1
4
1
Ambitious but poorly written
Since the ancient times, people have been engaging in hypothetical ethical dilemmas, challenging their sense of justice and morality. One of the most popular philosophical thoughts experiments is the trolley problem, in which a trolley is about to kill a number of people and the driver has the option to divert it onto a sidetrack with less people. Just how can we measure death and life? How can we dictate who gets to live and who is left to die?
Bloody Flower started off as a psychological thriller which centered around the aforementioned dilemma: would you rather kill other people if that meant you would save other lives? Woo Gyeom, an aspiring medical school dropout, gets arrested for the murders of 17 people. According to Woo Gyeom, he was working on a treatment that could cure any type of diseases, not only simple ones but incurable ones too. The prosecutor who is responsible for this case, Cha Yi Yeon, is doing everything in her power to sentence him to the death penalty. And then, a third person gets involved; a lawyer, Park Han Jun, whose daughter suffers from brain tumor and struggles to get treatment.
The drama had a strong start. It established its themes regarding death and life from early on, making the viewers question every decision of the characters. On the one hand, Woo Gyeom wanted to prove that his cure was real while Prosecutor Cha, on the other hand, was adamant about sentencing him to death. As for Han Jun, he became entangled to this case by choosing to defend Woo Gyeom in a desperate attempt to save his ill daughter, if Woo Gyeom's cure would be proven real. These three characters had their own motives and beliefs and it was up to the audience to criticize their actions.
The first half focused more on the moral aspect of the story and the complexity of the situation. While Woo Gyeom had targeted criminals only, the fact he had murdered people couldn't change, therefore he should receive capital punishment. But how can could they sentence him to death while he was claiming to have found a cure for all diseases?
In the second half however, the drama started to lose me. It was as if I was watching a different story and the characterization felt inconsistent. The story delved deeper into Woo Gyeom's past and his connection to Chaeum Medical Group but 8 episodes were far too few in order for the story to breath. In addition, there were some scenes that felt kinda out of place, particularly the ones between reporter Cho and Min Gyeong. I love myself an entertaining duo, especially if they work together efficiently but at times, I felt like their humorous interactions disrupted the flow and tone instead of providing some breath of fresh air.
The villain was very underwhelming, Kwon Soo Hyun did good as Chairman Chae but acting alone is not enough to carry lackluster writing - and the same applies to the other characters too. Hewas painfully underutilized, I understand that through the few flashbacks we got, there were some hidden layers of a complex, abused character, but alas, these layers remained vague, leaving everything to the imagination of the audience.
Ryeoun did a respectable job portraying Woo Gyeom but at times, I felt like the script didn't allow the character to unfold more. Ryeoun's expressions and gestures conveyed Woo Gyeom's attitude convincingly but personally, I would have liked it if the story had delved into the emotional aspect more. At one point, the way Woo Gyeom was portrayed felt too restrained in order to flesh his character out more, which is a pity because Ryeoun is a great actor and he could have easily pulled off something more demanding.
Sung Dong Il delivered a performance that was expected from a veteran actor like him. His acting was subtle yet it carried many emotions while Han Jin's character was dealing with his inner conflict. I found Dong Il to actually be well-written, his developing relationship with Woo Gyeom felt organic and I really wish we could have gotten more scenes between them.
The biggest fumble however was Prosecutor Cha. At first, I tried to understand her point of view. Although her determination to sentence Woo Gyeom to death and her arrogance irritated me at times, I found her rather intriguing and alluring and I expected her to develop more as a character. At the end of the day, she represented the law, therefore the fact someone had committed 17 murders, should have been punished accordingly. She was a necessary force to enhance the moral conflict the drama wanted to address. But the problem wasn't that. The problem was the way the writers treated this character.
The way her character was handled was beyond lackluster. In the second half, her actions and attitude were very inconsistent compared to the first half, which couldn't be explained by her development as a character, simply because the story didn't explore her change of heart in depth. What the writers wanted to do couldn't been handled in eight episodes only. The rest of the main leads got enough scenes to flesh out their motives and development but Yi Yeon was sidelined in my opinion. In an attempt to create a strong yet flawed woman, the writers didn't let her develop properly, which is a pity.
Keum Sae Rok's performance, while good and commanding, took me out at times. I found some of her gestures over dramatic for a cold and calculating character like Prosecutor Cha. It was as if I was watching an entitled teenager, instead of an overconfident prosecutor. While I understand that Yi Year's arrogance is supposed to be an act of immaturity, it came across as too childish at times. I would have preferred something less flashy and more subtle but that's a complaint aimed at the director, not the actress herself.
The ending was both climactic and underwhelming. Some events were emotionally heavy but due to the overall writing, the dramatic moments didn't hit as hard as they should. Many unfinished business was left and instead of wrapping up the story for good, the writers gave an unnecessary nod of the possibility of a second season, which will most likely never come to fruition.
In conclusion, I didn't enjoy Bloody Flower as much as I wanted to. I don't know if the novel which inspired the drama was better but the series felt poorly written for such an ambitious plot. Had it had more episodes, it could have been better developed. I don't think I'd recommend this drama to avid fans of the genre but if you want something quick and challenging, it might be your cup of tea.
Bloody Flower started off as a psychological thriller which centered around the aforementioned dilemma: would you rather kill other people if that meant you would save other lives? Woo Gyeom, an aspiring medical school dropout, gets arrested for the murders of 17 people. According to Woo Gyeom, he was working on a treatment that could cure any type of diseases, not only simple ones but incurable ones too. The prosecutor who is responsible for this case, Cha Yi Yeon, is doing everything in her power to sentence him to the death penalty. And then, a third person gets involved; a lawyer, Park Han Jun, whose daughter suffers from brain tumor and struggles to get treatment.
The drama had a strong start. It established its themes regarding death and life from early on, making the viewers question every decision of the characters. On the one hand, Woo Gyeom wanted to prove that his cure was real while Prosecutor Cha, on the other hand, was adamant about sentencing him to death. As for Han Jun, he became entangled to this case by choosing to defend Woo Gyeom in a desperate attempt to save his ill daughter, if Woo Gyeom's cure would be proven real. These three characters had their own motives and beliefs and it was up to the audience to criticize their actions.
The first half focused more on the moral aspect of the story and the complexity of the situation. While Woo Gyeom had targeted criminals only, the fact he had murdered people couldn't change, therefore he should receive capital punishment. But how can could they sentence him to death while he was claiming to have found a cure for all diseases?
In the second half however, the drama started to lose me. It was as if I was watching a different story and the characterization felt inconsistent. The story delved deeper into Woo Gyeom's past and his connection to Chaeum Medical Group but 8 episodes were far too few in order for the story to breath. In addition, there were some scenes that felt kinda out of place, particularly the ones between reporter Cho and Min Gyeong. I love myself an entertaining duo, especially if they work together efficiently but at times, I felt like their humorous interactions disrupted the flow and tone instead of providing some breath of fresh air.
The villain was very underwhelming, Kwon Soo Hyun did good as Chairman Chae but acting alone is not enough to carry lackluster writing - and the same applies to the other characters too. Hewas painfully underutilized, I understand that through the few flashbacks we got, there were some hidden layers of a complex, abused character, but alas, these layers remained vague, leaving everything to the imagination of the audience.
Ryeoun did a respectable job portraying Woo Gyeom but at times, I felt like the script didn't allow the character to unfold more. Ryeoun's expressions and gestures conveyed Woo Gyeom's attitude convincingly but personally, I would have liked it if the story had delved into the emotional aspect more. At one point, the way Woo Gyeom was portrayed felt too restrained in order to flesh his character out more, which is a pity because Ryeoun is a great actor and he could have easily pulled off something more demanding.
Sung Dong Il delivered a performance that was expected from a veteran actor like him. His acting was subtle yet it carried many emotions while Han Jin's character was dealing with his inner conflict. I found Dong Il to actually be well-written, his developing relationship with Woo Gyeom felt organic and I really wish we could have gotten more scenes between them.
The biggest fumble however was Prosecutor Cha. At first, I tried to understand her point of view. Although her determination to sentence Woo Gyeom to death and her arrogance irritated me at times, I found her rather intriguing and alluring and I expected her to develop more as a character. At the end of the day, she represented the law, therefore the fact someone had committed 17 murders, should have been punished accordingly. She was a necessary force to enhance the moral conflict the drama wanted to address. But the problem wasn't that. The problem was the way the writers treated this character.
The way her character was handled was beyond lackluster. In the second half, her actions and attitude were very inconsistent compared to the first half, which couldn't be explained by her development as a character, simply because the story didn't explore her change of heart in depth. What the writers wanted to do couldn't been handled in eight episodes only. The rest of the main leads got enough scenes to flesh out their motives and development but Yi Yeon was sidelined in my opinion. In an attempt to create a strong yet flawed woman, the writers didn't let her develop properly, which is a pity.
Keum Sae Rok's performance, while good and commanding, took me out at times. I found some of her gestures over dramatic for a cold and calculating character like Prosecutor Cha. It was as if I was watching an entitled teenager, instead of an overconfident prosecutor. While I understand that Yi Year's arrogance is supposed to be an act of immaturity, it came across as too childish at times. I would have preferred something less flashy and more subtle but that's a complaint aimed at the director, not the actress herself.
The ending was both climactic and underwhelming. Some events were emotionally heavy but due to the overall writing, the dramatic moments didn't hit as hard as they should. Many unfinished business was left and instead of wrapping up the story for good, the writers gave an unnecessary nod of the possibility of a second season, which will most likely never come to fruition.
In conclusion, I didn't enjoy Bloody Flower as much as I wanted to. I don't know if the novel which inspired the drama was better but the series felt poorly written for such an ambitious plot. Had it had more episodes, it could have been better developed. I don't think I'd recommend this drama to avid fans of the genre but if you want something quick and challenging, it might be your cup of tea.
Was this review helpful to you?
