle to. I personally thought Consort Honnette, Consort Fleur, Ling Rong, Attendant Joie, Consort Estime, Jinxi, and Noble Lady Guwalgiya were just as much, if not more better than her. This man had a whole treasure chest of gorgeous women and yet Zhen Huan is the only one really treated as a beauty except for maybe Consort Fleur.
- Now, for what might be my biggest issue: the plot points that seem to lead nowhere and the terrible "resolutions" to the plots that do have an ending. Good golly Miss Molly this pissed me off so much. So much feels like it was added just to fill time and to lead nowhere by the end. I am a firm believer in making plots link in one way or another and to have resolutions for as many as possible by the end of air time. This show, however, lacked this to the extreme. Also, why does almost everyone have such an anticlimactic and unsatisfying ending? Consort Fleur, Meizhuang, Empress Yixiu, Empress Dowager, Noble Prince Guo, Shen Shichu, Noble Lady Cao, Noble Lady Paix, Ling Rong, Concubine Beaute, Vermilion, and Third Prince Hongshi. The only endings I did actually kind of like were those of Noble Lady Guwalgiya, (maybe) Attendant Chun, and The Emperor. I deadass liked no one else's by the end.
- Bitches be dropping left and right yet I still don't feel any tension 9/10 of the time. Such a let down.
- Also, where the fuck did Wenyi and Jinghe disappear off to? They are also the Emperor's children yet I swear I couldn't even see them on screen later on.....
- Not enough Hongli and Zhen Huan interactions which soured her becoming Empress Dowager for me. It also kind of ruined the moment for me when Zhen Huan noted Hongli's tenseness over the sixth prince and how Zhen Huan seems distant from him because she isn't his "birth mother". Ruined the found family vibe for me.
- Creepy Mongol guy that gave rapist vibes.
- That excruciatingly long trip to the Buddhist mountains that I wanted to fast forward soooo baaaaad.
The Characters: I'll sum up how I felt towards each important one by the end here:
Zhen Huan: Overhyped and underwhelming, but still intelligent; which I appreciated.
The Emperor: Extreme asshole that deserved to suffer in his last moments after being poisoned. Served his role as an antagonist well.
The Empress: Underwhelming and frankly not intimidating at all. She never exuded regal vibes to me. Her scheming was also kind of weak. Empress Nara from Yanxi Palace did it way better. She stays ON TOP!!!
Noble Prince Guo: One dimensional and too idealistic for me to be invested in. So clearly written by a shoujo enthusiast.
Jade: So annoying and selfish. Couldn't stand her at all.
Jingxi: Loved her. She was just great all around. Loved her motherly vibes.
Fleur: Entertaining but underused by the end. I could have almost felt sympathy for her if they gave her more backstory and fleshed her character out a bit more. She got more screwed over than Noble Consort Gao in Yanxi Palace.
Meizhuang: Liked her but I have to admit that she just felt like background dressing in Zhen Huan's story (also I know this is called "The Legend of Zhen Huan" so don't come at me for disliking the intense focus on her, okay?)
Shen Shichu: Another background dressing that honestly annoyed me with his simping. Take a hint, mate.
Ling Rong: Bitch that was so insecure and took it out on everyone around her and lived her days being a pawn to someone else. I hated her ending so much like the most anticlimactic thing ever, man.........
Honnette: I liked her <3
Estime: I liked her :)
Joie: Deserved more time to shine. Unfortunate because I can tell I would have really liked her had she been put in a better show.
Empress Dowager: She existed, I guess? I liked her actress but her character barely did much for me to be excited about so she ended up dying pretty forgettably. She also didn't seem even slightly shaken up Meizhuang's untimely demise. That threw me off big time.
Everyone else: probably forgettable idk I'm getting tired of typing lmao.
In conclusion: Go watch the Story of Yanxi Palace instead <3 (which I'd rate a 7.5-8.0 btw if anyone was wondering).
Was this review helpful to you?
